Follow
Share

Top specialist and extensive testing by the Mayo Clinic diagnosed her in the past and ruled out Alzheimer’s. I know it doesn’t make any difference in her care but it bothers me that this was carelessly added to her list of diagnoses. I am certain no one tested or assessed her to come up with this. Is this a common thing in nursing homes to label all dementias carelessly or for paperwork reasons? It truly won’t change her care but my family spent years seeing specialists and seeking diagnosis and this is not correct.

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
I'd bring it to the staff's attention. I agree that it probably won't impact treatment decisions but I'd let them know that you are watching the file for accuracy. I'm sure they want the file to be accurate too. Hopefully, they will investigate how that diagnosis appeared on the file.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

I’ve noticed that some very skilled professionals who deal with geriatric clients do use the terms “Alzheimer’s” and “dementia” interchangeably.

Since the period of time in your mom’s life has passed during which differential diagnosis would have mattered, wouldn’t it just be more work for you to question this or attempt to have it changed?

That said, if the question were asked casually and non-defensively, you might feel better if you were given a reasonable answer.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

The diagnosis may not have been correct during those years; however, things probably changed and the diagnosis may be correct now. There is not one straightforward way to diagnose Alzheimer's. It's a combination of neuro imaging, mental status testing and interviews with those who can speak to your mother's current and previous functioning. Even Mayo Clinic experts state that there's not a one size fits all approach to diagnosing Alzheimer's.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
Invisible Mar 2020
Autopsy.
(0)
Report
It is possible to have more than 1 type of dementia.
The VERY important thing with your mom is that they still have the diagnosis of Lewy Body Dementia.
There are medications that can be given to people with other forms of dementia but they can be FATAL if given to someone with Lewy Body Dementia.
Unfortunately people seem to use Alzheimer's as they would the term Dementia. (I think many people do not realize there are many types of dementia, Alzheimer's seems to get the most "attention".)
I would make sure to review the medications that are being given and they should notify you of ANY change in medication.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report
Dollie1974 Feb 2020
So true...my mom was diagnosed with Vascular Dementia and right away the Neurologist wanted to prescribe Aricept along with other meds and I said no, after a long research on them, they do nothing for Vascular Dementia and may even cause very bad side effects instead. My mother’s Brian injury came from ischemic strokes, only those parts of the brain where the stroke happened is affected and can never be reversed...vision loss, judgment & reasoning, no cure for it. Just need to try and prevent further blood clots (strokes) so that her condition doesn’t worsen.
(3)
Report
See 1 more reply
People sometimes get 2 or 3 types of dementias. A neurologist would be able to.figure it out.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
Invisible Mar 2020
Assuming you get one that knows what they are doing and doesn't outsource the data interpretation.
(0)
Report
I don't think a GP or Nursing staff can make this assumption. ALZ is pigeoned holed at a form of Dementia but it effects the brain differently. I would question it.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
chrissy56 Feb 2020
My other reason for not wanting Alzheimers on her record as a diagnosis is that she is enrolled in a Mayo Clinic Brain Donor study on Lewy Body and other Dementia's. Carelessly choosing the most common dementia to add to my mom's chart can affect statistics etc.
(7)
Report
In looking up Lewy body I found this great article explaining the differences between Dementias.

https://m.activebeat.com/your-health/women/robin-williams-death-9-things-to-know-about-lewy-body-dementia/?utm_medium=cpc&utm_source=google&utm_campaign=AB_GGL_US_MOBI-SearchMarketing_TR&utm_content=g_t_303659477008&cus_widget=&utm_term=lewy%20body%20dementia&cus_teaser=kwd-35132660&utm_acid=3040947159&utm_caid=1599827680&utm_agid=62022144433&utm_os=&utm_pagetype=multi&gclid=CjwKCAiA7t3yBRADEiwA4GFlI1zRMR8YQE6QZSvW8x_fjiS6ey2mB8hlkBJcODGI56Y99zRIOa1NPRoCG7sQAvD_BwE
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

I would certainly ask about it but I wouldn't go to war - who made that diagnosis and based on what? Although it likely wouldn't make any difference to her care the diagnosis that will ultimately be written on her death certificate will become part of the statistics on which both government and research funding are based.
I was appalled at how little many the people who worked with the elderly every day seemed to know about dementia, right up the ladder to RNs as well as administrative staff. Many of the senior staff were older and still clinging to information and techniques that they had learned 30 years previously and the worst part is that they didn't appear to be open to learning new anything either, more than once I was made to feel like a hysterical amateur full of doubtful hypotheses gleaned from the internet 😬.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report
NYDaughterInLaw Feb 2020
That certainly is true, cwillie. The amount of ignorance about dementia and geriatrics in general is appalling. For example, too many doctors and nurses either have forgotten or never learned that drugs are NOT tested on patients older than 65. Old people are not just older adults. Adjusting for weight and BMI is not enough. I too have been given the "you're a hysterical amateur" looks, and I just hold firm and keep repeating myself until someone addresses my underlying concern. We have to advocate for ourselves and our loved ones.
(6)
Report
See 5 more replies
I am not convinced that the doctors know much of anything about Dementia, they talk in circles, with no conclusions. I wouldn't give this a second thought, whatever it is called doesn't make any difference, there is no cure!
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
JoAnn29 Feb 2020
Yes it does make a difference. See what I wrote previously. Read the article. I thought the same thing. A person suffering from Lewy Body cannot be given certain meds. It will kill them. So it "is" important that the right Dementia is diagnosed.
(7)
Report
Chrissy,

Earlier I posted an addy about an article I read. Lewy Body is one Dementia that they have to be careful what meds are given. Some are deadly. If the addy I posted previously doesn't work the article was...The death of Robin Williams: nine things to know about Lewy Body Dementia.

As a Nurse you probably do scare them. My daughter, as an LPN and an RN, worked in rehab/LTC facilities for 20 years. I loved when staff was trying to intimidate me and then my daughter walked in with her scrubs on. Boy did those attitudes change. My Mom had done a 180 in the hospital and they wanted to release her to rehab. I got an extra day but it was my daughter who found the antibiotic had penicillin in it that hospital records showed she was allergic to. My Dad was in rehab. Mom mentioned that he had blisters on his heel. My daughter looked at them and found dead tissue. Read the chart, he was brought in with pressure points and not given an air mattress. She went right to the DON. I really think she saved her grandparents life.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
whaleyf Mar 2020
Thanks for the info about Robin Williams. I had a friend die from it and didn't realize he could die from Parkinson.
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
We thought that my mom had Lewy. All we ever got was 'Alzheimers.' I think that all the doctors just automatically write this down. Every person I have talked to who was looking after someone with dementia says this same thing. It's like most doctors don't know how to diagnose dementia. I was able to get her off of a psychotic meds and that possibly gave her a few more months with us. A nurse told me if you have serious doubts about it - then balk. I decided that I would not let them give her something that could make her worse. I got so frustrated because even the neurologist just acted like - well at her age, it doesn't matter!
Both my parents have been pegged with Alzheimer's even though they recognize people and can communicate.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
Invisible Mar 2020
Yes, I get really annoyed at that attitude of "at her age, it doesn't matter".
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
Lewybody.org has a list of medications to avoid, but the doctor still argued with me that Seroquel would be great. I still stopped it.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
Mbnichols Feb 2020
My dad was given so much Seroquil that he had to be placed in a geriatric psych unit for a short time. They tried it in my mom, until I found out about it and it was immediately discontinued and she rebounded a bit. To me Seroquil is a death sentence to those with dementia. My dad had Alzheimer’s and my mom, vascular dementia.
(4)
Report
It should be corrected. Lewy's manifests much much differently from Alzheimer's Dementia. You should now meet with the director of the facility and calmly sit with your proof and with your questions. "Who added Alzheimer's Dementia to my Mom's diagnosis, and when." "Do you understand the difference between the various types of Dementia?" The truth is that, until it hit my own family (my bro has early Lewy's), I, even with a medical background, but retired 15 years, didn't know how unique the presentations of different types of dementia are. Even the expected progression differs markedly, with Lewy's having a sort of jagged up and down progression, and Alzheimer's have a certain slow downward tragectory; others go in sort of stair steps. Many of us here get our educations because it is FORCED upon us by what we are dealing with. THAT SAID, a place that deals with elders suffering from these conditions should/MUST know all they can in order to provide the unique care these conditions can demand.
You can help. You can help their recognition that not everyone fits the cookie cutter forms. Please do so. Do it calmly and with love.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

The nursing home staff have no idea of the complexity of a dementia diagnosis nor the different treatments. They can barely pronounce the names of the medications. You might want to engage in a conversation with the nurse caring for your family. A Nursing or Medical education does not make you an expert in dementia care. Experience is the best teacher. The best you can do is advocate for your family member. A CNA may recognize the diagnosis of Alzheimer's but would have no idea what Lewy Body Dementia is. The legal staffing ratios for skilled facilities are less than ideal. Getting involved politically may be the best way for you to advocate. Also, get to know the staff day and night staff, a relationship with the staff will help everything. Suddenly, your family member is more than the lady in room 101 with dementia. My husband is 48 years old with early onset dementia. Frontotemporal dementia is the current working diagnosis. Dementia by any name is not fun, not fun at all. Blessings.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

Should you care? If I were you, I would go absolutely ballistic.

Where did you see the reference to Alzheimer's Disease? - on what bit of paper, I mean.

And whose signature is on the document? Because if you were me, that person would find you in his or her office at the earliest opportunity, having a complete sense of humour failure and demanding an explanation.

In the absence of a satisfactory explanation, it is formal complaint time. Medical records MUST be accurate and complete or they become worthless.
Helpful Answer (9)
Report
jacobsonbob Mar 2020
"sense of humour failure"--I love it! Thanks, CM!
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
Thank you for your concern for your loved one. My journey with my wife was 7-1/2 years. If your current facilty has diagnosed Lewy Body with Parkinsons symptoms then cudos to themm. There was a time when LBD was not recognized as bei ng different from Alzheimers. There is a big differe nce in their care and longevity.. A book I considered a bible in LBD is "A Caregivers Guide To LBD by Whitworth" available from Amazon. Some care and meds are totally different . I actually was the go to person at the assisted living facility for my wife. I have a lot of e xperience with LBD which was beneficial to both the asl caregivers and my wife. I was home caregiver all but for last 2 years. Be patient, alert and understanding.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Yes, make sure they keep an accurate record of the type of dementia. My husband who has Fronto Temporal Dementia was given Risperadone by his primary care doctor (not his neurologist). It can be useful for Alzheimer’s patients but can be deadly for patients with FTD, and very nearly was for my husband.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

My sister was in AL facility (94 beds)and all her medical care was handled by her
own PCP of several years. I took her for appointments, etc. Last year I moved her to a 6 bed Care home and continued with her PCP for medical care. When hospice
is needed (not needed now), I will continue with her own Dr. of many years. I am confused why most comments here indicate having dropped using their long time, established relationship, of their family physician. This isn't necessary in CA.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
Mymomsthebest Mar 2020
most places ..you still go to a doc but like, when hospitalized they now use “hospitalists” who just act as primary for everyone. We had my moms docs complain repeatedly because these doc in a box guys would change her meds without consulting them ..it may be okay for most people but for those with a complicated medical history..it is awful..also as I said above ..they just acted like stuff was normal due to age ..at 80 my mom was like the new 70 ..alert and very active, so the issues she experienced were not her normal at all.
(3)
Report
See 2 more replies
All info in a patient's medical chart should be accurate. When my mom was having low sugar issues, her PCP said it might be strokes - it took nearly a year to figure out she was taking too much diabetes medicine. Upon release from a hospital, they doubled the amt she took prior to hospitalization and it was causing her sugar to be dangerously low early each morning. To this day, her chart notes strokes even though I have asked them to correct it. Another time, during the diabetes thing, the same dr told my sister she had Parkinson's without doing one single test...just her weirdness from low sugar and shaking hands also caused by the low sugar. He prescribed a Parkinson's med and I vetoed it based on all the problem started after her hospital stay. Even after many trips to the ER - I finally figured out what was wrong on my own by looking back at doses of meds and what changed. Not one ER doctor or nurse ever mentioned low sugar even though all her symptoms are mentioned all over the internet as low sugar.
I say all of this because - in keeping her issues as accurate as I can, she has avoided being treated for an issue she absolutely does not have. So it does make a difference in her care. Imagine giving Parkinson's medicine to someone who does not have it. Or adding stroke meds to someone without stroke issues.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
Mymomsthebest Mar 2020
From my experience with my mother over years..medical people , overall, once she hit eighty, treated her differently ..just as an old person. They would stereotype her and talk more to me or my sister instead of my mom ..and completely missed important things due to this. Like , asking how she usually gets to bathroom ..a walker or wheelchair and how many people to help ..even though the day before she had been completely independent . That issue turned out to be critically high calcium levels causing weakness, muscle contracture and tremors and confusion, once the calcium was normalized she was fine again.
On a serious note ..they completely missed her having a stroke ..even though we had brought her to the hospital because we thought she was having one and it was actually supposedly a regional stroke center. They felt it was just her age and a generalized weakness ..despite a prior more mild stroke...we left her there for observation ..relatively normal except for the weakness ( reason they kept her) , and a facial droop we had noted and speech changes ( which I told them was similar to during her prior stroke) ..the next am ..my sister arrived to find her sitting up in bed with a tray in front of her..trying to eat but the food just dribbling back out again since she couldn’t swallow right and her entire left side paralyzed. The hosptial staff had failed to even notice the change!
Sorry for the vent but ..my point is ...that once you reach an old age ..somehow they think you are supposed to be confused and weak ..and fail to look past the numbers
(3)
Report
See 2 more replies
Talk to administration about how they came up with Alzheimer's disease as a diagnosis. Let them know your loved one has Parkinson's dementia - which does have different components and treatment methods. If Alzheimer's disease is a new diagnosis, a doctor should have made the diagnosis and your can question him/her about their assessments.

FYI, Alzheimer's disease is the most common form of dementia. You loved one can have Parkinson's dementia and develop the other or both of the other forms of dementia - vascular (from having a stroke) and Alzheimer's disease.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

My Aunt warned me not to let them diagnose my father with Alzheimer's because they (medical community) treat you differently medically and personally.. She had spent a lot of time in different stages of continuous care, ending her days in a nursing home. I think she is right. My father's doctor listed him as having Alzheimer's after an office visit - without MRI diagnosis - but the death certificate said Vascular Dementia. They are not the same thing and should be treated differently.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

I agree with all those that say "YES, it makes a difference". There may come a time when certain medications are being considered for control of agitation or anxiety and there are medications commonly given to people with Alzheimer's dementia that should be avoided for someone with Lewy Body dementia. And, as other's have pointed out, there is a different set of expectations regarding the trajectory of the disease. I think this can absolutely be done without being adversarial. Right now, it is a medical charting error that simply needs to be corrected. If you have your mother's chart note from the doctor that diagnosed her, that should be sufficient. You will want to go to the Director of Nursing rather than the floor staff. Take the stance that her caregivers are well-intended and would love to provide more appropriate care, and correcting this will help them do it. Even if there is Alzheimer's mixed with LB dementia, the differences with regard to medications, do matter. Be kind, be respectful, but be clear that her records need to be accurate.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Find out from the Head of Nursing or the Ombudsman of the facility why the Alzheimer's dx was just now added.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

I just read your update - it sounds like if you want anything changed you will have to tackle the doctor, which in my experience can be a formidable barrier. My mom's doctor tended to pop into the facility whenever he had a free moment, so other that bumping into him in the hallway when he was on his way to see another patient I never saw the man and I was certainly never part of any care decisions made by him, rather I was informed after the fact. Then of course there is the whole god complex that so many physicians seem prone to, if you have had difficulty being believed by the nurses I can only imagine an MD would be many times harder. (But who knows, yours may be a caring, compassionate people person🤞)
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

So Chrissy, your next conversation is with the doctor, by appointment and face to face. If your request for an interview is declined, you make it clear that the alternative is a formal complaint. You'll get your interview.

At the interview, you ask the doctor to explain his additional commentary and its basis. He may - for all I know - be able to; so don't go in there being antagonistic. You're asking him to explain, you're not there to wring his neck. [Tip: when really angry with fellow medics he felt weren't doing their job properly, my ex used to clear his throat and then sit silent, ominously waiting. That seemed to work beautifully!]

If he can't explain and thereby justify his statement, he must revise and correct the history. As long as you get that, that'll do - you won't want this doctor gone because he'll have learned his lesson.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

so just what was she diagnosed with?  maybe it was a form of dementia but not a full state of dementia.  make an appt with the doctor yourself (IF you have POA) and ask him about the diagnosis and why her chart was changed (or whomever changed it).  make an appt and find out.  ask for test results, etc.  wishing you luck.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

after re-reading your post, I think what she has is in a class of Alzheimers. so maybe that is why they added the dementia part to her chart.  ask the doctor to explain the differences.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

The pandemic gave me lots of time on my hands so I decided to send the medical director/physician at my moms nursing home a letter regarding the Misdiagnosis of Alzheimer’s disease.
I respectfully acknowledged that it would be difficult for one person in charge of a Large facility to review each patients medical records and history, and stated that I feel it is our responsibility (Family)to pass on that information when needed.
I succinctly explained our Extensive journey of testing And diagnosis and included copies of records from the Mayo Clinic and University of Wisconsin stating her actual diagnosis and ruling out Alzheimer’s.
i pointed out that some medications for Alzheimer’s are contraindicated for a person with Lewy Body dementia and for that reason I would like the diagnosis to be correct.
within days of mailing the letter I got a call from the nurse in charge of my moms unit. She is the person who told me in a care meeting that the Dr added that diagnosis and she couldn’t change it. She was apologetic and took the blame for mistakenly choosing that diagnosis while working on her care plan.
she said the letter was “put in her lap” to address and that the diagnosis was corrected.
I am glad I pushed this issue and will continue to advocate for my mom. As I nurse, I know that the staff is aware that we are involved and watching. I hate to be “that family member” but know it is best. Thanks everyone for your replies and encouragement
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Good girl 😊 Bet you feel good.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter