Follow
Share

My Dad has been going downhill.. every time I go home to see him, he has lost more weight and can't seem to keep up with what's going on around him. Then he sleeps most of the day.
My mother just had a pacemaker put in, so her days of being caregiver have gone, because she can't do a lot right now. So she asked my Dad's Dr. About a program to get a caregiver in the house to give my dad a bath and help get him in his chair and back in bed. (My dad is completely disabled)
The Dr. actually suggested at home hospice care. Is she trying to tell my family something? I have had plenty of people tell me that hospice doesn't always mean the end... but I have had people tell me the opposite. I know my daddy is declining rapidly and I want him to have the absolute best care... I just wish the doctor would tell us what is really on her mind... What do you think?

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
I can think of two reasons why the doc suggested hospice. The first is your father is "going downhill." The second is if he may pass within six months, hospice provides a lot of support not just to the patient but also to family members.

I strongly recommend a frank talk with the doctor. Unless you have medical POA--I don't believe you do--you may have to take your father and mother to the doc's often and ask tough questions. It's possible your doctor can do this via the internet and video chatting. Hospice has to be prescribed. Ask those tough questions.

It's true hospice isn't the end. Hospice is geared for those who are likely to die within six months but some do continue on or even are released from hospice because they're doing so well.

I'm sorry you and your beloved parents are going through this.

On a side note, to help you help them, encourage them to have their end-of-life affairs in order (will, living trusts, POAs, et al). I hope you all feel comfortable for them to transfer the authority for you to act on their behalf--if you're willing to accept it.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
Ballen1012 Dec 2021
My mother is his POA, but we make decisions together. I'm also listed on all HIPAA paperwork, so doctors will give me answers.
I guess I will have to get more stern with them. They are communicating to my mother and my mother has anxiety about Hospice because all of her life. That has always ment "The end".
I'm afraid the doctor may be sugar coating everything on my mother's behalf.
(1)
Report
"I just wish the doctor would tell us what is really on her mind..." - I'd ask. Be frank and clear, "Have you recommended hospice because you think my father is near the end? How long do you think he has?" This sort of question, asked clearly and calmly, may prompt her to be clear in turn - she may be avoiding this wording because she's not sure how the family will take it, emotionally. Also, you say you recognize that he is declining rapidly - if you've said the same to her, she may think that you and she are on the same page about your dad's condition and that she doesn't need to clarify.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
Ballen1012 Dec 2021
This doctor is new for him. I have tried telling my mother that he is "declining rapidly." (She agrees first and then seems to think he is ok.)
I have not had the opportunity to speak with this doctor personally. My mother has, and the way my mother is informing me of the doctor's decision for hospice, dosen't sound normal. According to my mother, She is making it sound like an aid is just coming in to help her give him a bath and move him from point A to Point B for her and that's not all that hospice is. Either the doctor is not telling my mother everything or my mother just isn't comprehending this. My mother honestly dosen't want to hear anything other than that, so she won't ask those tough questions. So I know I'm going to have to.
(2)
Report
You have to realize that the human body has an expiration date, which cannot be reset. It seems that the doctor can do no more for your father. Yes, hospice can be the end of the rope. Brace yourself. You don't need to feel guilty, it's not your fault.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
Cover99 Dec 2021
Right, she is trying to drop him to focus on those who still have a chance of living.
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
Call the doctor and ask these questions, it’s okay to want a clearer idea of what to expect. Hospice was a great help to my dad and our family, I hope you’ll find the same
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Drs don't bandy about the term 'hospice' for the fun of it.

They 'see' things we don't and have far more experience with EOL behavior.

Yes, sit down with Dr and ask whatever ?? you may have. Hospice can be a beautiful, peaceful and HUMANE thing to do.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

The doctor is trying to subtly drop him from her care. Happens all the time.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
Daughterof1930 Dec 2021
Leaping assumption. Not all doctors are the same, much like all of us as we all differ
(4)
Report
See 1 more reply
Hospice IS end of life care. There is no longer treatment of illnesses though there is such treatment as needed for comfort. However, today many docs, desperate to help situations just like yours, will fudge the rules of death expected within six months, to get more help. This CAN be a mistake at times, because hospice is trained to give medications to sooth and ease pain, EVEN IF these medications are given in amounts that may hasten death.
You need to speak with the doctor and with the hospice team about your own particular case and I wish you good luck. Hopefully there is a POA taking over from Mom now who will need all the help she can get.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
TouchMatters Dec 2021
No, Hospice is not totally 'end of life' care.
This is my understanding.
This is really important to know. Otherwise, we will both confuse people here.
(2)
Report
See 1 more reply
Hospice is wonderful. 6 months left to live is what they say qualifies, but many people live longer than that and can stay on if they do. Basically, Hospice just means he is not go get care to make any of his issues better, just keep him comfortable. If he needs surgery or something, he ha to go off it, but can go back on. Don't hesitate to get the doctor's recommendation for your dad to have them come. However, since your mom is not able to do as much now, you may also need to hire another caregiver for him. Hospice will bathe him and get him in his chair and send a nurse once a week, yes, but aren't there many more chores that he needs done for him?
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
Ballen1012 Dec 2021
@MACinCT

*telling "her" mother.
(1)
Report
You don't just start receiving help from hospice because a Dr. referred you to them. And if a Dr. refers someone it is because he/she believes that their patient has 6 months or less to live.
Now that being said, the patient still has to qualify for hospice care, as hospice does have guidelines that they must follow.
My husband was under in home hospice care for the last 22 months of his life, so you can see many people outlive the 6 month timeline.
The purpose of hospice now will be to just keep your dad comfortable in his final days here on earth, however long that will be. And remember only God knows the day and time that He will call your dad home, so just enjoy whatever time you may have left with him and leave nothing left unsaid.
Blessings to you and your family.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Why not speak to your dad's doctor directly about what s/he feels is going on with your dad?

But if he's obviously going downhill and losing weight rapidly, sleeping most of the day, then he's likely approaching the end of his life. When there's nothing medically more that can be done for an elder, that's when hospice services are called in to help.

My mother had a friend who lived for 3 years on hospice. But normally, hospice services are called in when the elder is thought to have 6 months or less to live. The person must QUALIFY for hospice also, otherwise Medicare won't pay for it.

People here are making ridiculous/unfounded statements about your dad's doctor 'trying to subtly drop him from her care. Happens all the time.' When a doctor drops a patient, they lose that income generated by the patient as well, which makes NO sense. If this doctor has treated your dad for quite some time, why would you not trust her to have his best interest in mind and simply 'drop him' b/c she wants to get rid of him? That's the ridiculous statement here, imo. The medical people who have cared for both of my parents over the years have truly CARED for them and when it was time to recommend hospice care, they did so with compassion and with good reason. It was because my parents were sick and dying.

In my experience, when an elder is approaching end of life, the last thing that's good for them is to keep going back & forth to the hospital to be poked and prodded and tested with loud MRI machines and needles etc. They should be left in peace & comfort to enjoy their remaining time on Earth. That's the beauty of hospice. My mother was accepted into hospice care yesterday and already they brought her a better wheelchair to try to prevent her many falls. Already they've taken her off of the many vitamins & supplements she's been given daily b/c the nurse feels they're contributing to her chronic nausea. And, at 95, what good is vitamins and supplements ANYWAY?

Wishing you the best of luck getting the answers you seek and understanding what's happening with dad. Peace and prayers sent your way.
Helpful Answer (9)
Report

Trust me, I understand your confusion. We are all pretty confused by all of the uncertainties of what may be happening when someone is going through their last months or years. Part of the difficulty is that, really, nobody can say what is going on, exactly. Do get as clear an answer as you can from the doctors, but they are often vague because each case is so different.

My Mom was dying for 3 weeks or 6 months or 10 years, depending on the symptoms, the definitions, and the optimism of the person considering. She lasted longer than anyone predicted and actually enjoyed her failing years more than one might expect. If your Dad qualifies for hospice, go for it. We found the hospice people to be very helpful. The other helpful thing might be to not even try to guess how much time your Dad has.

He could die tomorrow, he could live another couple of years. It depends on what it going on in his body and how strong he is. That strength is not just physical. Mom was unable to lift more than a couple of pounds in her last years (she died at 96), but her ability to withstand disease and disability was astounding. As we all said in her final years, she was "a tough old bird." On the other hand, my Dad, who was strong as an ox died in an instant when he was 62. He was walking across the lawn and simply fell over dead. Try to take some pleasure in remembering good times, looking at photo albums with your Dad, and taking it a day at a time. Do whatever you can to make the journey easier for you both. Hospice sounds like a really good thing for now.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

You need to ask your dad's MD vs trying to guess what she means by this suggestion. If the MD doesn't tell you/the family what is 'really on her mind,' you need to very specifically ask and tell her what information you need to know.
It sounds like you need to be more assertive to acquire the information you need vs waiting or wondering what is going on.

[It is my understanding] In California, a person on Hospice for six months is re-evaluated to determine if they continue to qualify for Hospice.
* Hospice will not give medication to 'keep someone alive' so you need to be very clear on what will be provided by Hospice and what care your Dad's medical provider will provide, if any care.
* Hospice wants to keep a person 'comfortable' -

Get everything in writing and have at least two people from your family talk to the MD together and to Hospice administrator.

Gena / Touch Matters
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

My Husband was on Hospice for almost 3 years.
What Hospice can mean is that given the “normal” course an illness takes, with no intervention a person’s life expectancy is 6 months or fewer.
It also means that a person has reached a point where further treatment will not cure or improve their life. If a person wishes to pursue treatment then Hospice would not be recommended but Palliative care could be.
I think your dad’s doctor has done you and the family a great disservice in not fully explaining the prognosis and the reason or reasons she has recommended Hospice.
With Hospice though your dad will get supplies he needs to be safely cared for at home. Your mom will get support as well. A Nurse will come at least 1 time a week to check him, a CNA will come at least 2 times a week to shower/ bathe him and order supplies. They can also take advantage of other services.
I can honestly say I would not have been able to care for my Husband the way I did if it had not been for Hospice and that Angels that work there.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Hospice care is the kind of care that is delivered at home, with a priority on the patient's comfort. It can mean discontinuing lots of specialist visits, regular lab tests, and other interventions meant to monitor chronic illnesses, slow their progression, and delay complications. (Heart failure, BP and lipid and blood sugar problems, chronic kidney disease, and all the other accumulated chronic conditions. most of us will have in our final decade or so.
Diseases that do occur such as urinary tract infection or chest infection can be treated in hospice, and will be if that is the pt/family choice - but an infection that keeps coming back after oral antibiotics is allowed to progress. If patient can no longer swallow oral medications, the meds are discontinued - not replaced by injections or IV doses.
Hospices do not hasten death...and they know a lot about meds and other interventions to relieve distress/promote comfort. Conversations about medications start at admission, to try to dispel the idea that "hospice gives patients morphine to make them die."
Talk more with the doctor...and talk to a couple of local hospice agencies. The ones that are willing to come see you and your folks and listen to concerns and provide information are much better than the ones that come out with the enrollment forms all filled in for you to sign!
Ask about staff continuity and after hours coverage...a different nurse every two weeks is not good care. An answering service that calls back in a few hours is not good care. (hospice nurse suggestions)
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

My mother is in flat out denial. I won't be able to speak with his hospice coordinator until tomorrow, but I tried to get some more information from my mother today. 
Her words were... "They didn't put him on this program, because he is dying." "It's a different kind of Hospice care?"
I didn't know hospice had different programs?
They brought him all kinds of equipment today... a nurse came and checked him over... 
I will speak with the hospice coordinator myself, but I had no clue "Hospice" had different programs? Not sure if my mother is understanding everything or just not wanting to understand everything.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
Grandma1954 Dec 2021
Most Hospice will do Palliative Care. In most cases with Palliative Care you do not get the equipment, supplies that you would get on Hospice.
Hospice does not mean he is going to die right now or very soon. As I mentioned my Husband was on Hospice for 3 years.
The great thing about Hospice is..if your mom decides, or actually if dad decides if he is cognizant that he no longer wants Hospice service he can withdraw and return to his other doctors. Later if they decide that it is time for Hospice they can be called and will evaluate him again for service.
(2)
Report
See 2 more replies
I would think she was telling you something, but perhaps the best thing to do is ask her? She is only a Doctor, most of them don't bite and whilst respect is reasonable being overly deferential or afraid to speak to her is not. - This is NOT a criticism, a lot of people find Doctors imposing due to both their reputation and their manner, but honestly you are free to ask questions of her and especially your father's prognosis as you feel there has been quite a decline. She owes you an explanation of that although unless you have POA she may want your father to tell her she can talk to you about his health.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
Ballen1012 Dec 2021
My Daddy has made it very clear to everyone he has come in contact with, that I am allowed to know everything going on with him. My mother is telling me, what she has been told.... Which is only what she wants to hear. She won't accept anything else.
I love my mother so much, it just makes me sad that she suffers with such denial. She has moments where she breaks down crying about his condition, then she bounces right back... Telling me he is fine.
I have held conversation with her about this, and it just makes her upset. I just don't want reality to slam in to her all at once.
(2)
Report
I agree that the statement, by itself, is ambiguous. Unfortunately doctors are seldom able to accurately predict a person's life expectancy (with a few obvious exceptions, such as someone who's in the final stages of decline).

Nonetheless, a straightforward question along the lines of "Is my father approaching (or near) end of life?" would be appropriate, assuming you're prepared for an honest answer. For by asking you signal to the physician that you want to know and will be able to handle the answer.

It's true that many hospice patients live longer than estimated (although some of this is probably for-profit hospice organizations signing up patients who may not meet Medicare's eligibility-for-hospice guidelines. In any case, before signing up with the first hospice to offer services try to do some research to see which of those available might provide the best service.

You might also do some work to understand what hospice will and will not do. For the reality is, hospice will provide at best a few (less than daily) visits, and these will generally be less than an hour each. And as a hospice patient declines, someone (not hospice) almost always will have to assume the burden of providing daily care and companionship.

In any case, the first step is to ask for a reasonably complete and honest medical assessment. Doctors tend to be hesitant in offering this as not everyone is necessarily ready to hear the full story.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Ballen1012, I can fully understand what your mom is going through.
It is not easy to comprehend that your spouse, the person that you have spent most of your life with, raised a family is going to die.
I had Hospice and I had the support from them. I also fully understood what the prognosis was and I spent 12 years watching the Love of my Life slowly decline. I, in my mind was prepared. NOTHING prepared me for the day he died.
I have said that you are ruled by 2 major organs. Your Head and your Heart. You have to trust that when the time comes that the Head is the one that makes the important decisions.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

The best part of hospice is that the medical professionals come to you instead of you having to get Dad to them. That alone is a huge help, and the care is much more personalized with the hospice nurses than with any doctor.

Dad is "dying," but he may not be dying tomorrow. He's declining, and bringing hospice aboard changes the focus from fixing the unfixable to making his quality of life better. If he takes medicines that no longer work, they'll probably take him off them or reduce them. (That's with everyone in agreement -- not an automatic thing.)

My mother was on hospice for almost eight months, and nothing changed in her general treatment until we began to withdraw medications that were no longer working about three weeks before she died. Otherwise, the reason I put her on hospice was mainly because I was not going to subject her to the trauma of any more hospital stays.She was treated in place as much as was possible, and it worked very well.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

I want to thank everyone for the information and comforting words.
My Dad has many health issues at 83 and I want what is best for him, no matter how bad the truth hurts me. I was just curious if anyone relates to my confusion.
Its never easy to lose a parent, let alone at 26 years old. Watching my Dad decline has absolutely tore me apart.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
MJ1929 Dec 2021
You're terribly young to be losing a parent -- I'm so sorry.

Keep in mind that your mom might not be the best person to handle Dad's medical decisions if she's in such denial. Is it possible for you to at least be put on as a secondary POA for Dad? Is he competent to do that?

Take advantage of the counseling and social worker available through hospice to help you and your mom. Hospice is not just for the patient -- they're there for the family, too. If the hospice company doesn't feel you and your mom are also important, consider getting another company. I had to do that when my dad was on hospice. Their social worker said, "This isn't about you" when I asked what kind of support they offer the family. 😠 They were fired the next day. (Not only for that reason, though.) The new company made all the arrangements to switch everything over from the first company, and we didn't have to do anything except put Dad in bed in another room for 45 minutes while they switched out his medical equipment (hospital bed mainly).

Good luck, and keep asking all the questions you want.
(4)
Report
Do you think that your Dad has health issues that need major medical intervention and treatment, and that the treatment is likely to be successful in turning things around for him? If you do think this, then hospice is not appropriate for him.

If you don’t think this, then there is everything to gain and nothing to lose by involving hospice. He and your mother will get more help, he will have excellent care to minimise pain and discomfort, and he will not die any sooner. It may be less than 6 months, it may be much more. Only the medical issues kill. Hospice helps, it doesn’t kill.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Hospice is not always end of life care, however, they are all about making their client comfortable, not prolonging life. If that is what your family agrees is "the plan" then find a Hospice provider. My experience with Hospice has been mostly positive, but like everyone else in our area, they struggled with employee shortages from the beginning. The CNAs have been great for helping with Mom's personal needs. The RNs have been great with all other monitoring and care. The social workers even came in and decorated the Christmas tree! They helped us get hospital equipment needed to enable me to help her better myself. Prescriptions are ordered and filled with no charge to Mom. If necessary, I can run short errands or jump in the shower while they visit with Mom. They have a pastor, but Mom has agreed to have him visit so I haven't yet. The only drawback is they do NOT offer sitter service, which is $24-$28 per hour with a 4-hour minimum in our area. Respite care on Mom's insurance is provided at their facility for 5 consecutive days per month, but I have not taken advantage of this. Our experience has been very positive.

I know that my mother does not want her life prolonged. She has told me numerous times over the years. She has signed a DNR form. Hospice was the right choice for us. Evaluate carefully before moving forward. Make the logical decision for your family based on what you know. Try not to think with your heart. It makes difficult decisions even more difficult.

Praying for you and your family. These decisions are not easy for anyone.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Accepting hospice means abandoning any medical treatment or rehabilitation meant to be curative or something to prolong life such as tube feeding or intubation. The focus is on keeping the patient as comfortable as possible. So something like a UTI will be addressed, but he would not receive surgery to correct a heart valve. He will also be given pain medication with no concern about him becoming addicted to it.

Usually an aide is sent around three times a week to provide bathing, and a nurse will come maybe once a week to monitor, but you will not get around the clock care as it seems he needs. You would have to provide that with private pay aides unless you have long term care insurance or want to put him into a facility.

You can call the hospice company and ask to speak with the nurse who did his evaluation to be brought up to speed.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

No matter the reason you should probably prepare yourself. Here when a Dr refers you to hospice the criteria is less than 6 months to live. But the Dr might be trying to be be helpful and a work around so your mother can have help, either way with sleeping all day situation that is a symptom I saw in later years of life, closer to the end. Good luck 💜
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Why is your Doctor not giving you all the facts? With due respect, something is missing. I've not heard of a doctor who would leave you in the dark and not answer your question. Yes, I've heard of people in hospice care for years, years. But it also usually means that some level of care will not be available to your Dad. My response is I don't understand why your Doctor isn't clarifying this. It could be that she simply feels that no treatment is going to be beneficial, she has done all she can do. Is this doctor the PC? The family's GP? Before hospice, speak to the doctor and tell her you need clarity to make the hospice decision. Failing that, request a referral to a specialist. I will say that sleeping most of the day does indicate a possibility of end of life scenario but not its certainty. Again, I've just never heard of a family doctor who is intentionally keeping family confused on such an important decision.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

In Mass, the provider must certify that pt is expected to live less than 1 yr to qualify for hospice. Speak to the MD.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Tell the Dr instead of putting Dad on Hospice that you would like him to be on Home Health.

Hospice Care is end of life and it's really giving up Dr's appointmentso, Hospital Stays, Ect once on Hospice, you are made to be kept comfortable by the use of pain pills, etc.

Home Health is much better because it gives you the option to continue with treatments whenever needed.

With Home Health you also will get Aids 3 times a week to clean you up and you'll get a Nurse come by once a week to check your vitals and a Nurse Practioner come once a month.

You can also have therapy done if they think it will help.

The main difference between Hospice and Home Health is you intend to keep doing things to help you live longer. Once on Hospice, you've decided whatever happens happens and you won't be running to the Hospital, you'll just get meds at home to keep you out of pain.

Of course with Hospice, you will get a Hospital Bed, Potty Chair. Walker, diapers things free to use where on Home Health, you have to furnish everything yourself.

I would choose Home Health.

Onice the situation Getz worse, you can always switch to Hospice when you really plan to let things take it's course.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

One needs to face the facts. Medical care is not magic, miracles don't exist. Once all available medical treatment have been tried, there is no more to be done. Instead of sending patients back home to die, we have now hospices where the goal is to make the dying patient more comfortable. The human body is designed to die after reaching its expiration date. It's a harsh reality.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
craftslady1 Dec 2021
Most hospice care takes place in the home, not an official hospice facility. Most people who are in those facilities have no one to help them at home or else have homes not suitable for their care. Hospice workers will also take care of people already living in nursing homes.
(0)
Report
my friend was with Hospice three times. She came home. Lived another seven years before she passed. Let the family decide when it is time to say good by to your dad.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Your doctor is trying to help - with hospice care in your home, you will get many services. A part time in home aide, a weekly nurse visit, social worker, even a visit from a clergyman. It provides care items such as walker, diapers, oxygen, hospital bed, etc. You CAN choose to retain your own doctor, and I would advise that you do when you sign up. You can always change your mind later. If your Dad needs emergency care and needs to get to hospital, it is your right to send him there but he will go off hospice during that time. Hospice can be re-started upon his return home. The criterion to meet hospice is that the patient can die within 6 months, and the patient is assessed every 3 months - at which time the hospice care can be extended or denied. There is nothing to lose by putting your dad in hospice care at home - it will give your Mom the help she needs and your Dad will be cared for in his own home. Just do the research on which hospice care company will be the best fit for you. Ask questions, make sure you have POA, and stay involved to advocate your Dad's needs. Patients can be off and on hospice care for years - so don't focus on the hospice word - rather on the services it provides.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter