Follow
Share

My family home and my mother live in PA. My brother and oldest sister live nearby. My Sister is a retired RN and has POA. I live in Florida along with 3 other siblings. My sister recently institutionalized my mother in a long-term care facility without the consent of her three younger siblings (two of which have expressed interest in having our mother live with us). Even two grandchildren that are extremely close with my mother showed interest in caring for their grandmother.

Find Care & Housing
Yes, POA gives her that authority. She does not need your permission. Mom really needs to stay close to the POA. Grandchildren should not take care of grandparents. They are young and should be planning their future and getting jobs to secure their future. Not caring for a grandparent.
Helpful Answer (12)
Reply to JoAnn29
Report
BTHOM0927 Jun 13, 2025
Jo Ann, I thought this forum was monitored by professionals that can provide factual information from law not someone's opinion. You know the saying opinions are like ----and everyone has one. If you don't know facts then keep your opinion to yourself. My nieces are in their 50's and are successful, I am 60 and well off. Caring for my mother and ensuring my mother is surrounded with love and compassion in her remaining days seems much better than being in a facility with strangers that views each resident as a source of revenue. I am seeking information on what are my legal options and if I have a legal right to pull her out of the facility so I may care for her.
(0)
Report
See 5 more replies
Generally speaking - yes. The POA does not need anyone else's permission/consent to place the principal. Provided the POA is invoked, and your mother is incapacitated/incompetent with decision making - your sister is her legal advocate and responsible for making decisions that she feels are in your mother's best interest.

If others disagree with the decision - I feel certain that consulting an elder care attorney and understanding if you have any legal rights in this situation may be your only option.

You've stated that there are multiple family members who wish to provide care for your mother. You have to understand that you would have no legal right to consent to anything for your mother if you were to take her in. If she is incompetent to make her own decisions, she cannot legally change the POA at this point. And even if she lived with one of you, your sister would still have all legal rights and responsibilities to make decisions for your mother.

And in that case - decisions that you would wish to make for your mother would require your sister's consent to do so.

Additionally - while you wish to have your mother come live with you - have you considered what that move could do to your mother? We were advised when my FIL declined that each move was essentially a reset for him when he was going from home to hospital to rehab and back home. Basically it served to confuse him and cause more and more agitation. And that was all local. A move like that could be very detrimental for your mother if she is incapacitated. And again, you would need the POA's permission to move her I believe.

I urge you to talk to your sister and understand WHY she felt it was necessary to move your mother to a long term care facility. The use of the word "institutionalized" is very telling of your opinion about long term care. And while you have a right to your opinion, you live a long way away from your mother and may not be fully aware of the day to day issues that are occurring. You may not understand why she made the decision and it is critical that you understand the realities before you pursue this any further.

Best of luck.
Helpful Answer (9)
Reply to BlueEyedGirl94
Report

BTH, Yes, the POA has ALL the authority that was given them, in this case by your mom. They do not and are not at liberty to share personal information with anyone, it is a legal fiduciary position and is governed by the law. She didn't need your consent or to even tell you.

To battle this you will need an attorney that will go for guardianship and have someone willing to accept the responsibility. And since you are in different states, that means multiple attorneys or one that is licensed in both states. If you lose, you will be subject to paying everyone's court costs.

Sorry, I just can't imagine how hard this has been on the POA sister, she was present for mom and you all were off in other states living your lives. So you know, I have never seen anyone that wasn't wracked with pain over having to make the decision to place a parent in a facility. Now she gets to deal with this, truly unfortunate that you all weren't more present to see how mom was doing or to bare some of the boots on the ground caregiving. I know that you can not just place someone, there must be a reason, what are they really?
Helpful Answer (10)
Reply to Isthisrealyreal
Report

Who was taking care of your mom when she lived at home? Most people don’t place anyone in a NH unless they need care they can’t get or aren’t getting at home.

Your POA sister has the right and the responsibility to see that your mom gets the care she needs. She doesn’t need anyone’s consent to do what she feels is necessary.

I hope the family makes time to visit their mom and GM and to check on the POA sister. A person in facility care still needs family.

edit:
I just saw your reaction to a post below. Believe it or not, we nonprofessionals know more about the pain you are all feeling (and that includes your POA sister) than you can imagine and we have the scars to prove it.

Take some responsibility here.

Your mom might not be in care if you and her GDs had been paying attention to her life. How could you possibly not know?

You asked did POA have the right. Yes is the answer.

If you had led with “ I am seeking information on what are my legal options and if I have a legal right to pull her out of the facility so I may care for her” you wouldn’t have needed to get your bowels in an uproar and blast people who are trying to help you.
Helpful Answer (8)
Reply to 97yroldmom
Report

POA made decisions in the best interest of your mother, which she was legally entitled to do.

Have you ever given care before? It sounds like you have exactly zero understanding of what it takes to provide in home care.

Are you planning 24/7 care? It takes 3 adults to care for one adult.

Her grandchildren have NO IDEA what is coming for them. People say things all of the time but after a week, you will be looking for help close to home because it’s too much. Reality will slap them hard in the face.

None of you are trained caregivers. The one of you who was chose to put your mother in a home because it’s that hard.

You sure are letting “expressed interest” do the heavy lifting here. You don’t have the support you think you have with everyone who expressed interest….
Helpful Answer (7)
Reply to Bulldog54321
Report

BTH, I'm confused: Did you think you would get free legal advice here?

Anyway, I'm curious how often you and your sister who "expressed interest and desire" to have you mom live with you traveled to PA to visit Mom in recent years? And when in PA, what did you do there?

And the same for the grandkids. How often did they visit, and if they did visit, were they hands-on helping to care for Grandma?

I'm not being judgmental. It's just that the folks out of state typically don't realize what it's like being the actual caregiver day in and day out.

Finally, there's a reason why your mom picked eldest daughter--who lives nearby and is a retired RN--to be POA. And there's a reason why the POA made this decision in your mom's best interest.
Helpful Answer (11)
Reply to JRwornout
Report
Bulldog54321 Jun 13, 2025
I sort of feel like if OP can’t figure out that this isn’t a free legal advice board then how is she at age 60 going to take care of her mother?

And yes, here they are at the very beginning and she is taking to heart that her other family members are interested when in reality we all know that when they start off with lukewarm interest, it quickly ends up as no shows.

So basically it’s mom ends up staying where she is or mom gets moved to her detriment only to end up in a nursing home in Florida.

I wonder how much an ambulance ride is from PA to Florida? I’m guessing mom isn’t getting on a plane.
(9)
Report
See 2 more replies
One more poster who gets angry when they don't get the responses they were expecting.
Helpful Answer (8)
Reply to lkdrymom
Report
Bulldog54321 Jun 13, 2025
Exactly, and you know there is nothing holding back the “well off” OP from flying to PA for a month to provide hands on care for her mother. That is step #1. Go up there, roll sleeves up and change diapers and wipe poop off everything.

OP should go see what has been going on up there while she was thousands of miles away living her life and getting to do whatever she wanted whenever she wanted to do it. Living for herself while her retired RN sister was slaving over a mother whose brain is dying….. her sister is in a no win situation but finally had to call time out so that she didn’t become one of the many caregivers who die before the person they are providing care for. One of the MANY who are now statistics.

OP’s mother wanted that RN daughter to be POA. Not OP. I’m guessing mom knew OP would cause trouble. I’m of course inferring things based on the word choices OP used and all the things we have seen here.
(8)
Report
See 4 more replies
BTHOM0927,

This forum is made up of caregivers with varying levels of expertise. We provide support for one another, and give advice based on our own experiences to others who are newly going through the same.
There may be some members with legal expertise.
If you are seeking legal advice, it would be best for you to contact a lawyer directly.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to CaringWifeAZ
Report

As others have said, the short answer is "yes." Neither your sister nor your mother needs anyone else's consent for your mother to reside in the long-term care facility. Given that you mentioned "revenue" (from your mother to the facility), I wonder whether you have concerns about who is paying for the facility. When my mom moved into an assisted-living facility a few years ago, my siblings and I agreed that we are comfortable with her money going to the facility rather than to us (as part of the estate when she dies).
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to Rosered6
Report

Yes, the POA is the decider. Apparently this offer of care was made by the other siblings and offered? And the POA, who is an RN, believes that the best interests of your mother is to be in good 24/7 care with several shifts of workers with several working on all shifts. To tell the truth I am in agreement with her.

Cooperation, visits, and best supporting wishes are the best way forward. This is the sister who has BEEN THERE for mom and who has done the care, and who was chosen to make these decisions. She has made them and need not discuss them with anyone else if mom is no longer competent to make her OWN decisions. The best thing for your mom's end of life comfort is you all agreeing on her care and supporting it.
Helpful Answer (12)
Reply to AlvaDeer
Report

Hey, fly up to see your mother in the facility once a month. Give your POA sister a week off every month. You handle all the details, the phone calls, the supplies shopping, the visits, and entertainment of mother. POA sis is free for a week or more every month. She can count on you, right? Maybe another of the siblings in Florida can come up for a second week. No, not to change anything. No, just show up and do what POA sis is doing every day and you can’t change anything. Maybe what mom wants to drink, which entrance you wheel her to, what view she sees, what conversation only you can talk with her about. Don’t disrupt what your POA sister has put in place. It’s likely there for a reason. Look for ways you can lighten sister’s load and keep the train of your mother’s care moving ever slowly, forward. Just walk every day in the shoes of your POA sister. Try really hard to convince her, POA sister, that you and your other siblings in Florida can help take care of your mother by your actions , not words. By being there and shouldering the load that elder caregiving is. Just shut up and show up and do what she tells you to do. You will learn a ton. Good luck. Carry the load she has. Don’t give opinions, just do what she asks. You may get further with your agenda. Your opinions come later, once you’ve demonstrated through your actions you are able and willing to be a help to your sister and your mother.
Helpful Answer (9)
Reply to Beethoven13
Report
AlvaDeer Jun 15, 2025
Amen, Beethoven.
(0)
Report
“Caring for my mother and ensuring my mother is surrounded with love and compassion in her remaining days seems much better than being in a facility with strangers that views each resident as a source of revenue.”

My beloved husband is in a memory care facility, and it’s nothing like that. From the directors to the aides and the handyman, they are focused on the residents. They hug them when they need it. They call them affectionate nicknames. They bring them special treats; in my husband’s case, it is root beer floats. Today his hospice nurse dropped in for a visit even though it’s her vacation. I visit almost every day. A resident’s wife is there most days and brings their dog to see her husband.

My husband is my fourth family member with dementia. I provided hands-on care at home for the first three, who were my parents and another relative. That was 5 years of my life.

I wish you well in being able to take care of your mom. Please get back to us soon and let us know how it’s going.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to Fawnby
Report
AlvaDeer Jun 15, 2025
BTOHM has a dire take on care facilities. I have often written here about the stellar care my brother got at Pacifica Senior Living in Palm Springs. Were they there for revenue? Yes, they were a business. But each and every person there was so kind, the care so meticulous and so loving. WONDERFUL care. This OP is assuming that she and family can become a well oiled machine that a care facility with several shifts with many workers on each cleaning, helping, directing, even walking the DOG. I have seldom seen families taking this on without the end result being bickering about who did most, and who is best, and whose opinion is the right one. It is often a fray, with with this OP in it I guarantee the outcome. Perhaps she should stick around on the Forum and read a while, and get what is going on in people's lives firsthand. She will find that perfection in elder care is hard to find, and difficult to maintain. It's not a happy time. And families are not required to MAKE it a happy time, and in fact canNOT make it so.
(1)
Report
Thank you everyone for backing me up. It made my day.
Helpful Answer (12)
Reply to JoAnn29
Report
Bulldog54321 Jun 14, 2025
OP was rude and out of line
(3)
Report
See 1 more reply
To answer your question, the answer is a qualified "yes": if the PoA is actually active, or if the PoA is durable and the principal is not making decisions in their own best interests. The active PoA does not legally need to get consensus from anyone who isn't your Mom's PoA. That being said, if the medical PoA is a different person than the financial PoA, there can be snags if they don't agree upon the care plan. The disclaimer is of course that things may differ by state or if the principal added something different into their document. The PoAs need to read the document to see what activates the authority. If your Mom is competent then no one can make decisions for her. Please understand that the responders here have actually gone through what you currently think is a good idea. Sometimes it is, and many times it is not. When it is not is when loving, well-meaning family members get into the weeds. In-home care for her: a lot will depend on how sick your Mom is now and what her medical needs are, and what will transpire in the future, which no one knows. A lot of nuance and context gets lost or misinterpreted on this forum. It even happens amongst us long-time responders. What each participant has gone through is a fact for their situation, but not for other situations. Too many variables. I wish you and your family clarity, wisdom and peace in your hearts as you work through appropriate care for your Mom.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Geaton777
Report

My,my. You can thank your sister for the bullet she just saved you from! Although your intentions are good, care-giving is a very difficult job. Just making sure the right amount of prescriptions is administered can be difficult, even life threatening. Watching them wither away drains everything out of you. I wasn't so lucky to have my father placed, I cried when I heard the "death rattle" and no way to leave his side. He died with his eyes open and not symmetrically balanced. Is this what you want? You want to remember the good things and not what you went through at the end. Sister just saved all the good times for you, I know it hurt her more than it does you. You hold onto being family, caregiver doesn't have that privilege. Sister had to take the role of being the mother, she's not her daughter anymore. You should be proud of her!
Helpful Answer (7)
Reply to JuliaH
Report

Wow, what an interesting thread! So much good advice, hope the OP gets it.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to GSDlover
Report

The answers didn’t go her way so OP never came back, right?
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to JRwornout
Report

Dear BTHOM0927,
It's September already and I'm not sure you want to hear more. You speak from your heart that you care about your mother but live a distance from her. This is hard for you. (I'm also in that position.)

To be honest there is no easy solution. Each situation is different.

I do have some questions: Is the POA your sister has eliminate your mother to be involved in the decisions? The POA is responsible to the one cared for regarding their desires. (Of course in my Mom's case our brother was able to disqualify her from decision making her own decisions due to short term dementia.)

The bigger issue here is IFS (internal Family System). The 5 of you siblings are born in a certain birth order. Each one has their own strengths and weaknesses along with personality type. Looking back in your family system how was the communication between you siblings like? (With my brother he is angry about his growing up years and won't talk to me though he is the caregiver for our 101 year old mother.)

Apparently your common ground is your mother but is there anything that your siblings and you have in common? How has the communications between you all over the years?

I don't know if it would be possible to find a geriatric manager or someone from the nursing home so that he/she can mediate a conversation between the five of you siblings?

Remember your sister cares for your mother too. It is important that you treat your sister with kindness and understanding. (My personal challenge is that my brother is not kind to me but I refuse to deal with him in a nasty way.)

Maybe you have made some progress by now and some things are better. I do hope so. It's hard to be caught in a difficult situation but how you and I choose to deal with others who disagree strongly with us in a loving way is more important. Take care of yourself.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to JuliaRLE
Report

Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter