Follow
Share

Last year I tried to actively intervene for my concerns regarding my mother's care knowing what she wanted but what my brother, the primary caregiver, appeared to ignore. After pursuing a number of attempts I stopped before I went on the legal route due to financial and emotional concerns. My brother continues to control everything about our mother's care having her cut me off of the list to contact medical information to cutting off any means of my ability to communicate with her. He then had her evaluated for dementia which at this point is only short term dementia but is able to carry on a cogent conversation with family and friends. So now he controls even her own medical decisions. Looking back maybe I wasn't forward looking (which one of my other brothers would say) to see that my brother would make things worse for me. It appears to me that he isn't as concerned about our mother's needs as he is the one who determines what is best for her without consulting our mother. So now my therapist says I'm off the hook for any responsibility for my mother. BUT this is hard for me to work through as my mother is still living and it's important for me to connect with her as she lives the rest of her life.
So letting go of this toxic situation means almost no contact with my mother. Any POSITIVE thoughts or suggestions? Thanks

Find Care & Housing
I'm sorry you're in this situation. Where does your mother live? Does your brother have control via powers of attorney or via a guardianship?
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to Rosered6
Report
JuliaRLE Jan 23, 2026
Rosered6,
If you read the previous responses to ShirleyDot, Geaton77 and SnoppyLove you'll see what I wrote in response to their comments and will clarify your questions.
One thing I didn't say is that our mother lives in our childhood home in northern WI. My older brother now is the full owner of the LLC meaning the house which makes it his responsibility but our mother has the right to live there as long as she can or dies.
Bottom line: Letting go my brother's toxic attitude and actions is one thing but letting go my very limited contact with my mother is the hard part.
(0)
Report
How sad, I’m sorry.

Just to get a sense of the family dynamics— you mention another brother. Are the other sibling/s also being blocked from having any sort of contact with your mother?
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to SnoopyLove
Report
JuliaRLE Jan 23, 2026
SnoopyLove as it was mentioned before you only hear my side of the story. Read my response to Geaton77.
I have to two other living brothers. One has some contact with our brother and the other brother is cut off like myself.
As I said before: Letting go my brother's toxic attitude is one thing but letting go my very limited contact with my mother is the hard part.
(0)
Report
We are only getting your side of the story. If your brother is the PoA for your Mom, you don't have any recourse except to take it to a family mediator, or to challenge the PoA. If your Mom made your brother her PoA then she must have chosen him for a reason.

Have you offered to have supervised visits with a promise to refrain from interferring with the PoA's decisions?

If your brother is NOT the PoA nor guardian, then you have the legal ability to fight to become her guardian and be the decision-maker.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Geaton777
Report
JuliaRLE Jan 23, 2026
You are right that you only hear my side of the story. I've always said that there is three sides to a story - yours, mine and the truth.
Read my response to ShirleyDot and maybe you can understand my concern. As I said at the very end: Letting go my brother's toxic attitude and actions is one thing but letting go my very limited contact with my mother is the hard part.
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
If your brother is the POA, that means that your mother chose him to represent her before she had dementia. If he was appointed guardianship, it means the court found him competent and he agreed to be the responsible party. You should try accepting this decision, that you were not chosen, and that he is now taking on a lot of work on behalf of your mother that you and your sibling do not now need to do.

Try looking at this from his perspective: he is doing all the labor and getting nothing but grief from you. It is always easy to criticize. Maybe you don't agree with all of his decisions, but if you try approaching him was gratitude or even just acknowledging his work, he might be more generous with giving you access to your mother.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to ShirleyDot
Report
JuliaRLE Jan 23, 2026
I hear you. I did have the POA but my brother 'convinced' her that he was the one who needed it. He continues to manipulate our mother in many different ways.
He had our mother sign me off the contact list for medical input with the doctor while he was present. The doctor asked if my mother understood but what was she to say with my brother in the room? Later when I talked to her she said to me "you can still call the doctor" not fully understanding what she did.
I have told him many times that I'm thankful that he's caring for our mother. He has not been willing to talk with me but yell, shout, and attack me verbally.
The bottom line is that he has cut me off from any chance for me to be part of our mother's care out of anger over childhood issues and his dysfunction.
Letting go my brother's toxic attitude and actions is one thing but letting go my very limited contact with my mother is the hard part.
(2)
Report
I'm in a toxic family and caregiver situation as well, and even if they are stating the logistics of things, some of the prior responses are a little harsh. I feel for you. I won't go into all the details of it, but I'm 43, I live with my elderly parents, I do a ton of stuff to help take care of them, and I work full-time. Then there's my 53 year old, snooty sister that swoops in to visit 3 times a year. She sometimes shows up for holidays and during emergencies and hospital stays for my parents. They don't have a poa, so my sister walks in making all the decisions, bossing my parents around, and tries to tell me what to do. It's exhausting. My best advice is, no matter what people think or say, step back from it all for your peace. Even if it hurts. My sister is so miserable in her life that being the captain of everybody else's ships is her only time to shine. Some men have an elevated moral duty towards their mothers, so that may play into your brother's demeanor too. For you, spend some time outside and take a relaxing walk around. Not for exercise, just to meander. I love looking at trees, creeks, wildlife, and rocks, etc. It's therapeutic and healing. For a positive way to keep in touch, think of things your mom likes in life, and find a happy greeting card with that theme to send her with a handwritten note inside. I get my mom snoopy stuff and I send my dad bird pictures from work. Hang in there and give yourself some grace. Best wishes.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to JustWantPeace
Report
JuliaRLE Jan 23, 2026
Thanks for sharing and I'm sorry you are in such a difficult situation. Yes, I pretty much let go of any control. My part was to ask how I can help and my brother's response "give me money". He doesn't feel a need to be accountable how he uses our mother's money which he has complete access to. I try not to upset the situation when I visit. I basically want to be there to spend time with my mother. I can't force any change but I can be the kind, helpful daughter when I'm able to visit.
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
Is your brother the SOLE owner of the property in the llc?
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to Khrules
Report
JuliaRLE Jan 23, 2026
Yes my brother was able to buy out one of our brothers who had the major control and my other brother who had a smaller part gave him his shares. It has been a situation of manipulation and control over many years. He wanted this but now has the huge task and responsibiliyt of the house and large property.
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
I’m sorry for your hurt in this. As I see it your choices are to pursue legal recourse, consulting with an elder care attorney, trying to reconnect and heal the relationship with brother, or accepting the situation as is. I wish you the best in trying to decide the best course of action for you and mom both
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to Daughterof1930
Report
JuliaRLE Jan 24, 2026
Thanks for your kind response. Yes, I realize I would have to pursue legal recourse but at this point I'm not willing or able to do this. I did want to do something with a third party mediator but my brother isn't willing to do this. He insists it all has to be his way.
As long as our mother insists on dying in her own home (and our childhood home) she lets our brother decide things for her even if she would like something.
(0)
Report
You should tell your brother you want to be able to visit your mother because you love her and you are her daughter. But stay out of the medical issues. That is his domain.

I think you are feeling that your mother doesn’t love you as much as your brother because she made him her primary caregiver and not you. She had her reasons, just respect them.

Finally, do not give your brother any money to care for your mother. If money is needed, house and property will need to be sold to pay for it and she will need to live someplace else.

I am sorry for your situation and I hope you see your way through this ordeal without it destroying you emotionally.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to Hothouseflower
Report
JuliaRLE Jan 24, 2026
I appreciate your kind, caring response. When I'm able to get back home I do visit my mother but having to deal with my brother on any basis is toxic. It just isn't about the medical issues though I orginally had POA for my parents and my brother 'convinced' her that he should have it. I'm the one who has medical training so that made more sense for me to oversee the area.
The bottom line is our mother wants to die in her own house. Because of this she doesn't express what she wants to my brother or if she does rarely say anything he pushes it aside and does what he wants.
And yes, I'm working with a therapist on attachments issues I have.
(0)
Report
I'm not getting how if you stop trying to control your brother's care of your mom that means you won't get to see her or talk with her any more. She has dementia. There's no such thing as short term dementia, parts of her brain are dying and this only gets worse, not better. She absolutely shouldn't be making her own financial and medical decisions. That's the whole reason you give someone POA, so they can do what's best for you, rather than do whatever you want. If he wasn't concerned about what she needs he wouldn't have gotten her properly diagnosed and taken on the huge responsibility of managing her care. It seems to me that if you stop criticizing all his hard work you'd have more access to your mom, not less.
Helpful Answer (7)
Reply to Slartibartfast
Report
JuliaRLE Jan 24, 2026
Things for sharing your thoughts. I dont' know if you read my previous responses to other question and answers?
There is a long history of family dysfunction concerning my brother who is the caregiver. He has little by little taken over control of the house and since our mother lives there he is now her primary caregiver. I do thank my brother as often as possible for his care for our mother though I don't always agree with him. For example, I was giving my mother cottage cheese and peaches which she enjoys. And he came in and started shouting at me and later my Mom that he was the ONLY one who can give her anything to eat.
Since I don't live in the same state as our mother I can't at this point move back home to be closer to her. BUT I did enjoy talking and seeing her over the Alexa machine. So now my brother decided to take it out even though she wanted to be able to use it to connect with me and another brother and his family.
It comes down to the bottom line that my Mom wants to die in her own house so other options offered her do not work. I had hoped to connect with her on a more frequent basis since she doesn't use any phone or do email.
(0)
Report
Make peace with your brother. Go help your brother, however he asks you to help. Do it, don’t argue or try to negotiate. Clean her house. Take care of the yard or pets. Get rid of her junk. He is stuck with the responsibility of your mother. Help him. It will help her indirectly. Go to the care facility twice a week. Help with baths. Bring supplies. Entertain her. Just sit there with her so he doesn’t have to and have them call you with every emergency. That’s how you can help. So brother only has to come every other week. And he has his own life. That’s how you can help.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Beethoven13
Report

Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter