Follow
Share

My 91 year old mother-in-law came to live with us a few months ago. She had been living in another state with her daughter for about half a year, but had not been well taken care of. She has 2 other children (one is retired professional person and the other a physician) who live in other states and who want nothing to do with her either physically or monetarily. She requires oxygen and has has some ailments, (COPD, emphysema, atrial fibrillation, hypertension, depression, GERD, hyperlipidemia) and her short term memory is just about completely gone and I also suspect that there is some beginning dementia. She cannot be left alone because she would attempt to do things that she cannot do by herself and that would be unsafe (bathing, cooking, walking around unsupervised, taking her meds, etc...) She is a good natured pleasant person, but she is very needy. I find myself getting very irritated by her and although I don't show it to her, I end up taking it out on my husband and son and am feeling stressed out. We bring her breakfast and lunch in her room and she has dinner with us and I find myself dreading dinnertime listening to her repeat the same thing over and over again and making little or no sense. When you spend just a short time with her, she appears to be more competent than she really is, and although we visited her several times a year when she was living in another state, we did not realize the extent of her needs before we volunteered to take her in with us, although it really would not have made a difference because her other children want nothing to do with her. I work out of my home, so it is difficult to get away for any length of time. We have tried senior day care, but most of the time she doesn't want to go and getting her prepared and ready and getting her on the bus (our town has a door to door senior transportation system) takes a lot of time and hardly seems worth it given the extra time and money involved. I believe her needs place her somewhere between an assisted living facility with extra help and a nursing home, but she is not yet ready for a nursing home and that she would suffer emotionally if she were in a nursing home (and we would feel extremely guilty!) She has very little income, just her social security ($1000/month) and we cannot afford to pay for a nice assisted living facility for her where I think she would do well because she is a social person. My mother lived with us for several years before she passed away 2 years ago and although she was difficult a lot of the time, she was much more alert and oriented and less needy until her final illness and I had respite from my family members so even though it was tough at times I did not feel as irritated and stressed as I do now. I am having a hard time understanding my feelings because as I mentioned before, my mother-in-law is a very pleasant person, she does not complain, and is appreciative of all that we do for her.

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
I care for my husband at home 24/7 and even though it is hard at times, I find it better than sending him to a home full time. First, I don't have the money for a home and eventually will need home health to help me once he is not able to attend day care like he does now. All of this is very expensive and insurance does not pay for it. We make to much so we can't even get aid. To much is both of us collecting SS each month. Life goes on and you have to make the best of it. We have 8 children between us and we never see them. They are totally no help and if you ask they are busy. What comes around goes around I say.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Care is not cheap whether you hire thru an agency or private. Good caregivers are difficult to find and they are never paid enough so they move around a bit.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

had "poor" money and ltc planning skills i meant to say
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

ChrisA1, i don't believe you are qualified to make such a statement....and help is not inexpensive or free...what planet are you from....good help is difficult to find and is expensive. You are "caring" for ALF client....that is no comparison to 24/7 care!
Although some are very lucky just as many CG and situations have been gifted with parents who had good money and LTC planning skills.

Please be considerate of others situations as you are not in their shoes.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

You should not be a caregiver. You are not helping the other party or yourself. Getting assistance is inexpensive, in fact it is free.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

To Give a Hug,
Just to give you some background, my mother lost her husband in Florida, and then she immediately moved in with my sister. She did NOT want to move out. She did not want to go to my house, or anywhere. Dementia patients do not like change, and they also seem to always want to "go home," which in some ways is a place/time that was happier for them. That is a sad thing. It is sad, because she can't even remember that she is not in Florida anymore. It is all part of the disease.

Her condition was gradually getting worse at my sister's place. She kept getting rashes on her face, and we believe she was putting something besides face cream on her face, because the dermatologist said it looked like an allergy. I caught her with toothpaste all over her face the other night. There are many great dangers that you have to be aware of when you are taking care of a dementia patient at home.

When we were moving her into assisted living, she had a cough, and the nurse at the assisted living facility immediately took her temperature, and it was 102.9. She called 911, and got her into a hospital. My mother had pnemonia, but pulled through thanks to the nurse. Ordinary ailments can rapidly progress into something serious in the elderly.

Another time, she fell over boxes that she keeps moving in her room and PASSED OUT. Thankfully, again a CNA on duty was able to call 911, and I met my mother at the hospital. She was okay.

Home health aids are a great idea. Many of these companions are trained in dementia to come in during the week. They can develop wonderful relationships with them, and the aides know how to handle dementia patients. It also gives you a break. I have someone from Visiting Angels take my mother out once a week for 3 hours and the cost is $18.00 an hour. Sometimes insurance or medicaid will pay, if you qualify. I hope you success in finding a solution for everyone. It is not an easy situation.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Yes, to everything Havefaith said. My mother wouldn't have lived much longer, if she had stayed at home.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

HaveFaith,
I agree with you on all points of your Mom being better off. I wish I could convince my Mom that she needs to be in a facility of some kind, but she wants to be home. She is currently in rehab because she fell. This time gives me a breather which I desperately needed. I was a wired-up mess. But, Mom wants to be at home, so I'm going to try and work with her a while longer by having home health aids come in a give me a break on a regular basis, something I hadn't been doing. She might not need it; but I do need the help so I can stay healthy and sane. I am still checking out local facilities if she gets worse, far worse than she is now. I wish I could have the relief you so obviously feel!
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Hi,
I can empathize with everyone here. My mother came back from Florida after her husband died, and lived with my sister. She has progressively gotten more forgetful. My sister couldn't handle it, and we both agreed that assisted living was the way to go. We found a beautiful memory care unit at the Atria, and mom looks better than ever. They have a salon in-house, so her hair looks great. She gets manicures and pedicures. She also is cleaner and there are psychologists that come in, and a doctor that visits once a week. There is a cheerful recreation director that gets her involved in activities all week. There are weekly outings on the bus supervised by a CNA.

Compare this with her life before. My sister and I both work full-time. My mother was by herself in a small apartment, watching TV (Jerry Springer, etc.) all day. She had absolutely no social interaction. She was forgetting to eat lunch, even though my sister would try to run a sandwich home. She also was found outside and had a wandering tendency. Unfortunately, her mentality has decreased to that of a 4 year old, and you wouldn't leave a 4 year old alone all day. In today's society with many folks forced to work two jobs, there is little time for our dear parents to spend with us during the day. My mother is in a much better environment. She gets THREE excellent meals a day and snacks. Her unit is bright and cheerful, and she can sit out in a beautiful courtyard. Since the unit is a locked dementia unit, we don't have to worry about her wandering off somewhere, and I get to visit all the time, and when I visit, I am in a happy mood and we do fun things.

If you are with someone and miserable, they are going to sense it. Plus, your family is also being put under a lot of stress. Giving mom some independence and good meals and supportive activities is not a bad thing. Just be sure to thoroughly check out the facility before making any decisions.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

I think it was too soon for you after taking care of your mom. Since your MIL has other children in different states maybe you can find a facility appropriate for her. Sometimes we forget with 24/7 duties, that maybe the patient would be having more fun and be better off living somewhere else. I am so tired of the caregiving that i am too tired to do the fun stuff with my mom. And sometimes i think she would be better off, but i have no choice. Nursing home care varies by state. Florida is one of the worst states for elder and special needs children care. The system is overwhelmed- i am being polite.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

I admire you. I am able to love and dote on my mother because she is my mother, she is easy and sweet but I could never give what I give to my mom to another (except dad). Not to criticize but your husband should be caring for his mother, yes all of the hands on--i would have a very hard time if I were in your shoes. I am a little curious why her other children want nothing to do with her as it seems so harsh.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

The only blessing In this task is what I've learned about human nature and how most people only care about themselves and the majority of society can turn their back on their elderly family or just want their money and not give a rats arse what happens to the cargivee....the lessons this has taught me and how it made me a different person is something I needed to understand...I had such a Pollyanna attitude that majority of the world is good and will care for you the way you care for them....what a rude awakening!!
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

I don't think any of us have the personality for taking care of someone with dementia or who is just simply aging.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

I would try to get your MIL involved in an adult day program. Contact the office of aging to see if there are any programs which are low or no cost since she only lives on social security. Having two other adult children who could contribute to her needs financially should be addressed.
I suspect you are doing the lion's share of the caregiving as the daughter in law, your immediate family needs to step up as in the end "blood is thicker than water". It isn't fair for her children step down while you, an in-law, step up.

If you are left alone with the work, you should ask her children to select a nursing home for her. If she has no assets and low income, she has nothing
financially to lose. However, the move to a so-so nursing home will not be in her best interest mentally.

I am sure you are doing your best but you should not be expected to walk with your MIL alone. God bless you and your mother in law she made it to 91 and that would normally be an achievement. Too bad our society has no good plans for the fragile elderly.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

First of all, don't feel guilty. Caregiving is HARD on so many levels, that the fact that you are trying to do the right thing is worth feeling good about. From what I understand is that your 91 year old mother-in-law is at a point where she can't take care of herself physically or mentally, yet is a lovely person and you feel guilty about putting her in a facility.

Sometimes, putting an elderly person in the right assisted living facility is more beneficial for them than not. She would have round the clock care by trained professionals. They may notice new health issues sooner than if she were at home. They can adjust her meds faster if needed. She can have help with all her daily routine, etc. Then there's the socialization. Most places have lots of social activities geared towards the elderly making it easier for them to take part.

The key to this is to find the right place. Do research. Consider location, do they take Medicaid?, and other services your mother-in-law may need or want. If she likes bingo; make sure they got bingo! I have learned that not-for-profit assisted living facilities, typically are good!

Of course, not all facilities are good. I found a list of facilities in my area on the internet. I googled "assisted living facilities in (my city)." I got a list of many facilities, but also a website that listed each facility with their amenities and service ratings on everything from food to cleanliness to patient care. This is a good place to start. Then go visit see what it's like. Then ask your questions.

Once you get her placed, visit often. This is good for both of you. She'll love the company and you can make sure all things are running smoothly.

Regarding you, whatever decision you make with good intention, is the right decision. We can only make decisions with the info we have and the circumstances we're in. If needed, there are caregiver support groups that may help.

I received the most help from a social worker that was referred to me by the doctor. The social worker can tell you your options and what direction to go in. They can help you with everything needed to take care of your mother-in-law; financial or medical help for low income, home heath care if needed, finding a facility if needed, legal services (Power of Attorney, HIPPA) etc.

Good Luck
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

HI there - Well, at least you MIL is pleasant and it helps that she is appreciative. All of us caregivers do not have that luxury but there are obstacles. Like red said there are no right or wrong answers. All I can tell you is to look into other resources out there. I have had to feel my way through. At times I feel overwhelmed and not up to the tasks ahead of me. A lot of times I have to be selfish to save myself. Do not give in to guilt and re-thinking yourself. It will make you nuts. Again, see your way through. I have stumbled and tripped but this website has helped me along the way. Just take what you need and leave the rest. Remember to take care of YOURSELF.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

omg clarae51, how dare you be so obtuse.
I looked at your profile and you are 'caring' for someone who is in assisted living.
You are clueless so when you take someone into your home and become a hands on 24/7/365 caregiver you check in again and let's hear your tune then.
Service to others my a$$.
bless this.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

THIS TOO WILL PASS. and someday, YOU will be your motherinlaw. The guilt comes with the job YOU VOLUNTEERED to do. look beyond the guilt. you are truly blessed. Take the advice of many others above who have been there and are now grateful for what they lived through in service to others. THIS TOO WILL PASS.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Just remember that when you got married you both vowed to 'forsake all others', not meaning that you don't care about anyone else or try to assist, but that your primary priority is to each other. If your MIL and her extreme neediness is in between you and your spouse then some other arrangement needs to be made. Ditch guilt; it serves no purpose. If she is social, at least some of her interaction with others is after all up to her, no matter where she lives. Don't let this ruin your marriage, tear up your home and cause your kids to act out too due to lack of attention. It can happen and I have seen that several times with other family members and friends. At her level of income there are places she can go to live and I would pursue those. And then visit her frequently. If your husband isn't helping enough, then he needs to step up. Sounds like you both work and she IS after all HIS mother.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

I felt that way when my mom first came to stay with us, my mom has always been quiet and nice, but now she has her days. The Alzheimer's doesn't help with memory or making sense of some of the stuff she says, but I have learned to chalk it up to the disease that nothing can be done about. I work out of the house and the daytime help uses up all of her s.s. so anything after that comes out of my pocket. She owns her own home that my sisters think I should just keep taking care of without any support from them. Sometimes I think that they are just selfish people, which they really are, but in the long run, they are the ones missing out on the rest of her life. Phsyically she can probably go for years and I feel stuck some days, I would like a life of my own, but this is my life.
Good luck, I'm sure that you are doing the best you can, maybe a little outside help from an agency will help with your situation.
Sorry I babbled on.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

With love and patience. Get in touch with your local Area of Aging, they have many resources available. Try and get respite care and give yourself a break. It is hard to answer you since you didn't get much detail. I think the answers you're getting are more like my situation is worst than yours and it makes you more depressed then helpful. I am a licensed CNA and understand your circumstances since I have dealt with all types of situations.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Red17 roses couldn't have said it any better. You're damned if you do and damned if you don't, and forget the guilt. It helps no one. As someone about to put mom in a AL facility, who vowed NEVER to do that, I know what it feels like. I tried doing home health care for mom for about 13 weeks (late stage dementia on top of dual diagnosis psychiatric problems), and realized I just wasn't able to do it. I'm TRYING to forget the guilt, since everyone keeps saying this is for the best. (Three answers were from this site yesterday! They were SO helpful!) Good luck and blessings to everyone ~ and as I always try to remember too, don't forget to take a deep breath.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

I am so sorry things are looking so bad for you. I have been caring for my husband for about 13 years now. He has vascular dementia and Parkinson's disease. The dementia started out slow but has now moved to the advanced stage. I did have full time care for him at home while I was working full time but just recently retired. I now care for him 24/7 but two days a week I take him to day care and he seems to be ok with that. It gives me the day to do what I want or what is needed. When I am home with him it is a little harder because he wants me to sit with him or he wants to kiss my hand so he needs attention. He hates to take his shower so he grumbles and I laugh and make jokes and finally he says he was nice and thanks me. I was very angry at the beginning and frustrated to say the least but I have learned that it doesn't do any good to be sad, frustrated or angry. You are only making things worse for yourself. I give my husband Xanax the day he has his catheter changed. He used to fight the nurse and myself during this time so he now sleeps thru the procedure and all is good. I only give the Xanax one time every 3-4 weeks and makes life much easier when the catheter change is done. I have been with my husband for 35 years and there is an age difference so I suspect it might be easier for me to care for my husband who is 87 years old. He has 6 children who never come to see him or help so if I get respite care, it is because I pay for it. I figure one day I will be able to live a normal life but until then, I will be there for him. I have accepted the responsibility and I am happy I did. I also go to support groups which is a great help and I read thru all the comments on the different memory boards which I find very helpful. May God Give you strength in your journey and you will be able to find some peace.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

There is an old saying that 'your feelings are your feelings and feelings are not right or wrong'. Once years ago when a counselor asked me how I felt I launched into 'well, I should..." and she stopped me. She asked again how I felt and I realized I was hard pressed to even know, let alone express it. We can 'should all over ourselves' and nothing good comes of that.
My mother has been, in my life, a font of useless advice that included things like 'compared to _______________ you have nothing to complain about'. Surprisingly, that never made me feel better!
What has made me feel better is to admit that I am struggling with 'this' - whatever this is - and am doing the best that I personally can do. Or, if I am not doing the best I can, then I search my soul, write things down and weigh them, talk to a trusted friend or counselor who I know I can count on to help me get clarity and will tell me the truth, then figure out a game plan that I know I can commit to. We all have gifts and the ability to do for others. Do NOT compare yourself to someone else. Only strive to do your personal best. If a vessel is empty nothing can be poured out and that is the problem for many caretakers. If you need reinforcements, if you need to draw a boundary and say 'this is what I can commit to and no more', then you will be more effective at WHAT you CAN do. You do NOT have to lose your life and identity and complete happiness to prove you are a good or caring person.
My BIL is so resentful and punishing to my 93 year old MIL because he takes everything on (and there are perks for him, ie, he controls her bank account and has full access to it which we know he occasionally helps himself to). My MIL is afraid of him and he bullies her and resents her but his 'image' on the outside of things means so much to him and being a perceived martyr in his circle of friends, family and church acquaintances makes him feel truly always 'in the right' that a) we are not able to be a part of caretaking for my MIL b) he resents her and takes it out on her and c) she is unhappy too.
Allow others to help if they offer and do not expect them to do everything the way you might think it should be, loosen up and don't be hard on yourself, do healthy things for yourself, and admit to yourself what you are truly able to do and fill in the blanks the best you can. There are resources out there and you should not feel bad for just being who you are.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

I am sorry for the situation that you are in. Many of us have gone through it in one way or another. My in-laws had moved their mom from IL. to AZ. to help take care of her and it made things 100% worse, for grandma. Moving isn't easy at any age. She had to be taken back to IL. and admitted to one of the nicer NHs.

Not everyone (very few) are cut out to be caretakers. Don't look at it as failing, look at it as trying. Your Mother needs full time care, in a facility that can see to her needs.

My own 94 yo Mother would have sat in a chair and died, without a fall sending her to the hospital. She is now in a NH and is much better, nutritionally and her grooming needs are taken care of.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

I couldn't have said it better myself. I agree with Madeaa five a hug. My mother passed away on June 2, 2013. All the conflicting feelings you are having, I had with my own mother. You need to understand there is no wrong or right answer to taking care of your mom. You are going to feel guilty no matter what you decide. So doing everything with LOVE. I know that sounds so simple, but its really difficult when you are tired and angry at the disease, and tired. Your MIL is blessed to have you. After all, her other children needed a break and you took her on (regardless of your reasons). At this point in your MIL life, you and hubby need to make the decisions that are best for her and your family. If you let the guilt take over your decision making, the guilt will destroy your family and your MIL. I went to visit my mom at the nursing home that I swore I would never put her in. She passed away from dementia, and I believe it killed me more then it killed her. In the end she passed away peacefully, and I spend every day for 4 years visiting her in that nursing home. I hated putting her there, but I had a special needs daughter, hubby and son to also take care of. I had to pick (if you can imagine) which I was more responsible for. I felt guilty, angry, sad, happy at times, and every imaginable feeling you can think of. But in the end I did what was the best for my entire family. I would have loved to keep my mom at home, but financially and emotionally it was to much. I tell you all this, because even though our stories are a bit different, we are all the same in our caregiving rolls. You are dammed if you do, and dammed if you don't. So do the best you can with love in your heart and words, and keep on moving. Above all take care of your health first, because your body will break down fast. Remember, let go of the guilt, it helps no on.
Helpful Answer (12)
Report

Hi I hear you loud and clear. The thing is you did the caregiver route with your own mother for some time before your MIL. I know I would never ever ever want a repeat performance after this stint. You are probably conflicted because you did it for your mom now it is time to do for your husband's mom. You've been there done that and gotten the T shirt. It sounds like you need to decide if you accommodate your MIL with some help. My mother refused the day senior center, now she can't wait to go. Yes, it is at times overwhelming to get her out the door onto the bus, but those few hours are bliss, I listen to my music and if I have any energy left, I go for a bike ride. I must push myself, you understand, she takes so much out of me, that I want to curl up under a rock when she leaves. But, the more I push myself to get out during the time she is gone, the more energy I get. You know how hard this is, she does deserve the same treatment your mom received from you and your husband, and yes I can understand fully how you feel. My suggestion would be to get her out to the day center where she can make some friends, they take trips, although I am praying for my mother's day trip. If not, get someone in to help you or her, with either doing your housework, sitting with her, taking her out. In other words, you need to find a way to make it work and you will find it, you need to try to be objective and find a solution, forget the guilt, it helps no one.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

Hello,
The tasks of a caregiver are just tremendous and I can only begin to imagine how you feel. Have you asked your Mom's doctor for help? Everyone thinks of hospice as end of life but honestly it is much more than that. Get in contact with your local senior care, faith based organization, social security and see what other help is available. You may want to consult with an attorney. This is no easy task and navigating through the process is challenging. You can do it - one step at a time. Best wishes to you and your family.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Try a memory care assisted living that will take medicade. This has worked well for my mom with a similar profile. It's more homelike than a nursing home. Good luck!
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Well that previous comment was not supportive please ignore it! I would suggest going to some Nh and checking them out. It might ease your mind about her having to live there. You have to take care of yourself first.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter