Id like to start by saying I am not the one being accused of abuse. My mother works as a nurses aide in 2 different nursing home facilities. The first one, she has worked at for over 22 years and the second for ~5ish. Up until now, she has never been accused of abuse or neglect and is often complimented and receives cards from family members in the mail. She takes pride in how well she treats her patients when the other NA's don't really care. Recently, a newly hired NA has accused her of slapping a patient and my mother has been suspended pending a review. This has all occurred over the past 3 or 4 days.

Now, this is my mother, so people will expect me to be bias but if I am to be honest, her side of the story leaves me with a lot of questions and doubts as it keeps changing. I don't believe she hit the patient but I do believe she is suffering from anxiety and depression over the accusation and is unable to clearly tell her side of the story. She is in tears for most of the day and can barely operate.

What I know; both her and the NA were in the same room, they both left at the same time and on the way out she patted a patient (maybe a bit too rough?) and the other NA believes that she had hit a patient.

What I don't know; How hard was the pat? Did it leave a welt or a mark? How far away was the other NA to hear this? Did this event even occur? What is the relationship between my mother and the other NA? Is the other NA an honest person or just causing trouble?

Personally, I feel most NA's that work at these nursing homes are scumbags and shouldn't be employed. Iv met them, I don't like them, I wouldn't trust them. The nursing homes she works at are bottom of the barrel and hire virtually anyone (most the time, they cant even speak English) and then fire them. She only sticks around due to seniority. Id shut the whole place down if it were me. However, that's besides the point and my mothers license is on the line and I need to be as unbias as possible.

Right now they are investigating the accusation but I need help guiding my mother on what to do next and how to handle this. My opinion is she should hire a lawyer immediately; doing this will prove that she is confident that the accusation is false and she is willing to go to any length to prove that. The problem is, we're already stretched tight on finances and with her out of a job this only further exasperate the situation. Hiring a lawyer would be very difficult. What else can we do?

Thanks for your time


This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
yadd yadda yadda.............opps....too many yaddas.......

I wanted to apologize to you for being so mean about your paragraph about the homes and different nationalities of people. This IS a place to vent and say your TRUE feelings. I let it get the best of me and I went off on YOU at the end of my letter and it was wrong to do that.
(In fact.... the same way YOUR letter would have had better credibililty without the scumbag paragraph....MY letter to you would have been more credible if I had not included the paragraph about races and being lazy and such and such....)
Please accept my apology.
Helpful Answer (3)

Yadda, Yadda,,,,, i want to put another yadda there sooooooooooooooo bad;)
I can feel your pain and love for your mom. this kind of situation would hurt so bad if it were happen to MY mom. I agree with another post that the sooner you get mom to a therapist, counselor, social worker....the better!!!
You mentioned mom is a NURSE. By her chosen occupation...she is a CAREGIVER. The unfortunate thing about caregiverrs is they NATURALLY take care of everyone else and put themselves dead LAST. This is the MONTH or YEAR that mom decided to stand up for herself. I hope so bad the patient herself/himself is able to give his/her account of what happened that day. This needs to be asked ASAP. The elderly. by nature, don't remember things a few days later..... all of us have that problem. I she/he can't remember the actual act.....ask the head nurse or supervisor or owner of the dam place to talk with this patient. Something like this"
your mom: "Mrs. Mccarthy, I have done this job as best as I know how for 22 years. I am concerned, saddened, and a little nervous about the charges brought up against me. Will you consider talking to Mr. Jones and ask HIM about my professionalism and character? It would mean a great deal to me if you get his/her opinion.... or recollection of the facts, asap. thank you."

As far as YOU are concerned.....Yadda yadda.
You NEED to leave all the CRAP you believe at the DOOR about people, race, how these homes operate for people without money, etc. etc. etc.
Have you EVER gone home with "these" workers and talked with them with an interpreter?
Are ALL people that are from Mexico lazy and mean?
Are ALL people from Canada lazy and mean?
Are ALL people from America lazy and mean?
Are ALL people from the islands lazy and mean?

Before you talk about scumbags and nursing homes that need to be shut down....ask yourself this:

How much more credible would YOUR letter have been to the world if you had just left out your opinion with the entire paragraph of hate and anger????
Helpful Answer (2)

Wow, I really feel for your mother. This must be such a trauma to her - to have given for so many years and now be accused.

I generally agree with Blannie and think hers is good advice. Just one comment from someone who's worked in law for almost all her life. Blannie, don't take this personally; it's not meant to challenge your advice but rather to offer insight from the perspective of someone's had to sign and/or notarize probably a hundred different types of affidavits.

Notarization means basically nothing except that a notary signed it. It's not an affirmation or inclination of truth or sincerity. In the personal injury field, documents which need to be notarized are sent to the client who sends it back, then a notary signs it - typically the notary has never even met the client and sometimes never spoken with her. So much for the acknowledgment that the notary knows the person to be who she/he says she/he is!

Notarization in so many situations is just a required step for filing. The main exception is in estate planning, which is handled with much more caution.

I do think though that getting an attorney involved now would be advisable. A medical malpractice defense firm might be a good choice; some of them have nurse consultants and others have attorneys who formerly were nurses.

Ask of the nursing home also what the standards are for the investigation - who is investigating (nursing staff, independent party?), providing information, what are their qualifications, and especially ask what background check is being done on the nurse accuser. The fact that she was just recently hired makes me suspicious; perhaps she has an axe to grind. Perhaps she herself was fired for cause from a previous job. An attorney can hire a private investigator to get this information.

In the meantime, do whatever you can to focus Mom on something more cheerful - take her out to lunch, buy her flowers, plan a garden, anything to take her mind off the investigation.

As to returning to that place, I think leaving even after cleared might look suspicious. It might be a good idea to quietly and slowly begin looking for other opportunities though. As yet I have no experience with the various home health care groups other than those that are hospital affiliated and one for profit organization which is top notch, but that might be an alternative. It would be a lot less stressful than her current job.

Good luck, and I wish you both the best in addressing this situation.
Helpful Answer (2)

Your mom needs to write a clear, concise version of what happened, since talking about it upsets her. It will help focus her to get the facts straight, and clear her mind of clutter.

Start there with the "who, what, when, where and why" and see what happens. If she can't do it on her own, act as a reporter and ask her calmly each of the questions and then help her write it up clearly. I'd get her statement notarized, which would signify she's telling "her truth" about it.

I'm not sure about hiring a lawyer, that might be an expense that is unnecessary at this point. I'd wait to see what happens with the review. You can always hire a lawyer to fight it if they find your mom at fault. Good luck and keep us posted.
Helpful Answer (1)

Get mom on antidepressants and counseling first and foremost. If this is the first accusation in the last 22 years, she will be cleared. The bigger question is whether returning to work a healthy choice for her. Something to think about.
Helpful Answer (1)

The NH has to investigate your mom, it's not personal, although I can understand why your mom is so beside herself over this. I am sure they will find your mom did nothing wrong. She's been there for a long time and has a good record with no blemishes.

When your mom interacts with anyone regarding this (supervisor, etc.) she needs to be calm and cool. Matter of fact. She can cry at home but being emotional with her superiors will undermine her side of the story. Tell her to be strong!

Not all people who work in facilities are scumbags. I pop in and out of facilities everyday and I've learned who the caring, capable staff are and who the uncaring and rough staff are. There are good people working in facilities, they're not all horrible.

Your mom will get through this. She's good at her job and I'm assuming that she hasn't had any prior complaints. I know she's devastated but she has a great daughter who believes in her.
Helpful Answer (1)

so sorry to hear about this, with youre mum doing this line of work for so many yrs, she is bound to be shocked, confused, angry, and of course depressed. I certainly would not go to a lawyer at this present time, no-one has had a bad word to say about youre mum, if the patient had been hurt at a pat on the back which was hard and painful, then this new nurse would have heard the patient let out a moan. it could be that this is in her nature, I see nothing wrong with patting a patient on the back,its like a child being rewarded for something they have done well, they get a pat on the back from their parents. your"e mum is doing the same with patients.i hope for your"e mums sake this is sorted out soon, she obviously loves her work and this person has shattered her confidence, I would be crying too if someone accused me of the same thing, I hope when things are fixed out, she will walk into work with her head held high, refusing to ever work with the person responsible, I can understand why you are angry, you know mum better than any of the nurses. just be there for her at the moment. who knows maybe tomorrow it will all be over. good luck.
Helpful Answer (1)

Just a comment here. In any professional job that deals with people, I always tell everyone to save all the cards, letters and any good written comments of thanks for your good care. You never know when you have to stand up for yourself & these Thankyou notes/letters/cards could very well come in handy. Hope things work out well for Mom.
Helpful Answer (1)

Yadda I hope all goes well for your mother. Her situation is stressful. Like others posted I think you should get her to answer the 5 w's. Especially if she is having a hard time explaining her situation. I hope that she didnt do as she has been accused and that the patient can speak up and say what happened. If she is working two jobs it may be two much for her and she may have been over worked. The nursing home situation is so bad as far as nurse to patient ratio. Its bad for the NA and RN. Its hard work and some patients can be very mean and have to be dealt with at a distance. The same can be said about nursing both RN and NA you have vicious people in that field and that is a reality that i know from personal experience and observation. In any case your mother needs to get it to gether so she can speak up clearly for herself. If she can't remember or seems confused about what happened she could look incompetent. If she is under attack then she needs to stand strong and sure. Wish you all the best in the outcome.
Helpful Answer (0)

Forgot to mention that if she does not have a union rep who would check other staff on how your mom works handles patients and situations then it might be good to find out who she works for that can speak up for her if needed. If there are enough people who will validate her good work with patients it could help. Also i did mention those mean and vicious folk who are out there. But I hope your mom is one of those loving caring people. Who go out their way and get behind schedule because they cant just leave the patient a certain way. She needs all the support she can get as her integrity is being question and she's got to fight the good fight.
Helpful Answer (0)

See All Answers
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.

Ask a Question

Subscribe to
Our Newsletter