Follow
Share

Hi, Im new. Youngest of 3 siblings. All male. My mom has ...rapidly progressing Parkinson's like full blown just about every symptom from the textbook. I am a recently graduated doctor...so everyone at home looks to ME for the answers.


But, I don't have all the answer. I only have limited experience so far.


I am also engaged, and I often feel like caring for my Mom ....evelopes everything else, even my relationship with my fiancee.


I often end up arguing with my family, because they expect me to be at Mom's side 24/7 just bcuz I am a doctor....as if I have no personal life of my own.


Can anyone else relate? Any other guys out there caught between keeping your wife happy and an increasingly weakened needy mother ?

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
I moved out for some time out. Was in medical practice. Cared for 27 years and worked - last 16 was when it got really tough. It’s possible but hard if siblings opt out / use excuses. Partner understanding (for the most part though got frustrated at rest of my family at times.)

Sibling took remaining parent for 3 days over Christmas for 3 years till they weren’t able to manage the stairs.

But yeah, on call 24/7 re parents and an average day was up 0530 - finish work around 1700 -1800 care till 2300 go home do reports etc bed at 0130 - up at 0530 again... if not alerted earlier that there was an issue with a parent. ...
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Thanks for all the responses... many of them quite frank and candid. Hmm....yea I guess as the last sibling I still see my older brothers as "always right" so whenever I tell them no, I feel guilty about it.....sigh.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
TXGirl82 Sep 2019
I'm sorry you feel guilty, and I hope I wasn't *too* frank or candid. Families can be hard on each other.

I was thinking about you last night. If your siblings become willing to work together to coordinate your mom's care, it would be so awesome for your mom to have a doctor in the bunch. I mean this for down the road, with you living your life and pursuing your career and such. I'm not chiming in with your siblings to say, "But you're a doctor!"

Here in the US, anyway, a physician will often speak more easily with a family member who is also a physician, sort of a "professional courtesy". I have known several people with close relatives who are doctors that have had this happen, and I have an elderly friend whose doctor will personally call her son -- he lives hundreds of miles away -- to fill him in on her care. It' quite a perk!
(1)
Report
A good friend of mine (man) cared for his mom for 3 years with the help of one home care person (also a man). He did fine, but he did not have another job. My son helped me care for my mom for 4 months out of the 7 years I took on. He was really too young to do it long term. There is no difference whether man or woman. Care giving is difficult, especially when it is for family. You most certainly cannot do it alone. Find home care for her that you can oversee and visit her often to make sure all is going as well as possible. And live your life.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

I took care of my mom, very short stint, 6 months, easy compared to a lot here, and it tore me up. It didn't help that my father pretty much gave up after it. I went through 2+ years of grief, trying to get him to start living, he is, finally, and PTSD, because, well, I worked for a control-freak boss, who, thankfully, is no longer my boss. If anyone's ever dealt with that, really dealt with that, they know it's a form of near constant violation.

Note, it's been 2+ years since she passed.

Trying to take this on yourself, and a career, is a form of suicide. The rest of the family needs to get involved or you need paid caregivers. Despite what doctor's think, they aren't experts in everything, and most of the decisions you make in this process aren't medical, per se, they are logistical, financial, caring, etc. You have some extra experience because you are in the system but that doesn't justify you taking on all of the work.

Good luck with it.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Exvee,

Im a 65 year old man. Went through caring long distance for parents with no sibs, no help.

whether you’re a man or woman has little to do with the challenges of elder caregiving. It most often falls to the women in the family.

I don’t have an easy answer for you. You mom will get worse through the years. You have no choice but to stand up to your sibs and demand your life. She needs paid caregivers in her home or placed in a facility.

There is is no shame in this. No one, male or female should ever be forced or guilt tripped into giving up a marriage, career and life for caregiving.
Helpful Answer (11)
Report

What does your mom have to say about this arrangement? Just curious.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Your fiancee wants to be assured that she is number 1 in your life. Loosing her will only be your fault, not the fault of your siblings. Does your mother have any money or qualify for Medicaid to set her up in some sort of facility like assisted living, etc. Her condition may plateau, but it is not going to get better, only worse. You probably don't want to hear this but you must decide emotionally who you want to be married to? Some men are emotionally married to their moms and thus can't get married. Don't let that be you. Oh, the same goes true of some women also like my wife before she got her freedom.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

I think the "rules" should be the same for women and men and for wives, husbands, and unmarried folks. And if I were making the rules, they'd include the following: 1) A person with a disability or an illness should receive care from paid caregivers, if possible. 2) No one should be a caregiver 24/7. 3) Family caregivers who are in relationships should prioritize their partners and children, not the people to whom they're providing care. 4) Every available family member should contribute to caregiving, with time and hands-on care, money, decision-making, and supporting the other caregivers.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

So...... "If the wife is caring for her mother" the husband should just accept it and be strong and supportive
but if
husband is caring for his mother, then he is failure as a husband ?" Why are the rules different if it's the man who has the sick parent ? I really wish there were some men here to tell give me some advice on how to balance this.

Sigh...in any case I have made the small step of moving out of my parents' house. I still visit very often, but I make it a point of duty to not spend the night.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
TXGirl82 Aug 2019
I would never say a husband who is caring for his mother is a failure as a husband. Man or woman, a person who is caring, hands-on for a parent without help, will eventually have a hard time simply surviving, much less maintaining healthy relationships with others. There are only so many hours in a day.

Btw, I believe adult children should care for their parents if possible, but I think that "care" can mean involvement in making sure their parents are cared for by someone, somewhere safe. Even that doesn't always work, as some elderly parents won't cooperate.

How can there be anything wrong with refusing to run yourself into the ground in order to provide round-the-clock, hands-on care to a parent? Steeling yourself to stand up to your siblings is the first step in finding a better long-term solution.

From reading your responses, it seems to me that you don't quite believe you have the right to say no to your siblings.
(0)
Report
See 2 more replies
How can you do the work of "being at my Mom's side 24/7" and do the work of "being a doctor?" Doctors often work very long hours. Who is with your Mom when you are not?
To be frank, I would not marry a man who was taking care of his mother in his home. While I might thing that love can overcome all, I do know that one the blush is off the rose it would be me sitting at home while my doctor husband was off being a doctor, certainly at least one half of the time.
I don't consider it worth argument. I would simply say that I was sorry, but I intended to have a life now, that I was a newly graduated doctor and would be hard at work developing my practice,that I was marrying, and my wife didn't sign up for me and Mom but for me.
I would hope that Mom would have excellent placement in care and visits by the entire family. But no one in the family is required by obligation, by job,by guilt or by anything else to do hands on care. Mom may well and easily live at least another 20 years, just as NY DaughterInLaw says. During that time, you and your wife may actually raise several children. That will be plenty to do right there.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Please, don't become your mother's caregiver. My ex-husband became his parents' full-time caregiver several years ago. His siblings were happy to have him do so. Why wouldn't they be? This "job" was a major factor in the destruction of my marriage. I think that a person's spouse and children should be the person's top priority. My ex made his parents his top priority and was encouraged to do so by his dad (his mom has Alzheimer's disease and didn't know what was going on) and his siblings.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
Exveemon Aug 2019
Yep. I know they would only be to happy to leave me as caregiver. I remember once I spent an entire weekend with my fiancee...I didn't call home ahead of time...and it was this big argument amongst us...and I was like ...WTF...I'm always shifting MY schedule for Mum's sake...was it so impossible for them to take care of Mum for one measly weekend ?
(2)
Report
Your mother is only 69. She may well live another 20 years with Parkinson's if she is committed to doing the hard work of living with the disease i.e. daily exercise, medication management, good nutrition, positive outlook, etc. Do you want to live your life around your mother for 20 years?

"I often end up arguing with my family, because they expect me to be at Mom's side 24/7..." It does not matter one bit that you are a doctor. Expecting anyone to be a caregiver is wrong. That is a very personal decision - for a man or a woman - and only you can make it.

Your mother's needs will only increase. You may not get to practice medicine, you may lose your fiance, and you may bankrupt your own future if you succumb to the fear, obligation and guilt that is being thrown at you by your siblings, who already have their lives, now don't they?
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
AlvaDeer Aug 2019
I know I am not what the writer is asking for, as he wondered if there are other men on the site. The few men I have seen on the site seem to be the caregivers of their own spouse, but there certainly are some. Whether man or woman I would absolutely agree with NYDaughterInLaw. You may absolutely lose your own life in caring for another for the next 20 years. If this is not the position you wish to hold I would not continue in it.
(6)
Report
@Exceemon "if I lose my fiancee whilst caring for my mum....I don't think I could ever forgive my sibblings."

(Gently) Why could you not ever forgive them? You are allowing their expectations to rule your life.

There is a huge amount of emotional stuff surrounding dealing with family -- even during easy times. This is not an easy time.

What kind of positive answer are you seeking?
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
AlvaDeer Aug 2019
I so agree. The choice is not in the hands of the sibling. It is in the hands of EdVee.
(2)
Report
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter