Follow
Share

My 92 year old mom with dementia was recently hospitalized for two weeks, then lived with us for a month before being placed into a memory care assisted living. She can no longer live alone safely. She is adjusting slowly to her new place, but she continues to ask to go to her home which she lived in for 65 years. She hasn't been there now for about six weeks. We will be selling the house within the next few months so it already looks different than it did when she lived there. It breaks my heart that she will never return there or live there again. I know it is best NOT to take her there again, but wondering what others have done in their situation.

Pictures. My daddy held his pictures in a box. He had ripped them out of the photo albums and put them in a box. He would tell me stories of the "good ol' days". Dementia patients live in the past so sit down with the pictures and let them tell you stories of the "good ol' days"
Helpful Answer (9)
Reply to Ohwow323
Report

You tell us:
"I know it is best NOT to take her there again, but wondering what others have done in their situation."
In my humble opinion you just answered your own question.
When she is more adjusted to her situation help her make a scrapbook of memories around this home.
I think it is clear from what she is saying that she is not saying "Can we walk through one more time so I can say goodbye", (for to ME, our homes are almost sentient beings). What she is saying is she wants to go home. And that can't happen.
It's heartbreaking, isn't it. And it is worth grieving, so allow her that and be honest with her.
Helpful Answer (7)
Reply to AlvaDeer
Report

Are you sure she isn't in fact "sundowning"?

Asking to "go home" is a very common dementia behavior and they are really thinking "home" is their childhood home.

My (now deceased) Aunt lived in her own home and had adv dementia. Every afternoon like clockwork she'd start getting agitated and wanting to "go home". Even though she was sitting in the house that she'd been in since 1975.

My MIL has short -term memory impairment and was transitioned into AL. We handled downsizing her home ourselves. She asked to go see it (it was empty and in foreclosure). Since it was in foreclosure and she no longer had ownership of it we told her no (and there was no real point to just "drive past" it). It would only serve to make her sad all over again. She kept asking for a while and we just kept making a reason to not do it (therapeutic fibs, redirect the conversation or distract her). Also, she was barely mobile and overweight and just the effort to get her into the van was a deterrent. There was just no upside of taking her... it wasn't going to help her "process" anything emotionally since her memory problem would prevent her from doing this. It would just be Groundhog's Day.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to Geaton777
Report

I'm with Geaton on this one. It's been proven that when someone with dementia asks to go home that it is often NOT the home they lived in more recently but in fact their childhood home, where they felt safe with their parents.
Because dementia robs folks of their short term memory first, all that remains is their long term when they were much younger. And so it makes great sense that one would want to go back to their childhood home.
So I would leave well enough alone and when she brings up wanting to go home, you can tell her any kind of little fiblet, like the house is getting some work done and that you'll let her know when it's finished, or just try and redirect as in changing the subject.
Helpful Answer (9)
Reply to funkygrandma59
Report

Daughter

I know that nostalgic feeling. It always reminds me of the play and movie “Trip to Blessing” by Horton Foote and the great gospel singer Cynthia Clawson who sang “Softly and Tenderly” in the movie version.

It’s a bitter sweet proposition that only you can decide for you and your mom. We have in life a few times where we know in advance this will be the last time. Regardless of life being full of losses we also can find great joy in a bowl of vanilla ice cream and as much as I promise it will be the last time, here we are again.

Hugs to you DaughterJ57, you have a tender heart.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to 97yroldmom
Report

Don’t do it. It would be a difficult day, and then there’s the aftermath. Better to repeat that she’s already in her home, and it’s almost time for (dinner, bingo, exercise). She’ll stop asking soon, probably.
Helpful Answer (8)
Reply to Fawnby
Report
Lovemom1941 Feb 20, 2024
18 months in my mom is still asking. The answer is always “soon” as no would upset her and I don’t do anything g I know will upset her.
(2)
Report
Don’t do it. I think you know this is a bad idea for all involved.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to LoopyLoo
Report

NO...make that an emphatic NO.
In your heart and your mind you KNOW the answer to this.
Taking her to see the old house is not a good idea.
So what happens if you do bring her by.
Will she be happy just driving by? Probably not.
What will you tell her each and every time you go to visit and she wants to go "home" what will you tell her.
What happens when you drive by and find the house torn down and a new one being built?
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to Grandma1954
Report

No.

it's a complete sentence and often a very powerful one.

Here is the thing. She has dementia. You are assuming that she means that she wants to visit the home she live in for 65 years - maybe a safe assumption. Maybe not. Maybe she frames it that way even.

But she may be talking about her childhood home. She may be talking about her happy place.

There is no guarantee - with dementia - that she means a specifically reference home.

AND there is a significant chance that see it may upset her. Or she may not remember certain things. Or only bad things. Or the changes will upset her.

There are too many variables that can cause problems for everyone.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to BlueEyedGirl94
Report

Additional thoughts: We tend to want our LOs to be able to keep their memories. It comforts us to think that showing them something dear to them would help them to do so. But it's dementia! A condition that makes it (scientifically, medically, thoroughly) impossible for them to keep old memories or to make new ones. Show her the old house. The image goes into her eyes and she looks happy, but it cannot connect with the memory grabber in her brain. The memory grabber can no longer grab.

Memories are important to us, but not so much to them. They live in the Now. Occasionally the Now produces ice cream, and that's all they need to know in the Now.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to Fawnby
Report
Lovemom1941 Feb 20, 2024
I love that last thought about the Now producing ice cream! My mom has come to love it so much.
(1)
Report
It may be too late, but I would always suggest taking photos or a video of a house before you sell it or leave it. Every room, every cupboard, every bit of the garden. It preserves the memory, the way it was when you were there rather than after it all changed, and it can be a substitute for that last visit.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to MargaretMcKen
Report
AlvaDeer Feb 20, 2024
I so like this, Margaret. Combine it with the advice above to reassure that another family now will raise their children here, and love and care for the home, and I think it's a win-win.
(2)
Report
From my experience I will say NO, definitely not, here is why:
1: you might have difficulty taking her back to the AL/MC which will cause stress and resentment on her part.
2: As many mentioned here the "home" she is referring to might not be the house you will be selling.
3: She may not fully comprehend or remember the significance of the visit, which could lead to confusion or stress
4: Consider how your mom might emotionally react to visiting their old house. It could evoke positive memories and feelings of nostalgia, or it could trigger sadness or agitation if they struggle to recognize the surroundings.

If you do decide to go ahead with the visit, make sure you have a strong support system in place to assist your mom and manage any potential challenges that may arise.

Best wishes.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to SusanHeart
Report

Our dad isn’t quite 90 but he knew he and his wife were not managing things well. Honestly he never put up a fight. In time I think your mom will stop asking. We were up front with Dad and told him a sweet family bought our home of 50 years and will now take care of it! His wife would never allow him to do necessary repairs and such so it got a bit run down. He was so happy to hear that someone will love the home as we did! We needed the money to pay for his care bills.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to Stovegirl
Report

I took my mom back to her house before we sold it. I was nervous that it wouldn’t go well, but it was ok. My brother died there and she took a few moments to sit in his room and have a little conversation. I wouldn’t recommend it for everyone, but it wasn’t the big drama I was warned about. She put up a fight about taking almost everything back to her AL apartment, She got to say her goodbyes and we left. She still asks about going home, but I don’t think she means that house. Home represents something else to her now. Best of luck in your choice.
Helpful Answer (11)
Reply to LoriF1
Report

If it's close enough, do a lunch. Drive by the place. See if she recognizes it or even reacts.
Shouldn't make it a big deal. Dementia doesn't do well with big deals.
Use YOUR brain to make it simple.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to Pyrite
Report
TouchMatters Feb 21, 2024
In using our brains, we must understand the brain of a person inflicted with dementia.

They are scared, confused, want what is familiar (if they remember).
The worse a person / family member could do is bring up these memories / desires by bringing their loved one 'back' for a visit.
Yes, use YOUR brain. Which means understanding how the brain chemistry changes when a person has dementia.
(1)
Report
You can take her…but by the end of the day, she’ll be asking to go again. She won’t remember. Take some pictures if you must, but frankly it’s best just to distract her.

Possibly distract her with family photos taken during good times at the house.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to Donttestme
Report

I took my momn back to an empty home before it sold. She did OK and never talked about it again. Periodically we would drive by on the way to an appointment but there was no drama. Her personality was always one of compliance
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to MACinCT
Report

I know it breaks your heart but I think you would break hers more. It's going to hurt you having to go there and relive the past, clean and close up,you will get overwhelmed. Remember to breathe and take it easy, it took years to accumulate. She doesn't need to know about it, what's done is done. Instead of talking about going home, talk about how good she has it now in MC. She is safe and fed and checked on a regular basis. She no longer has to cook (maybe microwave?) or clean or do laundry. She has no need to think about the life she had but enjoy the comfort she has now. She's a queen getting the royal treatment she deserves,waited on hand and foot! I'm hoping you have a Will in place that will help you sell the house, notary public are hard to find for MC residents.
Take care!
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to JuliaH
Report

It does break your heart - You could Let her go and Pick out a few items and tell her " it has to be sold . " I know I got My Mom Out of a rehab and we spent 2 weeks in her apartment - she was very Ill . The VNA nurse came and we decided to dial 911 . I got to the Hospital and the head nurse said " She Needs 24 Hour care , You Can Not do this - Here is the Name Of the lawyers to contact . " I got back to her apartment and almost cried " Mom will never be coming Home again. " She couldn't walk, was incontinent , was having trouble swallowing . I got the 30 documents the Lawyers needed, went to the senior center got Names of Nursing Homes . Got her Into a Good Place - she kept saying " she was bored , there were really Old People there and she wanted to go home . " Now mind you I had been Lifting her and changing diapers and seeing a chiropractor . /////////////////////////. My Father on the Other hand was Kidnapped from His Home in Boston to California . I have only spoken to him twice and he says " Karen I want to come home " and he is really sad and he Belongs Home . Wether he will ever see his Home of 30 years I do Not know. He was taken for His Money By a Very Greedy sibling . people have cried in the Neighborhood and tell me " They Miss him. " So I really do Not see the harm in a Visit and let her take a few objects and make sure she has all her photographs to Look at .
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to KNance72
Report

Just bring her pictures . If you bring her back there she won’t want to leave . Especially since she’s so far along in her dementia that she is in memory care . She won’t understand why she has to leave .
I also think it will cause her to take steps back in her adjustment . She may always ask to go home whether you took her once or not . I brought things in a box a few times for my mother to choose from to put in her room .
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to waytomisery
Report
TouchMatters Feb 21, 2024
No photos can activate fear, grief, sadness, confusion.
This is exactly what we want to avoid.
No pictures (of the house).
Just photos of the family.
(1)
Report
I would not bring your mother back to her former home, since it may cause confusion. Very sad about her situation after living there for 65 years. As others have said, take pictures of the former residence to share with her at her new residence. She may frequently ask to return "home" but may eventually forget it as the dementia progresses.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Patathome01
Report

Please don't. My mom wanted to see the house, but I felt it was more distressing to her. I also had a very real fear of her getting in the house, then refusing to leave, as she wanted to go inside.

The nurse is at the assisted living told me a story of one family that takes their loved one by the house. Whenever he asks. Then they bring him back to the assisted living and he starts lashing out at everybody. I certainly wouldn't want to do that to the people that are caring for my mother.
Helpful Answer (7)
Reply to darts1975
Report

Wow, like almost most times, it’s a question by a woman pertaining to a woman.. I wonder why.. Not looking for an answer to that question..just making an observation.. My dad is in memory care. I am selling his house, cars. Etc. all this to pay for his care. He wants to go home to his properties, his business, his $$$. Every meeting is contentious. I’m threatened every which way.. He says he doesn’t belong where he is.. he says he’s not like “them”. (The residents). I cannot take him out of there to make any dr appointments because he is a flight risk. I want to take him to his properties to visit etc, but NO WAY IN HELL will i do that..
Its nice if some of you have had A positive experience, But its not happening on this end..
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Vladtheimpaler
Report
BlueEyedGirl94 Feb 20, 2024
Vlad - I hear you. My FIL agreed to go to the SNF. HE signed the admission paperwork!!! But lord help us - before the ink was even dry he was lashing out. Attacking all of us. Blaming us for him being there (and not the fact that he weighed 300+ pounds and was nearly immobile). He was brutally mean to his son and daughter. He was down right ugly to me and to BIL. He actually reared back and tried to hit my DH (his son).

Even if we COULD have taken him out - we would not have done it. He was a "flight" risk - meaning if we had taken him out ourselves, he would have dug in and refused to return. He only left the facility with facility transportation and CNAs. We met him at Dr. appts if needed.

That would have been pure insanity and just asking for issues.
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
I belong to a support group through our local ALzheimer’s association. They offered an online session with a geriatric psychologist. When I asked about taking my dad back to his home for a day-trip, the doctor would it would only cause more confusion. He said I would also have a very hard time getting Dad to come back with me. The best way to handle this is to say, ok, we’ll go next week. (or tomorrow , or in a few days.)
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to BigSis1
Report

I knew enough not to take my mother in the car with me ever after placing her or she would demand to go back to her house and she would have dug her heels in .
My mother’s facility would take residents on “ Country Rides “. The activities dept had a new employee who took a group of 3-4 women one day , my mother being one of them . According to the facility one of the other residents asked to drive by her old home. The driver obliged. Then my mother asked to drive by her home . My mother was not aware that I had put the home on the market and the realtor sale sign was put up just an hour before my mother rode to her house . Apparently my mother went off the “ deep end “ when she saw the sign on the lawn . I was not given any other details other than it was really bad and the new employee was quite shaken up . I can only imagine that my mother probably tried to get out of the car . It was a sedan . Then when back at the facility , my mother proceeded to call 911 from the facility about her house being stolen by her daughter .
It never occurred to me that the AL facility would drive people pass their houses , which in my opinion was dumb given that a lot of the residents had dementia . Apparently it wasn’t something they normally do . The new employee fell for this . My DH says my mother hijacked the Country Ride.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to waytomisery
Report
SnoopyLove Feb 20, 2024
OMG! Yeah, not that new employee’s finest hour. 😬
(2)
Report
See 2 more replies
My mom's grandson lives in her house. He, his girl friend and 5 kids live there. The house is a mess. She's been back. She's just sad that it is a mess.
I'm surprised that people think it's a bad idea.
I think you should tell her that you are selling it.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to BeeSuz
Report

DaughterJ57: An individual with dementia requires a static environment. Do not take her to her former home.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Llamalover47
Report

In reading the comments below, while you've asked how others have handled this situation, the challenge is that you / we do not know what kind or degree of dementia others' family members have / had ... so each situation is very different. Generally speaking, most here say "No." This is the general recommendation from medical professionals.
_________________________________
No. It will bring up pain and sadness/grief, confusion, frustration and possibly anger. Check out Teepa Snow's website. She is one of the country's leading experts on dementia and how to interact / communicate, and understand the changing brain. I took her webinars for 1-1/2 years.
She has written many books, has You Tubes.
She is a master and you will learn a lot.

In time, your mom will adjust to where she is now.
It is good that you know what to do and looking for support and feedback.

Perhaps you can tell her "Once you settle in,' we can go back for a visit.

With time, she will forget. In the meantime, you are giving her a bit of peace (of mind). The goal is to keep her calm as possible. This may help.

When dealing with dementia the (definition of) truth is what provides as much calmness as possible in the moment.
Agree with her, do not argue.
Give her hope in the moment.
Hold her hand and tell her you understand.
Smile, tell her you love her.

Gena / Touch Matters
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to TouchMatters
Report

My Mom was in mid-stage dementia when we moved her from her condo to MC. The move to MC was pretty smooth and she adjusted well as the people there were much more attentive to her needs than we were.

Prior to the move, she was rifling through stuff and tossing things out saying that these things were no longer needed. It was no longer wise to let her have money since she couldn't remember where she put it and claimed the caregivers stole it (they didn't).

After she moved, we needed to clean out her condo because it was going to be rented.

About 6 months later, my sister took her back. However, the look inside the condo was significantly changed as we had moved things around. Nothing looked the same. Pictures still were in the same place, but the furniture was moved. My sister sat down and went through a little bit of her stuff with her so that my Mom could say who to disposition some of the goods to. After the end of the visit, my sister says my Mom was glad to leave.

About 1 month later, my Mom asked me to take her back. By this time, everything was out of the condo. I warned my Mom that everything was gone, and she understood. She went to the condo, opened up drawers and cabinets, and looked into closets, then said she was ready to leave. Her comment to me was "you found it all, it is ready for renters".

She never asked to go back again. She would ask me from time to time whether we had renters in there and I told her yes. The visit provided closure for her.

I'd do it again under the same circumstances.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to ChoppedLiver
Report
Lovemom1941 Feb 21, 2024
It’s good that it worked out for you and your mom. If we did this, I believe my mom would be VERY upset that things have been moved but 10 minutes after we left, she wouldn’t remember having gone there. I take her to lunch and on returning, she doesn’t recognize anything about her facility, down to the bed she’s been sleeping in for 6 months.
(4)
Report
Much depends on her mindset - would she just go to have a look-see and be done or refuse to leave. We ran into slightly similar situation with Mum. Dad passed away and she was in rehab for post surgery care. I needed to find clothing for dad's funeral, knew where it was, but she insisted on tagging along....hours later..... There was no getting around it and not a pleasant situation. I did not have a good alternative at the time, but for your situation, instead of taking her back to the house, maybe gather lots of good photos of the house, organize them into a slide show on a phone or tablet that she can look at whenever she wants? And not just pictures of the house, but include photos of family and friends enjoying their time in the house? I had to gather photos for a tribute video when parents passed away. Funeral home took them and created an absolutely outstanding tribute video - I found myself wishing my parents could have seen it.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to JLyn69
Report

Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter