Why does my mother turn everything into an argument?

brdlvr, I have a feeling it isn't you. My mother is very argumentative. She has been as long as I can remember. Talking with her is like a Point-Counterpoint show. If I say I like something, she says she doesn't. This is about everything. If I say I don't care about something, she says that I should care. There is no winning and nothing to be won, anyway. She is just contrary. She has dementia, but I can't blame it on the dementia. It does get on the nerves when it feels like conversation is only an argument. If I say I don't want to argue, she'll say that she wasn't arguing, she was just trying to explain something to me. ARG! In Caregiver Heaven there will be no arguing I hope.

Your profile says your mother has mobility problems. Do you think that she has trouble getting in and out of the Starbucks? I'm just trying to figure out why she might have opposed the idea, after seeming to want to sit and talk.

Is your mom normally reasonable and pleasant or normally cranky? Is she suffering from pain?

Have you noticed any mental decline? I know that when my cousin, who first started with dementia symptoms, I didn't know what was going on. She would disagree with me about anything. Every conversation was of her getting upset over nothing. In hind sight, I see how it was actually her brain changing and she wasn't responsible. I ended up walking out on her a lot, because you couldn't reason with her. Later, I hate it was like that, but, I just didn't know.

If your mom is just being unreasonable to be unreasonable, I might discuss it with her doctor to see if she has a UTI, cognitive decline or depression. All you can do, is all you can do. You can't make her happy if she's either unable to be or chooses not to be.

When every trip becomes a battle, you STOP taking her anywhere. You were absolutely correct to excuse yourself and leave. My SIL got to the facility to pick up mom, who met her at the door with "Where the F--k have you been?". She turned around and immediately left. You have to do that to survive.

Is this argumentative behavior new for your mother, or just her usual behavior ratcheted up a notch? If she's always been like this, there really is no point in asking why, is there? But if it is new a little investigation might be in order. Is she suffering more pain lately? Does she seem depressed? Do you think that her cognitive skills have declined any recently? Might she have a UTI or other illness?

Have you tried asking her why she is doing this? "Mom, it seems like lately we get into arguments no matter what. Can you think of why that is?"

Why she is doing this might help determine how to react to it. For example, if she has an illness or pain that might deserve a different response than if she has always been crabby.

Can you take the wind out of her sails by agreeing with her? "You are right, Mom. I did complain about not getting home early enough. But today I'm willing to relax a little over a croissant. Is that OK, or would you rather take them home?"

You certainly don't have to put up with her crabbiness. But if the cause is something like depression (which often manifests as anger) or mental decline or pain you might also want to try to help her while you are protecting yourself.

So sorry to hear this! I can share my experiences and see if this somehow relates to you. Others might also find it helpful.

It's called ANGER ADDICTION, now exacerbated by aging, medical conditions, and a controlling personality. It just gets worse and worse as these things contribute to the addiction. She's always had a bit of an angry, disagreeable personality, because she always had to be "right!" That's classic sign of a controlling personality. Scenarios are invented to control an outcome so she can be right, to push buttons, be disagreeable, create anger, to feed her constant addiction. The best thing you can do for yourself is learn to understand this disorder, how to deal with it. (Anger addiction, controlling personality, manipulation) That's exactly what I did and it's helped me tremendously with my now 96 year old grandmother who has given me plenty of grief throughout my life! I only found a particular book a couple of years ago when I began to learn more about myself, and then several others through self-help, was struggling to make a new life and was not going to let anyone emotionally abuse me again. It's called "Controlling People" by Patricia Evans. She has a series of books I found insightful. Best of luck to you. You must always take care of yourself first!

brdlvr1, try to picture your Mom with her ears layed back when she is in a argument mode.... kinda like an animal does while growling. It might lighten the situation for you.

Or give her a Snicker's bar.

brdlvr1, it is tough for a person to get older. Gone are the days that they could just hop into a car and drive it to the store for croissants and do errands. Gone are the days that walking was easier, seeing was easier, even taking a shower and getting dressed was easier. Depending on your Mother's age, probably most of her friends/relatives have either moved or passed on. I would be grumpy, too.

Sometimes it is easier to just say "Mom, you are right" so then she would shut down the argument, hopefully.

Does Mom have a chance to be around anyone her own age? Any senior centers nearby or would she dig in her heels and not go.... or say "that's for old people". Wouldn't it be great if she made some new friends, to give her something else to talk about.

... and a protective helmet so you can bump your head on the wall without hurting yourself. :)

Something I've thought about with my mother is that she does it to push me away. She was always a hermit and doesn't like many people. The contrariness usually sets in about 5 minutes after I'm in a room. It makes me want to argue out of self defense, but I just get up and leave after a few minutes. Maybe that is what she is actually trying to accomplish -- getting rid of me. It often seems that way.

Yes, I agree that I believe that it's a combination of cognitive decline, difficulty in doing most things, pain, and probably some depression. I try to do things for her and make it fun, but like I said in the post, it seems that I can do no right on certain days. She even apologized one day for being so hard on me. She was arguing with me basically the minute I came in. She does have a history of being defiant, but I think it's just getting worse. Sometimes I feel like it's just for the sake of arguing and keeping me there longer, What she doesn't seem to realize is that when she does this, it makes me want to leave sooner. I know I have to be patient, caring, and understanding, but I'm not perfect either.