Follow
Share

Mom (80s) has lived in a 5-star SNF for 4 years and suffers from multiple chronic conditions, takes 10 meds daily, uses a walker but generally is not happy. She disengages from the other residents and refuses to participate in activities, shower, etc. The staff and facility are A#1 and have been a god-send! It is 15 minutes from where I live. However, Mom wants to move in with her niece, 2 other adults and numerous pets into a small 2-bedroom residence. This would be a 2-hour drive for me and I have medical and legal POA. Mom remembers when she was 15 years younger and she shared a residence with her niece. Mom also has cognitive decline with delusions, visions, etc. and is not rational, but according to her tests not bad enough to be in the dementia wing. Her niece is retired but in questionable health and travels for weeks at a time. She also has a laissez-faire style and would not enforce a med schedule or nutritious meals. I am worried that Mom would move in and things would not go well after the initial honeymoon period. Her niece does have some medical work experience but is not an LPN or RN. I do not believe that this is the best place for Mom and also I fear that her niece is really interested in her SS dollars. (She has a track record of lying, stealing and cheating others to gain material possessions and large sums of money.) I fear that Mom will move out of the SNF and then I will have a very difficult time getting her back in or at the very least locating another top-notch facility. Mom is a narc and very manipulative and is getting worse as she ages. There is no pleasing her and the relationship if affecting my health. Any suggestions out there?

Find Care & Housing
Don’t allow it. You already know it would be a train wreck!
Helpful Answer (14)
Reply to Fawnby
Report

In one word, No.
Helpful Answer (13)
Reply to Hothouseflower
Report

No! This will be horrible for everyone involved.
Helpful Answer (7)
Reply to LoopyLoo
Report

If you allow this, your mother likely will be homeless as she will have given away her assets to this niece and won’t be eligible for a Medicaid SNF. She already IS in SNF for a reason.

Is your financial poa in effect now? If not, enlist the snfs help in securing the documentation of sufficient decline so that your poa goes into effect.
Helpful Answer (8)
Reply to PeggySue2020
Report

Wow. Sounds like a disaster waiting to happen. Your mother wouldn't be happy in that situation, either, in the long run. ALL of the things would land squarely on your shoulders, especially when niece travels.

I was going to suggest making a list of pros and cons... but it doesn't seem like there are any pros at all!
Helpful Answer (7)
Reply to Stardust
Report
CaregiverL Sep 14, 2025
Exactly
(0)
Report
Leave her where she is - another bed may not open for her If she Leaves . Be Firm say " No "
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to KNance72
Report

Always Be Skeptical Of people who Make Promises they can't keep . Huge Red Flag .
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to KNance72
Report

I truly cannot believe that you are even considering moving your mom after telling us that your niece "has a track record and of lying, stealing and cheating."
I mean really....are you just messing with us here???
This is a no brainer and the fact that you would even consider such nonsense makes me wonder about you.
Your mom is where she needs to be, so leave well enough alone. Period, end of sentence.
Helpful Answer (11)
Reply to funkygrandma59
Report

Heck no.

Hopefully you are her PoA? If not, you may not be able to stop her from doing this. If you aren't her PoA I strongly suggest you get this in place before she cooks up a plan with this niece and makes her the PoA.

If somehow she pulls the trigger on this move, do not lift a finger to help her plan or move a stick of furniture. Be MIA.

You may need to pursue guardianship if your Mom is past the legal assessment for cognitive capacity. An alternative would be to download PoA forms and have it notarized at a bank or city hall.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to Geaton777
Report

Nope
NO
Not a chance.
These are just 3 things that popped into my mind.

You can tell mom that due to her medical issues it is not a good idea.

You can tell mom that having more than 2 adults living in a 2 bedroom apartment is not allowed by the landlord.

You are POA and this move does not sound like it is in her best interest.

I would caution the Attorney that if mom comes in with her niece trying to make the niece POA that you need to know. That mom has some cognitive issues and that the niece may be trying to take advantage of her.

Your other and worst option is to let this all unfold, you tell mom that you are no longer going to act as POA and let this circus play out. **not advisable in the least!!**
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to Grandma1954
Report

Why on earth would you consider this nonsensical plan.

Stop trying to make your mother happy.

Google "Out of the FOG".
Helpful Answer (13)
Reply to BarbBrooklyn
Report

I would suggest you stop trying to be responsible for your mother's happiness. It's unlikely, if indeed she is as you diagnose her, "a narc" that she will ever be happy.

As you are a grown adult I trust your judgement to weigh a "5 star" facility against a "lying and cheating neice".
Helpful Answer (13)
Reply to AlvaDeer
Report

Begging you not to change mom's current situation here! If the relationship is affecting your health with her at the 5 star facility with A1 staff (please please remember how hard that is to find!) imagine how it will be once she you start getting calls from her at the niece's... And you have to drive two hours to deal with a crisis. Or when the niece kicks her out etc etc.

Talk to the social worker at the snf for help intervening if this talk continues. Unsafe environment at niece's etc based on her medical needs.

Don't even entertain it as a possibility.
Helpful Answer (12)
Reply to casole
Report

Tell Mom she NEEDS to stay where she is at her nursing home .

What Mom WANTS is not the priority here . We all want things or situations that we don’t get .

We need to learn that we should not feel we are obligated to ignore the consequences of aging and try to make someone happy and blow up our own lives . Take it from someone who learned this lesson the hard way .

She’s old , very often that means no longer happy in general, no matter what .

I had a narc , manipulative , unhappy mother too , who expected me to follow her orders and take her out of her assisted living facility.

I finally , at my wits end , told my mother ,
” Mom I did not make you old , I can’t fix old “.
Helpful Answer (16)
Reply to waytomisery
Report
ElizabethAR37 Sep 12, 2025
Note to longevity researchers: find a way to "fix" old before you announce the latest medical advance intended to prolong the existence of failing bodies and minds.
(2)
Report
See 1 more reply
If your POA is "Durable" its Immediate. Meaning as soon as Mom signed her name to the documents your POA was invoked. The word immediate should be in the wording, too. With cognative decline, your Mom is not capable of making informed decisions, thats why your POA. You have good reasons why this is not a good thing. One that sticks out is niece likes to travel. Can't travel when you are taking care of someone 24/7.

Go with your gut. If your looking for confirmation that moving her is not a good decision, I will chime in with...don't do it. She is safe and cared for where she is. I would tell the facility that no one is to take her out of the building but you. I may even ban niece because she is trying to influence Mom. You are in control. No one should allow anything without running it by you.
Helpful Answer (10)
Reply to JoAnn29
Report
waytomisery Sep 7, 2025
Durable where I live is not “ durable “ .
Where I live banks , doctors , facility administrators etc , are making their own judgements whether they are going to listen to the patient or the POA.
Unfortunately , It’s an uphill battle for caregivers in my state .

Not all Durable POA documents say immediate in them . Many people have these drawn up ahead of time for when it’s needed down the road , ( like suddenly becoming unconscious ). That is what causes problems.

Where I live there are no longer Springing POA documents drawn up either , only Durable. I recently had my POA’s drawn up . They are durable but not immediate.
(6)
Report
Absolutely no. Your mother is always going to be unhappy. That is the reality.

Don’t give up her spot at this place.
Helpful Answer (17)
Reply to Bulldog54321
Report
KNance72 Sep 7, 2025
Exactly they don't hold the spot for you if you leave . it is not easy getting a bed In a Good Place . I had to call 8 Nursing Homes that were good and finally on the Ninth try found a bed at a decent Place .
(11)
Report
This shouldn't even be up for discussion.
Helpful Answer (18)
Reply to lkdrymom
Report
TouchMatters Sep 12, 2025
Right. And the question is ... why is the daughter needing to discuss or 'ask' us. There is something more going on with the daughter ... she is torn for some reason(s) and we didn't really hear enough of her feelings about it to understand why / how she thinks this is even 00.01% a 'good idea.' And she gives us the stats as to why it isn't a good idea ... although she doesn't seem to see it - thus writing us here.

Gena
(2)
Report
Make sure the Niece does not take her out to lunch then Kidnaps her - it sounds Like Money is involved . I would warn the Place not to let the NIece come in Unless she Is watched . Once a Person is Kidnapped it is hard to get them Back .
Helpful Answer (14)
Reply to KNance72
Report

3 adults and pets are already living in a 2 bedroom home is a red flag.
Helpful Answer (19)
Reply to MACinCT
Report
TouchMatters Sep 12, 2025
And stealing. Don't forget that part.
(3)
Report
See 1 more reply
Hard NO. Get an eldercare attorney with mothers funds immediately. You need legal representation for this situation.
Helpful Answer (9)
Reply to AMZebbC
Report

No!
Helpful Answer (8)
Reply to Daisy9
Report

Sorry, but your mom should not leave the facility. It will be very detrimental to her. The niece is very selfish. Her intentions are very suspicious. This is a huge mistake.
Helpful Answer (11)
Reply to Onlychild2024
Report

Not just no, but **** no! The niece sounds like she has her own agenda. Did you mother suggest this or did the niece suggest it to her?
Helpful Answer (11)
Reply to dmg1969
Report

" Mom is a narc and very manipulative and is getting worse as she ages."

My mom is NPD. She also is refusing to accept her placement. The best answer to your mom is, "No, never in a million years are you moving." That's the only sane, compassionate answer. You can't make NPDs happy. You cannot convince them that you are doing what is best. You can only go ahead and do what is best. In this case it is keeping her where she is. Let the niece know this is not up for discussion and if she pushes things you will get guardianship so she has no way to get around you.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to JustAnon
Report

I would not! The niece had no idea what she's getting into. The nieces home is too small.
is the niece in it for your Moms money? 24/7 care is overwhelming and what happens when the niece gives up?
Helpful Answer (7)
Reply to Jodahlia
Report
CaregiverL Sep 14, 2025
Niece will give up day 1 and get plane ✈️ ticket somewhere, anywhereville after 1st bowel movement accident
(0)
Report
Another NO!
Helpful Answer (7)
Reply to RedVanAnnie
Report

My thought after reading your post is this is a disaster waiting to happen. Read it again carefully. It's a perfect list of all the reasons this won't work!
Helpful Answer (8)
Reply to iameli
Report
TouchMatters Sep 12, 2025
That's right. This daughter answered her own question - and that is one of the gifts of this forum. By writing out our situation / issues / dilemma, we can see the answer(s) we are looking for. Good to point this out. I, too, quoted the daughter in part of my response. She does answer her own question ... the key is that she sees it ! Gena
(4)
Report
No. Talk about a less than ideal living situation for your mother and her numerous health problems. Which are being managed by trained medical professionals now. Given your description of your niece's behavior, why on earth would it ever be a good decision to have her chiseling money from your mother? Nope. You lucked out with the SNF. That's worth its weight in platinum.
I'd discuss this with a lawyer who specializes in Elder law to see what you need to do to keep your mother and her assets safe from a predatory family member. It seems that the niece may have visited your mom and "suggested" that she could live with her. It's such a specific request from your mother, I find it highly suspect-even if she lived with her years ago.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to Ariadnee
Report

Mom isn't in control of all her mental capacities and needs to stay where she is.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to Evonne1954
Report

Under no circumstances should this terrible plan be discussed or planned. Further, I’d tell the SNF that the niece is banned from the premises and they should have no discussions with her. Does your mother have a phone? Block the nieces number.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to LakeErie
Report
TouchMatters Sep 12, 2025
Thank you. I agree.
And I said something similar, but not as succinct.
Yes, the niece is bad news. Gena
(5)
Report
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter