Follow
Share

Not my first post here. Most probably know all the trauma I have gone through with my grandpa. He is now in a Memory Care and is still claiming he 'does not need to be there'. So his NP just saw him today and she sent me a portal message stating "FYI he doesnt want to spend Thanksgiving here and asked if I could reach out to his doctor to see if he can be released, since we obviously know its not in the cards for him to leave, any chance someone could visit for Thanksgiving?" Heres my thought process (which is very on edge as I type). This man has given me so much trauma in the last 2 years I have had to seek therapy AND medication. I go when I can and usually leave upset as he is almost always nasty to me. That totally triggered me as the last 5 years of holidays with him at home were miserable, isolated and spent alone as no one wanted to spend a holiday dealing with him, and to be honest, I do not want to spend anymore with him either. I also dont want to be seen as a terrible person, which is how I feel when put on the spot like that. I hate being stuck in this cycle of anxiety and stress but there is NO ONE else that could go see him since he alienated ALL the family well before his dementia kicked in. How do others handle this kind of situation?

Find Care & Housing
Just say no. He has alienated everyone else, why should you be the exception? Consider yourself alienated as well, BY HIS OWN BEHAVIOR, and stop visiting altogether. Facilities have their own holiday celebrations and he can choose to enjoy those if he wants. No one who knows him will think you are a terrible person and even if someone randomly does, who cares? He is the terrible person, not you. Walk away permanently and live your life in peace.
Helpful Answer (10)
Reply to MG8522
Report

It doesn't really matter how others handle a situation like this. What works for one person doesn't necessarily work for another. So put that thought process out of your mind.

Do you WANT to visit him? Not do you feel obliged to so, do you feel guilty not doing so, do you feel other people will look at you less favorably than you would like should you not do so... do you WANT to? If the answer is no, then that's ok. Don't go. You have every right to have a happy Thanksgiving as anyone else does, and if seeing him on that day will make it less so, you are perfectly justified in saying "no, I will not be visiting him on Thursday". That's all you have to say.

You don't own this NP ANY explanation why you won't be seeing him. Who cares if she thinks you're a "terrible" person - that won't affect your grandfather's care. She doesn't know the dynamic you have with him. It's not her that's going to be upset all day on the holiday if you go and see him - and why would you think it would be any different this time than all the other times before?

I personally think it's pretty crappy for this NP to reach out to you and try to lay this guilt trip on you 4 days before the holiday. Totally uncalled for.

"No. I will not be seeing him on Thursday." That's the ***only*** answer you need to give - and give it as often as you have to.

Good luck, and please give yourself permission to enjoy your Thanksgiving guilt free.
Helpful Answer (10)
Reply to notgoodenough
Report

Respectfully decline. No explanation needed.
Helpful Answer (11)
Reply to AMZebbC
Report

Just say no to the request. No need for explanation.

Most facilities try extra hard with their holiday meals knowing that many seniors will be eating them without family but together. And that’s the best grandpa gets as he’s burned all his family bridges leaving only fellow residents to talk to.
Helpful Answer (9)
Reply to PeggySue2020
Report

Please change your visits to “around the corner” ones, where you see him minus him seeing you, check in with the staff, see about his needs, make sure he’s clean and cared for, then leave and go do something positive for yourself. Many have needed to do this for emotional health, and it’s okay. As for the NP, medical professionals simply cannot ever fully comprehend the history, the nastiness, the whole dynamic, they haven’t lived it. Take the request with a grain of salt and move on. You already know you’re doing your best. I wish you peace
Helpful Answer (14)
Reply to Daughterof1930
Report

One more point, the NPs in a facility have a large patient population (usually they make rounds through several facilities) and might only see the patient briefly a few times a year. So she may have no idea what the family dynamics are and is just checking a box that she relayed a message. She probably forgot about you and grandpa the minute she finished sending it because she has to see several dozen more people before Thanksgiving. So absolutely no one is judging you or actually expecting you to do this. On holidays it is more common for a person in Memory Care to NOT have visitors than it is for them to have some.
Helpful Answer (16)
Reply to MG8522
Report

I suggest that you reply to your grandpas NP, that you will not be traumatized any longer by this sick man, but that they are more than welcome to go spend the day with him if they are so concerned about him.
Helpful Answer (13)
Reply to funkygrandma59
Report
Zookie Dec 2, 2025
I love that sassy attitude! Definitely THEY can spend the day with him if they want!
(1)
Report
NP can call SW or church groups who may be willing to visit on the holidays. In our experience, church groups drop off a goody bag for 5 minutes. Candy and decorations. Not needed. What the elders need is 1 hour of visiting in attendance and maybe some supplies dropped off. Ensure, depends, or yard work or pet care. Scoop the box. Maybe make them a cup of tea and sit with them for 1 hour.wash the dishes in the sink. Listen to their old stories. That’s what they need. Stop wasting money on goodie bags and flags. Come spend an hour a week with the elderly and ask the family what help they need. They will tell you.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to Beethoven13
Report
laura9574 Nov 25, 2025
He lives in a facility and all of his needs are being met. I just feel like the guilt trip was not necessary as he and I already have a strained relationship. This would be the first year I can spend Thanksgiving with my family after years of him living here and being so isolated due to his broken bridges.
(5)
Report
See 2 more replies
Stop agonizing over it and just do what you want to do. If you don't want to visit for Thanksgiving, then don't. It really is that simple. I'm not going to be with my father at his nursing home at Thanksgiving and I am fine with it. No guilt here.
Helpful Answer (7)
Reply to Hothouseflower
Report

HE burned his bridges. Your the last one. He does not have the right to dictate what you or anyone else will do for him. You go and have that Thanksgiving with your family. Grandpa will get his Thanksgiving dinner at the MC. He will be surrounded by residents and staff. You are entitled to have the holidays to yourself.

I am with MG that the NP made the call for a patient then she went on to her other patients. It was not personal, just doing a patient a favor. Probably has to load herself up so she can get Thursday and Friday off. She did what she was asked and went on her merry way.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to JoAnn29
Report

I feel the same way. I dread all holidays because of the expectation I will visit my Mom in assisted living. I don't want to. I am tired. I am sick of worrying about it, and just want to be left alone. The facility is supposed to keep them busy on the holidays. Since your Grandpa treats you badly anyway, I just wouldn't go. You shouldn't have to live your life unable to enjoy the Holidays without this drama. I always feel guilty anyway, but I have to avoid it for my own sanity. We do some activities with her leading up to the holidays, but we are planning to go camping for the entire week of Christmas just to get away from it. Currently dreading the setting up of her Christmas tree and nativity set tomorrow - I am incredibly anxious today just anticipating it. Two more "activities" after tomorrow and the season will be over. Then her birthday in January, then a few months of reprieve until Mother's Day. I have taken care of my Mom and Dad (until he passed) from the age of 14. Just can't deal with it anymore. But I'll be there tomorrow with my festive face on and put up that tree! But I will not stay home for Christmas - I'm outta here. I sound awful, I know.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to Lylii1
Report
LakeErie Dec 2, 2025
You are not awful. You are doing what is enjoyable for you, and that is very healthy. She is taken care of and you should go and celebrate the holiday in any way that makes you happy.
(5)
Report
No is a complete sentence and does not require explanation, apologies or guilt. Just say no and drop it.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to LakeErie
Report

In addition to what others have said, I suggest telling the provider to not call you anymore with these requests. You have expressed being triggered just from the call and it’s taking a great emotional toll on you. Your grandfather is in a safe environment and his needs are being taken care of. Based on what you’ve shared you don’t need to do anything further. Please take care of yourself.
Helpful Answer (8)
Reply to WayLeadsOn2Way
Report

You have carefully detailed what you want, and why. You do not want to spend another holiday with him. Period.
Then, the reason for your anxiety and stress is that you feel put on the spot and "don't want to be seen as a terrible person". Seen by whom?
Do Not live your life to please someone else because you're afraid it will look bad if you don't.
The NP does not know your relationship or your history with your Grandpa. She is simply passing on his request. For all she knows, Grandpa might have a family that would be happy to visit him on holidays. Some residents do.
If you do not, Do not feel compelled to do something out of guilt.
No one else in your family will go to see him, because he alienated his entire family. Boy, he must have been a real jerk! Let him live with the consequences of how he lived his life. In other words, let him reap what he has sown.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to CaringWifeAZ
Report

I actually spoke to the nurse who manages the facility on the Tuesday prior as he claimed his arm was broken so she needed approval for mobile xrays. (arm was NOT broken, he was arguing with another resident and grabbed something away from them) She told me that she was sorry that the NP said that and that she would speak to her about her 'delivery'. She told me it would be better if I didnt come for the holiday since he was in a particulary bad mood so I didnt. I spent the holiday with my family and it was AMAZING. The NP actually sent me back a messge and said she was sorry that she didnt realize our relationship was so toxic/caused me so much anxiety and that she hoped I had a great Thanksgiving. I appreciate every single response here and feel so glad to have a place where I can get these things off my chest to people who really understand.
Helpful Answer (11)
Reply to laura9574
Report
CaringWifeAZ Dec 3, 2025
Thank you Laura, for the update! I'm glad you enjoyed your holiday!
(1)
Report
Don’t visit your grandpa. With his dementia, he may not understand the purpose of your visit. Go out for fun for yourself.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to Patathome01
Report

None of us have to visit relatives during holidays if we don't want to! It's been drilled into us that family is fun, holidays are family time, the best place is home for the holidays, etc. etc. etc. ad nauseam. The truth is that many families aren't that great, that relatives often aren't the best company, and that family gatherings require a lot of work that we don't want to do.

Sometimes we need to stand up for what we really want. If it requires making other people angry, so what? It's your life to live as you wish.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to Fawnby
Report
CaringWifeAZ Dec 3, 2025
You are so right, Fawnby!
My Dad and Stepmom live a mile away. We did not spend Thanksgiving together. They make plans with their friends, as they have for years, and I chose to spend it this year quietly with my non-mobile husband. All our kids are several states away, and they are now old enough to create their own family traditions.
I used to enjoy cooking for family on holidays, which my husband eagerly helped with, but after 10 years of caring for him, and he can't eat solid food, I'm just burnt out on doing anything that is too much work.
My dad and stepmom don't cook. They go out. So I get tired of offering dinners and cooking for them, which I do about once a month. They are rude, loud, get drunk, and bring their little dog with them, who is underfoot while I'm in the kitchen. I'd much rather have dinner without them, Holiday or not.
(1)
Report
If your loved one isn’t in a facility, bring the holiday to them bring them food, gifts, and friends
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to Sample
Report

Before I read any other notes, 1) leave him where he's at...there will be parties and lots of wel wishers in December, coming in, and no guilt...2) what I did was go into my bedroom,watch TV, and let the others be stupid and drink until they fall down...3)where is it written you have to have all people you know in one house? It seems most don't want him around either...do they feel guilty? If they don't, relax and have a good time...
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Kidd12
Report

Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter