Follow
Share

I took care of my father for over 10 years while my brother and his wealthy wife traveled the world in luxury. I paid for every restaurant lunch and dinner, with the exception of like two times, probably on my birthday. Recently my brother, who now lives close by, bought my father $300 in groceries. He forgot some items and my father asked me to go out and get them, at a cost of about $80. I am not in the same situation as my brother, particularly right now. I kind of hesitated and my father looked me up and down with this look of "what kind of disgusting person doesn't have $80 to buy groceries for his elderly father?".



Yesterday I told him my work is consuming all my time, which is true, and he says "Well, your brother is the only one with time that can help me." That is so insulting to me! It's like he's trying to play me against my brother. Am I imagining this? I am ready to leave right after the holidays. I don't care if I leave with just the clothes on my back. This just feels so abusive to me and I want out! Am I overblowing this?



PS. I just found out that my brother's wife has cut him off from large spending and has given him a long list of daily chores. So now my father will have to make plans to have a paid caregiver tend to him if I leave. This will be good for him. I now feel like the position of parent and child has been reversed!

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Father is doing this because it’s worked so effectively to divide the two of you sibs.

You came in, in March, and since then, have enabled Dad to have both a care contact paid for via wife, plus additional time spent by you, your nephews and so forth.

If wife is putting her foot down on these aides, and you can’t do what these aides do, then perhaps the whole discussion should pivot to managed care.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
lisatrevor Nov 2022
Oh, it is. And I'm not feeling bad about it whatsoever. In fact I can see a whole new life for me, by me and only me! I'm sick of trying to please my father.
(7)
Report
https://www.agingcare.com/questions/looking-for-advice-on-a-recent-home-maintenance-situation-at-my-fathers-house-475030.htm

https://www.agingcare.com/questions/caregiver-treated-this-way-am-i-wrong-476855.htm

https://www.agingcare.com/discussions/issue-with-brother-update-relationship-over-473809.htm?orderby=recent&page=2

Lisatrevor your posts are always looking for validation of some sort. There's nothing wrong with that in itself, but we only get 1 side of the story so it's not objective validation. But maybe that's really what you want.

The overarching answer to all your posts is to move out and move on. This is called a boundary. Have you ever talked to a therapist about co-dependent relationships? It might be helpful. Plus you'll get a truly objective opinion of your situation.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
lisatrevor Nov 2022
I have never spoken with a therapist. I don't have anyone else I can talk to. The last 10 years or more have been devoted to my family and work (and I work alone). I looked up some old friends (from like middle school!) but I learned many of them have major problems themselves and I don't think that would good. For example, some are alcoholics and turned out very irresponsible. Some of them have major health issues. Some have large families and busy careers. At least this forum is easy to access and might have some good ideas. What I say about my situation is not in great detail but the "gist" is exact.
(0)
Report
See 2 more replies
Lisa, I didn't even read this. But I will say that people cannot play games with you if you aren't an active participant in said games.
You and your brother have had problems from the beginning. The family dynamics are what they are, what I suspect they always will be. If you don't like it, your idea of moving away, whether figuratively or literally--the idea you always mention--still sounds good to me.
Sorry to be rude, as far as other reading this go, but suggest reading the history of lisa, the father and the brother; it's a long one.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Can we just not?
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

Simple, back off let your brother handle everything.

You have done enough, time to leave the drama behind.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Parents definitely Play siblings against each other - Why I have No idea But you can bet your Brother has a hand in this especially if the wife is cutting him off and giving him chores . What your Father is doing is abusive . 10 years is a Long time . I Hope you can Move forward with your Life .
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

You and your brother created a monster because you both believed dad deserved to live like a king. But it seems the king has become a tyrant. Your dad has been playing you and your brother against each other for a long time.

Based on your other posts it didnt sounded like you were taking care of him for 10 years that was all your brother.

I bet you are regretting not supporting brother when he wanted to move him into a facility right about now.

The lack of communication in your family is sad. But not uncommon with a dynamic like your family has. You need to sit down and have a talk with dad. Tell him you cant afford to buy him groceries and whatever else is on your mind.

Now that husband's wife has finally stopped the nonsemse of buying dad whatever he wants maybe real change can happen. It's not going to be easy but it can be done.

Good luck to you.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
lisatrevor Nov 2022
I took care of my father for 10 years before he moved to be near my brother. My brother then took care of him. Then I moved to be near both of them.

I forgot to add that I did all my father's house chores over those 10 years and gave up most of my precious vacation time to make sure he was not alone. It was never a burden, I did it gladly, but the way I'm treated now makes me feel like I wasted so many years. The good news is still do have a fairly long future ahead.
(1)
Report
You're back, Lisatrevor? It's been a while. What new tall tales will you be captivating us with today? Maybe your brother and SIL also went to the moon or the lost continent of Atlantis on one of their luxury vacations. It sounds good. Why not throw it in with your story telling?
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

"I took care of my father for 10 years before he moved to be near my brother. My brother then took care of him. Then I moved to be near both of them."

THAT was your first big mistake.

NOT moving away like you claimed you would do months ago is your second big mistake. Why didn't you do that?
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
lisatrevor Nov 2022
You are getting closer to the reality; it's much more subtle though. I love my father, brother and his family. It's just that the emotional abuse (like shaming, trying to incite envy, telling me my faults, true or not, etc.) is so hard to put up with. Maybe everyone goes through similar levels and I just need to deal with it. I do believe there's people in family relationships where this type of behavior does not happen at all.

Leaving would take me away from my father's remaining years. He took care of me and my brother as children and did so at great sacrifice. He wasn't perfect but overall he was and is still a great father. It's a tough decision. At least I have a little bit of nature here where I can go safely for walks. If it were a totally urban environment I would have left by now.
(0)
Report
Simple end to this.
Stop playing games.
Games generally need at least 2 people to play. If you quit the game sounds like you will be the "winner".
You do not mention in your profile what "caregiving" your dad needs.
But if he was/is physically or financially able to do all the things you have said you have done for the past 10 years then he really has pulled the wool over your eyes.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
BurntCaregiver Nov 2022
@Grandma

There are no "games" being played. Lisatrevor like always is playing games with us. Making up stories to get attention or pity from the members of this group.
(3)
Report
See 1 more reply
Can we not bully LisaTrevor? She deserves acknowledgment for recognizing that no dad, I can’t or won’t provide you extra money regardless of what brother does. That I have a job that’s not about tending to him like these aides do. That if it’s become mission critical for aides to do that and Dad can’t or won’t do that with the assets remaining, that it’s either that or he goes into care?

Give her credit and acknowledgment for acknowledging this now instead of harping on her for what she said before.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
BurntCaregiver Nov 2022
PeggySue,

Look at past posts. He/she is not a caregiver.
This is a bored person looking for attention. This isn't the place for that.
A therapist's office or a support group like group therapy is.
(4)
Report
See 2 more replies
"I'm sick of trying to please my father."

I think that is your problem. You are looking for Love where there isn't any. You Dad looks at women differently than men. They are just there to wait on him. Your Dad is a "taker" not a giver. He does it with you and her does it with your brother. As long as you two cater to him, he is going to lap it up.

The wife has the money and she is tired of spending it on a man who just takes and takes. Time for Dad to go to an AL. It would benefit everyone. And if he refuses to go, the money train stops. Having boundries does not mean your disrepectful. I have followed your posts. I know members have told you to move out. Please Lisa...move out. Your beating a dead horse. Dad is not going to change. For you its been this way for a long time. Your only hurting yourself trying to continue to look for Dad to say "thank you". He can't say it because he expects it. He can't because he does not know how.

Time to realize you will never have the relationship with Dad (and brother) that you want. It won't happen. You need to MOVE OUT. Make another life for yourself or your going to be a very lonely person. Don't expect things out of people. Just be happy when someone does a nice thing for you. The big thing "look inside yourself". What can u change about yourself. Time to move on from this situation. It will not get better. You can build a better life.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
BurntCaregiver Nov 2022
JoAnn,

It's Lisatrevor you're saying all of this too. Surely you remember past posts from this person? Don't give him/her? anymore attention.
(0)
Report
This past weekend I was planning on picking up some items for Thanksgiving at a particular supermarket that is close to my brother's house. I was going to drop everything off at his house then. Well, I called my father and he told me he was invited to my brother's for dinner. I said that I would stop over to drop off the items. He gives me the hint that I should not stop over then and I should drop everything over on the weekday (when it's not a family gathering).

For so many years I made sure that all our holidays were really good. For my father, nephews, my brother and his wife's birthdays I bought them very thoughtful gifts that they enjoyed. I went way above and beyond what a good daughter, sister and aunt should be. I moved here from far away out of the goodness of my heart to a place that has higher crime, worse weather and many problems of a larger city and now I'm being excluded from family gatherings during the holidays? What the heck! What did I do (or not do)?

I hope someone else who is in a similar position reads this and knows that it's not you - it's them. It's time that I start living my life for myself! I know I've been saying this but it's so difficult when it's your parent who raised you well (by my standards). Thanks for listening. I'm going for a walk before it gets dark!
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
sp19690 Nov 2022
Why don't you ask your brother why you are not invited to Thanksgiving and ask your father why he thinks that is ok. I am sorry but your father sounds like a terrible person and I have to question if he was even a decent father at this point with alk the bull sheet he does to you and your brother.
(2)
Report
See 2 more replies
It's difficult to leave because your parent raised you well?

That was their job, to raise you to become an independent individual.

Your job is to live a successful life, not hang about and wait for gratitude.

LIsa, move on and leave your dad to your brother. Stop competing with your brother to be "the best".
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Quit begging for love, appreciation, and validation. Move on like you've repeatedly said you wanted to do.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

LIsa, I ask this question with kindness: have you been diagnosed with an Autistic Spectrum Disorder?

You appear, quite consistently, not to get the subtleties of social relationships.

You brother invited your father to dinner. Having you show up at brother's would be awkward, as you were not invited to dinner. Thus the "hint" not to show up at brother's.

There is much you seem to miss about the social "big picture". Perhaps you should consider working with a therapist who can help facilitate the development of your social skills and "savvy".
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
lisatrevor Nov 2022
No! My father told me subtly not to bring Thanksgiving groceries over to my brother's house last weekend because they were having dinner with the whole family. My father told me that I was invited to my brother's house for Thanksgiving. My brother did not but I think I am in fact invited, but really these days I don't know! At least I will be bringing some goodies that the family will appreciate,

I have never been diagnosed of anything but all my life I do not do well in social situations. It seems others can't get things out of a relationship with me that they can with others. This started when I was started middle school. I was part of the "in", cool kids. That's ok because I learned that works in my favor in a number of ways. I have one good friend but we haven't spoken in a long time because they are having major issues with their family. I am more of a decent person than most people. For example, since I moved here there have been so many problems in my neighborhood. A lot of people are simply disrespectful of others (noise, unbehaved dogs, dishonesty, etc.).
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
LIsa, In your shoes, I would contact the organization Autism Speaks and read some of their literature.

Many adults, especially women, present with the sort of profile you do and are in fact on the Autism spectrum. The diagnostic criteria have changed over the years and there is increasing recognition that ASD in girls looks different from ASD in boys.

You should read this book:

https://www.amazon.com/Journal-Best-Practices-Marriage-Asperger/dp/1439189749?ref=d6k_applink_bb_dls&dplnkId=7226f65d-458c-4ab9-8f5f-778d5f302170
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
lisatrevor Nov 2022
I looked at what you recommended. I don't have autism at all based on the signs at any age! I don't even think it's possible to make any kind of diagnosis by what someone posts on the internet. In my experience most people are "normal" and a small percentage have what is called autism. Autism is a disability in that interferes negatively with one's survival. That's not to say people with autism can't have exceptional or even amazing qualities. The fact that someone wants to get opinions from strangers online is not just "normal" it can be a very good idea. On another forum I got a recommendation for a walking shoe that literally changed my life!

But thank you for listening and your opinion. I believe the internet is overwhelmingly a benefit to mankind; it's people who abuse others on it are the problem.
(2)
Report
Lisa,

In the future, ie Christmas, contact the host family directly. Don’t take Dads word anymore.

Plus I thought dad had aides already. But you called them “service providers.” Sorry, but that piece of the story makes no sense.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

If anyone cares, I went to Thanksgiving at my brother's. Everything went ok except one major thing! First some background: My father had a dispute with a contractor at his house. My brother said there is no recourse. I said I would check with an attorney. So I called two attorneys. One got back to me last Wednesday and said my father had absolutely no recourse. I told my brother and he told his family. At Thanksgiving my father brought up the dispute and my nephew says to me "My dad told you there was nothing that could be done; you're incompetent." I didn't say anything but all I could do was think that if I ever said something like that to my aunt I would have been in big, really big, trouble! I made sure this nephew had the best birthdays and Christmases ever for many years. This year they may get coal, or nothing. Probably nothing.

Well, on Monday the other attorney got back to me - he said my father has "definite recourse" because of certain criteria. I told the contractor's office this and they settled the next day! Amazing!

I hope someone else finds a valuable lesson in this. Just because someone may have more money than you it doesn't mean they are automatically right, like my brother's foolish family did. And secondly, when faced with a legal issue ALWAYS get at least two opinions from two different attorneys. I can't believe in this case each one had two opposite opinions and one of them was right! Didn't they both go to law school and pass the bar exam?

It's a jungle out there! Always know that there are people who care, even if you can't see them!
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
JoAnn29 Dec 2022
Sorry Lisa I just don't know why u put up with your family. Seems all they do is demean you. You may be looking for love from Dad but I do not think u will ever find it.
(4)
Report
JoAnn29: There is love between me and my father. It's not constant demeaning, they say good things about me, too. Still the demeaning things are hard to put up with. Even my father's friend who called over the holiday weekend said to me "I heard you went away for the weekend recently." I said "Yes.". He then says "Now you're back there. Haha. Sorry I didn't mean it.". He was making fun of me that I got to get away from this negative environment for awhile but now I'm back. Why say something like that? What kind of crap is in his brain? He should have just said "I heard you went away for the weekend recently. I hope you enjoyed yourself." and just ended it like that.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Sorry Lisa, but in previous posts it has not sounded like there is any respect there. You have said you Dad takes your brothers opinions over yours. And I do admit, you are usually right. But, it seems the males in ur family are male chauvinists. Your a woman with no brain in ur head. I know where I am coming from, my Dad was one. I can remember him saying "you'll make a good wife". Why, because I enjoyed cooking and baking. He expected my Mom to wait on him hand and foot. Yes, he loved Mom and me and he showed it in his way. But, my brothers were allowed a lot more freedom because...they were males.

IMO, what is expected of you is to clean cook and do Dads wash. That is it. Otherwise, you keep your opinions to yourself.

"My dad told you there was nothing that could be done; you're incompetent." Really! At least you "went" out of your way to find out. Did the same nephew apologize after you told brother a lawyer said there maybe some recourse. If not, maybe you should demand that he apologize because you are not as incompetent as ur brother thinks. And, does not look like dear Dad stands up for you.

"Now you're back there. Haha. Sorry I didn't mean it." This friend is seeing something that you seem to turning a blind eye too. He sees that you are getting no respect or appreciation for what ur doing. Really, I don't know how you put up with the disrespect. You deserve so much more. Just because you aren't financially set like brother does not make u less of a person. And look, its his wife that brought in the money. If you are going to continue to care for Dad, you need to stand up to these bullys. Me, I would have walked away by now.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
BurntCaregiver Dec 2022
JoAnn,

The name lisatrevor is from a video game so who knows it this is a female or male. More likely this is a troll or a person with problems looking for attention in the wrong places for them.
(3)
Report
See 2 more replies
Thank you to everyone who listened. I have a theory that demeaning comments and behaviors are endemic - in highly developed countries. It's actually all about economics, i.e., money. There are lots of opportunities in highly developed countries, but also lots of competition. This causes some people to resort to behaviors that hurt the self-esteem of others thereby making it easier for them to get ahead. The perfect example, would be a coworker belittling another in front of others. The other worker then doesn't do their job as well and they are overlooked for the promotions. Obviously not everyone engages in this kind of behavior. In my recent case with my nephew he said what he did to give himself importance and me none. It was a way of ensuring that in the future I will never be in any control in any way over resources within the extended family. He wants it all.

So how does one successfully deal with it? Simply just keep on living your life, not someone elses, without doubt of your abilities and always do the right thing. What will happen is you will cut right through all the negativity and you experience countless joys in your life that you create. Don't let anyone bring you down!
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

I feel compelled to tell what happened to me earlier this evening. It is the last I will post about my family. I was ready to get a takeout for me and my father when my brother called and invited my father, and me, to his house for dinner that would be ready shortly. We arrived at his house and I was very hungry. They had a shrimp cocktail dish on a kitchen counter that was maybe 1/3 full, about 7 large shrimps left. I went to reach for one and my nephew takes his bare hand and palms all the shrimp in one swipe and grins like "I'm smart. I know you won't eat these now, These are mine." I just gave him a really dirty look and walked away. This is my family? Well, thank you all for telling me it's time to go! It is!
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter