Power of Attorney Nightmare Has 91-Year-Old Man Facing Eviction by His Daughter


When John Potter built his house in 1957, he never dreamed that nearly six decades later, someone would be trying to kick him out of it.

Yet that is the situation the 91-year-old widower is facing as his daughter, Janice Cottrill, is aiming to evict him, after having secretly transferred the deed to the property to herself during a brief tenure as her parents' power of attorney (POA).

The Potters appointed Janice, their only daughter, as their POA back in 2004.

One of the couple's primary concerns was that their elderly son, who suffers from autism, would be properly taken care of, in the event that they themselves could no longer do so. It wasn't until 2010 that the Potter's learned of their daughter's clandestine real estate transaction.

They promptly switched POA to their granddaughter, Jaclyn Fraley, Janice's daughter, who is now helping her grandfather fight to remain in his home.

John won his initial suit to get his house back from Janice, but the ruling was later overturned in appeals, due to the statute of limitations that applied to undoing the property transfer.

After a few failed attempts to declare her father legally incompetent and sent to a nursing home, Janice served him with a notice that terminated his lease in February 2013, with a formal eviction hearing to be held on June 12th.

Faced with few options for keeping her grandfather in his home, Jaclyn made an unusual move—she turned to "crowdfunding," a form of online fundraising that allows individuals and organizations to ask for monetary donations to pay for everything from healthcare expenses, to art projects. (Learn more about how crowdfunding can help caregivers raise money.)

According to the profile Jaclyn set up on GoFundMe, a popular crowdfunding site, Janice plans to sell the house that John currently lives in.

"The efforts of the family to convince Janice to allow John to live out his life in his home have failed," Fraley writes, "Janice states she needs the money, so the old man must go."

Jaclyn's campaign, "A Plea to Save Grandpa's House," has raised enough money to buy John's house back from Janice. The profile's goal was to raise $125,000. In less than a month, over $137,000 has been donated by the public. Jaclyn says that all of the additional funds will go to help pay for her grandfather's care needs.

Here's a video about John and his fight to stay in the house he built with his bare hands:

Being granted POA allows a person (usually a trusted friend of family member) to make legal, medical and financial decisions on behalf of an elder. It is widely considered advisable for aging adults to appoint a POA before their health begins to decline.

However, the issues surrounding POAs are complex and can thus be easily misunderstood, or exploited.

In the above situation, Janice initially used her POA to "gift" her parents' house to herself—a move that the court eventually deemed illegal, given the specifications of the document that granted her authority to make decisions based on her parents' behalf. However, since the statute of limitations for John to refute his daughter's claim on the property had already passed, Potter was unable to reclaim the deed to his house.

Gifts of property, assets and money are sometimes allowed in POA arrangements, if spelled out in the document ahead of time. And, there are a variety of protections that can be built in to an agreement, to protect an elder from potential abuse by their appointed POA.

An alternative to a designating a financial POA is for person to place their assets in a trust and appoint an individual (known as the "trustee") to manage those assets. POAs and trustees have similar decision-making authority.

A trust may be a safer alternative for some, since it's easier to hold a trustee liable for the decisions they make on an elder's behalf than it is to hold a POA responsible, according to Buckley Fricker, J.D., G.C.M., a geriatric care manager and president of Buckley's for Seniors, a companion care company for elders. "For anyone who has even the slightest doubt about who they are naming to be ‘in charge,' it is worth at least checking with an elder law attorney to see if a trust would be appropriate in their case," she says.

Trusts allow for very precise language about safeguarding an elder's assets. There are also state-specific laws that strictly regulate trusts, even those with ambiguous language.

In the case of John and his daughter Janice, for example, Fricker says that placing the deed of the house into a trust and then outlining the specific rules governing the handling of the deed might have prevented Janice from illegally seizing her father's house.

There's no one-size-fits-all approach when it comes to planning for an elder's future.

Caregivers tasked with helping an aging loved one make long-term care and end-of-life arrangements may benefit greatly from the input of an elder law attorney. These legal professionals can provide guidance on whether an elder would be better off appointing a trustee, or a POA to manage their assets; as well as a host of other legal issues.

Ultimately, the most important thing is to plan ahead, whenever possible. This means making sure that a loved one (and you, yourself) have prepared the following, must-have legal documents:

  • HIPPA authorization
  • Power of attorney (both medical and financial)
  • Advanced Healthcare directive
  • A Will

Without such safeguards in place, elders and their families could potentially be exposed to unnecessary strife when making important medical and financial decisions. For more information on each of these essential documents, consult our Money and Legal section.

You May Also Like

Free AgingCare Guides

Get the latest care advice and articles delivered to your inbox!


Either way, sounds like a family making money from a scam. It really is a scary world. I imagine Gifting the house to herself saved it from being used to pay for nursing and medical bills also.
GOD will be the Judge, and she will have to answer to him for what she is doing to her father. GOD will also have vengeance. I hope that someday she will have to trust someone and that person does to her what she has done.
My husband and I put our assets into a revocable trust (rather than a simple will). One motivation is to keep our financial issues private as well as allowing everything to pass through without having to go to probate. We also have done the aforementioned documents but I am wondering if this kind of trust is what you are referring to in the article above or something else. We also recently met with a financial planner who suggested that an 'non interested party' rather than a family member is a good idea to administer things, be one's executor, etc. Also, that it is never a good idea to have more than ONE named. And finally when choosing someone, if it must be a family member, be honest with one's self about who would really do what you would want them to do in spite of any pressure from others. So many elderly people just 'want everybody to get along' and all their lives they've known who does and who doesn't, etc. It's hard enough for a stand up son or daughter to weather the storm with other family members who may have their own best interests at heart. But if you want them to do it, write everything down, make sure a lawyer is involved up front and have through planning or you set them up for failure as well as family conflict.