Follow
Share

A few years back I use to give a friend rides from her assisted living to our women's vet group. The last time I took her she had an accident and all these ladies decided it was my job to clean her up. I didn't hesitate (someone had to do it) so I did, took her home and missed the meeting. I felt really bad for her but never took her again. Then we had a special meeting and took her and another lady to a luncheon and they had a wonderful speaker. I was really looking forward to hearing her. The two ladies were sitting in a different area than me. Just as the speaker started I was asked to step outside. Apparently the two ladies decided they couldn't hear her and wanted to go home. Apparently one of them forgot her hearing aide. I explained that I wasn't ready to leave and they needed to go back inside and wait. At that time they already had their stuff and didn't want to go back inside. I insisted. It was going to be only another 30 minutes and I had felt that since I had been nice enough to bring them to begin with, it wasn't fair of them to think I should just miss the speaker because they were tired of sitting. Our leader had her husband take them home because twice I had a lady come to my table and tell me I should take them home. I told the lady, no, that since it wasn't a medical emergency they should wait. It made it almost impossible to enjoy the speaker. Fast forward to a few years later and I had one of the members tell me off about it. She felt that since I brought them I should have been willing to take them home when "they" wanted to go. I still don't feel I did anything wrong. I wasn't their caregiver, they weren't in any physical pain or destress, just tired of sitting there. Was I in the wrong?

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
This is keeping you awake now just because of the group member's dredging it up again? Or does it bother you from time to time anyway, regardless of what anyone else says?

Were you in the wrong...

It depends, yes and no, in what way in the wrong, how do we define your role in that particular moment, etc etc etc

No, you were doing them a favour, you weren't there particularly in a caregiving capacity, your responsibility to these ladies was limited.

But possibly yes: one of the ladies may have needed to go home for reasons she hadn't disclosed to you, but possibly had disclosed to her companion, who was therefore being indignant on her behalf to other members seated near them. As there had previously been the bathroom incident, my guess would be something related to that.

Whatever, we live and learn - don't volunteer to escort unreliable attendees to a lecture you yourself definitely want to hear! But honestly, fancy the member's bringing this up again *now*. What on earth's the point of that?

What's that people say about "no good deed goes unpunished?" Feel better!
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

No, you were not wrong. Don't histrionics drive you nuts! It was very giving of you to transport them at all.
Helpful Answer (9)
Report

No, if they didn't want to wait for their free taxi service they could have called a cab or Uber.
Helpful Answer (9)
Report

Absolutely NOT.
If they/she didn't disclose a reason that may, or may not, have led you to a different decision, that is on them.
You have every right to not be a pushover.
As for anyone bringing it up EVER again...make an announcement right there that 'so & so' has just offered her car as a cabbie for anyone and GUARANTEES to drop everything on a dime to deliver them.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

I'm not very impressed with someone who would bring up that kind of issue a few years later.    To me that reflects a few things:  (a) this person doesn't have much more important things going on in her life, or if she does, she's not focusing on them, and (b) it's none of her business.

It's done, over with, and if there's anything about which to be concerned it's whether or not you can treat it as a "lessons learned."  And that would be not provide transportation for those women.  

Personally I would have been irritated at what I think was a selfish demand.  People who hitch a ride with someone else can't expect cab service at their beck and call.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
NeedHelpWithMom Aug 2019
I know, right? I agree.
(0)
Report
No you were not. It was not unreasonable for you to have asked your two passengers to wait awhile because you came to hear the speaker. If anything, the 2 ladies were rude to you.

As for this person who dredged up the past some people just have too much time on their hands and don’t have much joy in their lives.
Remember, misery loves company. They want to share theirs with you. While your head may be exploding, realize she’s the clueless one.

Go on being you. This is hurtful to you & for that I am sad. She wants a reaction from you. Don’t give her one. If she does it again walk away politely.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

I think what these women are trying to do to you is called gaslighting. They are trying to manipulate you and make you question yourself. And they have succeeded to some extent as evidenced by "Was I in the wrong?". Of course you were not the one in the wrong and, deep down inside, you know that.

Stop acting like a chauffeur and stop explaining yourself. Just because someone asks for an explanation does not mean you have to give it. Be busy. Be unavailable. When they ask for a ride say something like "Sorry ladies, I've got plans after the luncheon. Enjoy the talk."
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

Just to clarify: the "critic" was not one of the two ladies whom Whaleyf had kindly brought to the luncheon in question. This is another member of the same group who seems to have taken it on herself to moralise after an interval of heaven knows how long; and most unattractive it makes her appear to be, too.

I really regret this sort of thing because it can ruin activities and social networks for all concerned, and that would be such a shame. Whaleyf, are you okay?
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

The old saying 'no good deed goes unpunished' is far too true.

I am famous for getting WAY too involved in situations that come back to haunt me, and only because I wanted to do the right thing. It's beyond frustrating. Last year I spent 4 months, 60+ hrs a week trying to help a 'friend' pack up and move as she was losing her home to foreclosure, had been given custody of her 3 (horrid) grandkids...and she was sinking, fast. The mother is in jail, the father hasn't made any attempts at contact and does not pay a dime towards support--and she is 68 years old!) I literally worked myself into a coma 'helping' her.

Long story short, the entire house is packed, my SIL was going to sell her home with a 1% commission--she could not have had more support--and the son calls her and tells her not to sell. So she doesn't. There sit 3 fully packed pods in her driveway (on my credit card!!) and she is mad at ME because I cut off her 'funding'. She's been mad at me for almost a year now.

People have said some unkind things to me about 'abandoning her' in her time of trial, and I don't bother to explain. I did the best I could, actually, way more than I should have and I will regret it forever.

I am not mean to this woman. I simply had to cut her out of my life completely. She was the champ of gaslighting and acting all Southern and sweet--but wow, my radar is still up. By now she's taken advantage of so many people it's crazy....

You did NOTHING wrong.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
GardenArtist Aug 2019
MidKid58, Your post reminds me of  a situation decades ago, when a co-worker asked to stay with me for a short time while she started separation proceedings from her violent husband.    I don't recall the incident, but there was a big blow-up and she felt she needed to escape from him that day.

Feeling sorry and concerned for her, I went to her house, helped her pack, got her settled in my apartment, and tried to help her plan to move forward.

After midnight, her husband came over, banging and pounding on the door.  I wouldn't let him in.    She changed her mind, decided to go back to him, easily dispelling all the hatred she allegedly had a few hours ago.

While I continued to be courteous to her at work, I never again considered her a friend or did anything that dragged me into her life.

MidKId58, I'm soooo glad and proud of you that you stood your ground!  

If the others who criticize you are so supportive of her, why don't THEY step up and get involved in her manipulations?
(3)
Report
See 1 more reply
The women were rude to make u think u had to take them home. Like said, they could have called a cab.

I would think the lady that mentioned it years later may have some Dementia and now has no filter.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

Short and simple answer to this question. The answer is NO! You did nothing wrong but they did!

Don’t sweat it. There’s always going to be people with crappy attitudes. You were kind, doing them a favor and they were rude. Anyone else that jumped in to defend them is rude too. You know this. Validation from us? You got it from me!

The world will always have wonderful, thoughtful people like you and also have jacka**es like them. Do yourself a favor and forget about it and don’t ever offer them a ride again!
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

I’ve always felt that if someone gives you a ride, you are at their mercy. You leave when they are ready to leave. You go where they want to go.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Cali,

With your sensible, caring attitude, you could catch a ride with me anytime. Love your response! This is the right attitude when tagging along with others. Being grateful and considerate goes a long way. I bet you say, please and thank you as well because you have manners, common courtesy.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

The person who confronted you all this time later is a nut case with the memory of an elephant. Why in the WORLD would you bother to argue with such a person. Next time someone tries to mind your business for you why don't you tell them that you are willing to listen to them when they pay by the hour. Then name a price beyond their means. Honestly, how far must some people go to be critical of others. Had the women been having a medical emergency I am certain you would have been happy to return them home despite the ruination of your own day. Dr. Laura when she used to be on air on radio had a habit of saying "No good deed goes unpunished". I think you just proved her right.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

This is where you learnt that no good deed goes unpunished. Remember it
There Are things called taxis

tell that lady and any others who may still be virtue signalling, politely but firmly that you do not appreciate her unsolicited opinion and that it makes you feel singled out and hurt. Then refuse further conversation on the matter

this is called assertive without aggression. It puts the ball back in their court and they have nowhere to go

Ot you could just tell her to piss off
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
NeedHelpWithMom Aug 2019
Hahaha

Panda, love the last line !
(1)
Report
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter