Follow
Share

My sister bailed on me 2 years ago, moving far away, leaving me “holding the bag” alone, as far as caring for our parents. But even when she lived nearby, she never, ever offered a bit of help, not even for relatively minor things. On the rare occasions that I asked her to give me a hand, she always said No, with a lame excuse. I finally gave up asking her for help, or even confiding in her about any of it. And once I did that, it was sort of a relief. Once you stop asking for, or silently expecting anything from such a person, it’s actually a relief to just do what needs to be done without waiting for others to do the right thing and step up to the plate with you…



Anyway, even though I have totally stopped complaining to her or confiding in her about how overwhelmed, miserable, and alone I constantly feel, my sister still often likes to compare how her daughter raising 4 kids is just as overwhelming and stressful as caring for two elderly parents. I just let her talk. And then change the subject. When she calls me, I am polite towards her, with NO attitude. But for me, that’s the extent of it, and I’m unable to muster up much else…



But her comparison is ridiculous. It’s like comparing apples and bananas.



I also find her comparison is dismissive of what I am going through because it minimizes the magnitude of it, as far as the anxiety and depression that is caused by caring for two elderly parents in their 90’s for the past several years.



Is raising 4 children overwhelming and stressful? YES, of course it is. But the massive difference is that it is a journey that is also filled with great JOY as you watch your children grow and accomplish new things.



In comparison, caring for elderly parents is basically a front row seat to watch them slowly deteriorate more and more and more. To watch them lose their independence, their strength, their health, their hobbies, their family and friends, their home in some cases, and so much more. Old age is all about LOSS. There is NO joy in old age. Nor is there any joy in caring for elderly parents…



I care for my parents out of LOVE. But there is NO joy in it. I am absolutely HEART BROKEN to witness all they have lost, and all they continue to lose. I often leave their house with tears in my eyes because I can’t stand it…



So please, sis, do NOT compare the caring of our parents to the raising of your grandchildren. It’s so invalidating and lacking empathy, and it makes me feel even more alone on this journey…

This discussion has been closed for comment. Start a New Discussion.
You raise good points, but I have to wonder if your sister who “bailed” and moved far away, moved to be closer to and more involved with her 4 grandchildren? If so, I think that’s a valid choice, though of course it complicates your situation.

Should relationships with grandchildren come second to care of elderly parents?
(3)
Report

Absolutely. While I never raised kids, I would tend to agree that despite the frustrations and anxiety in childrearing, there must be some joy, especially watching a baby develop into a toddler, when they are taking first steps, verbalizing, etc. In caring for the elderly, there's little to no joy. Even for happy occasions the amount of work involved in trying to get them to an event often outweighs the event itself. You can never really enjoy yourself because you're busy looking after the needs of the loved one. I wonder if caregiving for a chronically, severely ill child is also this joy diminishing.
(3)
Report

Even if it’s a valid choice, her comparison is incorrect, invalidating, and hurtful.

But her moving hasn’t complicated my situation at all because even when she lived nearby, she never, ever helped. Never offered, and never said Yes when I occasionally asked her.
(2)
Report

Exactly! The prep itself is so exhausting, and caring for them while at the event prevents any real relaxation and enjoyment of it for the caregiver.
(3)
Report

You know I wouldn't even compare the two experiences to apples and bananas because it doesn't even do it justice.

Raising kids are the apples (the apple of your eye as the saying goes).
Elderly caregiving is like a moldy piece of bread. You can't just leave it there on its own. If it isn't taken care of eventually it will ruin the rest of the loaf (the adult caregiver child's family, marriage, job, home).
Sometimes when there's advancing dementia, caringiving for that kind of elder can be described as being the nanny of an adult-sized, very unpleasant toddler. Tantrums, orneriness, diaper changing, bathing, feeding, lifting, etc... I'm sure you get a mental picture.

As you say can be love in caring for elderly, but there is no joy.
There's joy where there's children and what a difference that makes.

Your sister does not want to be a caregiver and has made that pretty plain. She has a right to say no to it and so do you.

Maybe you should consider bringing in some homecare help to give yourself a break and some regular time off.
It may also be time to start getting serious about the possibility that your parents may need to be placed in managed care for their own good as well as yours.

This is something to be considered. I want you to give some mind to this. What happens to them if something happens to you (God forbid)?

Your sister puts them into a "home" then probably forgets about them.
You can get them placed then be a good advocate for them and make sure they are well cared for by staff.

Think about it.
(4)
Report

It’s a different kettle of fish losing a child to cancer. So much of your life is taken over by illness and treatment. You channel so much energy into getting them through that when they die, you’ve lost part of your identity because that’s what you’ve done for so long.

While your child goes through treatment, you live in changing states of anxiety, hope, fortitude, resolve and despair for months or years. Lots of parents say that they were just getting through and running on adrenaline for all this time. This can leave you feeling utterly exhausted.

Tynagh, This is what folks say about taking care of children with cancer, doesn't sound like much joy going on there.
(2)
Report

Children start out helpless, then become more independent over time.
Your parents start out independent, and then become helpless.

Plus, you know that children will become potty trained in 2-4 years. You could very well be changing your parent's diapers for decades.

Babies are small and are easy to control and carry. Parents, not so much.

Children generally do not have mental issues that can be prone to violence. Parents can and do lose their mental faculties.

Children will eventually be able to feed, clothe, and entertain themselves. They become more independent and less of a burden as they age. Parents will do the opposite as they age.

And, most importantly, you choose if you have kids, and how many. Nobody decides that they would like to take care of their parents at some time in the future.
(4)
Report

Thanks for your suggestions!

Neither of my parents have dementia, thank God! Both still as sharp as whips!

They are getting in home care from Visiting Angels, for which I am very grateful!

But there is still plenty that I need to do myself. Doctors’ appointments, anything of a financial nature, house upkeep, all the phone calls that need to be made. Stuff like that. My burden is far more EMOTIONAL in nature than the actual tasks I do for them.
(1)
Report

@SnoopyLove

No. Relationships with grandchildren should never come second to caregiving for elderly parents. Children are more important than elderly parents who have lived their lives.

I say this from experience because my grandmother was the important part of my life when I was a kid. She was the reason why I have any happy memories of my childhood.
I can't even imagine what life would have been like for me without her. She was the parent who loved and cared for me.

Let's be honest here. Elderly people had long lives and they have lived those lives. Of course when they become needy they must be decently care for. Making sure they are cared for should never come at the cost of their adult children's lives, marriages, families, careers, and homes though.

The grandkids are more important than the elderly parents. I can't fault the OP's sister for choosing them. I would too.

The elderly parents can be cared for by homecare or assisted living. The grandchildren can't.
(3)
Report

Well said!
(0)
Report

OP you stated , "Anyway, even though I have totally stopped complaining to her or confiding in her about how overwhelmed, miserable, and alone I constantly feel, my sister still often likes to compare how her daughter raising 4 kids is just as overwhelming and stressful as caring for two elderly parents. I just let her talk. And then change the subject. When she calls me, I am polite towards her, with NO attitude. But for me, that’s the extent of it, and I’m unable to muster up much else…"

Don't take her calls anymore if you don't want. Let it go to voicemail. Get back to her if/when you are in the mood. You are not complaining to her about your parents, there is no reason for her to be giving you a comparison lecture.
I had a narc sister who lived far and I never asked her for help with my parents. Nor did I complain to her. Sis was retired, empty nest. ( I still work and had one teenager still at home at the time) . She used to call me up and literally laugh and ask me if I was still working, and tell me she was glad I was stuck taking care of our parents and not her. She used to brag about all the free time she had and tell me about her various vacations she took. She called herself "a lady of leisure", I stopped taking her calls, told her I was too busy to chit chat. But when i had to finally place my parents in a facility , all of a sudden she wanted to have a say in things. Told me I was wasting money. My parents passed and , and I have nothing to do with my narc sister.

Maybe your sister moved to help out with grandkids , I don't know. The point is your sister wasn't even available for you to at least vent to since she moved. You can't make her help, but she could have at least listened and given some emotional support to you, but she didn't . So you don't have to listen to how hard it is to raise 4 kids. Cut the call short . Politely say , sorry , you are busy, you have to go.
(3)
Report

I hope the admins will move your notes to us to "Discussions".

All you say is true, but of all you say, I suspect that the single most true statement is as follows from your note:

"Once you stop asking for, or silently expecting anything from such a person, it’s actually a relief to just do what needs to be done without waiting for others to do the right thing and step up to the plate with you…"

We get many who think they can change OTHERS as well as care for their elders. It is a lesson to be learned in life that we cannot CHANGE others but we can CHOOSE others. To compare care of elders and children is indeed, as you say, comparing apples and bananas and entirely irrelevant.

As to listening to this nonsense from Sis, yes, I would agree, I would listen politely, but I would ALSO listen very BRIEFLY.

Best to you.
(4)
Report

What I find amazing is that those adult children who bail on their elderly parents because they no longer consider them their “core family” - still totally expect an inheritance, and they make sure they show up for THAT, although they won’t ever lift an occasional finger to help their caregiver sibling…
(3)
Report

Oh, I didn't mean to suggest that caring for a terminally ill child is not stressful or joy sucking. I just didn't want to suggest that a parent didn't find joy in their child. I can't imagine anything worse that watching your child suffer and die.
(1)
Report

I can't see how there can be any joy in caring for a terminally ill child.

Maybe very devout Catholics or Buddhists who take holy vows as nuns or monks that care for the sick can find joy and beauty in the work of caring itself.

These people also take a vow of poverty and will often deprive themselves of the most basic things like food in order to suffer as a sacrifice.
Back when I was in Catholic school the very well-behaved students used get the day off to go and help these monks at the monastary. They took care of sick people, homeless, etc...
I remember one monk who was the nicest person ever had blood on his robe one time. So I asked him if he hurt himself. He said no but was wearing a cilice belt which caused him pain and injury as a Lenten sacrifice. That's pretty old-school.
Devout people like this can maybe find the joy in suffering and pain.
I can't see how regular people can.
(1)
Report

@UmbrellaGirl

You may want to consider dropping Visiting Angels if you still have to take care of so much for them.

I was an in-home caregiver for 25 years and now have my own business.
When I finally went over to private-duty cases (no agency involved) the families of clients basically didn't have to do anything.
I did the housekeeping, doctor's appointments, phone calls, and pretty much A to Z with the exception of banking and bill paying.

Maybe a private-duty caregiver would be there best bet. It would cost about the same or maybe even less than what Visiting Angels gets per hour. You and your parents would get a lot more.
(2)
Report

Sissy is coming up with bogus comparisons simply to try and justify her ridiculous excuses for never helping out with mom. Obviously, had she ever lifted a finger to help, she'd see the huge, glaring difference between caring for children and caring for elders. To even make such a comparison is to underline her ignorance.

You can love your parents AND yourself at the same time by recognizing you're burned out and need a break from caregiving. Please hire some in home help, on moms dime, to relieve you of this workload which is too burdensome. Even God rested on the 7th day.
(3)
Report

I am so sorry you are yet another caregiver let down by their parents’ other child(den). And I could not agree more about the comparison of raising kids to caring for our elderly parents. If I hear one more person call it a “role reversal” I will cry or scream or both. I was no picnic to raise but it was an entirely different situation than the one my mom and I find ourselves in now. Best to you.
(5)
Report

I wanted to add that siblings who don’t help or even visit their parents, come up with the most ridiculous excuses . My brother also lived 4 hours away and when I called to inform him that our mother had had a stroke , he came up with the most ridiculous reply . Mind you I never asked him for help or to come visit . I was merely informing him of my mother’s stroke . Because he and my narc sister wanted to be kept informed of things .
His reply was “ Well we ( meaning my brother and his wife) can’t come because we don’t want to put the dog in the kennel because the last time I did that he got kennel cough”. I didn’t say anything but that’s a ridiculous thing to say because he could have come by himself and left the dog home with his wife .
When I placed my parents in a facility , I eventually decided that I don’t work for my siblings and did not have to keep them as “ in the loop “ anymore with very frequent updates that they thought they were entitiled to. Sibs didn’t show interest all the years before my parents went into a facility . I started a phone chain which my narc sister was not happy about . She wanted a daily phone call from me when Dad was on hospice . I had my other ( willing ) sister calling my narc sister because I did not want to talk to her. Narc sis , would interrogate me like I was her employee . She was getting her kicks out of that , so my other sister said she would talk to her instead . When a parent gets put in a facility and/or they get close to death the sibs come out of the woodwork . It’s amazing .
(3)
Report

@UmbrellaGirl

Those people who bail on elderly parents should not expect inheritance. The parents' money and assets should be used to pay for their care in their old age. If that care is done by a sibling then they should be paid for it.

If adult kids want to have a go at preserving any potential inheritance by caring for elderly parents themselves, they should. I wouldn't judge someone for doing that.

As for not lifting a finger for the caregiver sibling. If they refuse to take it on then no one should judge them either.


The caregiving sibling should be the one who inherits and no one else.
I think it's wrong for their to be an equal division of inheritance when there wasn't equal sharing of the caregiving responsibilities.

As harsh as it sounds all caregivers choose to take it on in some way or another. They may choose to caregive for parents out of necessity for themselves because they've fallen on hard times and have nowhere else to go.
Or they do it out of guilt, or a sense of duty, or love, or to preserve inheritance. Their reasons are their own, but it's still a choice.

Not becoming a caregiver is a choice also and no one should be judgmental to the people who choose to say no.
(3)
Report

@Alva

I wouldn't listen politely and no mistake. It's better for people to find a support group like this to vent to.

I learned to live by the philosophy of England's Royal Family.

'Don't complain and don't explain'.

This is my motto. One day I decided I was not going to take my mother on her usual royal progress of doctor's appointments. I did not offer any explanation, not did I wait for my sibling to step up and start taking her.


After she missed a few she finally started calling other family members to start bringing her.
I will take her occasionally if I have the time and want to. Otherwise I simply say no and offer no reason or explanation.
When I was married and not working family members who need elder or child care believe this translates into that woman being available to babysit your old people and kids.

No it doesn't. I said no to several family members and friends who needed someone who could just sit with their elder for a while or pick their kids up from school and keep them for an hour or so on the weekdays.

I simply say I'm not available and refuse to discuss it further.

People need to stop listening politely and stop trying to explain themselves when they say no to something.

No one has to listen to their sibling carry on about their vacation when they're stuck at home with elderly parents. I think it's kind of cruel to brag like that. I'd tell her to STFU and I don't care. I've told my sibling this many times.
(5)
Report

@ Burnt, I think you may have missed my "politely but (capitalized) BRIEFLY." By that I would elaborate to say they have fewer than 60 seconds of time.

We each find what works best for us. To me, just leaving these folks "behind" works very well. And I do it politely. Not apologetically, but politely. Make no mistake; they GET IT.
(1)
Report

@Tynagh - oh gosh, I didn't think you had suggested anything untoward - I had just been reading about parents taking care of their children with cancer and thought their take was pertinent to your post. I read all kinds of stuff while looking for people in a similar situation to myself. There just aren't many in my position, most parents of adult children with cancer are sidelined from primary caregiving roles.

I cannot imagine how parents can parent their ill children who want to keep living when the odds are against them.
(2)
Report

Raising children is nowhere near as stressful as dealing with elderly parents. That said, I raised one child with special needs, and my elderly mother has mental illness. At least, when you are the parent of a minor, you are fully legally in charge of everything, have access to do everything they need, etc. With an elder, the law still liens to their favor. For example, you can’t make someone go to a nursing home even if they need it. You can’t make someone go get a Dementia evaluation, even if they need it.
(6)
Report

And I bet dear sister takes the kids off daughters hands or babysits for her. But like said, grandchildren over parents. Me, when my Mom was in care, I took my 3 yr old grandson with me. He hadca ball. One man played ball with him. Tgey would roll it back and forth to each other. Tge other residents and Mom just loved seeing him.

My one brother lived 7 hrs away the other 30 min from Mom. They did very little for her before Dementia so I expected nothing from them when she was diagnosed. No regular calls. One week a year visit from brother 7 hrs away. Gifts for Christmas, birthday and Mday were sporatic. My other brother did better because his wife made sure Mom got something. By the time Mom went to an AL after living with me 22 months, I did not expect anything from them. At the time one was 60 and the other 56. Adult men so I did not feel I should have to remind them to see their Mom. So as POA, I did my own thing. Made all the decisions. I refuse to feel guilty if I did not do it just right. Made mistakes. I was the one who was there and took care of my Mom. My brothers are not bad guys. Just raised by a mother who asked nothing of them. Me, oldest child and a girl. The one who lived nearby. Its what it was.
(3)
Report

Agreed. Why don't you tell sister how you feel? Then you probably will have to talk to her again never. She's actually being pretty rude and uncaring toward you. Let her wallow amid the endlessly sticky 40 fingers of her grandchildren and relish the fact that she's not changing elders' diapers. And if she ever needs help, well, you just can't.

You're not alone here, and I wish you peace.
(4)
Report

Totally agreeing with old dude (Sept. 26) with his points. There is no comparison.

Bottom, line, people choose to have kids, some even dream of them in their future, but no one dreams of caring for elders.
(1)
Report

I cared for both my parents - dad died 5 yrs ago and mom 6 months ago - for me it was stressful but I was joyful since I loved them so much and it gave me purpose and I felt fulfilled and very busy. Once My mom died, I lost my will(I dont have my own family) and purpose and fell into a severe anxious depression and no treatments are helping- For me personally, I would rather spend caregiving 24.7 vs grieving 24.7.......it was a labor of love and yes, no comparison between raising kids vs watching elderly parents decline and die.....your sister is actually missing out .....
(0)
Report

@Mhillwt,

So sorry for your loss . Have you gone to grief counseling ? Perhaps when it’s not so fresh , you could consider volunteering in a nursing home since you enjoyed caregiving . Perhaps it would fill some of the void . Some nursing homes need volunteers to spoon feed residents . Or you could read books , or talk with the residents .

Do you have friends nearby? Perhaps you could join a book club or see what other clubs or classes your local library , community center or college may have.
(((Hugs))))
(1)
Report

This discussion has been closed for comment. Start a New Discussion.
Start a Discussion
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter