Follow
Share

I'm getting tired of having to stay home taking care of everything here while husband goes out of state to help his elderly mother. Flights are costly so one stays behind while the other goes. We take turns, but I usually only stay 10 days, that's all I can take with all the work there, and having to return home to stuff also. It's not good for our marriage either. Does any of you have the same situation?

Find Care & Housing
Your MIL needs to sell her home and figure out what she needs to do for the next stage of her life. It might be best for her to go into AL near you.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to Hothouseflower
Report

I've been to Hawaii (Maui) 28 times. Every roundtrip is exhausting to me, even from California (via Oakland Airport).

The Hawaiian culture praises seniors as Wise Elders. Why she will never leave.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Dawn88
Report
MeDolly Dec 24, 2023
Her not leaving Maui is her problem, not yours.

If your husband doesn't have the backbone to embrace your needs there is a marriage problem here.

This is all crazy, it is no longer about what she wants, it is about what she and your family need.

Stop going, let hubby take care of her, not your responsibility.

Believe it or not, you have rights, although you seem unwilling to stand up for yourself.
(7)
Report
See 1 more reply
I used to be part of a family care support team. I called it The Magic Doll House.

After a (insert long story) needs +++, my stress +++, professional & informal advice, then 💡 in short, I quit.

I thought my enabling may cause a floor to collapse. Didn't - but, the other enablers had to find replacement services. They did & more Non-Family help was employed. While resisted at first, now fully welcomed & much appreciated.

The Doll's House gained MORE support (without frying up family). Success!

Folk can think "oh they are ok, do most everything themself, just need a little help". Yet if it was YOU Dixie that ran the household, did the chores & errands & kept it clean, you have a magic dolls house situation too.

Let your Husband go to play House alone with his Mother.
Helpful Answer (8)
Reply to Beatty
Report

Dixiepenny, I have caught up on your posts.

You can make changes now, you don't want to, big difference. Obviously, your husband rules the roost and you follow his lead.

That is your choice and I wish you the best!
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to MeDolly
Report
lealonnie1 Dec 24, 2023
Exactly. We ALL have the power of choice in this life. And we teach others how to treat us and how far they can push us, too. W/o boundaries, a person can be pushed into an early grave!
(5)
Report
He is as stubborn as his mother!
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to Dixiepenny
Report
Beatty Dec 24, 2023
Often, they just don't what else to do!

Turning up to 'fix' things is their go-to. Quick, fix it, go home.

Long term planning are skills I see clearly in many woman friends.. but even my own DH is like, see that problem, spear it, done. A cave-man really 🤪
(3)
Report
Dixie, my 2 siblings and I took turns traveling for two years to take care of my mom (80 w/Dementia) and my dad (84). The time, the effort, strain on marriages & cost isn’t sustainable as the caregivers. We finally (with much opposition from my dad) sold their home and moved them close to us 3 kids (from UT to FL). Still lots of work, but now it’s just a short drive away.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to KristyRivera
Report
Dixiepenny Dec 24, 2023
That'd be nice if she lived within driving distance from us. There's an ocean between us so it's difficult, especially when dealing with someone who's stubborn. For now, I'm happy to be able to vent on here, as that's all I can do at the moment.
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
Dixie, you say “If it wasn't for the cats, I'd be more ambitious to leave and live somewhere else”. You have FOUR FERAL CATS. If they aren’t neutered, you could move on to 12 feral cats in about a year. Are you going to stop yourself from dying because of them, just because no-one else will care for them? This is even more silly than the care for MIL. Take a look in the mirror.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to MargaretMcKen
Report
Dixiepenny Dec 24, 2023
Hi Margaret, The next door neighbors moved and the cats were being taken care of by them. All are spayed. No kittens from them. Having compassion for animals, I started feeding them, and giving them a place they could rest and stay as a colony as they were.
I wouldn't feel good walking away knowing they depended on us, so that's a problem, but then again, If we decided to sell our house I could try taking them somehow with us, OR list it saying the cat family comes with the house, and hopefully get people who have a heart to care for them as we've been doing for over 6 yrs now.
(2)
Report
See 2 more replies
I have to say at 96, I do not understand how she is not ready for Visiting Angels or to be placed in a home with people her own age.

My mother is 98, loves being in assisted living, new friends, bus trips, activities. She doesn't have to maintain a home, cook or clean.

You two are her crutch and don't want to face the truth, she is no longer independent.

She is his problem not yours, back away, let him do the lifting from now on.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to MeDolly
Report

MIL is "not ready" for Visiting Angels or housekeepers or anything else because she has YOU and her son to do it all FOR her for free. Why would she be "ready"? And your husband puts you on speaker phone with her to shame you into going there to care for her FOR NO GOOD REASON. She's capable and in good health, just needs errand boys to do her bidding, which should be her SON 100%. Let HIM do 100% of this nonsense from now on, w/o excuses and w/o saying how it isn't easy. It's very easy to say ENOUGH. I'm done being an errand boy and housekeeper for an old woman who can easily PAY others to do these things for her! At my age, I've EARNED the right to STOP doing these things for others and have others do them for ME, for petesake.

Stand up for yourself now and let hubby feel the pain of doing all this nonsense for mother ALONE. Her needs and her wants are 2 different things and neither one of them will see that until YOU step OUT of the picture. You're enabling BOTH of them, don't you see that????
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to lealonnie1
Report
Dixiepenny Dec 24, 2023
I see that. In the future trips I'll try making him go more often. Time is moving fast and this may change eventually, not sure when though. Say some prayers for us please. Could use prayers.
(0)
Report
Dixie,
You say in your responses to us that you continue to do this, even recognizing that she needs to be in some assistive care, and you do it because "your husband is not ready" to force this issue.

That you continue is really, then, your choice. I wouldn't. I would tell hubby "Hon, I admire your supporting love for your Mom, but I am not up to it. I can't make this trip, do this care any more. I will come with you one day every few weeks, but I think your Mom needs to be in care now. My attempting to sacrifice my needs is simply enabling the denial that this needs to get done. I will let you and Mom make decisions now for her. And I love you, will be here to make YOU a lovely home and meals, and here to talk, but I won't be doing this any more".

Don't expect agreement.
Don't expect others to help; they have no intention of doing so.
Simply make your own choices for your own life and stop enabling this merry-go-round.
Best out to you and thanks for being so responsive to suggestions.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to AlvaDeer
Report

It sounds like Mom is doing pretty well at 96. Outsource everything you can. Grocery delivery, door dash, meds delivered, weekly cleaning lady, yard guy etc. I'd try for some caregivers 4 hours a day.

Next time you are in Hawaii do a hiring spree.

When both of you are out there get a motel for several days for the two of you.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to brandee
Report

Ok she is old and needs help...so she can hire the help. My father used to complain to my daughter that I never "visit" him. She pointed out I was there often but he said I was always doing something. Of course I was because the second I walked through the door he was putting me to work. So it was no longer a visit. Tell your husband you are done with the work visits. The next visit you make will be to look for AL places for her. And I agree with the need vs. want. She wants to stay put but in order to do that you all have to do the heavy lifting. What is she doing to insure she can remain in her home?
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to lkdrymom
Report
Dixiepenny Dec 23, 2023
She can get around good enough to make her morning coffee, and always has to have 2 cups. It's the same with me, when I go there, all I do is chores and run errands non stop. Then she likes to visit and tell stories about her life so time gets late and it's bedtime. She does need to be in assisted living place, but my husband and his mom are not on track with that, not yet. She may end up having someone move in with her, but she always makes bad decisions and having someone move in there, it'd not be the best idea since she's too weak and will let people walk all over her and not do much, just wanting a free place to live, seen it happen before in past years what she's done. Long story. so that's kinda why we're in this situation right now, husband says it won't last too long....then there are a couple grown grand kids who plan on coming out there from the east coast for "vacations" and free everything, more to that story, it's another issue. They don't work or do much, just have a good time being tourist and going places and out to eat at a place she is a member and she pays the tab. We don't even do that, it isn't that thrilling to go there, so we just cook and eat at her house and help complete needed repairs or etc.
(2)
Report
Either she really needs those visits, in which case she should be in assisted living instead - you and your husband cannot keep this up

Or, she does not really need those visits and dont do them.

If she is really in enough need to require visits of 2-3 weeks, she needs assisted living

My own mom who lives in senior independent living claims she does not need assisted living. My sister in law tells her, you already are in assisted living. It is called Karsten (me)

I should add while I have more toxic issues with my mom, I do live twenty minutes way so helping her out for her practical needs is not as burdensome as having to fly there for two or three week stretches.
Helpful Answer (7)
Reply to Karsten
Report

Next time you go "visit" (i.e. become MIL's slave), investigate some of the nicest assisted living communities. Talk with their sales staff and ask what incentives or advice they offer to move in someone with your MIL's issues. They see this all the time.

Some places have such advantages for their residents that once MIL sees how great it is, she may want to do it. What kind of life does she have in her house? No company, and things are bad enough that you MUST go there? At home she gets food delivered, but at AL she'd have friends to eat with, field trips, assistance to shop, go to entertainment, etc. etc. She has housecleaning help at home, but at AL she would too, and they come and they go efficiently, maybe when she's out having fun.

People get stuck on "I want to die at home." They have no idea what a burden that is to someone like you (and I've done it for my parents, so I know whereof I speak). Someday you may deeply regret that you spent precious days and weeks of your life jumping to the tune of an old woman who, deep in her heart, couldn't care less about you and your husband and your marriage. I know I do.

Let this sink in for a bit, and I may be back with more thoughts.
Helpful Answer (11)
Reply to Fawnby
Report
Dixiepenny Dec 23, 2023
Gee, you are so right. I know you have the experience like we're having now, and I already do regret and recent all the precious time this is costing me and my husband and not sharing our life events and experiences together because we are too busy with her and her needs. I agree she doesn't care that much about me, and seems spoiled with all the help from us, and leaving our home to go to her mess. She's a hoarder and it's difficult to get rid of anything, and when we do, it's "gotta be donated" to a cause, Charity, church, library, or etc. but that all takes time too.
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
She hires a cleaning person but not when ur there. I have a hard time getting up enough gumption to clean my house (74) let alone clean someone else's. I would tell her to continue to pay that cleaning person because at 78, I am not cleaning ur house.

It is said that at 96 you have to make changes but thats how it is. Her child is now a Senior too. When Alva said maybe she can move "near you" she did not mean in with you. Not a good thing for two women to live in the same house especially when both are Seniors.
Helpful Answer (11)
Reply to JoAnn29
Report

Husband is not understanding the situation.

Instead of you cutting back or plea bargaining, put your foot down.

You can’t, and won’t, go out to mother’s anymore. You are done.

Since the husband and his mom think she is the center of your family’s universe, they can go on living in their fantasy world.
Helpful Answer (8)
Reply to LoopyLoo
Report
Dixiepenny Dec 23, 2023
Wish it was that easy to say and do. I'm almost to that point. We have 4 feral cats who depend on us to care for them, and they live on our property too, very comfortably. If it wasn't for the cats, I'd be more ambitious to leave and live somewhere else, not CA.
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
Dixie ,
In one of your replies you said you suggested Visiting Angels and your mother in law says she’s “ not ready for that yet “.
She’s never going to be ready for that as long and you and your husband are her free visiting angels.
Tell her and your husband , it’s time . You can’t be her visiting angel anymore. She has to hire them.
Helpful Answer (15)
Reply to waytomisery
Report
AlvaDeer Dec 22, 2023
Of course she isn't ready. Why would she be. This is working just fine for her.
To me this is unthinking selfishness. My own parents endeavored all their lives to do ANYTHING not to be burdens to their children. When parents don't do that, then that says it all.
I am sorry, but at some point "what we want" just doesn't figure in the equation. In fact, if you've lived a little while when DID what you want figure in the equation.

I don't understand children who get drawn in this out of guilt, out of bullying, out of expectations of others, out of anything. It seems to me a lack of basic honesty to sit someone down and say "I am sorry. We cannot continue this. Let's help you explore YOUR OPTIONS." This can be said with love and with gentleness.
(10)
Report
How about you take Mil to a good Elder Law attorney the next time you visit and have her explain about the greedy relatives.

He can write a cease and desist letter which starts a paper trail, putting them on notice that you're on to their shenanigans.

Has DH accompanied her to doc appointments and asked about the wisdom of her remaining home alone?
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to BarbBrooklyn
Report

Dixie, your MIL sounds very able for 96, healthy & quite reasonable too 😀

However, the East Coasters.. yikes.

Has MIL nominated a POA to act on her behalf if she needed it?
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Beatty
Report
sp196902 Dec 22, 2023
You are joking about the healthy and reasonable stuff right? MIL needs to be in a facility at this point.
(4)
Report
Hi Dixie
your latest comment is a whole other issue - Sounds like you are saying that she is not that bad but that you are going there for 2-3 weeks to ward off the east coast family from coming?
this is a whole other monkey wrench then.....
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to strugglinson
Report

So MIL doesn't want to move from Honolulu. OK. I get that.

Do they have assisted living in Honolulu? Just saying..

MIL doesn’t want to move from her house either? OK.
What about visiting angels/CNA's?

Houses. A place to live, roof over our heads. But also so much more!

Just because someone lives in a house does not mean they are still independant. That's a farce.

But sometimes familes can make a dependant family member's life stage work out. Sometimes they move in with them fulltime - would you consider that?
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to Beatty
Report
Dixiepenny Dec 22, 2023
We have our own life and house here in CA, and we don't want to live with her either. The easiest has been to leave her alone for a couple wks and then fly over to help her for a couple wks and etc... We are going there more often to fill the calendar to ward off the east coast relatives from coming there taking advantage of her and swaying her to do things like change her Will or give them things or maybe even moving in with her to accomplish what their motives are. So this is one reason why we're in this position right now.
She is not disabled but uses a cane to get around and walker to go outside for mail or newspaper, she's actually okay for now, as a person who is 96, but not sure for how long. Sits at computer doing emails and replying to people. Reads the newspaper, and watches TV alot. She takes a couple naps each day, and sleeps approx 7-8 hrs a night, so she gets plenty of rest. She hires people to do yardwork, and sometimes a maid to do chores, except now that we're coming there more often maids are not needed as much.
(2)
Report
See 1 more reply
This ‘need’ versus ‘want’ thing…. My grandson when aged three already understood this. He liked playing with my spectacles, and said to me very seriously “Grandma I NEED your spectacles’. Clearly even a very small child can guess that ‘need’ is more important than ‘want’, even if he had absolutely nothing useful to do with my spectacles! 'I NEED your spectacles" has become a family joke. Try it on MIL, and see if she gets the point.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to MargaretMcKen
Report

It's good to look at this.

#1 Timeframe.
Is this a short-term situation?
Eg rehabing or time-limited treatment - with hope of return of function?
Or long-term? A new normal.

#2 Fuction level - in your opinion, where does your Mother-in-Law's daily life mostly fit?
1. Independant: able to manage all activities of daily life inc medications, diet, hygiene, transport, home enviroment, finances.
2. Semi *light grey area* requires some help eg have groceries, meals, medications delivered, cleaning service. Help with larger financial matters. (Services could be set up but supervised long distance by family).
3. Semi *grey area* requires assistance to set up & manage home services or personal care services, help with money. (Needs more hands-on care on site).
4. Dependant. Unable to arrange own help/services. Requires family/staff for ADLs & maintain safe environment, manage medications, hygiene, diet, money.

These could be conversation starters with your Husband.

Call it Where Are We?
You need to know where you are, before you start planning how long to stay there & where to next.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Beatty
Report
Dixiepenny Dec 22, 2023
long-term? A new normal. Maybe # 2 Semi *light grey area* requires some help eg have groceries, meals, medications delivered, cleaning service.
(1)
Report
“ needing my husband and I to come help ….”
She needs help. It does not have to be your husband or you . She can hire caregiver if she has funds .
If she needs a lot of hours of help or can not be alone, then assisted living may be more affordable .
Your husband needs to tell Mom this cant keep going on like this.
Does your mother in law have money or a house to sell for assisted living ? Would you and your husband want your mother in law moving closer to you?
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to waytomisery
Report
Dixiepenny Dec 22, 2023
She doesn't want to move from Honolulu house she's lived in for so many years. Plus she enjoys the weather there, basically in the 70's - low 80's. And our house doesn't have a bdroom downstairs. She doesn't want to move to CA either, she's said. So we try to get reasonable priced tickets to go there often as I've mentioned. Leaves us with not much quality time as a married couple. She's 96, in very good health, eats well, loves to read newspaper and watches the news on TV a lot.
I've noticed she has long term memory but not very good with short term memories.
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
Nope. Just nope. You have to put an end to this.
Helpful Answer (9)
Reply to Southernwaver
Report
Dixiepenny Dec 22, 2023
I'd love to end it, or just make it easier to do less often. What we're planning on doing, now that I've told my husband how I'm feeling with him there with mom and me here alone, is in future trips over lapping a little on the visits. BTW, each time he calls he has me on speaker phone, so his mom can hear our conversations, but I asked if he'd not always do that.
Planning if he's there for over 2 wks, I go in the middle for a few days, to get me out of here and to possibly have a little enjoyment with some fun, w/o mom. all the time.
(0)
Report
"Mom, Dixie and I won't be able to stop by this month. What are your thoughts on us sending a helper from an agency by to give you a hand this month. I've called around and some nice ladies can come around from 8:00 am - noon every day to give you a hand."
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to brandee
Report
againx100 Dec 21, 2023
I'd edit that to not ask what her thoughts are but tell her this is the solution. Like many elders, she will likely be unhappy and probably say she doesn't need the help. Right - they often only want YOU to provide the care, no one else. Too bad.
(10)
Report
See 1 more reply
Hey Dixie. How long has this been going on? If it's more than a month or two to deal with an acute, short term situation, then it is much too long and needs to end.

Time to talk to hubby. How is he feeling about this? It is not something anyone "has" to do. His mom appears to be failing and can not navigate taking care of her home and/or self any longer. If I were you, I would back out ASAP and help hubby come up with a game plan. Short term and long term - she probably needs someone to take care of her house and someone to take care of her. This could be difficult to coordinate, so selling her house (assuming she has one) and moving into AL is probably the best solution.

Hubby may feel uncomfortable with this and MIL may whine and cry about it, but too bad. Your husband needs to put his marriage first.

Best of luck.
Helpful Answer (7)
Reply to againx100
Report
Dixiepenny Dec 22, 2023
It's been about a couple years, but lately our visits are more often, not spaced out like before. Husband wants to continue doing this for awhile, as we live closer to her even tho there is an ocean btwn us, than any of her other relatives do.
Plus he's learning about everything since he'll be the executor if he's still living by that time.
I agree with you, she'd be good in assisted living place. But she doesn't want to leave house just yet. I figure in time she will have to so we're playing it by ear for now. And thinking of spacing out our visits there a little bit longer in between as she's still able to function w/o us there, just doesn't get much done and has meals delivered which makes it easy too.
(0)
Report
Can’t your MIL hire a caregiver? Or possibly look into other living arrangements like an assisted living facility?

Wishing you and your family all the best.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to NeedHelpWithMom
Report

MIL doesn’t ‘need’ this. It’s a ‘want’, not a ‘need’. There are other options that work better for your marriage. Just because MIL prefers this one, doesn’t make it a ‘need’.
Helpful Answer (11)
Reply to MargaretMcKen
Report
MeDolly Dec 21, 2023
This "Need" vrs "Want" thing needs to be understood better by caregivers, most cannot get that straight.

When old age & dementia is involved, it should all be about need, forget their wants.

I want a new car, but I do not need it...big difference. And I don't even have dementia but I am older than dirt!
(6)
Report
If MIL needs help for all but 1 week out of each month, then she either needs full time live in paid caregivers (not you or hubby) or she needs to be in managed care of some kind. Because obviously "aging in place" is NOT working out for her, with you propping up her illusion of independence.

Time for a heart to heart talk with hubby about what needs to happen here, for MILs sake and for the sake of your marriage. You've done all you could and now it's time for others to take on this burden.
Helpful Answer (12)
Reply to lealonnie1
Report

Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter