Follow
Share

I suggested to my 93 year old mother that it was selfish to expect me to move over 150 miles from my home of 28 years, leaving everything behind for an unknown length of time, to be her unpaid carer. She snapped back, 'why shouldn't I be selfish! and I remembered my GP's advice. When it comes down to it, do you think my GP is absolutely correct in his assessment that it is either us or them?

Your GP is 1,000% correct! Since I stepped back from my mother's care, I've never felt better.
Helpful Answer (16)
Reply to SRWCF1972
Report

I fear our doctors have too often seen the consequences of one choosing to be basically enslaved to an unreasonable elder out of misplaced obligation or guilt
Helpful Answer (14)
Reply to Daughterof1930
Report

Listen to your GP!!! I agree with them 100%!!

I wish mine had given me that advice. My parents lived across the street from us, and while I don't think they did it intentionally, they treated me like their personal 911 service for 4 years...24/7/365. Anytime they had a real emergency--or thought they did--they called me and it didn't matter if it was day or night with the expectation that i would come over and take care of things. On many occasions, that included multiple calls over night before finally deciding it was time to go to the ER at 4am. I spent Christmas Day 2023 with my mom in the ER and missed spending the day with my own family because Mom's pinched nerve in her back was acting up, missed Thanksgiving Day with my family because Dad had chemo on Wednesday and kept falling all day on Thanksgiving and couldnt get up by himself, etc.. Between the two of them, they had 47 ER visits in 4 years and I took them every single time, along with all the routine visits, check ups, procedures, cancer treatment, hospitalization follow ups, etc.

My health finally broke last year when I had RSV, bacterial pneumonia and viral pneumonia simultaneously. I was sick for 6 weeks. My GP said it was the result of the culminating stress and depleting my immune system thanks to the non-stop phone calls all night, every night with supposed emergencies.

It forced me to step back. I wish I had done so years earlier.
Helpful Answer (14)
Reply to JRwornout
Report

Yes. Your GP is telling you to live your life. Selfish mom has already lived hers, and now she wants to drag you down with her.

Do not move. Do not leave the things you love to become her care slave. Help mom find a place where she will be cared for by professionals. And it should be near you so that you can visit and be her advocate.

It is up to the elderly to make plans for their own care. Your mom thinks you're it. She was wrong! Her aging is her health problem. SHE should make the adjustments in order to get care, NOT you. SHE should be inconvenienced. NOT you.

Just from what you told us, it appears that she's an overentitled, mean, selfish and bossy elder who will make your life miserable over this. Don't give her the pleasure.
Helpful Answer (13)
Reply to Fawnby
Report

YESSSS! It does come down to you preserve your own life or give up your life if you have a selfish parent .
You should NOT move and uproot your life. Your mother should not expect this .
Your mother can sell her home , use her money for assisted living either in her town or by you .
Do not let Mom live with you .

My mother’s geriatrician said these 8 words to me ,
“ I’m more worried about you than your mother . “ It was what I needed to hear .
Helpful Answer (12)
Reply to waytomisery
Report

You are correct. It IS selfish for your mother to expect you to care for her.

I agree with your GP too.

Being a loving daughter does not mean you have to be a hands on caregiver.
Helpful Answer (12)
Reply to Dogwood63
Report

Your Mother is allowed to be selfish, but only with her own time, her own finances, her own home, her own assets. With that, she can get the care she needs elsewhere.

She does not own any part of you or your time.
This is not a piece of pie you both need to share, she has her own pie. You have your own life.

Why this is an argument with her escapes me. She can ask anything she wants but this one qualifies as a big, firm "NO".

Your GP's advice is unique and maybe it speaks to you in a way that you can relate.
It sounds like the best advice ever, are you going to follow it?
Helpful Answer (12)
Reply to Sendhelp
Report

What he said sounds harsh, but in the end, that is what it comes down to. No matter how much you do, you will not be able to make everything o.k. or pleasant for the aged and terminally ill. You can kill yourself in the process of trying and it won't change the outcome. My own Mother went to rehab after falling and breaking 3 ribs at age 92. From there we transitioned her to assisted living where she was for 4 years til she passed. It still took a lot of time, effort and tears. She was mostly a sweetheart, too.
If I had tried to manage it at home, I would be dead by now. It still took a toll on my own mental and physical health. Her gp said to me when she fell and broke the ribs "I think this can be a turning point for you both", meaning it was time for the situation to change.
Your Mom needs the help, the changes/relocations need to be made by her, not you.
Helpful Answer (12)
Reply to Pjdela
Report

I am sitting in a chair at my sister’s assisted living facility right now. An aide is bathing her. She had dinner with three friends in the dining room this evening, and stopped to participate in their activity on her way back to the room. There was flavored iced coffee for everyone at the planned event in the lobby today. She has been here two years, and this is her new home. She loves it here.

My mother-in-law and my husband seem to expect that when MIL got too frail she will come live with us. She is 91, and during Covid came to stay at our home for two months. She could not do the stairs, so she sat in the TV room on the second floor and watched TV all day. I had to cook three meals each day because she was there. If she needed to go somewhere, I had to take her. There were no friends, no activities, no one to help with her personal needs, no bus to the doctors and the store. Just me. Anything good or fun that happened only happened if I made it happen. That alone was extremely stressful. And she was mostly still able to take care of her own needs.

I feel so frustrated when people talk about assisted living centers as warehouses for old people, where we just send them to die. I see the assisted living place where my sister is (and where my mom was until she died) as a great blessing. It is a wonderful community where, if your LO will allow it, they can have a life. Care for an old person takes a team.

my MIL will go to assisted living when the time comes, and not to my home.
Helpful Answer (12)
Reply to WearyJanie
Report
JudyTeen30 Jun 3, 2025
I agree with your comment of people saying assisted living are warehouses where people go to die being so unfair to those who cannot mentally or physically continue to care for older people with multiple issues. In the main we are not trained to manage all the problems because the world requires us to now work until we drop. We cannot sacrifice our lives to devote to the elderly who have multiple needs, unless we want to go back to 19th century living where the eldest daughter stayed at home first to help rear their siblings then to look after their parents. It is utterly selfish for a generation to expect to be pandered to in their or our homes and have us as their unpaid help when they most likely never did it for their parents nor did they give any thought to managing their situations as they aged.
(1)
Report
Love your GP's bluntness. Would have helped me a while back..

I remember back when the demands were growing & multiplying.. (I called it the bottomless bog of needs).

I need ABC-XYZ. I want YOU to do ABC-XYZ.

I said "I hear you. You need ABC-XYZ. I will do A. You will need to find OTHER people to do all the rest."

You get the LOOK.. of What!!??
How Dare You. 😂
But in time, my LO saw the truth of it. They did in fact hire & arrange OTHER people.
Helpful Answer (11)
Reply to Beatty
Report

See All Answers
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter