I will try and make this within the space limitations. Sister lived with mother all of her life. They had a good set up for many years. Mother paid for a place to live, groceries, utilities, etc. Sister provided transportation and some of the general household expenses. No doubt that mother had more than she would have had if sister had not been there. Sister raised her two children in this household.
Through the years the other children couldn't "go to grandmother's house" because it was also sister's house and she had her children there so it made it difficult for the rest of us.
Father was alcoholic and abused all children both physically, emotionally and sexually. Finally when me and sister were grown we had him thrown out and they got a divorce.
All went fairly well until about 10-15 years ago when mother reached her 80's and wasn't able to help out very much. Sister really began to complain. They rented the same house for over 50 years and it was small and crowded and add to that the fact mother was a horder.
Husband and I bought house next door to us, remodeled it, mother and sister moved in with understanding sister would get loan after 3 yrs. and buy house. We were not going to charge her anything only that she get a loan for the same amount we had on the house. At the end of 3 yrs. had to force her to get the loan. Then she became responsible for upkeep of house, payments etc. etc.
We helped in everyway we possibly could except for moving in with them but the complaining never stopped from my sister. It was always I can't do this, I can't do that, blah blah blah.
Then mother fell and broke hip and from that day forward really couldn't do anything. THen my sister really got angry. I tried everything I knew to do. I took meals to them, cleaned their house, bathed mother, did her hair every week, worked out a system with other sibs and sister's children to take turns at night, was always available if my sister wanted to go anywhere. Nothing helped.
I realize now that she was getting burn out but so was I - only not from mother but from dealing with her. Sister would never directly tell mother that any thing was wrong - she would make smart and hateful remarks to mother.
Then mother started having falls. She fell 8 times in 6 months. When she fell my sister would not call 911 - she said "mother won't let me". The morning mother fell into the bathtub at 4:30 a.m. my sister finally called me at 6:30. I called 911.
My sister quit taking vacatons, quit taking time to go to her children's houses and basically just worked and went home. Even though I tried to get her to go with me to my house in FL like we had always done in the past she said she couldn't. I even worked out for our children and my husband to take care of mother if she went on vacation with me but she said they couldn't do it. These children are all in their late 30's to early 40's I felt like they were capable adults.
Anyway, in Dec. 2010 mother had an episode of not being able to stand up, not being able to control her bladder. It had been going on all night and my sister finally called me at 5:30 a.m. Again, I called 911 and this time insisted she be taken to an emergency room. As we were leaving the house mother said "I'll never get to come home again". That was true because when we got to the hospital I begged the doctor to request nursing home placement for her.
To shorten the story it worked and mother was placed in a very good local nursing home and has been there for 1 1/2 yrs. Do you think this has helped my sister - NO. She still blames all of her troubles on mother. Constantly complains about mother and relives our childhood of how she had to do everything starting when she was 5 yrs. old. I know she had a hard life but I grew up in the same house and experienced everything she did. Mother was not mean or anything she just wasn't a loving person. She always put her needs above ours.
After mother went into the nursing home I visited her on Sunday afternoons and picked up her laundry. The following Sunday when I visited again I would take her laundry back. After about 3-4 months I started taking mother out on Sunday afternoons and then started bringing her to my house. My sister volunteered and asked that mother come to her house every other Sunday, then she insisted she do mother's laundry. (I need to insert that my husband is a double transplant patient and is disabled.) Except for complaining by my sister all went well until 2 weeks ago. My sister got mad at me, said she was tired of mother taking up her weekends and it had to stop. I said ok, give me two weeks and then I can take care of that. We ended up having a shouting match in which she said it was all my fault and that I never did anything to help her with mother.

All I want to do is leave town - that is not an option at least until next year when I can retire.

Any suggestions I'll take into consideration.

This discussion has been closed for comment. Start a New Discussion.
Find Care & Housing
What great advice you have been given. Trust me these two know what there talking about & I have been seeig things different because of them See I was about to screw up my life & become your sister. I am fulltime caregiver of MIL brought her to my house & I took on that responsibility but, YOU can get bitter when no one is there at ten or midnight and 2 a.m. You have to blame someone My SIL stood in a NH 7 months ago on MIL release date telling Nurisng home staff WE TAKE CARE OF OUR OWN! Im thinking get me & MIL out of here where my hubby was waiting What if we need them What if this doesnt work.????? Well Sounds like I would do anything if I had you in place of that SIL today because she can no longer do this blah blah she still does checking bill paying of corse still joint POA with Hubby. But Im hiring help Ive took advice from here Made dailey scedule easier Have to put myself first & kids. I know your sister needs to talk to someone Its NOT YOUR fault Sounds to me like you both have really had it rough . Love Idea about letter writing & Leaving everyone else out!!!!
My Mother was a big letter writer & left us 3 girls a box of letters she had written to us over the 3 years she was suffering with terminal cancer they are so dear to me days Ive had a bad day I use to journal so Im starting that again as a dailey journal about caregiving MIL instead of venting what all i did or what someone didnt do so I can fix it. Your sister needs to wake up but sounds like she might not listen to you write the letter from heart and just see what happens good luck get her on here these ladys will help her see we could say things to her you cant. sounds like she has alot to let go.GOOD LUck Keep us posted...

1234: I think Jeanne hit the nail on the head. I want to offer one more thing. Do you think you can talk to your sis and let her know how much you love her. Leave your mom out of it and tell your sis you want to communicate about just the two of you. Tell her you are going to write her a letter and you want her to write you back. See if you can agree to talk about how you each feel without talking about mom's care. Stay with how each of you see yourselves in your lives. No kids, no husbands, no mom, maybe even no dad. Just what are the feelings inside. That's hard to do, but it makes you take stock of who you are, while not being allowed to blame. Give it a try. Doesn't have to be perfect, just a new way to communicate. Good luck, Cattails.

Let's go back to childhood a moment ... Father was emotionally, physically, and sexually abusive. Mother did nothing to prevent this and protect her children. Children had to basically run the household. When her children were old enough they stepped in to protect Mother.

Sister has been very helpful to Mother over the years. But she is something of a martyr and perhaps a little emotionally unstable. Surely none of this is surprising. Has Sister ever had counseling to deal with the childhood trauma?

You have been helpful to Mother and to Sister. Sister thinks the bad stuff in her life is Mother's fault or your fault. Does she ever consider it might be Father's fault? Or no one's fault? Or her own responsibility? Again, has she ever tried therapy?

You grew up in the same house, but you did not have the experience as your sister. You each had your internal coping mechanisms and ways to protect yourselves. If you came out of the experience more stable and with more of your personality intact than your sister did I am very glad for you.

If your sister has seen herself as the Caregiver since she was five, and now Mother is in a place where someone else is taking care of her, what is Sister to do with her life? Work and come home and do nothing? Stop taking vacations? Maybe. Because if she is not the martyred caregiver, who is she? And if she's off having fun and living her own life, how can she be the martyr? I really think some counseling, perhaps even some family counseling that would include you, might be what she needs most.

After what you've been through, both of you sisters deserve to live happy, meaningful lives, and to have the comfort of a deep and caring relationship with each other. Mother will be gone in a few years, but you'll have each other for a good many years. I'm not sure what would make that possible, but I think family therapy might be a good place to start.

Best wishes to your mother, but especially to you and to your sister.

Start a Discussion
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter