Follow
Share

My father in law’s dementia has gotten progressively worse over the past few years. We’ve been able to work around it, but now his safety is compromised. As well as the safety of his wife. She is now asking for help from us adult kids. He has conceded some help paying bills and managing his finances because he was careless and spending in discriminately to the point of not having enough money. How do we approach this when he won’t recognize it himself… or discuss it?

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Sorry for your difficult situation.

He does not need to acknowledge or understand his dementia. That's OK. No one should continue to explain it or reason with him, etc. It just doesn't matter.

What does matter is his safety. Knowing that he is a danger driving, that has to be stopped. Yup, he'll be mad. That's OK. It's not right to let someone drive when it is very likely they will have an accident. If only they would get hurt, then I would be pretty OK with that, but of course he could hurt or even kill someone else and his family can not let that happen.

I took a passive approach on this with my mom. Bad winter roads helped and then I loaned my car to someone and had to use her car and took her keys in case she got it in her head to take a drive. Luckily she didn't try to sneak out! Her geriatric doctor finally told her NO more driving. She was angry. But has complied and accepted it. Not easy but had to be done.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Wow, your family has my sympathy. There is no good answer for this tough situation, except to advise that safety has to be the priority.

The problem is, that you can’t always have a rational discussion with someone whose judgement is impaired. Accept that you may not be able to reason with him.

And, if you - or even a doctor - gets a point across, then your father-in-law might very well forget the discussion.

You are very lucky that your father-in-law has made concessions on the finances — but set up safeguards. You cannot guarantee that he won’t forget and do something reckless again.

Same with the driving. Even if a license is revoked, and even if a doctor says that he cannot drive, your father-in-law may forget or deny, and pick up the keys and go anyway.

Remove temptation. With respect to driving: hide the keys, park the car elsewhere, etc. If he needs to go somewhere, then have a competent driver accompany him and take the wheel.

It’s a lot of effort - but necessary. It might be a good idea to think about having a helper come in to keep on top of things and to support him and his wife.

Definitely have regular family communication and check with his wife. Talking to him might be fruitless and frustrating (on both sides), depending on his stage of dementia.

Has there been any discussion of moving them both into an assisted living situation where help might be available on call?

My late husband had Alzheimer’s, but never acknowledged it. He insisted that he was capable of doing all sorts of things (driving, working with tools and machinery, etc) that were no longer safe for him. We’d talk - I would turn my back to do something - and he would forget the discussion and return to unsafe activities (to the point where I parked the car at a friend’s, took the blades out of saws, and got rid of things). As the dementia progressed, he became frustrated and sometimes violent, In the middle of one night, he walked out of the house and was missing when I woke in the morning.

All these things are possibilities. The more safeguards you can put into place, the better. There sometimes is no warning before a new behavior begins.

Set up your support system, take shifts, and stay in touch. If you haven’t already, you might discuss with his doctor whether there are medications (e.g. exelon, namenda) that might help for a while.

Very best of luck to your family.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

LyndaL: Imho, YOU don't approach this, but instead your father in law's physician has a conversation with him.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Hello. There is a topic on this site about something called anosognosia that may help you.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

I see a son has POA. If that's the case, the car can be either dismantled not to run or tell him it's stolen and get it out of there. To allow him to keep driving could be dangerous to not only him but to others! A simple call to DMV asking them to reevaluate his driving would suspend his license. If you feel he's a danger or his wife is scared and in delicate condition, put him in austere living or memory care. Knowing he has dementia and not getting him tested is irresponsibe on POA's job. Also. Just tell him it's a requirement now that he must be seen by a Dr before his medicare will kick in. Heads up to his dr so he can be tested for dementia. Good luck!
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
Shari49 Apr 2022
All of those things did not help in getting my father to quit driving. I had to get the police involved when he disappeared three states over getting lost going to the bank. Three months later the DMV finally revoked his license but he passed from a massive brain bleed first. thank god). The police could not convince my father to turn over his keys to me. All they could do was advise me to let the air out of his tires. Which he then dragged the air compressor out and refilled the tires. Looking back on those days, I should have done way more. And sorry I didn’t. As POA I would have been held responsible for not having been more pro active if he had killed someone.
(2)
Report
See 1 more reply
Ability & insight are key.

FIL's condiction means he is losing ability but also lacks insight to see it. Or does see it.. but is determined to fight it.

This is the time MIL, who does have ability & insight, needs to take the reins. In finances, arranging care, making decisions.

A great mountain of support will be needed for MIL to accomply the takeover. From FIL's point of view - he may well feel ganged up on so stealth, trickery & therapeutic fibs may be needed. I dislike suggesting those - but you cannot reason with unreasonable people. The reasonable people must lead.

There are some that allow the takeover, this shift in powers, who are happy to trust their family & accept this stage of life with grace. There are others that will holler & shake their first (& worse) keeping an iron-like grip on control. From their point of view - they are FINE. It is OTHER people being bossy & controlling!

Be guided by safety & FIL's temperament. Do what you have to.
Helpful Answer (13)
Report

Once he is diagnosed with dementia by a doctor, he can be taken before a judge, who will declare him mentally incompetent and a guardian will be appointed.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
Chris52 Apr 2022
Going before a judge to have someone declared mentally incompetent can be a very unkind process for someone in the early stages of dementia who is not even aware that he or she has it. I would not do this unless an unusually extreme situation warranted it.
(19)
Report
So the actual issue is driving? You'll find many previous questions and discussions of this thorny topic on the forum. In general it doesn't pay to pussy-foot.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

No, he does not recognize his own dementia. He does realize he needs help with his finances, which the sibling with POA has, but not really more than that. I see physician evaluation is our next, or first, step. We will have to get his wife comfortable with working with us in this regard. She does recognize his dementia, but is hesitant to bring it to topic with him. It’s complicated. Thank you so much for your response!
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
Maryjann Apr 2022
We have never said the D word to MIL.
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
Does anyone have power of attorney for him?

Tell him that he needs a physical as per Medicare, let the doctor's office know in advance that he needs cognitive testing and that it's part of "the physical," and go from there. Once you have a doctor's diagnosis, the power of attorney can be activated.

If you don't have POA, then you've got problems. You could ask the doctor to counsel him on allowing the kids to handle the finances, but don't count on that working. Try to get him (and his wife so he doesn't feel ganged up on) to set up POAs and plan for the future. That'll only work if he's not so bad that he seems incompetent to sign the documents. They'll have to be witnessed and notarized, so if the notary or a lawyer (if you use one) doesn't believe he's competent, they may refuse to do them.

Is his wife a co-owner of the accounts? As a last resort she could add one of you to the account as a signer, and she could require two signatures, or she could close the accounts and reopen them in her name and one of the kids's names only.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
LyndaL Apr 2022
Thank you for your response. Yes, one of the siblings has POA. This sibling also has been handling his accounts and finances. It’s probably leading up to him taking over it all. Our biggest concern now is his safety and that of his wife. She is not healthy and doesn’t want to argue with him. He is still driving long distances and shouldn’t be. We’re trying to work out adult kids driving him on his next trip, but we are anticipating resistance. I guess we need to take it one step at a time. Interference with driving and contacting his physician. I guess our biggest concern is his refusals and the stress of having to fight him for more control. Thank you so much for the reminder that we need to involve his doctor at this point. I really appreciate it!
(5)
Report
Frequently a patient with dementia doesn't know he has it (anosognosia). He needs to be evaluated and diagnosed before someone can obtain POA.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
Countrymouse Apr 2022
On the contrary: if he's evaluated and diagnosed as mentally incapacitated by dementia, he won't be able to create a POA. Too late! Fortunately this gentleman's family has already taken care of that point.
(13)
Report
See 1 more reply
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter