Follow
Share

Father in Law with dementia is giving visa number on the phone to charities and is losing lot of money he needs!

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
Who has POA?

It sounds like FIL is not capable of managing any money and should not have access to the CC. Time to chop it up or get him a prepaid one with a limit of $500 or less and let him use it.

Is his number on the Do Not Call registry?

If they are legit charities, call them and let them know he no longer has capacity to enter into a contract and any charges will be disputed.

It is shameful how some charities prey on seniors.
Helpful Answer (10)
Report

Get his landline phone on a VOIP (voice over IP) system like Ooma. He can keep the same phone number, but there are some good call filtering controls not available on most landlines. He does need wifi internet for VOIP.

If it is a cell/mobile smartphone, there are apps that can block most spammers, too.

Maybe give him a cancelled or fake credit card to use.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

Suzanne, this is a frequent problem and subject for discussion here.  Others face similar unsettling and annoying situations, and I'm sure you'll get a lot of responses and suggestions.

 Does FIL live alone?   Are there any family members who do live with him, or close by?   Anyone helping him with his finances?

I've found the best way is to call the charities directly and tell them that they're not welcome, and may not call or send snail mail again.   Call the headquarters, not any local office.   The decent charities will stop calling; that's been my experience.  But it doesn' t mean that there aren't others lurking around.    That's just as concerning.

I never raised the issue of authority to call on behalf of my father; it's none of the charity's business who is proxy pursuant to a POA or DPOA.   I just used my tough voice and attitude and haven't had to call twice.  

It wasn't unusual though for someone to advise that it takes 2 - 3 (+/-) months to remove the name and address from their mailing list.   That's BS in my opinion.   So I'd tell them that every time we get a solicitation despite advising we don't want them, I'd report them, either to the Better Business Bureau, one of the charity ranking agencies, just on social media. (which may be the most effective anyway.)    And I'd ask if they'd like to be identified as manipulating older people. 


The other aspect is controlling your FIL so he doesn't give to any others who may solicit him.   We discussed the situation when it occurred, and I pointed out that the execs of some of these charities and other solicitors made several thousand dollars, while we were scrimping and saving our money.  That did it.

From then on when a new solicitation arrived, I was asked to find out how much the execs made, which was always much more than SS either one of us got.   The solicitation was discarded or shredded.

The issue could be whether your FIL is able to understand how manipulative these outfits can be.   Do you have lists of those to whom he gave?   With whom, if anyone, does he share a checking account?
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Charities aren't included on the No Call List. Either are surveys and places u have done business with.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

How sad. These are robo calls. They will never stop!

I have a friend who separated her mom’s funds. She set up a very small checking account for her mom. That is the only debit card she has allowed her mom to have.

Her mom is like your father in law. She has a huge heart and would give every penny away! This way, her donations are limited to small portions at the time.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Something just occurred to me.    Do you have any old VISA cards with FIL's name?   If so, could you figure out a way to convince him that old defunct card is his new card, and let him give an erroneous card number to solicitors?   You might want to contact the card issuer though to confirm that the number hasn't been reassigned.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
NeedHelpWithMom Jul 2021
Interesting. Unless he is smart enough to contact his bank and asks them to send a new card out because his isn’t working properly.

It is sort of like the person who disable their parent’s car, and the parent calls AAA to repair it!
(7)
Report
I wish there was an easy way to end telephone solicitations. Even if we block numbers, these people will generate new numbers in a heartbeat! If we have our names on the DO NOT CALL list, it doesn’t matter. If we don’t answer our phones, they send junk texts messages. There’s no end. It’s like a contagious, incurable disease!
Helpful Answer (7)
Report
GardenArtist Jul 2021
One of the limitations of the Do Not Call list is that so many of the numbers shown on caller ID are fake.  I had faithfully been reporting the numbers until one day I decided to block my own number and call back, just to see who really was calling   I think probably 75% or more of the numbers are fake and nonexistent.

I don't know what the solution is.
(2)
Report
See 2 more replies
Unplug the phone. Change the number. My best ideas. If he cannot dial numbers correctly any more unplugging it will work! God bless
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Get a cell phone and transfer his telephone number to the cell phone service. Update his contact address book on the cellphone to those phone numbers that are ok. Most cellphones now have a feature where you can set it to ring only on approved contacts. All other calls will be transferred “silently” to voice mail. Maybe this might be available on your landline too.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

He should not have access to a valid credit card or one with more than a set amount on it. If you have to get him a pre loaded card.
You do not indicate where he is living or with whom. If he is by himself, he should not be living alone. if he is living with someone they could monitor calls and stop him from giving info out.
.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

I had a client whose children put a filter on her landline. It blocked all calls other than those recognized as acceptable callers and it worked really good. I don’t know the name of the filter but if you google something like, “blocking landline spam calls” you’ll find it.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

I get calls all day long over and over. I have had it. So I started doing "my thing". I played dumb and pretended to be senile, etc. I told them my memory was not good but if they give me their contact data, my son or daughter will call and do whatever it is they were asking for. Then I proudly went on to say my son is a FEDERAL PROSECUTOR and my daughter is CRIMINAL ATTORNEY. Wow I never heard someone hang up so fast and I never got another call from them. Make up stories like this or say they are now deceased. it works every time. NO MORE CALLS.
Helpful Answer (14)
Report
graygrammie Jul 2021
Oh, that's a good one. I'll have to try that one day when dh is not around. I've done the "Hello, welcome to our show. Our listeners are eager to hear your story today . . . " My son was in stitches, my dh was furious because I was "lying."
(6)
Report
See 1 more reply
Take the card away from him. He is getting robo calls - the technology just dials one number after another until someone actually talks to them. Might be charity and more likely a scammer just trying to get personal info like credit card. Once you give money to a charity that calls, of course they will call over and over. That's the whole point.

Giving away money can negatively impact his ability to get medicaid for a nursing home should that become a need.

Ditch the card.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

Make sure he only has a cell phone. Adjust settings on phone to block all calls except those in his phone directory - number that you input.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
SeaMar Jul 2021
And change the ring tone for all the "real" contacts. For my MIL's, we have one that is "ring, ring" for all the people she knows. She knows not to answer the others.
(1)
Report
I went and talked to the phone company and had my moms phone number changed. They gave me an old fax number and she NEVER gets any calls now! Before that, she was getting calls every day from someone because my dad use to donate to everyone under the sun!! Plus, I took her Visa card away from her. She never had a problem with that.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Block their numbers or tell them he is dead - seemed to be the only way I could get my MIL's callers to go away. I don't know if you can get help from his phone provider to block calls, or if you can provide him with a phone that will only allow pre-programmed numbers in. Failing that it you know which charities they are then phone them up, tell them he is a vulnerable person and if they call again you will report them for fraud in taking money from a person with dementia. Personally if I were concerned about a close relative in this situation I would take away their cash card. You don't say where he is living but that may affect what actions you can take.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
craftslady1 Jul 2021
I would never tell a dubious charity that someone is a "vulnerable person." That's like putting a bulls-eye on his name and saying, "
Here's an easy mark—Come and get him!!"
(4)
Report
find his card, take it away, call the company and cancel the card.......tear up the card and that should solve the problem......in fact if he has more than 1 card do that for all of them. wishing you luck
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

My dad had a call from a scammer. We were talking and he mentioned this. He had also given his CC this was all within 24hrs. We immediately went to the bank, explained the situation and cancelled the card right then and there. I convinced him that he no longer needed the card. That was the end of my worry. Get rid of every cc he has. This people will continue to prey on him.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

Sounds like time to get him a financial conservator, which you do through the probate court. If you are unwilling to be the conservator, the court can appoint one. This was done for my mother in law, after she was taken by the 'Jamaican Lottery' scam, lost tens of thousands of dollars, and refused to believe even the county sheriff when HE tried to tell her. So now she gets a small allowance to cover her immediate needs but cannot access her bank accounts or sign financial papers or dispose of assets without it going through the court-appointed conservator.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Hopefully he is not living alone. That's a big recipe for disaster in itself!

Also hoping someone has POAs for him. This will allow someone to do what needs to be done:

1) take the card away (preferably when he's not looking)
2) cancel the card/close the account
3) if possible, dispute any recent charges
4) If he *must* have a card, use a pre-filled very low limit debit card with no overdraft.

Trying to stop the calls is like trying to plug the dam with your finger. Many are "spoof" calls, using someone else's number which shows up on the caller ID. Even legit charities will take their sweet time to remove him from the list AND will sell his info to whatever mailing lists they get $ from, continuing the cycle with other "charities."

IF there are apps or filters that can be used to reduce the calls, those should be used as well. Contact the service provider (cell and/or landline) to ask what's available. Those calls are SO annoying! I do believe there are also some cell phones that only allow calls from numbers programmed into the phone, most likely for people like FIL. I have NO knowledge about this phone or how much it costs, I'm only using this as an example (found searching 'cell phones for dementia'):

https://www.razmobility.com/solutions/memory-cellphone/

This looks promising - to block numbers not in your contact list (cell phones):

https://www.technipages.com/android-phone-only-allow-calls-from-contacts

For the most part, I just dismiss/ignore the calls if the numbers are not programmed into my contacts. Now that I've posted the ways to block non-contact calls, I may give it a try. But for now, if the calls persist, I block that number (my plan only allows 5 blocks, so they are saved for the VERY annoying ones!) I've been somewhat lucky because when I moved to another state, I kept my old number. Most of the junk calls come from the state I used to live in. The rest come from all over the country and even outside the country, places I've never been and where I don't know anyone, so I dismiss them all. If they are important, they will leave a message. Most of my contacts are up to date, but there are some that either haven't been added yet or come from a business where the outgoing calls can be different from the main phone number. Except for the first year here (one time only), they haven't figured out I live here now, so calls from this area code are generally "safe" for me to answer!

If there are legit calls from trusted sources, like utils, doctors, insurance, bank, etc, have YOUR number posted to replace his number. That way you won't miss the important calls (he may forget to tell someone or not know what to say to them.) Sign up as Rep Payee for SS (the only LEGIT way to manage another person's SS.) This will make YOU the contact point for any SS or Medicare issues. POA may or may not be needed for most of these, I was able to update contact info (mailing address vs residential, phone number, etc) without using the POA. The only exceptions were the bank and CC. NOTE: SS/Medicare do NOT honor POAs - you need to sign up with them as Rep Payee!
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

If he has dementia he should not have a credit card period. Tell him the bank took it back and will send him another. It's always "in the mail". put the phone on Mute for the ring tone or just unplug jack from phone - looks like its on but ring will never happen
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Need more info..
has he always given to charity?

How bad is his Dementia ?
If it's real bad then he has no business with a Credit Card.

Maybe you could set up his phone to not receive those types of calls.

You could tell him that there are lots of prank calls and he shouldn't give out his info because they will charge a lot on his card.

Tell him that you will help him do an auto pay to the Charities that he likes and whenever he gets a call just tell them thank you, he's already given and to hang up the phone.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

I have dads credit card and Medicare card. He can't give out those numbers to anyone and I am with him for all medical visits. I am his only child and caregiver.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Riley's comment reminded me of how we addressed some of the calls, when there actually was a person calling.  Since we had agreed that many of the so-called charities overpaid their executive staff, when I could think of it I asked the caller how much the CEO made.   That usually resulted in a gap of silence.   If it didn't, I asked for executive salary amounts down the line, and once even asked how this person felt about working for people who made so much money while getting someone else to do the solicitation.

That didn't happen very often, as many of the calls I get are robo-called.    The same monotonous (probably computerized) voice is always a clue.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

My Mom was so bad about this. She would call me and say “I think I did it again.” The routing number is the one I’m not allowed to give out, right? No Mom!!
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

My mother died a year and a half ago, and the mail hasn't stopped, and the calls haven't stopped. We have contacted the charities directly. I have answered maybe a third of the phone calls, telling the callers that she's dead, but only about a quarter of those callers apologized and said they'd update their records. The rest tried to get MY money. Change the number and take the credit card away.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

The unsolicited calls are not going to stop. Period. There is no way you can stop these calls, whether they are legit or scammers. The best thing you can do is NOT answer the phone when they call. Since your dad cannot remember not to pick up the phone, you have to eliminate the opportunity for him to respond to these calls. If you must have a phone in the house, turn off the ringer. Anybody who needs to reach your father, such as doctors and family members, can leave a message. If it is important enough, a message will be left. Your dad is extremely vulnerable and, unfortunately, there are way too many people who want to take it advantage of him, me, you and everyone on this forum.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Most - if not all - of these calls are from scammers. You can’t stop the calls - his number is out there. You can take some comfort in knowing they don’t like victims with dementia because they have trouble getting them to follow through sending money. If your FIL still drives, it is very possible he could be instructed to wire money from any of the wire services like MoneyGram, Western Union and GreenDot. He can also be conned into giving bank account info, credit card info, and ID info like his social security number. The scammers are experts at what they do. They take notes during calls of anything they can use to fool the victims. For instance, if the victim goes to church. The scammer will promise a cash prize and tell the victim how much their church could use their “winnings.”

To control the problem you need to take control. That means throwing out junk Mail, including charitable solicitations. I don’t care if it for “homeless kittens” or any other “charity” - legitimate or not. I tell my folks that they have donated enough in their life and that they can let the younger generation pick up where they leave off. Sending a response in to these “charities” leads to more solicitations at best. At worst, it collects the victims phone number and/or financial info which the scammers then use or sell as a “sucker list.” Once their name, address, telephone number is out there the scammers will be relentless and even threatening.

1) Teach your loved one to use caller ID
2) Let unknown calls go to voice mail
3) if 1 and 2 are not workable change the number and/or get an unlisted number and do not give the # to the victim. Provide the # to trusted family. friends and essential businesses/medical providers.
4) throw out/ do not respond to junk mail solicitations of any kind.
5) shred junk mail or at least tear up in little pieces. I dump the cat litter in with mine!
6) Be on alert for repetitive calls, questionable bank transactions, your loved one becoming protective/secretive concerning phone calls/mail
7) Be on alert for compulsive computer activity.
8) Get POA so you can keep an eye on things and intervene as necessary.

These scams can take a few hundred dollars all the way to a person’s life savings. Don’t underestimate the damage that can be done. Vulnerable seniors are targets - someone needs to protect their interests.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Before I looked at my dementia mom's account years ago she had so many charities that were "auto debit" from her account over the years.. hundreds of dollars each month from junk mail & phone calls. She never looked at her statement. (YB was controlling & liberally using her account too.) My mom was always polite on the phone, so I had to start reminding her do not explain anything, just say no & hang up. We went to the bank & stopped the auto debits. I printed out in large print a paper saying: DO NOT GIVE OUT YOUR ACCOUNT INFO, JUST HANG UP IT'S A SCAM CALL! Posted it on the fridge as a reminder. Maybe you can post something similar near the phone, and take away the card too!
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Suzannez2: Cancel his credit card.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter