Follow
Share

I have a mom, age 78, widowed 1 1/2 years. She immigrated here 40 years ago, doesn't speak the language, doesn't drive. She lives by herself but she needs her children for everything, remember doesn't speak the language or drive. My siblings and I are burned out.

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
I have a question to stillevolving.
When you and your siblings are not around, how does she amuse herself? Does she watch T.V? Does she listen to the radio?

My grandmother, an immigrant, also said that she did not understand nor speak English, yet she watched T.V. She laughed at the parts of the English speaking shows, where she should laugh.
It was concluded that she preferred her native language.

My father, an immigrant, did all the business duties of the household.
Thus mom's English was not the best.

Once Dad passed, I made Mom do the business chores and speak with people who did not understand her native language. Her English has improved.

I do help Mom when the situation is complex, for example filling out govt forms, other than that, she is managing and is happy that she can do things on her own. By the way, my Mom is 88.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

I suggest that you accept your mother as she is, as she is unlikely to change. So you need to change her environment by finding caregivers who speak her own language. Perhaps magazines or audiobooks in her own language. Perhaps if you speak to her in her own language (if you can do it), she might feel less isolated and perhaps less demanding.
You are jepordizing your own health by trying to meet all or so many of her demands. I suggest you ask yourself what terrible thing would happen if you did not attempt to consistently meet her demands and need for attention. As long as you are providing a safe environment, you should consider becoming less responsive to her requests that are not related to her health and safety.
If you keep up her current behavior, I guarantee that you will face severe caregiver burnout. You cannot afford that, not only for yourself, but also for hers.
My last suggestion may sound harsh and unfeeling, but adult children must admit that they cannot meet every need of their aging parents. Our culture leads us to believe that we as their children must try to meet their demands, no matter how unreasonable or reasonable. But in the long term, you must take of yourself.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

After 40 years, I expect she probably Does understand at least Some English, and the idea of ESL classes is a very good one! There, she would meet others who are also trying to learn, and she wouldn't feel so uncomfortable, and she may even meet a new friend or two!

I live next door to a Russian family, and the Mother of 7 kids can understand quite a bit of what I say, and the rest is communicated through sign and hand gestures, so it's interesting how much they Do know, but sometimes play down that part, to manipulate their kids do do more for them, not meaning that in a bad way, just my observation, my parents too were immigrants, though did speak English, thankfully, however my Mom was extremely shy, and often used us kids to do her communications for her, she got much better with time.

Research your Counties AREA ON AGING, as they will send someone out to meet with your Mom, and offer you some solutions about, home help, transportation, and Respite too, there are Vouchers you might qualify for, so you can  get a much needed vacation, knowing that she is being well cared for, and with every step she does take, with interacting with new people, she will become more comfortable, but understand that it will be a slow process for her.

Good luck, and I hope you find some much needed resources!
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Not speaking the language and not driving is certainly a handicap. Does she also have health problems? Does she have trouble getting around? Need to take a lot of pills? Is she incontinent? Can she still cook, operate a stove safely, etc? Besides communications and transportation, what kind of help does she need?

Did your father speak English? Was he doing all these tasks for her, or did she used to do somethings for herself?

I wonder if it would help if you and your sibling set up a schedule and limit your help to the schedule? On Mondays you drive your mom wherever she needs to go. On Thursdays a sibling does that. No other driving mom around except for emergencies. Going forward she makes her appointments for Monday or Thursday, because that is when she has transportation. On Sunday siblings take turns inviting Mom over for a meal, or taking her to a restaurant. If she needs household help (heavy cleaning, setting up pills for the week, changing high light bulbs, etc) one sibling takes that on once a week for a month, and then it rotates to another sib.

I am trying to think how Mother's needs can be met by her children, as she thinks they should be, without completely burning out all of her children and building up major resentment in everyone. Would it be less stressful if the help were limited to a certain schedule, and spread across the family? I don't imagine that Mother will welcome this with open arms but she is going to have to be flexible in order to get what she wants.

You mother doesn't speak the language of her community. That is Not Your Fault. Your mother doesn't drive. That is Not Your Fault. If she has health problems that is Not Your Fault. This doesn't mean you shouldn't help her but it does mean you shouldn't feel guilty if you cannot help her in exactly the ways and the timeframe she demands. Don't let feelings of guilt make this any harder than it already is!

Come back often and let us know how this is going.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

I sympathize. I don't believe people make problems where none exist. You are already committed and doing your best. You have to add self care into the commitment. That is easier said than done. Does you mother have a pet?
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Caregiver burnout is difficult to treat. It seems the only way to overcome burnout is to step away completely for an extended period. However, in your situation, that may not be so easy. I suggest that you and your sibling work out a schedule where one has complete responsibility for a short period and then her care rotates to the next sibling.
Investigate whether there are any "culturally compatible" caregivers, ones who speak her language or are from the "old country." As others have said, be careful about opening your door to strangers. Caregivers, even for a few hours a day or a week would give you and your sibings a much needed break from caregiving.
It is very hard to stay healthy for the long haul. Good luck and do reach out to this group.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

Can you hire someone who speaks her language to help her out on a weekly basis? There are groups like visiting angels who help elders out, do their errands, drive etc.
I know many people who have done this. May give everyone the break they need and mom can have a new friend.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

She can get metro card & there are language translation everywhere. If she's in good health, there are Senior Citizens centers to go to. You're making this a problem where none exists
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Respite care is *NOT* free in most cases. Depends where you live. However, be mindful if you let volunteers in your home it may open yourself up to whatever. Volunteers can be anybody off the street and even if they claim to fall in your home you can get sued. That rarely happens..but it can happen.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

cwillie makes a very good point. if there is a community of people who speak her language they may have suggestions that can help you.

Also, I'd think that this would be a good place of support for you since there are likely other adult children in your situation. They may be able to share tips with you. If not, at least they can share your frustration.

I wish you the best. This is hard enough without the drawback of language difficulties.
Carol
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Good luck--unless she is on Medicaid you have no help whatsoever. None.  Respite care is *NOT* free in most cases. Depends where you live. However, be mindful if you let volunteers in your home it may open yourself up to whatever. Volunteers can be anybody off the street and even if they claim to fall in your home you can get sued. That rarely happens..but it can happen.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

This is when Restbite Care is really needed. Contact Your Local Public Health Nurse and tell Your circumstance to the Nurse, and inform Her You are really burnt out and request two weeks Restbite Care for Your Mom. It is FREE and it is for the Carer. While Your Mom will detest the idea at first, Shel Love the Care and attention. I would not worry too much about Your Mom not being able to speak the Language as People can mime as They speak to Your Mom. Here in Ireland We have many People from East Timor and every Nation in the World Who can not speak Our Native Tongue, but We mime as We speak to Them and We make Ourselves understood. It reminds Me of Stan and Ollie, of Laurel & Hardy.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

As I was reading your post I thought you were talking about my mom. Moved here 36 years ago and still not a word of English. My dad also passed 1.5 years ago and immediately had to move my mom with me. My brother and I are exhausted and yesterday we moved my mom into Assisted living which will help some. I understand your burnout too well. In our case it was expected that we do everything and not complain because it is a priviledge to take care of your parents (according to my parents).  Unfortunately their peers were similar so no help there. Sadly I have no answer except to try to answer the phone less often. Spread the responsibily as much as possible. To reduce time spent dealing with her stuff try to schedule chores on the same day to reduce trips. I feel for you. It's a whole other level of burden that kids of immigrants can only understand.  I've been at this since the age of 13.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

blannie: The lady has been here for 4 decades and hasn't learned the language after all that time. It's not impossible, but it is unlikely that she would learn English now.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

I wouldn't give up on your mom. She's relatively young in my frame of reference (my mom is 97). I would get her enrolled in some English as a Second Language (ESL) classes where she can meet some others who are learning the language. Does she speak a language that is fairly common in the US, or is she speaking something more unusual?

I'd try hard to get her out and integrated into the community where she can make some friends and be able to use some other transportation options so she's not totally dependent on you and your siblings to go anywhere and do anything. What's her personality like? Is she open to learning or trying new things?
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Sadly, if she hasn't picked up the language after 40 years, she never will. Perhaps you can google "culture groups for her ____ fill in the blank language." If she's a religious woman perhaps that will lead her to a church, too.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

If she has managed to live in your area for 40 years without picking up any English then there must be a community of people in the area that speak her language (at least I hope so, I can't even imagine the depth of her isolation otherwise). Reach out to them to try to find caregivers or facilities that can welcome her.
Helpful Answer (10)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter