Follow
Share

My 86 y/oMom with Alzheimer's has been told by us not to open the door if she is alone for even a little while during day. But, she does. Her 85 y/o girlfriend can't understand this and keeps coming to see Mom whenever she wants. I have asked her to come after my brother gets home after 4pm or let me know when she wants to come so I can make sure to be there and stay. Both have ambulatory issues and I can't have both of them fall since both are wobbly even with their walkers. I am upset with her friend since she keeps 'doing what she wants' and ignores these safety issues and concerns that I have. Neither one can help the other if one or both fall...I have even suggested to have several of her friends come over for a little planned gathering or coffee/lunch get together but that hasn't happened either. I think I may have solved the problem and having keyed deadbolts installed on front door since the door lock has only a little thumb lock on it. I am worried that the day would come that Mom thinks it is her girlfriend but it isn't, that it is a stranger. I am only looking out for Mom, and her girlfriend safety.....but, they think I am being a bad and controlling person. Is hurtful. I'm sure they dont understand; I am looking for suggestions on other ways to possibly work with this situation. Please :)

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
You are endangering your mom by locking her in and it is illegal to do that.

Sorry, but you are being controlling and over zealous.

They are in their 80's, home alone and want to spend private (otherwise lonely) time together.

Your mom and her friend are grown women, please respect their choice to be together.

What if there is a fire and your mom burns to death? This is as great of a risk as her opening the door to find a malicious stranger on the other side. Only in the fire you would be prosecuted for her death because you had her falsely imprisoned.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Trying to clarify the scene.

Mum lives with your brother.

Your brother works until 4 pm each day.

You live somewhere else? It is not clear from your post or profile.

Mum, who is a fall risk, is left alone during the day, while brother is at work.

Mum and her friend like to visit during the day.

You do not want Mum opening the door for safety reasons.

You do not want the friend visiting if you or your brother are not there to supervise.

If I have a fairly accurate read on the situation, it does not sound like Mum should be left alone during the day. If she is a fall risk, she would be safer if her friend was visiting at the time, as the friend could call for help.

There are safety concerns if Mum is not allowed to open the door. In our family we had an incident about 10 years ago. We had an unexpected flood in our town and emergency services were dispatched to knock on the doors of every home in the path of the floor, telling them to evacuate. They were in uniform and had ID. My paranoid former mil refused to answer her door. She also refuses to answer her phone. She hid in her house.

We had to leave work an hour a way, when we heard the news and go pick her up. Luckily the flood waters had not yet reached her home.

What would happen to your Mum if there was a similar emergency situation?

Do not use a keyed deadbolt, they are incredibly dangerous in an emergency situation. If the key cannot be found it can lead to disaster.

You need to find another way to address your concerns about Mum falling.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Falls happen in the elderly, no matter what, even if you're at home & watching your mom 24/7. My mother has fallen 40x in the past 5 years and it's been nobody's 'fault'. Sometimes she wasn't using her walker, so that was her bad, other times it was purely an accident, etc. That said, here is a link to an excellent article on Creating a Safe Home for Dementia Patients:

https://www.aarp.org/caregiving/home-care/info-2017/dementia-home-safety.html

You can't explain anything to a person with dementia & expect them to understand the words or remember them at all. You can write a sign the size of a billboard telling them to do, or not to do, something and STILL it won't matter because they won't think to read the sign. And if they do, it won't make sense.

Now that you have a crash course in dementia 101, when you go run an errand, even if it's picking up an Rx or an item for your mom, you are still out of the house. Meaning your mother is still alone for X amount of time. Not a very long time, but still alone for a period of time. That's not to say you are a bad care giver or that you do not love your mother and that you wouldn't lay your life on the line for her. It is to say, only, that she IS alone for X amount of time on any given day. That's a fact. With dementia in play, any number of things can happen when a person is alone even for a short period; that is a greater danger than a fall or opening the door to a potential stranger.

It's also a fact that if you install the keyed deadbolt locks you mention on the doors that can be a fire hazard, or present a safety hazard that is more dangerous than the the threat of her opening the door to a stranger. You may want to install non-keyed deadbolts high up on the doors, out of her reach, which would be a better idea.

Nobody is trying to call you a bad daughter or anything like that. Just trying to make you aware of a few things you may not have been aware of before now. Having someone tell you that 'dead slots' are a good idea and that what you are doing is correct in an effort to make you feel better isn't the right answer either............allow the facts to prevail, not emotions. Use your head and not your heart when formulating a plan to keep your beloved mom safe. That's all we're trying to tell you.

Best of luck
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

If she's only ever alone for 15 or 20 minutes or so while you "go up the street ( 1 mile) to the grocery store for a quick run" then I think you are being overly worried, the chances of her opening the door to trouble seems pretty slim.
If, on the other hand, she (or her friend) is waiting for her opportunity to get into mischief while you are away and have repeatedly done so in the past you really can't leave her alone, not even for a few minutes.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Do you mean key locks where Mom cannot get out? If so, this may be against the fire code in your Township. Its a fire hazard.

I know its hard dealing with a person with a Dementia. But there comes a time when they can no longer be alone. Your Mom does not retain what you say to her.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Find someone to sit with your mom through the day if possible. MIL was in the hospital for a bad fall. The hospital would not release her to go home unless someone was with her at all times or we had to put her somewhere so they could keep an eye on her. She was 71 at the time. We now live with her full time. She didn't like it but we explained that she had no choice! Safety issues are scary. Hope it works out for you.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

to clarify, she is NOT alone during the day...if i go up the street ( 1 mile) to the grocery store for a quick run for something she needs, or to get her prescriptions is the only time she is alone . I am with her every day unless my brother has an off day, and I leave when he gets home from work. SHE IS NOT ALONE DURING THE DAY !!! Most of you blew this out of proportion...calm down. Heck, I probably care TOO much for her since my dad just passed away...I took care of BOTH of them every day... so, calm down she is not alone during the day. I am there before my brother leaves and there til he returns. I have not described in detail how her friends are and I don't feel as if I have to. My mother is VERY well taken care of. I even have her surrounding neighbors on alert for her whether I am there or not...I even have a bed there in case she is sick and I need to stay...I guess I didn't explain it very well. Didn't know it would snowball into something it's not...
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
Isthisrealyreal Jan 2020
Why would you be worried about her opening the door or one of them falling and then not being able to help each other up if you are there? Your answer and post contract each other.

Read your post, nobody over reacted, we responded to what you said. You can't get upset when you only provide some information.
(1)
Report
Dont worry what your moms says remember that in your hesrt you are watching out for her and her girlfriend. Those dead slots are a good idea. Stay strong you are doing what is correct.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter