Find Senior Care (City or Zip)
Join Now Log In
G
graygrammie Asked March 2021

What does the future look like for someone with heart failure who does not want any more medical procedures?

A few weeks ago my 67 yo husband was taken to the hospital. Initially they said it was pneumonia but upon release they said he had heart failure and referred him to a cardiologist asap. In less that two days, he was back in the hospital, turns out he was overmedicated on bp pills. BP was 61 / 43 when they got to the ER. (Two different hospitals as the ambulance crew that came and got him the second time thought he was having a stroke and the first hospital's machine was down.) Thirty-six hours and he was back home.


He saw the cardiologist a few days later, agreed to do the procedures required for the surgical team to evaluate whether he was able to have the surgery. Found out that he has left and right side heart failure, needs a valve replaced (has for years and has always refused it) plus ongoing afib and some other surgical interventions were also discussed.


He saw his pcp the next day, was all agreeable to the upcoming procedures. So glad they have to give a visit summary or I wouldn't have it in writing that he was positive with the pcp about getting this done.


The next day they called to schedule the procedures and he said he never agreed to any procedures. I told him he'd signed papers, so then I read them to him, and he said that there was no way he would have ever agreed to that.


On Sunday 3/14, he told me to stop pushing him about getting surgery (I purposely had not said a word) because there is "no way anyone is sticking anything up my veins or cutting me open." I told him I agreed and then . . . I told him about the two different dementia diagnoses that had been given to my daughter and I about him 2017. I told him that I was mad that no doctor ever sat down, looked him in the face, and told him these things. I'm mad that he hasn't even seen his neurologist in over a year, she should be dealing with this, not me. And then I put it bluntly -- Maybe it is God's mercy to take him sooner because of his heart than to have him in Memory Care later with a good heart. When I told him all this, he did not get upset (totally out of character) but was actually relieved and said that knowing about the dementia diagnoses actually made sense to him and answered some nagging questions he's had. So we're good there.


He has also refused to follow up with the "heart failure clinic" that is offered by the local hospital. He says he doesn't need monitored, just let whatever happens happen. Okay, so that is fine for him, he is a controlling man and no one is going to make him do something he doesn't want to do, but . . . and now I am finally at my question:


What about me? (That sounds so selfish.) I need answers. I need to know what the future looks like. I need to know -- are we talking months or are we talking years? If he's giving up, is it worth worrying about his salt intake and his fluid intake or just let him have what he wants and avoid the tension? What are things going to look like as this progresses? When does he go to the hospital and when do I say no? (He is "no CPR, no feeding tubes, no vent, or other life-sustaining measures" on paper.) Do we ask for palliative care? Or home health services? Or hospice?


I've been reading the articles here about heart failure and it is all a bit overwhelming. As far as I can tell (because no one has told me) he is in Stage 3 (or C, depending on what you read). What is the prognosis for that?

Taarna Mar 2021
With dual-sided heart failure, both sides of the heart do not "pump" well. When a "pump" doesn't work well, fluid backs up. One side of the heart, collects blood from the body and pumps it to the lungs to pick up a load of oxygen. When this side fails, fluid builds up in the body - especially the feet and legs. Those lower extremities will become swollen. The other side of the heart collects blood from the lungs and pumps it to the body. When this side fails, fluids build up in the lungs - mimics pneumonia. If his heart valve is compromised, blood that normally is pushed through the "doors" of a chamber of the heart can flow "backwards" since the "doors" don't close properly. This causes similar problems as heart failure but usually not as severe.

With stage 3, or C, heart failure, you can expect tiredness and weakness. Any exercise or activity may take longer to do and he won't be able to sustain efforts. Surgery may be able to reverse some of the heart problems so he could have more energy and less fluid build-up. The best treatment for those who opt out of surgery is following heart healthy diet, limiting salt intake (depending on medications), taking diuretics (pills that make a person urinate) and limiting his fluid intake to 1 quart of fluids per day. You will be able to see if he is on the right track by keeping a record of his weight. Usually daily weights are done in the morning with same clothes (or no clothes on). His weight should stay the same. If his weight trends upwards, his energy goes down, and he has trouble breathing - he is holding onto too much fluids. In this case, he may need hospitalization for more vigorous removal of fluids (usually with medications) and oxygen. Life expectancy might be as long as 5 years.

If his congestive heart failure progresses to stage 4. or D, he will have a dusky color because he will not by oxygenating well. He will have very little energy and exerting himself will most likely result in chest pain. In this stage, life expectancy is less than 1 year.

What you need to consider:
1 - Visit lawyer who deals with family law. Make sure your husband has a will and an advanced directive. The advanced directive tells others what kinds of treatment your husband wants if he has a medical problem and can limit CPR, artificial breathing, IV's for medications or fluids, whether or not to insert tubes for medications, fluids, and/or nutrition. If he does not have an advanced directive, medical staff are required to do everything to "bring him back" or to keep him alive. While you are at it, get your legal documents taken care of: will, advanced directive, power of attorney for medical, and power of attorney for financial. This way if you are sick or in the hospital, your affairs can be taken care of by the very reliable person you name in your powers of attorney.

2 - Talk to your husband's cardiologist and/or primary care doctor. Ask him/her to be honest with you about your husband's life expectancy. If he is not expected to live more than 6 months, the doctor can prescribe hospice. Hospice focuses on comfort care and not curing disease. Basically, you let your husband eat and drink what he prefers and not worry about what it does to his health. The focus is on his comfort and relationships. Most insurance will pay for hospice. You can get home health aides to assist you in caring for him and visits from RNs to manage his comfort levels with medications.

3 - Start making plans for life after your husband passes. This may sound callus, but you need to review what your finances will look like without him. Also consider if you can afford or want to stay in the same home. What activities or relationships do you wish to nurture when it is just your needs to consider. I recommend highly joining GriefShare, a group that usually meets weekly to share helps with each other who are suffering the loss of a loved one.
graygrammie Mar 2021
Thank you for the detailed explanation.
1) We drew up wills and other papers ten years ago after seeing what a friend went through when her mother suddenly died.
2) We used hospice in our home with my mil. It was a very good experience and I would use that agency again (with the stipulation that the pharmacy does not need to deliver meds at 11:00 pm., lol).
3) I have wanted out of this house for years. I began exploring options fifteen years ago. It has been too much for dh to handle but he insisted staying because the golf course is around the corner. We have a son that I would love to sell the house to, but he's the 40yo boomerang child living in our basement. He is going to be the biggest issue. Eventually I will have an inheritance from my father (as long as he doesn't get swindled out of it, he is such a sucker for scams). I've said for years that one day I'd love to have a little RV and travel the country, visiting folks and seeing the sights and then settle in a senior community that offers "the full package" enabling one to progress from a residence to assisted living to nursing home. I don't want my kids to be responsible for me even though my daughters have both told me they'll always have a room for me.
AlvaDeer Mar 2021
Yes, basically your husband has accepted that his heart will likely kill him, and sooner rather than later. And he has chosen palliative care, without further testing and procedures. This he should inform his doctor of. If POLSTS are legal in your state he should do one and it should hang in your home clearly visible so that any EMTs don't attempt to bring him back from cardiac arrest. His choice would be my own.
I think that you should refrain from encouraging him to have heart surgery. At this age this complicated surgery OFTEN goes wrong, and as a cardiology nurse for many years I can assure you of that. Clots are often a complication as they struggle to give and control blood thinners; there can be hemorrhages in brain. There can be strokes. And death or debility can come rather than valve replacement. If your husband has atrial fib there is more wrong with the heart than the valve so that the "electrical signally for a beat" (as an easy way to explain) is not functioning well as well as the mechanicals within the heart. Ablation sometimes works for this, and much LESS OFTEN than they will suggest to you it does.
With Palliative care the heart failure will be treated with diuretics to help manage fluids in lungs, in peripheral areas. This will require testing to make certain that potassium (which is washed away with diuretics and which is crucial to life) levels remain stable. Other testing would not be done. Your husband should explain to his MDs that risk of surgery is worse to his mind than allowing things to proceed as they will.
Heart failure means essentially a failing pump. Failure of left heart would mean difficulty in clearing fluids from lungs, more dangerous than right heart failure which will result in some abdominal congestion, swelling, and pitting edema in the feet and legs. Some people get what we call "Flash Pulmonary Edema" which can hit lungs quickly and severely.
Hospice isn't called for. People can manage heart failure for some time with medication and blood monitoring. But Palliative care seems to be where he is at. Do discuss with him if this is his final choice; then see a good cardiologist and get your staging information, and the way forward.
I am very sorry for this diagnosis. It is dire indeed. Informing yourself with internet on what to expect and what the diagnosis means is a good thing, but once you know the basics, stop scaring yourself to death with it. Some people manage with medications well.
Learn to do blood pressure at home. One of the most common admissions on our floor was plummeting BP. Because it is measured in MD office it is abnormally high; they give medications and it goes low low at home and the patient is down on the floor with their first trip up to the bathroom.
I wish you good luck in managing all this. If you have read "complications with valve replacement" you will see many; they may make you feel somewhat better about your husband's choices. While at 67 he sure is younger than we would want him to be, but I would, were I you, honor his decision, give him time to think, and discuss honestly what his choices mean for you both. Try to take this a day at a time. Don't let doctors rush you out the door; don't let doctors bully you. Despite their sometimes wrong ideas that they are God, they honestly aren't. Remember that much depends on the specialist you visit. As my Dad used to say "Surgeons cut cut cut cut." That's the facts. It is what they do. A good cardiologist will help you and your husband manage the facts of his condition.
I surely do wish you the best.
graygrammie Mar 2021
Thank you for such a detailed answer. It is what I need to hear. We have living wills but it seems a POLSTS is different in that the physician is involved. I will revisit your reply tomorrow when I am more awake.

ADVERTISEMENT


cweissp Mar 2021
I'm so sorry for your situation. You are not selfish and you have every right to say, think "what about me?"

Your DH is young to give up on life. My father in his 91st year ended up in the hospital for CHF where he was also diagnosed with Afib, a leaky valve and something else that I can't remember; he also had alzheimer's. Of course at 91 there was no talk of surgery. At discharge they sent him to rehab, but when he got home he said he was done, no more rehab, no nothing (he had been wanting to die for a couple of years). At his cardiology f/u appt dad advised the dr of his desire not to do anything else. I asked about hospice and the doc said it was an option. Dad was amenable to hospice, the hospice provider was wonderful and took good care of dad. Dad was taken off all meds, except for those to keep him comfortable. One day while or shortly after mom had visited dad he just peacefully died. He lasted about 7 months on hospice.

Check with one of his doctors re hospice and if it is an option contact for evaluation. If you get a good hospice provider you will find them a good support system not only for your husband but for yourself as well as the rest of the family. Lean on them and let them help.

Does your husband really want to die or is he depressed and just doesn't care? Depending on his answer can make a difference in getting treatment.

Daughterof1930 Mar 2021
I hope you’ll be able to contact your husband’s cardiologist and get many questions answered. My dad died from end stage congestive heart failure. Several years prior he’d had his aortic valve replaced. It was a very temporary help, despite much optimism after surgery over time things only continue to worsen. CHF is slow and insidious. It makes fluid up and leaves a person panting for each breath. It zaps energy and makes an active person inactive. My dad did many trips to the hospital to have fluid removed, most often by IV Lasix. One time 16 pounds of fluid was removed. It’s a very temporary fix and the fluid returns again and again. Dad wouldn’t change his diet and the cardiologist didn’t much argue with him, they both knew where things were headed and my dad felt at his age he’d earned the right to eat as he pleased. I’m pretty sure it wouldn’t have mattered. My dad had wild swings in BP, very high at times in stroke territory and other times so low he’d nearly pass out. Sorry to be so negative sounding but CHF is cruel and relentless. Last summer my dad had another hospitalization and decided to come home on hospice. After years of CHF he’d had enough and died in about a month. I’m sorry you’re facing this, we didn’t deal with dementia, can’t imagine how all that would complicate matters. Reach out for any help you’re eligible for and practice self care. I wish you both peace
graygrammie Mar 2021
Daughterof1930, thank you for telling me your dad's story. It helps me to understand what is ahead. (My parents were both born in 1930.)

A few years ago, my husband would walk 18 and even occasionally 27 holes of golf every day (course is 2.4 miles from our house, small easy course). Two years ago, the course manager started to see a decline in him and gave him a cart free for the second half of 2019. (Well, he actually told him to either use the cart or don't come back!) Last year he needed to use the cart daily and seldom golfed more than nine holes. By October he was too tired to even go over for nine holes (and his golf buddies didn't want to golf with him any more because he was so slow).

I have definitely watched this active person become inactive. I suspected heart failure last summer when I saw his game didn't pick up as he got into the season like it usually does, his energy level was so low, and he began huffing and puffing. But neither his pcp nor cardiologist pursued it when he off-handedly mentioned that he was short of breath. If he didn't take it seriously, why would they? Maybe I should have said, "Yeah, you can't make it from the living to the bathroom without being out of breath."

I don't want to see this go on for years and I'm pretty sure my dh doesn't want that either. His brother died last March and all he has talked about since then is "going home to be with his real family again."
cxmoody Mar 2021
GG,
I’ve read all of the responses. Such a hard season.

Watching my mother suffer the terror of dementia, I personally wouldn’t choose surgery for her, if she faced a heart issue. I would consider it a way out of the suffering from a deteriorating brain.

As your husband is refusing treatment, perhaps it will be a way to avoid that torture-for you both. Of course, this is just MY thinking.

Praying for wisdom for you both.

Hugs to you!
disgustedtoo Mar 2021
My mother was 90ish when dementia started. I was already aware of the parents "choices" for treatment, but even if I wasn't, I see no reason for extensive medical intervention at this age with dementia! Fix a broken bone somehow, sure, but major surgery? Nope.

She should have had knee replacement YEARS ago, and kept saying that before the dementia. During/after some intense leg pain complaints, I took her to ortho, who after looking at the X-rays said if she were 20 years younger we'd be talking surgery. I had no intent to ask for surgery, just confirmation that this might be the source of the pain AND if he could do an injection to perhaps take the worst pain away.

She made it to 97 before the first stroke, then a few months more before the next one came. Four years in MC to live comfortably and safely!
Grandma1954 Mar 2021
@greygrammie...
There really is no time frame when it comes to Hospice. My Husband was on Hospice for almost 3 years.
As long as there is a continued, documented decline. They can remain on Hospice
As long as the person is no longer getting treatment for the condition that made them eligible for Hospice they can remain on Hospice.
Medicare does have guidelines and recertification is necessary.
This is one of the reasons that documenting day to day changes can be important.

*Personal note about Hospice. There are 2 types For Profit and Not for Profit. In my case the Hospice I chose happened to be a Not for Profit one. I could not have been more pleased with the help, education, supplies and equipment. As I mentioned earlier interview a Hospice just as you would any other health care. AND if you feel you or he is/are not ready for Hospice ask about Palliative Care.

Bridger46146 Mar 2021
My mom died last year from heart problems. She had a valve replacement approximately 9 years earlier. She got along well with the surgery and recovered from surgery fairly well. Not cured but her quality of life was pretty good. She had about 7 good years. She was diligent about all of her care. She was a fighter and wanted to live. The last 18 months she was very short of breath, fluid retention. She became very frail. She died very quietly at home with family.

lealonnie1 Mar 2021
You are NOT asking a 'selfish' question at all when you say, 'what about me?' You are half of this team and you matter! Your life is being altered here with every decision your DH makes or doesn't make, so of course your input is important! He should take your feelings into consideration as you BOTH travel this path, too, because you're on it TOGETHER!

Like Barb said, you need to speak with DH's doctors about the questions you have and about his prognosis w/o medical intervention. The questions you have about salt intake & fluid intake are valid; if he's refusing treatment, why bother worrying about those things, even if it hastens his demise. If he's strong willed and has dementia, he's unlikely to follow YOUR dietary instructions ANYWAY, let's face it. So get all the 411 you possibly can from his cardiologist, and go from there.

Wishing you the best of luck with a difficult situation. Sending you a hug and a prayer for strength, too.
jacobsonbob Mar 2021
Any decision he doesn't make IN ITSELF becomes a decision!
JoAnn29 Mar 2021
Not having a valve replaced will not be helped by strengthening the heart. The Valve will continue to weaken until it doesn't work anymore. My Dad had two valve surgeries at 65 and 67 and pulled thru both. He also had a triple bypass why they were in there. Now each valve does something different and I don't remember which is which. But with Dad they put a Dacron valve in the first time and the valve clotted shut. This was not good because its the one that needs to open. They then went in and put a pig valve in. Again he did great but unlike the Dacron one that was suppose to last 20 yrs, this one only lasted 10 yrs. Which Dad said was OK because he wouldn't last 10 yrs. He pasted 12 years later and the valve was still good. He died from something else.

My question to the doctor is what happens if the valve doesn't get replaced. For my Dad, he would have died. I think at this point ur husband is with it enough to know what goes into having this surgery. What you need to do is worry about your future. Make sure everything is in order. That you are taken care of.

JoAnn29 Mar 2021
If he had his valve done back when, his life would have been so different. My MIL was a fairly active woman. But she complained of being tired all the time. Once she had the valve replacement, again 30 + years ago, she said she felt like a new person. She was 65 and died just short of her 92nd birthday. Still independent. Never having to have the valve replaced. She did not die from heart failure.
disgustedtoo Mar 2021
From what I just read, an untreated (replaced) valve can lead to CHF. Of course someone could develop CHF without that as well. But it is a shame that he didn't get this repaired years ago ("...needs a valve replaced (has for years and has always refused it)".) It might have prevented or at least delayed the CHF for OP's husband.

My dad had a valve replaced and the aorta patched at the same time, when he was early 50's. Pig valve. He was told they are good for 10 years. He got 20 years out of it and when he went in to have it replaced, he said he wanted that pig's brother! There were some issues during the second surgery (age early 70s), but he still lived another 10+ years.

Now with dementia at play... it's a tough decision. The anesthesia can make the dementia worse, and while many get back to where they were in a few months, sometimes it is a permanent regression. He could still have some quality of life if he had the surgery, but there's no guarantee. Same for skipping surgery, but modifying lifestyle and managing medication - could make life better. There's no way to know except to try, but he will have to agree to either surgery or changing his life and taking medications.
See All Answers

ADVERTISEMENT

Ask a Question

Subscribe to
Our Newsletter