Follow
Share

I found this article to be really interesting.



Written by, Rachael Bernstein LMFT, MSEd



It’s too long of an article to list everything. So, I am going to highlight the most relevant aspects that I feel fits in regards to caregiving.



Feelings of guilt



When you say “Yes” you may avoid having feelings of guilt. If you are prone to feeling a high level of guilt and feel as if you’re responsible for everything, then you will worry about feeling guilty if you say “No.”



You feel as if you are letting people down. You don’t know if you can live with yourself if you say “No.” You fear hearing the words, “We thought we could count on you.” So you say “Yes” to avoid hearing these words.



Family Influence



Saying “Yes” is related to the behavioral conditioning you went through while growing up. You learned to become a ‘people pleaser’ and never to say “No” to anyone in authority.



Lack of Energy



You might say “Yes” because you don’t have the energy to say “No.” If you have been neglected, abused or pushed to the brink, you are depleted of your energy. You may be so exhausted that you cannot handle being questioned, having to defend or justify your position or having someone upset with you.



Responsible



You often feel responsible for other people’s emotions. If you say “No” to someone and they become angry, you feel responsible for their anger. You will then do whatever will make things right to avoid “making them angry” again.



Integrity



Manipulators use the word “integrity” often. They expect you to be open to anything and say “Yes” to everything. Ironically, people who are manipulative do not have any integrity themselves.



Conditional Relationship



You sense that the relationship that you have is conditional rather than unconditional. You are afraid to say “No” to test the waters. You say “Yes” to please them. You are afraid to say “No” to set firm boundaries.



Dependent Personality



You are afraid of someone detaching from you if you say “No” You say “Yes” so you won’t feel abandoned.



Rescue Hero



You have found that it feels good to jump in and be the rescue hero, a savior by agreeing to do something. This is internally driven motivation. Controlling people love when people are motivated by thinking they are doing the ‘right thing’ because they don’t have to work so hard to coerce you to serve them.



Fear Of The Unknown



Saying “No” places you in the realm of the unknown. Some people will gravitate towards the familiar rather than opening the door up to the unknown. So they continue to agree and say “Yes” to others.



Reliance



You have either told yourself or others have told you that you are the only one that can do this job. So you may feel as if everything will fall apart if you say “No.”

This discussion has been closed for comment. Start a New Discussion.
Does anyone recognize themselves in any of these situations?
(2)
Report

I'm so very grateful that I have NEVER been a yes person, however I know lots of folks who are, and they stay stressed and overwhelmed all the time.
NO is a complete sentence. Period.
(1)
Report

Funky,

It is interesting.

No judgement from me about people who struggle with “Yes” and “No” because all of us have lived different lives and we process things individually.

I had my struggles and I had plenty of reasons as to why I struggled.
(3)
Report

Guilty of at least 3 of these .
My DH always tells me I say “ Yes “ too often to please people .
He’s right .
(2)
Report

Way,

I see a lot of people struggling on this forum. I have been there too.

My hope is that people will see this thread and know that there is no judgement and that they will see that there are valid reasons why they have struggled.

Growing up in a dysfunctional family certainly affects us.
(4)
Report

Wow.. This is an excellent find Need.

I do say no.. but I think I need to read, read & read again.

Someone I am supporting just will not say no. It puzzles me to say the least!

I see so many threads also where posters ask a question or vent their tale as if there wasn't a *no* option at al all. Saying Yes to avoiding saying No..? Looking at the movitvation behind this is very illuminating.
(3)
Report

Beatty,

It is interesting that some of our brains are wired a certain way to become susceptible to these things.
(2)
Report

That's a very interesting article. Thanks for posting!

Often more than one reason is involved when people say yes.

People who claim to "do the right thing" or "take the high road" so that they can "sleep at night" or "look themselves in the mirror." Those are pat answers, and I bet many people never realize why they are really saying yes.
(5)
Report

Excellent thread Need! Thanks for posting it. >>Yes and No person here<<
If speaking about being a caregiver for a LO, nobody asked me. I already lived w/ our mom (and dad bfore he died) but not as a CG for them. They were both in good health, 100% independent. After moms hospital fiasco she needed care&my sister assumed it was my responsibility. Nice huh?
(4)
Report

CTTN55,

Sadly, some of the things listed rang a bell for me.
(2)
Report

Cat,

I hear you and feel your pain too! There are many things I wish that I could do over.
(3)
Report

I think as children we aren't taught that we could say No. My Mom was a homemaker and because of that relatives, who worked, thought she had time to help them. Not that my Mom had 4 kids and the 5th one was my Dad. I am not sure if she ever said no. My Dad is one of 8 kids, 6 living in the same town. My brother lived in another State and was home for a visit. Mom got a call that our grandmother, her MIL, was in the hospital again and could she go sit with her. My Mom did not say "Sorry, no, J is here visiting". She went. My brother picked up a phone call later and it was an Aunt, grandmoms daughter, asking where my Mom was, J said "In the hospital sitting with your mother". My Aunt got the point because she complained to Mom. So, we were raised by a person who only said no to her kids.

Me, at 73 I am learning the word no. Seems my friends have no problem using the word. If I don't want to do something, I now say no. I am retired, my time is my own.
(4)
Report

You’re right, JoAnn

As children most of us weren’t allowed to say “No.”

Depending on how difficult our childhood situation was, not being able to say “No” can carry over into adulthood.
(1)
Report

I just wish I had found this forum before I starting taking care of my mom. Things would’ve been much different.
(3)
Report

Jada,

I second that! I didn’t know what I didn’t know.
(2)
Report

JoAnn is right.

Many of us are taught we can’t say No to our parents , no matter how old we get.
(4)
Report

Way,

Plus every household has different family dynamics. Some people truly don’t understand the struggles that some of us have faced growing up and how strong of an impact it had on us throughout our lives.

Those who are wise seek out therapy to find answers. Therapy helped me tremendously.
(5)
Report

I think this is very interesting. I had a hard time saying NO because I never wanted to disappoint someone or have them be mad at me. Funny these same people had no trouble telling me no. In my 30s I was afraid to say no. In my 40s I started finding my voice. And it was a shock when I stopped being all accommodating. In my 50s I am in danger of biting people who displease me. I guess it is all about maturing and realizing that I matter too.
(9)
Report

Ikdrymom,

I hear you. Very often things are one sided!

Sometimes, things are so subtle in the beginning that we don’t recognize what we are doing. Until we get sick and tired of being sick and tired.

You’re so right about us maturing enough to understand what is happening!
(2)
Report

It’s sad for me to see new posters come to the forum broken from caregiving and they are sometimes scolded by certain people for their actions or lack of actions.

Here’s the thing, first of all, they need to feel safe. They have been criticized enough by their parents. Secondly they are looking for comfort and deserve to have empathy and support from the forum.

They have been raised in a way that they truly don’t know how to say “No.” It’s going to take them awhile to process that other people have lived a different type of life and do know how to say “No.”

Even if they haven’t been happy, they have been in their situation for so long that it has become normalized for them.
(5)
Report

Hi NHWM - Really Thank You for creating such an important post. You so eloquently have touched on and addressed so many critical issues - and the range of emotions that one goes through in this challenging and difficult process.
XO
(4)
Report

Thanks, Hope

I enjoy reading your posts and know that you are capable of understanding all of the different aspects of caregiving.

Some people don’t seem to have the capability to see the reasons why things are as they are.

It takes time to process information and deconstruct what they have learned throughout their entire life.
(4)
Report

Hi NHWM - You're very welcome - I really enjoy reading your posts and comments too!!  In fact, after a recent OP's post that sparked an elaborate debate, this post that you created is so timely, helpful and insightful!
(3)
Report

Thanks, Hope.

Things aren’t always as simple as they appear to be, especially if we have grown up in dysfunctional families. We are confused growing up and life becomes very complicated.

I find that a lot of people question a situation, or judge others without knowing or understanding what the background story is.
(3)
Report

I think that saying "no" to your parent is a sign of adulthood.

I was very fortunate that I got to witness my mom setting limits and saying "no" to her mom early in my life.
(3)
Report

Barb,

Absolutely!

Most of us naturally yearned to be independent by the time we reached adolescence.

Some of us were able to maintain wanting to remain independent as adults and others became trapped by our various circumstances.

I was certainly trapped by my unhealthy thoughts for many years. We aren’t functioning as adults as long as we are living with our parents.

I became trapped because I felt it was my responsibility to do everything myself. It wasn’t my responsibility.

I wish that I could have been like you and many others who didn’t choose to do the hands on caregiving themselves.

Looking back, I can see that it becomes unhealthy for our parents too. We taught them to solely rely on us.

I never saw my parents take care of their parents, yet I still felt responsible for them. I think part of that was because I was the only girl and the most dependable child.

Once we start ‘at home’ care in ‘our’ homes, it seems to become harder to break away from it. It is better not to start it if possible. Or at least, set a reasonable time frame for how long the care at home will last.
(3)
Report

I saw my Grandparents say no, setting reasonable limits on babysitting. I saw Aunts saying no, setting limits to how much caregiving to give their aging parent when at home & also deciding the big things like guest status or permanent live-in when unable to live alone. I saw many times no to unhealthy situations, especially women deciding enough & leaving if a spouse's depression or drinking got out of hand.

I also saw the discussions on what were reasonable limits to set. How these could differ. One day a week of elder care was the top limit for some of my Aunts, but my Mother decided more would be OK for her. My Father had endless ability to give.. which I saw as generous... inability to say no??Hmm

OK here's a theory.. do the youngest children get more conditioned to say yes? Having to obey their parents but also older siblings (or even cousins)?
(3)
Report

Beatty,

Interesting that you bring up babysitting.

Our children had a beautiful bond with their grandparents. They babysat occasionally but I never wanted to take advantage of them.

I can see how a grandparent could get tired of babysitting if it was an everyday occurrence. For the most part we hired sitters when we needed them
(1)
Report

Need, I had a list of sitters, Grands being up there with Aunts but also others, including non-family paid sitters.

It IS harder for single parents that's for sure. But same as for elder-care, child-care needs to be a fair arrangement for both sides. Some Grandparents raise their grandchildren completely while the parents work. This was a common occurance for migrants in my city when I grew up. Probably still is. Many have that social arrangement of shared family care, old & young.

My parents, like you & like me, had the Grands sit occassionaly, never wanting to take advantage. They mostly made they own local arrangements.

I was truly shocked when someone called me with plans to make a roster for regular school children pick up, 45mins away, to save the parents paying a sitter! Ignoring my job + collecting my OWN children!

I had wished there was word that meant no + are you kidding + get some commonsense + a reality check.
(4)
Report

Beatty,

Yeah, some things do leave us speechless because we can’t find a word to describe it. A roster to pick up a child? Wow! That’s asking for a bit much when you were working and had your own child.

On the phone is hard because they can’t see our facial expressions.

In person, though, we can show a ‘puzzled or shocked’ look to get our message across to them.

LOL 😆 Then, the expression on our faces tells the whole story of how we feel about it.
(3)
Report

This discussion has been closed for comment. Start a New Discussion.
Start a Discussion
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter