Follow
Share

Mom has vascular dementia and has been living in AL for almost 3 years. She knows she she owns a house, and wants us to move her back. We cannot move her home because she needs 24 hour supervision, but she insists that she can live alone. She is still fairly active, but has very short term memory. She has great friends and the community is perfect in every way; safe, clean, staff and management are terrific, food is great, there is lots to do within the community, and the price is within budget.


Whenever Mom brings up the topic of wanting to go home — which is daily — she has sometimes said, "If I didn't have a house, then maybe I could be happy here." And then two seconds later, she says, "But I worked hard for my house with daddy to have something for my old age."


Do you think telling her the house is "sold" even if it's not, would spiral her into a bad place? Or do you think it would help her get past the idea that she can live at home alone? I know this is a pretty subjective question, but I just wonder if anyone out there has had a similar situation.

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
No matter what answer you give her she’s very likely to continue to perseverate on the subject. She’s stuck in a loop on the house and cannot make sound judgment out of any logical answers. When she gives up the house topic it may be replaced with another constant one. Change the subject as many times as it comes up, don’t discuss it with her at all as it leads nowhere. Consider if might benefit from anti anxiety medication to calm her thoughts a bit
Helpful Answer (9)
Report

I'm curious: after 3 years why have you not sold her house? Is there a renter in it?
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

Why haven't you sold it? Use the proceeds for her care. IDK know how old she is but my mother just died at 100 in AL, she was almost out of money.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

"When the doctor says you can go home, then we'll discuss it." Every single person in Memory Care Assisted Living wants to Go Home. Its the way things are. I posted a great blog about how one family handles their loved ones with dementia when they get upset and want to go ho e.

Its in 2 parts, here are the links:

https://www.agingcare.com/discussions/one-familys-way-to-cure-agitation-in-dementia-and-deal-with-wanting-to-go-home-and-bathing-493504.htm

https://www.agingcare.com/discussions/continued-one-familys-way-to-cure-agitation-in-dementia-and-deal-with-wanting-to-go-home-and-bathing-493505.htm
Helpful Answer (9)
Report
JooFroo Apr 29, 2025
Ooooohhhhh I know! Like the number one thing we ask her doctors and when she goes to the hospital- do not say the word home! Because then she takes that and runs with it and tells everyone that Dr SoandSo said she can go home and it’s a whole bad situation. I know they’re referring to her memory care as home, but ma will never feel like that place is her home. She will always thinks it means home home. And it starts a cycle of bad behavior for like 3 weeks straight.
(3)
Report
Why hasn’t the house been sold?
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

What a person says about *going home* does not need to be taken literally. Or taken as instructions for family to make happen.

Mother's plans can be heard - no action is required on your part.
Eg Oh I see. I am sure you'll find a way. OK.

Feelings can be met with feelings.
Validate her feelings if able/possible.

Eg If she is angry - that's ok. Angry is a normal reaction to loss of choice.

Re-phrasing has helped me a lot!
We have turned "I had to come here" into "I am glad I choose this place". From loss of choice & control to feeling empowered by her choice.

Sadness of losing a beloved home is also very normal. It's ok to say I miss how things were too. Reminiscing with a photo album or sharing old stories may work. Enjoying a trip down memory lane together.

If I reminisce about our old homes, or old holidays my DH knows I am not making a statemwnt based on logic. So he doesn't use logic to reply. No use telling me "Well those days are gone, you'll never get them back". We know that. He joins in & says things like "Yeah, that was fun wasn't it?" It seems to help me somehow.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

When "I hate it here" comes up, which it used to daily, I was saying that I hated her having to be here. I've now changed that to , "I know you do" and I say with a sympathetic smile. And mother smiles back. And we move on. It's taken a few weeks, but she hasn't mentioned that she hates where she is for a few days now.
I'm not saying that it won't come up again, but by validating her feelings, things seem to be a bit better.
Mum also asked if I'd sold her home. I said that hubby and I are living there for a while as we are getting a new kitchen in our home, was that ok? She expressed that she was pleased that we were living there. I asked her what we should do with our place, and she replied that we should rent it out, and stay living in hers. She appeared to be happy with that arrangement.
If (and she said if, and not when) I come out of here, where would I go? To which I said that she's go where we are, because she couldn't be on her own. I did wonder if I was walking into a trap, but she nodded and seemed satisfied. She hasn't mentioned that again.
Also, acknowledging that she doesn't want to eat much, and isn't hungry, seems to make mealtimes go smoother. Giving her choices of what she's like to "eat" first.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

My father has been in AL, now MC. We have learned a lot along the way. In the beginning, I tried to reason with him why he couldn't go home and sometimes we got into an argument and it never convinced him otherwise. Sometimes I think AL accepted him to get the $2000 move in fee. MC has been a godsend. And I have learned a lot. When he says I'd like to go with you, I say something like "I don't have a bed right now for you." Then quickly redirect like "Hey, let's see what's for dinner". He usually doesn't ask again during that visit.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Why isn't your mom's house sold already? That tied up money can help pay for important expenses. Is this house being passed on to a relative? Not sure why the need to hold on to an empty house. Anyway, sell the house and tell her the truth. That was too much house for you to take care of. This money will be used to provide you with the best care possible. My mom hated me for a few weeks, but realized her health was getting worse and I did what was best for her.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report
lorrising Apr 29, 2025
I had the same question, why hasn’t it already been sold?
(2)
Report
Three years is long enough for her to be talking about the house. You'll need to sell it eventually as memory care is about 2k more per month. She's happy there ,that's awesome! It's time to sell the house and tell her you needed the money for her care. If she gets bummed out, remind her that "Daddy" bought it so there would be funds for her care. He did it for her so she didn't have to worry. Moms like being reminded of how good their husbands are/were. Yes,"Daddy" is/was good to her for thinking ahead. It's been a long time since she lived there, she will always have the memories, let it go.
Helpful Answer (11)
Report
JanPeck123 Apr 29, 2025
Awesome response, Julia. Exactly right!
(0)
Report
My mother in law does this. She will even act out in negative behaviors in an attempt to get kicked out of memory care because she thinks she’ll get to go home. Which won’t ever happen because we tried that and it did not work out well because either her dementia it’s the behaviors and the anger and the falls and medication refusal, and even though we 3 kids, her husband AND hired help, it was taking a very large toll on all of us.
When we petitioned for guardianship, the court sent out 3 court appointed evaluators to determine if guardianship was right. And all three of them (as well as 3 other doctors she saw) said the guardianship was needed. So we got her into memory care (as suggested by the evaluators)
When she starts the “going home cycle” we just stick to telling her that the judge or the courts said she has to be there for safety reasons. That we aren’t allowed to bring her home. Which isn’t exactly the truth, but we do have documents that reflect what we’re saying if we ever need to show her. Honestly, we could bring her home with live-in nurses, but the cost of that and knowing how bad her behavior was at home, for her husbands health and our own sanity, she has to stay in memory care.
i dont necessarily think that it would be a bad idea to tell her the house is sold and you have all her belongings in a safe place. I wouldn’t just say” oh by the way we sold your house” But talk to her one day about thinking about doing it and maybe even ask her where she wants her belongings to go. Then in a few weeks tell her it sold.
Either way, she will probably still say the same thing she’s been telling you, or will invent a new reason on why she wants to leave the facility. My mother in law has currently been telling us that they’re trying to kill her, that someone is stealing her things, that when she fell, that staff threw her on the floor. *her falls actually get recorded by a motion camera that only records when it detects a fall, and not one single time has anyone pushed her. Most of her falls are “fake falls” or she has also thrown her own self on the floor. The staff is wonderful to her despite her threats to them that she’s going to tell everyone they hit her. I hope your mom doesn’t get as bad as my mother in law! She’s a doozy!
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

My Mom said that as well that she would like to go home. Her short term memory was not good and she would forget to take her meds. We had to move her to memory care and sold her house to cover her expenses. We told her that the home was some to pay for her care there and that where she was now is just temporary. Her strength in her legs was not good so we told her that she was there until she could get her legs strong enough so that she could go home. Needless to say that never happened and she became bedridden.
after that she went downhill I 8 months and passed away 3 weeks ago. I feel bad that we had to put her in a facility but it was better for her in the long run.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

You can tell her that there are plumbing problems that need to be fixed so it’s not livable. Then redirect
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

I had to clean out mom's house, fix it up to rent. If I sell it now, the capital gains would hurt.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

I’m very sorry to see your mother’s situation. This is a very difficult thing to accept. Perhaps tell her her house requires some type of work and not sure how long but tiday in a safe place. Since she will forget a minute later, it is easy to change the subject to move on.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

I'm going to say that telling her the house is sold might actually help, as she has indicated herself. After we moved my mom into AL after about 3 years in IL she was periodically irritated and asking every visit when she was going to move back to IL. Her two main complaints were: 1) they don't have encourage card games in AL (bridge only once a week), and 2) she wanted to get back to her boyfriend who she missed. So, after a while she found out that her boyfriend had been relocated to MC in another town altogether, and she also learned from another resident in her former IL that the services had gone downhill since she left (new owners), and the food and food service had gotten especially bad. Suddenly, she stopped asking to move back. She responds to social pressure, but I really think the main issue was the boyfriend and his attention. Now there is a new guy she is eating meals with at her AL and I'm just waiting for her to refer to him as her boyfriend.

Maybe your mom does need this closure so she can stop thinking about it as an option? I think it is worth a try.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

My favorite answer is ok, we need to stay here tonight but we can go tomorrow
Then change the subject, redirect her attention....many times a day.
The suggestion about anxiety meds sounds right on track.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

My mom was diagnosed with alzhtimers and vascular dementia 14 months ago. My dad had a stroke 10 years ago and his right side is paralyzed. Mom has been his caregiver since then. After her diagnosis they lived with me for 3 months. My sister and brother would not help and made up stories tell me and dad to get them not to want to stay with me or talk to me even. Her dr said she had to stop driving and should not cook and needed help with dad. So I told my sister if they wanted to make stories up to come get our parents and take care of them. My brother came and got them. Theresa (my sister) and roger (brother) was supposed to be taking care of them and staying with them. Come to find out there wasnt. I got ahold of aps and they did nothing. So I brought them back to live with me. My mom keeps saying she hates it here and wants to go home because she knows they have a home. My brother told mom he was done with them. My sister thinks she's too good to take care of them. But I know if I try and sell the house they will have their noses in and starting their mouths again. They havnt even tried to see our parents since they have been back with me since Dec. My brother hasn't called to even check on them. My brothers boyfriend 41 years old chocked my moms 72 year old sister sister in front of my mom because she told them they need to take care of the parents and not make me have to take care of everything. Its a mess. I know how you feel. I redone my whole basement into an apartment so they could live with me
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter