Follow
Share

My mother-in-love is 84, lives on her own, and is 100% capable of making her own decisions.



In her living room, she sits in an old recliner that she can't recline because it has a pull lever and she doesn't have the strength in that arm to recline it.



She has plenty of money to buy a new one. Her financial planner even told her so.



And now, because she has some aging issues with joints and such, her ortho and internist have told her she would be helped a great deal by reclining.



Still, she doesn't seem like she's interested. She's incredibly stubborn. And yet, she complains all the time about how uncomfortable she is. 😔🤦🤔



Have any of you experienced this kind of stubbornness, and have you found a good/kind/loving way to help your elder move past it?

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
A lot of old people tend to get stuck in a rut and just accept what life dishes out to them and don't try to fix it or even know how (at least with my parents). Does your hubby help her with her finances? Have access to her credit card? If it were me, I think I'd just go ahead and order her one. It's 99% sure that she'll LOVE it!
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

The holidays will be the perfect time to get her a new recliner delivered, and the old one hauled away! Get a big BOW for it. Everyone will be happy!
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

If she's "uncomfortable" enough, she'll buy a new recliner. Or, if she's stubborn enough, she'll use the old one and complain bitterly to you about how uncomfortable she is. Constantly.

These are the situations that cause the caregivers to stop loving the elders "to pieces" and having the resentments set in along with the frustrations. Because it's nearly impossible to teach an old dawg new tricks. If her ortho, internist and financial planner were unable to convince her to part with a few bucks, how can YOU convince her???

If her POA has access to the credit card or to writing checks, then that person can make the decision to purchase a new recliner for MIL, as I did with my parents. They had no idea the cost of their deluxe $1800 apiece zero gravity recliners 😁

You may have to wait until MIL becomes a bit less independent to make such a purchase, however 😑. Or buy her one yourselves.

Good luck!
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

I ordered My Dad a new recliner from Macys Over the holidays and saved $300 . Just say " Mom lets get you a Christmas present "
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

“My mother-in-love is 84, lives on her own, and is 100% capable of making her own decisions.”

Her “stubborn” attitude is a sign that she is not “100% capable of making her own decisions.” At least not good ones. When we deliberately and repeatedly choose to make decisions that cause us further problems, that’s a symptom of something.

Time to see the forest, not the trees. It’s time for a mental evaluation.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

We went through this exact thing when we downsized my FIL into assisted living. I found a beautiful recliner with remote control, the kind that elevated up and down to help him stand up and sit down. A button for more or less lumbar support. It was awesome and it was only $800 and it was in stock. Hubby and I were going to make it a gift.

Our big mistake was taking FIL to the furniture store to try it. We figured since he was the one who was going to be sitting in it, he should try it. He kept saying "I don't need this! I don't need this!" When I asked him if he was comfortable he said "Oh yes, but I don't need this! It's too big!" After an hour, I looked at my husband and said "Let's go. He wants a plain chair then he can buy himself a plain chair."

Well, my FIL can't buy himself anything anymore because he gets confused, perseverates, and cannot make a decision. My husband bought him a plain wingback chair. And two weeks later FIL went to sit in it, pulled it over, and landed on the floor. But by this point, I wasn't going back to the furniture store for that awesome recliner. Instead, my husband found a remote-controlled recliner for $500 on Amazon and had it delivered. It also lifts up and down but it's not nearly as plush as the one we wanted to gift him.

Moral of the story: Just gift her a recliner!
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Just an irritatingly annoying old person who has obviously outlived her purpose in life. Unfortunately this will probably be the least annoying thing they will have to deal with as the years go by.

If OP could afford to buy this wealthy elder a chair I am sure they would have done it already.

I can bet if they do decide to gift her a chair that said ekder will still complain.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

My FIL was pretty tight with his money.

And he too had a really ratty recliner that he didn't have the strength to make 'recline'.

We simply bought one with electric controls, took it to his house and set it up for him AND removed the old recliner.

He loved it and that's where he slept for the last few months of his life.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

La Z Boy
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Come over to help "clean" whilst moving the recliner...oops it broke.
(I think most recliners you can remove the back..do that and say it "just fell apart")
then go shopping for a new one.
Other solution is to just break down and get her one. You can find some of the lift chairs on FB marketplace. I would not buy a used one if it was fabric though. If you can't find a reasonable Lift Chair then a recliner with push button recline.

Tell her that the "doctor ordered it" and there is a good possibility that if it is a "medical necessity" it might be deductible as such.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
waytomisery Nov 15, 2023
I love the “ cleaning accidents” .
I did that when my mother would give me things she didn’t want anymore but insisted I take things I didn’t want . 😬🙄
She thought everyone would be happy to have her discards .
(0)
Report
Remove the recliner and have her sit on the floor like elders in Japan.

They live longer so they must be doing something right.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

"She is capable of making her own decisions" you say.
Good. I would allow her to do so.
Now it might be lovely to take her to lunch and stop at the recliner store in the mall telling her you are looking into one for YOURSELF.
Fun outing.

Like many of the elderly who stinted and saved a lifetime, it's merely a habit she's formed. I am 81. I still hesitate to buy these things meant to last a lifetime, because, you know, I don't HAVE a lifetime to live. We get a bit odd in our ways. I WILL however say that I got a relax the back chair and it's the best money I ever spent in my life. Old nurse's back, and wow, does this ever help!
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Maybe suggest she buy one when there is a good sale and keep your eye out . With holidays coming there should be a sale at some point before or after. I like Alvas idea too , taking her with you to “ shop for you” , ask her to try them to give her opinion. Maybe if you take her during a sale you can end up persuading her.
But if she’s still competent you can’t force her to buy one .
If you discover the cure for elderly stubbornness you will be rich and can buy many recliners .
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter