Follow
Share

She is in AL. I have her car. She insists she is moving out and she says she needs her car in order to find a new place to live. I am at a loss as to what to say when she tells me she needs to know how to get to my house to get her car. I stupidly attempt to reason with her by letting her know that she needs to take a driving test with DMV, then get the battery charged, then finally get the car registered and insured. She says I can't do all that, can you help me? I let her know that people who drive have to be able to handle all of that themselves. The conversation just goes round and round. Suggestions for responses to her request? She is very difficult to distract and just keeps returning to her question of how do I get my car? I need to drive. I need to get out of here. Distraction or diverting the conversation is not second nature to me yet. Suggestions for what to say to her?

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Hi. If you click on Care Topics at the the top RHS of the screen, then D for Driving on the alphabet that comes up, you will find 30 articles on the subject, and nearly 1000 past questions with answers. Try that first, then ask us anything you need extra help on.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

I have this same issue with my mom. When the topic of driving/moving comes up I agree with her and say “OK we will do that”. Of course she isn’t driving or moving anywhere. I just entertain her idea. She immediately relaxes and forgets about it for a few days. I learned that arguing and using logic always makes things worse. Agreeing with her and giving her a sense of control calms her down and then she forgets about it.
Helpful Answer (13)
Report
AnnReid Jun 2021
GOOD JOB!
(2)
Report
See 2 more replies
Let your last conversation on this be the last time you participate. Endless looping conversation frustrates everyone. Agree and change the subject. If it persists take a break and go for a walk (or a doughnut 🤗)
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

First you must realize that there is no reasoning with a person with Alzheimer's/dementia, as their brain is broken.
Have you tried just telling her that her Dr. won't let her drive any more and that we will have to talk to the Dr. before you can allow her to get her car back? That way it's the Dr.'s fault, and not yours. Or honestly just going along with whatever she is saying, is probably your best bet. If she says she's moving out and needs her car, just agree and tell her yes, you're right, we'll need to work on that----tomorrow. Wishing you the very best.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
disgustedtoo Jun 2021
Tomorrow is often good, because as WE know, tomorrow never comes! If they feel they've "won" the battle and will get their way, it can make it easier to change topics or distract them with something else, a task, an activity, a snack or beverage, a walk, etc. Short term memory loss will likely result in this being forgotten, for the moment. It'll continue to come back around now and then, until eventually they forget the car and driving (or going home, etc) altogether.
(2)
Report
You can't reason with her broken mind. Learn to redirect, you can learn that. Also try changing the environment. Not a whole change of AL places, just maybe from her room to the lobby, or lobby to garden. That may help to switch up the conversation to something else.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Do you use her car or are you just storing it? If its just sitting there, sell it if you have POA to do so. When my Mom was told she could no longer drive, I had her sell her car. Out of sight, out of mind.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

My mom still talks about driving again, but we gently point out to her than she can't see over the dashboard--she's hunched over from several botched back surgeries and cannot lift her head. She couldn't even GET in the car, much less drive.

YB 'inherited' the car, which is the one he drives her around in---and when he parks it, the parking brake is pulled to the limit, further keeping her from driving.

She hasn't driven for almost 10 years--so it really isn't an issue now, but she has enough friends her age whe ARE still driving that it makes her feel minimized.

It's a hard thing for most people to give up--esp if they are forced to do so.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

From what you're saying here distraction does not work when your mother when your mother is in a dementia loop of repeating the same question over and over again about driving.
Don't answer her every time she asks. This might help with the repeating loop.
As for the moving out part. Tell her that is her home and that she isn't moving anywhere because she can't afford to. Then as a last resort if she gets in a repeating loop about moving, tell her that the next move will be to a nursing home. That her doctor wanted to try AL first before putting her in one. Even with moderate dementia, many times just the mention of a nursing home is enough to break a repeating loop.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

My mom was the same way. I had to have my brother disable the car. When she realized it would not start she called the mechanic. Luckily we were able to head the mechanic off about the situation. He told her that the parts had to be ordered and nothing could be done. She soon forgot about it after not driving for awhile.
This is a hard one especially because most of moms life she was a delivery driver. Give yourself a break.... distraction takes a long time to learn and it is really hard with your own mother....she raised you ,hard to fool her, my heart goes out to you.
The one thing that helped me get through this was knowing how bad my mom would feel if she hurt anyone or anything driving. That as our way of saving her from that.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
disgustedtoo Jun 2021
You were lucky to get the mechanic on your side! When my YB gave mom the "talk" and took the key, I suggested disabling the car until we could get it out of her garage, as I was sure she had another key. Next day, who gets the nasty call about taking her key? ME! I brushed her off saying I never touched her key, which I didn't. Day 2, nastier call, demanding I get down there and fix whatever I did to her car. I could honestly say I didn't touch her car. We just had to get it out of there before she figured out how to call a mechanic! She didn't have a regular one. Matter of fact, we found the inspection was about 6 months overdue. An issue with the lights wasn't taken care of because she didn't drive at night. These plus white stripes on the fenders, back of the driver mirror missing (it was there last time I drove it, as if she checked that!), and a ruined tire and rim said get this off the road!!! She couldn't explain the tire/rim damage, insisted she didn't hit anything. Riiight.

Disabling it if it's still located where she can see it/get to it can work for some, but others either tinker with cars (mostly men) or can call help. It's best to really disable it (kill switch or the Club steering wheel lock) and then remove it, so out of sight, eventually out of mind!
(1)
Report
We are going through this with my mom and she is very angry and mean about everything, especially the driving. She failed all of her assessments with the neuropsychologist and he said she can't drive. But, she never received anything in writing and never had her license officially suspended and taken away. She thinks we are not letting her drive, blames the doctor, says she failed her tests because her blood sugar was low, says she wants to change her will because we are trying to control all of her life. I am taking her to her PCP tomorrow and hoping to get something in writing that states she cannot drive. How has everyone else received this info from the doctors and how can we have her license officially revoked?
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
rovana Jun 2021
Don't know about your state, but generally the doctor can report his/her findings to the Dept. of Motor Vehicles and they can act accordingly. Is there some reason why the doctor has not officially reported? Can the doctor at least give you a written report saying no driving?
(2)
Report
See 1 more reply
Does this facility have a "fake" bus stop? Identical in every way except for the purpose, these have proved very useful for prospective escapees - the resident takes a seat in anticipation of the impending 'bus to freedom' and enjoys the fresh air before forgetting why they are there or being encouraged to go in for lunch or cup of tea and return later.
Your mother has no interest in the car, but the mode of departure to meet her ends.
I would mention that she can no longer safely drive but can wait for the bus, and you could walk and sit with her if she is keen to action this immediately. If it is getting late, you might ask her to return tomorrow for the morning bus.
I guess it sounds a bit cruel, but in their mind they are being proactive in pursuing their objectives.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
MammaDrama Jun 2021
Nothing wrong with dabbling in a little fantasy if it helps the dementia patient feel comforted and happy.
(1)
Report
Keep the keys away from her! Disconnect or remove the car battery. The car will not start unless battery is connected. If you have power of attorney sale her car! Your mom needs to be under supervision at all times. You need to have her drivers license surrendered to the State. Have the doctor tell her she can no longer drive a vehicle. There are many ways to handle this situation. If you have a P.O.A. on her this can be resolved swiftly.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
disgustedtoo Jun 2021
The only sure fire method that works is removing access to the car. Fully disabling the car might work for many, but there are those who can "fix" it or get someone to fix it. We never cancelled mom's license. It wouldn't have stopped her from trying to drive, nor would a letter from doc or DMV. They dismiss it or forget it and will attempt driving anyway.
(2)
Report
I took my mom to her PCP today as she failed her cognitive assessments with the neuropsychologist. Her PCP has been a family friend for years and as I expected, he would not make the decision about her driving, even though the neuropsychologist said 'no driving'. Her PCP said she was fine with him today and he wants a 3rd party to determine if she can drive. She convinced him that she failed her tests because she was 'so upset' while taking them....(I picked her up from this appt and she was perfectly fine....she is a master manipulator) So, his office is contacting the agency that provides driver training and she will have to pass both the written and driving tests before given back the reigns. At least her PCP said "NO DRIVING" until she does the 'training' with the agency and then passes the tests . Any advice or I do just let things play out with the driving tests? She was very nasty, argumentative, angry and toxic today.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
disgustedtoo Jun 2021
"She was very nasty, argumentative, angry and toxic today."

With you, for sure... but oh so sweet and nice with the doc, right?

My mother was nasty to ME about taking her key, the day after my YB took it. I told her I didn't touch it and when asked who did, I replied "You're so smart, you figure it out" and hung up. She was just SO nasty to me for something I didn't even do! Next day, she found that other key I knew she had and tried to take the car out. I'd had YB disable it (pulled the battery cable) just in case. She called ME again, nastier than the first call and demanded I get down there and fix whatever I did to it. I could honestly say, same as with the key, I didn't touch it. Of course it was my idea to disable it, but she didn't need to know that! Usually my mother was that way - could be nasty to us, but sweet to everyone else. Only once or twice did she become difficult (understatement?) at a doc office.

Typical for the doc to pass this off. Many will not get into this. Even if they and the DMV do, with dementia the "talk" and the letters are either forgotten or dismissed.

As noted, assure her it's all in the works. You're on it (although you're not.) They are backed up because of the virus. They aren't allowing in person tests yet. SO many excuses to use, but meanwhile assure her you are on it. It'll be soon.... Hopefully you can find ways to change the topic then, after she's assured that you will take care of it right away (not) and calms down a bit.
(2)
Report
Forget about any responses along those lines. From now on, whenever she brings it up, same response: The car is in the shop for a major overhaul. - and then change the conversation. (If you need to, you can always add that they're waiting for parts.) Anytime you bring her to your house, make sure the car is parked out of sight.

Of course, you'll reassure her that you'll drive her (always in your own car!) - And if you need to at that moment, take her for a drive, a simple sightseeing cruise or a stop for an ice cream. Talk about anything other than cars.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

In addition to comments about the car and driving - are there plans for moving her to MC? She may not be ready yet, but you don't want to wait until it's too late. Typically with AL no one monitors the doors, so she can come/go as she pleases, but at some point that could be dangerous for her. If the current AL facility has a MC wing, perhaps you should find out how long the wait list is or if she would get preference should her needs change.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Would the old doctor says you can't drive any longer work? Or the plates have not yet been renewed? Or the insurance company won't insure you and I have to find a new company.....
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

My father continued to drive - much do my distress - I was taking him to Dr appts at this time. The IL living facility at the CC facility had a van to take them shopping - but he insisted he was fine to drive, sadly mom was still riding with him - also to my distress. Mom told me she'd stop riding with him when she thought it was dangerous. Mom wouldn't talk to dad about driving because of his passive/aggressive behavior and anger. So, it was better for him to be mad at me. Every time I was over at mom & dad I ask him to stop driving and giving him all the reasons for him not to drive. Dad did get lost a few times - but thankfully not the kind of lost that gets on the news - man going to neighbor market ends up in Minnesota. FINALLY, he agreed to stop driving, but for a couple of years after that I heard how I made him stop driving.

1. Tell her, her car died and can't be resurrected.
2. If that doesn't work, level with her that she is no longer capable of driving - you can always add that the dr told you it is not allowed anymore.

If she has to be mad at you for the situation, so be it.

I feel your pain.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

You tell her..
the car is in the shop.
the car does not run right now.
the doctor says you can not drive while taking the medication you are on,
you do not have a drivers license.

You can not "reason" or explain to someone with dementia about how or why they can or can not do something.

This might be the time you think about moving mom from AL to Memory Care.
In AL technically they can walk out the door and the staff can not stop them. In MC the doors are locked and they can not leave.
If mom is truly bent on getting to your house there is the great likelihood that she could try walking to your house. And she would wander off not knowing where she is. And then finding her before something happened to her would be a priority.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter