Find Senior Care (City or Zip)
Join Now Log In
H
HilaryHilary Asked February 2021

Muddle becomes major event. How do I settle this?

My mother had a phone call out of the blue from A. Mother asked A who gave her the phone number. A said it was B, her son, my brother. Mother was cross as she does not have B's own phone number (he writes nice letters quite frequently and calls her about twice a year but for some reason won't give her his number and has asked me not to). She felt he had no right in these circumstances to give out her number without permission. She became increasingly concerned about this and asked me (her daughter and LPA) to email my brother and say she was cross and would he ask permission first. I did this politely and suggested (as there have been issues between B and our mother ) that he might want to say sorry for the mistake to prevent any further trouble between them. B went ballistic. Emailed me loads of abuse, called me a liar, wicked, used weird over-the-top language in reply to a polite and friendly email. He said I had made this up, was trying to cause trouble and that mother loved him and would never be cross with him about this or anything else - and anyway, he did not give A the number it was someone else: C. He contacted A and got her to swear she didn't tell mother he gave her the number, that it was C, and to say that mother must have misheard her on the phone. Because of a huge unpleasant muddle now on the family grapevine with C getting the blame, my mother has has now denied asking me to pass on the initial message and says she doesn't mind who has her phone number! Fine, I'm prepared to weather being the family baddie for the time being but my mother, it seems, isn't going to rest until I apologise to my brother and to A and C for making trouble. She expects me to smooth it all out and she is waiting to hear from them that I've done this. I'm unsure how to soothe mother who certainly didn't expect all this trouble any more than I did (I should have let her write to him herself, I realise this now). She is obsessing about it and keeps phoning people up to ask what is happening now - what's the situation etc etc. NB: the abuse I had emailed to me was so vitriolic and was such an out of the blue shock that I had a bad angina attack which actually prevented me from visiting mother as planned this week. Neither A or B ever visit mother but they do write to her which gives her pleasure. I would like to settle this without sacrificing my own integrity which I am not prepared to do. Sensible and kind solutions welcomed!

BarbBrooklyn Feb 2021
Hillary, if your mother gets in a muddle talking on the phone and then gets agitated by the results, that is something to talk to her doctor about.

Increased anxiety about just about everything was the major outward symptom we saw in my mom's cognitive decline.

Beatty Feb 2021
HilaryHilary, I think you have received some excellent replies but please don't take offence! People do mean well!!

Your situation has been a shock to you but everything can be a chance to respond differently next time (if you want).

If your goal was to untangle the mess, you may have decided it's not actually your job. I hope so - as your own health is so very important.

But if your goal is to smooth Mother - that may be done, in a somewhat sneaky way instead. A soothing tone, confident manner & a hand sweep "Oh that silly mix up... that's all sorted. Don't worry about it one more second." Then quickly move the conversation on.

Some folk find the benefits of smoothing outway a few white lies (therapeaudic lies).

Teepa Snow has many YouTube's on strategies to deal with dementia behaviour if that is what you are (or will be) dealing with.
HilaryHilary Feb 2021
Thank you Beatty. I much appreciate all the kind replies I have had and would not take offence at anything I maybe would have preferred not to hear! Thank you for yours.

ADVERTISEMENT


Countrymouse Feb 2021
And who the eff is A?

Personally, I think you crossed the line when you took it on yourself to tell B to apologise. The fact that as it turned out B had nothing to do with the offence in question isn't the issue. It's that you chose to take a moral line on it.

And you were surprised that B took this in bad part? His resulting vitriol may have been disproportionate but what did you expect? - that he'd meekly comply with your recommendation?

Don't attempt to settle this. It won't go well. The lesson to take from the whole ghastly episode is that if mother wishes to communicate with anyone in future she can do it herself.

The mere fact that B feels relations with his mother are much improved by her not being able to telephone him does seem like a bit of a clue, mind you.

On the other hand... How good *is* your mother's hearing?
Beatty Feb 2021
Hearing. Good point.

I asked someone once "did you sleep well?"

Reply "What?? Do my feet smell???"
AlvaDeer Feb 2021
She expects YOU to smooth it out?
Forget about it. As you said , you are the current baddie.
I would tell them you are the bad guy in their book? Fine? But now you don't want to hear ANYTHING ABOUT THIS EVER AGAIN, and they get to talk to one another and straighten it out or NOT, but they are NOT allowed to mention it to you. If they don't wish to communicate with you at ALL tell them that this will considerable lighten an already overfilled "dance card" and they are on their own. Have a great day. I mean tell THEM to have a great day, and the fact THEY are all out of YOUR day will automatically improve YOUR day.
Sorry. I am furious at ALL of them. What a bunch. Let them squabble among themselves and step away. FAR AWAY.
HilaryHilary Feb 2021
Advice is always great and of course varies as people take different points of view but your sympathy here has done so much for me AlvaDeer. It is a novel experience to have someone furious FOR me. Such kindness. Your response will be something I will take with me to remember whenever I feel lonely and unsupported.
JoAnn29 Feb 2021
If you don't have a written diagnosis of Dementia I would get one if possible. Then I would send your brother a copy and anyone else who believes Mom. In the meantime, apologize to Mom and brother and anyone else you feel you should. Next time Mom asks you to be the go between say no, she is to do it herself.

Be aware though, if Mom has a Dementia, that things like this will happen more often. In the early stage they lose shortterm memory, so Mom may have forgotten what she said to you and misunderstood B for C. She will lose her ability to reason and the ability to process what she is saying. You will be the bad guy.
HilaryHilary Feb 2021
Thank you for this sensible advice JoAnn. Yes, I will move on getting a diagnosis. I am now forewarned of possible further muddles so I will tread very cautiously in future and won't pass messages but only facts as I know them to be true myself.
BurntCaregiver Feb 2021
HilaryHilary, my dear I think you have very likely been the family scapegoat for a very long time. No more you being the message bearer for them because when a miscommunication happens which I'm guessing is ALWAYS followed by a grand cluster-'F' you're the one who gets the blame for the whole thing. If 'B' your brother doesn't allow his own mother to even have his phone number, then they've had some serious issues for a long time, and those issues have nothing to do with you. That's between them.
I'd stay clear of any relaying of messages between family members and your mother. Don't smooth anything over or try to make peace with everyone because the situation and those involved in it will only come down harder on you. If they want to communicate with her, then they can do so directly themselves. Stay far away from that, my friend. And... don't apologize to any of them. Not your mother, your brother, or whoever 'C' is.
You didn't do anything wrong and have no reason to apologize. So don't.
HilaryHilary Feb 2021
Thank you so much for your response. I feel you are sympathetic. I probably made a mistake here but honestly tried to protect my mother from sleeplessness and agitation. He lives in Australia and I don't have his phone number and a letter written by my mother would have taken ages. I am now being stalked on social media by my brother who is saying slanderous things about me and I am now quite frightened. Can I take this post down so no-one can find it? If I delete my account here will it all disappear?
Geaton777 Feb 2021
Agree with what others have posted. Send a group text or email to A, B and C and tell them politely that you are no longer the messenger between them and Mother or them and each other. Tell Mother the same. No lengthy explanation. If they ask why, just tell them you don't want to do it and it's not your job to be the go-between. No further explanation. Then keep out of it. If Mother asks you to contact one of them, just smile apologetically and tell her you can't do that and change the subject. She'll figure it out.
HilaryHilary Feb 2021
Thank you Geaton. I will take your sensible advice.
BarbBrooklyn Feb 2021
You are being played by your family. It's called "triangulation" or "Let's you and HIM fight". Whether by design, habit or because of dementia, mom is "stirring the pot".

Get out of the kitchen.

Apologize all around for upsetting everyone and then stop carrying messages. Lesson learned.
HilaryHilary Feb 2021
Thank you for your advice BarbBrooklyn - I appreciate your kind response.
NeedHelpWithMom Feb 2021
Why are you the go between?

I hate being placed in the middle of other family members’ issues!

Whenever my mom would ask me personal questions about other family members, I quickly told her, “Why are you asking me about them? If you want information about them, speak to them directly. Do on place me in the middle!”

I have a cousin who does with family members.

She finally figured out that I will not give her information.

Usually every neighborhood has a person like this too.

There is a woman who rides her bicycle around in mine.

She sees people outside and wants to know ‘all the scoop’ on everyone!

I tell her nothing! She asked me how were my neighbors paying their bills after the dad got laid off from work.

I told her, “I am so happy that you are interested in helping the neighbors out with their bills.”

Her face turned red as a beet as she rode off on her bicycle!

Once, she confided in me that her husband told her that the reason that she never kept friends is because she was always minding everyone’s business and telling secrets.

So no one spoke to this woman.

I referred to her as the ‘wicked witch of the West’ from Wizard of Oz!

Others called her Mrs. Kravitz from Bewitched. Hahaha

Do not allow anyone to place you in the middle of issues.
HilaryHilary Feb 2021
Thank you for your response. I suppose I am so used to passing on messages to people for her as she doesn't use email and gets in a muddle when talking on the phone! (She is 86 and has some dementia). I think I probably over-reacted to her agitation and wanting to avoid trouble probably made it worse. I won't be doing any more messages for family members!
notgoodenough Feb 2021
I think you've been used as the message-bearer quite enough, don't you? It seems as if your mom and your brother are happy to create drama - from your brother not calling, to your mom not giving her number out to family members, which is her right. Your biggest mistake was getting in the middle of this, calling your brother at mom's behest.

So, if I were you, I would apologize to both your mom and brother - to the effect of "I'm sorry that this has upset both of you so much; since I seemed to have made matters worse, in the future I will leave the two of you to sort out your differences directly and stay out of it." I would send it in an email to both of them, and then if they continue on with this situation, gently but firmly tell them you will NOT discuss it any further and if they have a problem with each other, they need to talk to each other about it. You only need to apologize once - don't fall into the trap of being made to feel this is all your fault.

No offense intended to you, but this sounds like so much high-school drama to me. Remove yourself from it, ASAP.
HilaryHilary Feb 2021

ADVERTISEMENT

Ask a Question

Subscribe to
Our Newsletter