Follow
Share

The siblings live very far away and are not able to visit frequently. However, they have researched the legal and nursing care options made phone calls head long talks, etc but the caregiver refuses to follow up on any of this. At the same time, he demands that the siblings all fly down to help out. This is impossible when the caregiver is so controlling that they will not take any advice and become enraged.

My guess is that all these 'helpful hints' are just creating more work for the caregiver. Someone needs to actually visit and try and put those suggestions into action for the caregiver.

Sounds like when my cousin 2000 miles away thought she should be part of my father's care team. Unless she was offering to take him grocery shopping, to yet one of his many frivolous doctor visits or do his laundry I failed to see running every decision I made past her like it was a committee decision would be helpful to me. Cousin was cut off.
Helpful Answer (9)
Reply to lkdrymom
Report
Twirl87 Aug 18, 2025
We are not providing her helpful hints. In fact, if we hadn’t gone there at great expense and spent days on the phone, this caregiver sibling would not even have access to my parent’s bank account nor our father’s retirement. Without our having come down and looked up lawyers and found the will, and taken it to a lawyer’s office, the trust would still be in my deceased father’s name. We do visit and help when possible. This caregiver’s mental health has become an issue and she has become abusive, especially when we make suggestions pertaining to long-term solutions. As my mother worsens, we are trying to ensure power of attorney is passed to this caregiver so that she can make decisions if my mother cannot. She won’t listen to us nor look at the paperwork nor even discuss it. She won’t discuss eventually placing my mom in any sort of care facility. And like I say above, she has become abusive about her refusal.
What would you suggest?
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
Have you considered that perhaps the caregiver doesn't have the capacity to follow up. Does the caregiver have outside help currently? What exactly are you asking them to do. More information is needed.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to casole
Report
Twirl87 Aug 18, 2025
The caregiver has the capacity to make phone calls, but refuses to the caregiver distrust, agencies, and strangers being in the home. The other siblings want to get power of attorney established in case something happens to my mother or her AD worsens to the point that she can’t make decisions, although arguably she is already at that state now. The caregiver refuses to provide a heating system in the house. She refuses to be transparent about finances. She refuses to discuss the future and only wants a short term, labor type help. She has one part-time outside caregiver for the days that she is at work and claims that she can’t or that my mother can’t afford more than that.
The other siblings have full-time jobs and can’t go live in that town for an extended time. The other siblings need to know about my mother’s financial status in order to see if there is a way to pay for more caregiving in Home. We have even found a grant that could provide her money for caregiving because she doesn’t qualify for other types of programs. However, the caregiver refuses to call the number. And she has become verbally abusive when we bring up anything related to my mother’s future care, or any legal or financial matter, which may have an impact on the caregiver herself, as well as the quality of my mother’s future care.
Thank you for listening.
(0)
Report
See 3 more replies
Based on your description of the situation, I wonder whether your sibling is competent to provide care and to have power of attorney for your parent.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to Rosered6
Report
Twirl87 Aug 18, 2025
I tend to agree with you. Thank you.
(1)
Report
Just offering other reasons for opposition. Family member has lot of responsibility. Maybe she has a routine that works just needs some hands on help for such things as laundry, grocery shopping, prescriotion pick up or just a companion for Mom for a couple of hours of respite. Maybe not enough money for furnace repair. From.personal experience went the route of looking for assistance frim senior agencies. Zero. Lost track of actual numbrr contacted as often given another number to call. Told not qualified. It is hard for family members from both sides. Have you ssked her what you CAN fo for her and Mom. Would she accept help from aide you pay for, maybe a couple times a week ? As for Dr appts, my husband had 5 doctors. That kept us busy. A challenge for transport and required 3 month visits. Perhaps Hospice care is available now. I think your family member has a routine. It works but she needs your help but distancd makes that impossible. If you can pay a company of her choice and hours she could chooses for assist, please give hrr a chance. I also did not appreciate some telling me what to do when I was the one responsible fir the caregiving. Parayers to both sides.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to Memories42
Report
Twirl87 Aug 23, 2025
My sibling and I have not been telling her what to do. We have been offering ways to make sure my mom is comfortable and stays in possession of the house. We have been offering easy paperwork to transfer power of attorney so that she doesn’t lose the house in probate.
We have been flying out at considerable expense and doing all the chores, but we have limited vacation. We would happily pay for more caregiving and someone to do the shopping, but the caregiver sibling is very controlling and will not accept help from caregiver agencies or actually anyone that she doesn’t know. And she doesn’t know a lot of people. It’s a control thing. It is a long-standing problem.. I have an aging partner and a full-time job with limited vacation and can hardly be going there all the time.
Like I said to others, we are the ones who flew down in nature to get my dad‘s death certificate and my mom access to his Social Security and retirement. We want POA so the house doesn’t get eaten up in probate when we may have to sell it in order to pay for her assisted living care in the future. Or for more in-home care.
(0)
Report
Who is the caregiver providing care for? A parent? A sibling?

How old is the caregiver? Do they have any history of mental illness?

Is the caregiver the PoA for the care receiver?

What would you and siblings consider a solution in this situation?

Answers to your question will depend on what further information you provide.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to Geaton777
Report
Twirl87 Aug 18, 2025
The caregiver is providing for a parent. She also lives with this parent. The caregiver definitely has a history of mental illness, which she refuses to get help for. She is not the PoA because she refuses to ask my mother to sign over PoA. She refuses to contact local resources because she doesn’t like talking on the phone. The other siblings have spent considerable time talking with local resources, but at a certain point the caregiver needs to show up with my mother to get the help.

A solution would be for the caregiver to get mental health treatment and do what any lawyer would suggest and get power of attorney past to herself or all of our siblings. In case something happens to my mother. She needs to consider someday selling the house in order to pay for my mother‘s care.
At the moment she shuts down any conversation about the future, whether we visit her offering to help or do so on the phone. Thank you.
(0)
Report
Many more questions. Is the caregiver financially dependent on your parent? This would explain reluctance to move her. If caregiver is spending mom's money that would explain resistance to naming POA...unless it is them? If moving mom and naming a POA is a ploy to cut the caregiver out you might need to accept the situation. Unless it's about a large sum of money going the legal route will drain money. If you can't fly there to help hire someone local to buy groceries, clean etc. Remember this is about your mom not the caregiver. If she is safe, content and cared for you might be just stirring up drama.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to AnnetteDe
Report
Twirl87 Aug 23, 2025
To the first question, partly. The caregiver sibling has debts and won’t reveal their extent. She is paying a small rent. But the reason she isn’t considering home care is first of all it’s too expensive and second my dad made her promise never to put my mother in care. My caregiver sibling is honoring that.
My mother still has power of attorney because my sibling caregiver refuses to even look at the document or listen to us describe what may happen to the house in the medical decisions about my mom unless we get power of attorney. Doesn’t matter which one. We just don’t want her to lose the house in probate.
We would like to hire someone to help, but my caregiver sister refuses our suggestions and will only accept people in the house who she knows. She will not accept trained caregivers because she believes most people aren’t trustworthy.
Is it stirring up trouble to ask her to get a heating system when my mom is cold all winter and my sister box at spending the money on a heating system? I would say no. And we do fly out there and we get the door slammed in our face when we try to offer suggestions to help my mother keep the house and stay warm. I don’t call that stirring up trouble.
(2)
Report
Really, we do need more info. Is this sibling caring for a parent? And this sibling wants the rest of the children to come and help?

You can't help someone who won't follow through and thinks they know it all. I would not want to be around someone who is controlling. You want my help, I do it my way. (I do take advice) Is there a way each one of you can take a week off do give sibling some time to themselves. Space the time out. Supply funds so parent can have respite care in an AL or NH? If sibling bulks at these ideas then tell them they are on their own. They can't have it all their way. They have to take what is offered. If this sibling can't do the caring then the parent will need to be placed.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to JoAnn29
Report
Twirl87 Aug 18, 2025
Sibling is caring for the parent. Sibling is living with a parent. The other siblings are very far away and it is very expensive to fly there or even drive. The caregiver wants the other siblings to come “help” but the nature of the help would be things like grocery shopping. Caregiver has refused to discuss Important help such as getting legal matters settled like power of attorney, financial plans in case placement is needed, etc. To the point of being abusive to other siblings. Thank you for your helpful and supportive answer.
(0)
Report
If your sibling has a diagnosed mental illness, I don’t see how you couldn’t get POA. Especially regarding the fact about not having a hearing system (unless they live in Miami!). APS may need to be notified if the home is not properly heated.
Consult an elder law attorney- it’s definitely worth the investment. Regarding help with groceries- initiate Instacart or a similar service for grocery delivery. You could even do the ordering remotely if your mother can’t be part of deciding what to purchase. Best of luck in this difficult situation.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to puptrnr
Report
Twirl87 Aug 23, 2025
Thank you for understanding this situation and the good advice!
(0)
Report
When the term sibling and then caregiver are used separately, it is confusing. I assume this is both a sibling to you or a 1/2 sibling as well as your Mother’s full time caregiver. What I do not understand, is that if you and your other siblings love your Mother (I assume you do), then WHY in the world would you and your other sane siblings what your sibling with mental health issues taking care of your Mom? The sibling/caretaker may be absolutely overwhelmed with the health issues and the full time work of caregiving. It seems to me like someone in the family should take their vacation time from work, and go there to stay for awhile to SEE what is really going on there day to day. Then you and all of the siblings can have a meeting regarding what is the best thing for the woman who brought ALL of you into this world. If she took good care of you all, it is time to repay the favor in her hour of need.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Tiger8
Report
Beatty Aug 23, 2025
I so disagree.
Each adult is able to make their own desicion on their life, what they do, if they will offer support & how they will do so. From emotional support, helping find practical resources, to offering short-term assistance, from hands-on help. No-one is ever obliged to perform long-term hands-on help because a sibling guilted them to.

Eg A a nurse sibling lives care work. Thinks nothing of helping with incontinence issues. Insists all other sibs do same. Other siblings work as pilot, truckdriver, miltary & mechanic.
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
I am sorry you are living this. It seems to come up a lot. One *Lone Ranger* caregiver that cares.. but their care has blinded them. In their foggy vision, they assume all siblings must 'care' (ie provide hands-on labour) in the same way they do.

This is faulty thinking.

I will find the link for the F.O G website. While it will not change your sibling, it may help you to read.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Beatty
Report
Beatty Aug 23, 2025
https://outofthefog.website/
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
See All Answers
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter