Follow
Share
Find Care & Housing
This would be a good question for you to discuss with your faith-based Pastor. Belief doesn't impact suffering. This is, of course, a philosophical question that's as age-old as, I would imagine, our sitting in our caves round the camp fires. Surely you did not think that merely having faith in a God would prevent suffering? Do contact your clergy for help in coming to peace with this difficult question.
As an atheist, who hasn't had to suffer the belief that suffering could be prevented or helped by a god, I haven't had to face the questions of why all living things suffer. But I assure, all living things DO suffer. All living things, from a virus to a human are born, struggle to get breeding rights and territory, and die. It's simply the nature of things.

Putting aside a philosophical question that, to my knowledge has never been answered, may help you deal with the realities of what disease does to us, and what changes a disease makes in the best, brightest and strongest of us--changes both physical and mental. Spend as little time as you can in anger at either gods of the universe. You won't have the energy for that.

I wish you the best, and I am so sorry. I always laugh at the phrase, "thoughts and prayers", but even this atheist sees the sense of meditating on Reinhold Niebuhr's beautiful Serenity Prayer. I wish you serenity, courage and wisdom.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to AlvaDeer
Report

This post is from June. OP only posted one time and only replied at time of post. They have probably left the group.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to JoAnn29
Report

Your father is STILL a faithful Christian. Repeat that to yourself. If that was who he was before dementia - that didn't change because he got it. You cannot compare who he was to who he is.

Dementia is evil. It quite literally ROBS a person of their personality, memory, executive functioning, ability to process. You have to remind yourself that HE had no more control over what is happening to him than you do.

Think about it like this...you wake up one morning and you can't remember who your spouse is, or your child. Or you can't remember how to get out of bed and walk to the bathroom - so you sit there in a panic and urinate all over yourself. Or you can't remember how to turn the tv on or operate a phone. Or how to use the microwave or stove.

And worse than that - you don't understand why any of this is happening - because you have moments where you feel perfectly fine. And now you feel so angry all of the time, and helpless, and out of control. And oh by the way...since you can't seem to remember what is happening - someone else (that you likely care about and love and feels the same about you)...they are going to start making decisions for you and telling you what you are going to do.

And all of this after years of being self-sufficient and standing on your own and taking pride in who you are. Suddenly you don't even seem to get a say in your own life and can't remember things people say.

It must be very much like living in the light for years...and then suddenly you wake up and its dark...like really dark. And sometimes your eyes can adjust a little, but you still can't see where you are or where you are going. And every once in a while, the door might open, and you might see some light...but just as fast as you can see it...it's gone again.

Frankly it must be terrifying. And sometimes you know that people are just trying to help...and sometimes you want to smack the crap out of them and tell them to leave you alone and let you have your life back. And sometimes you KNOW something is wrong with you. And sometimes you think they are just trying to control you.

I know your dad is being cruel - and I'm sure that is such a shock when that wasn't who he was before dementia. But he literally cannot help what is happening to him. And it's not personal, even though it feels that way. You are in his path and likely trying to help - and that just makes it harder for him because he can't do what he did before.

For my grandmother - it was a merry go round. Some days she was sweet, and lucid. Other days she accused us of trying to kill her.

It's not easy. But you have to tell yourself - THIS isn't who my father is. Dementia has robbed him.

HOWEVER, if he becomes violent - there are medications that he can be given. Agitation is a big thing with dementia. And things tend to get worse as the sun goes down.

Take care of yourself. But I wouldn't spend too much time worrying about his soul.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to BlueEyedGirl94
Report

I'm sorry for what you're getting ready to go through, but Christianity or any religion has nothing to with it so leave that at the damn door. All those thoughts and prayers go unheard, believe me, I've cried out more than once and no savior came down to deliver me from this living hell.

There is no understanding dementia in any form; it is the disease that keeps on taking.

It is the disease that is cruel and not your father.

Cruelty is part of the disease; it is not subjective. Imagine the confusion inside your father's mind because the words don't come out the way they used to resulting in anger. He truly knows not what he does.

If your father is physically abusive, it may be time to consider putting him in a home. This is a progressive disease and his behavior will only get worse. Even then, your commitment will constantly be tested. Do not let it discourage you. You, too, are human.

Welcome to the ranks 🤕 Psalm 23:4
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to NeverABreak23
Report
funkygrandma59 Sep 26, 2025
NeverABreak, God ALWAYS answers our prayers, though it may not always be the answer that we're wanting, but it is ALWAYS His will being done. And we as Christians do not always understand God's ways, but we are to trust Him through it all.
Your user name says a lot, and tells me that you are more than likely burned out and overwhelmed in your caregiving situation, so my prayer for you today is that God will show up in an unexpected way to give you some relief and put a smile back on your face.
May God bless you and keep you.
(0)
Report
Dementia is a disease of a brain non-functioning, nothing to do with being a Christian, so your post is a bit confusing to me.

If he hits you something needs to be done, there are meds that can help him.

There are many church run facilities for those with dementia, he will be among his peers, safe and cared for. One does not need a front roll seat to care for another.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to MeDolly
Report

Hi. I read the other responses and they offer some great advice and encouragement. My Mom is a retired Pastor with Parkinson's and Parkinson's Dementia. Some moments are good and others are really hard to deal with. I used to say some days but now I have to take everything moment by moment. When Mom is herself, I take it in and treasure it. Sometimes I take pictures too. When dementia is affecting her and she is not herself, I deal with it the best I can and sometimes that may mean walking away to not get so overwhelmed and stressed. I wonder sometimes too why she has to go through this but resolve to keep going and hanging in there with her because she would do the same for me and she has over the years when I was sick and in the hospital myself. It's hard. Just want to say that I hear you and you're not alone. We're in the same boat riding this wave of illness together. Sometimes it even feels like I'm on a rollercoaster I never ask to get on. And believe me, I do not like rides! I go to the fair for the food! So I'm riding this wave and rollercoaster with you. Hang on and hang in there. You're not alone.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to CareBear29
Report

Dementia is BRAIN DEATH. It's like having a sudden brain injury that causes personality changes....the brain sections die.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Cashew
Report

If your Dad hits you, you need to tell his doctor and I hope its a Neurologist. There are medications. Your Dad could have frontal lobe Dementia. It affects his emotions that is why the personality change. They can become very aggressive. He could hurt you, they become very strong. If medication does not help, you need to consider placing him.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to JoAnn29
Report

You posted this under dementia and Alzheimer's.
The way you understand all this is to educate yourself on these conditions.
You will then understand that this isn't your father speaking, but the disease which is robbing him of who he is.

I am so sorry for the pain.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to AlvaDeer
Report

I’m learning so much about t
he disease and t
he process. What’s harder to understand and process is I know what scripture says about believers. Dad was a pastor and led us to the LORD. Was kind and loving. I do believe God does not hold against him the actions because of the disease but the sealing of, being a comforter, and walking with us/them through darkness-this is dad’s spirit already in the presence of the LORD and this is just a shell. I know it’s the disease and I do try to separate the two but I am struggling with being getting angry with him when he cusses or hits me when I’m being kind or trying to serve or dress him. He will be kind to a stranger or doctor or hired caregivers so it seems like he does have some control when he seemingly is cruel to his two sons and not his two daughters. Thanks for just letting me get this out of my head for the moment.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to Ara1970
Report
notgoodenough Jun 30, 2025
Have you reported to his doctor he is becoming physically abusive to you? If not, you are doing both yourself AND him a disservice.

There are medications he can be placed on to lessen his agitation. To make him calmer and less anxiety-ridden.

His doctor should be made aware of his behavior ASAP.
(7)
Report
I'm sorry you're going through this. I can't explain this disease. My mother had vascular dementia but was also being treated for Alzheimer's. She was a prayerful woman her entire life, devoting part of each day to prayer. But as the disease progressed, and sometimes in response to her own feelings of helplessness, she lashed out at her children. She was particularly cruel to my sister, who was responsible for most of her care. Now that my husband has Alzheimer's, when things get difficult, my mantra is "It's not him, it's just the disease." Maybe that would help you with your dad. Good luck, and God bless.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Quitecontrary
Report

I’m not religious and this book was written by a rabbi, but it’s all about why would God allow such a terrible thing to happen. In his case, his 3-year-old son got a terrible degenerative disease and only lived about another 10 years. How could suffering and early death be part of God’s plan for a 3-year-old?

Anyway, it’s called When Bad Things Happen to Good People by Harald Kushner.

Or you could try Man’s Search for Meaning by Victor Frankl. He survived imprisonment in a Nazi concentration camp.

Or maybe ask your own pastor. When my MIL was dying, the one person she asked to see again (besides family) was her pastor but he had dementia and wouldn’t have remembered who she was.

good luck.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to Suzy23
Report
Ariadnee Jun 30, 2025
Great suggestions. I recommend the 800 number for the Alzheimer's organization. I've called them twice to help me. Both times the person I spoked to helped me a lot. Perhaps they may be able to help the OP.
(0)
Report
I have found this quote to be true in my own journey with my Mom as she suffers from dementia. My Dad taught me how to die and be ready to be with God. My Mom’s journey has made me a better imitation of Christ, although I fought with God for a long time about it.

“It is not by sidestepping or fleeing from suffering that we are healed, but rather by our capacity for accepting it, maturing through it and finding meaning through union with Christ, who suffered with infinite love.”
― Pope Benedict XVI, Saved in Hope: Spe Salvi
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to sparkielyle
Report

You understand that your dads brain is now permanently broken and he no longer is in control of what he says or does.
And God knows your dads true heart and soul and loves him as much today with his broken brain as He did before he developed dementia.
We as Christians are not meant to understand everything this side of heaven, but we must trust that God is still on His throne and is still in control.
Perhaps educating yourself more about this horrific disease will help you better understand what is going on with your dad, so you won't take things so personally. It certainly can't hurt.
God bless you and keep you as you walk this very difficult journey with your dad.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to funkygrandma59
Report

Your dad has a disease not of his own doing, and not within his control. The disease alters personality, often in ways that makes a kind, loving person unrecognizably cruel. Believe me, your dad wouldn’t recognize himself and would be embarrassed by his behavior. I used to listen to by dear Christian aunt after her Alzheimer’s advanced and quietly think how embarrassed and shocked she’d be at the things coming from her mouth. It’s no one’s fault, if he lives long, the cruelty may be replaced by silence. Limit your exposure to the cruelty, no one deserves to listen to much of it. Remember the dad you were blessed to have, and practice self care. I wish you both peace
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to Daughterof1930
Report

He has a disease. I'm very sorry, this must be so upsetting. BUT try to regard it as any other disease. If he had cancer, you'd understand that he can't stop the changes that take place with that disease, such as becoming tired, unable to walk, etc. And cancer causes personality changes too, sometimes.

It's hard not to look through the lens of your religion, but changes in us due to disease have nothing to do with Christianity or any other religion. As my Bible teacher friend used to say, "God makes us and turns us loose. He doesn't bring the bad things upon us."

Your dad can't help who he is now.
Helpful Answer (7)
Reply to Fawnby
Report

Can you clarify your question a bit please?

are you asking as a Christian how you spiritually process with God this cruel turn?

the biological answer, which I’m guessing not your question?, is that Dementia is caused by damage to brain cells, which disrupts communication between different parts of the brain. Depending on which areas of the brain are affected, a person’s personality, mood, and behavior can change significantly. he is has no control over what his brain is doing.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to sparkielyle
Report

Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter