Letting Go of Alzheimer’s


Since my thorough neuropsychological evaluation for cognitive impairment in late August, I've been nervously awaiting the results, which had been delayed in part by the government shutdown, including the National Institutes of Health (NIH).

Last Tuesday, I finally got them: the tests were completely normal; there's no sign of cognitive impairment.

This is, of course, wonderful news and should be a great relief.

I tend, however, to be a glass-half-empty kind of guy, and I don' feel much relieved: I've traded a diagnosis (Alzheimer's disease) for a set of disturbing symptoms with no reasonable explanation.

In case you've been reading these posts only occasionally, let me summarize my situation.

About three years ago I started having symptoms of cognitive impairment (getting lost, inability to perform certain bookkeeping responsibilities, increasingly poor memory, losing things constantly, and so on).

Two years ago I visited a neurologist who administered the usual cognitive testing, which revealed mild impairment. Repeat testing a year later also show a mild degree of impairment. Other major causes of cognitive impairment were ruled out, so I was left with a diagnosis of Mild Cognitive Impairment (MCI), probably Alzheimer's. This blog has been a description of my ongoing experience with this impairment.

As part of research studies that I've participated in, I have had three brain scans over the past eight months, none of which has shown any sign of Alzheimer's disease.

This most recent neuropsychological set of tests at NIH was very intensive and extensive, about four hours in length. Unlike the previous, less thorough tests of cognitive function, this more rigorous evaluation shows no sign of cognitive impairment.

So I now have a set of symptoms that have impaired me for several years but for which I can find no reasonable explanation.

The reason I have avoided making entries in this blog over the past week is that I haven't known what to write; this has so stunned me that I've had to talk it through with family and some friends.

So far, I can't explain it in any reasonable way. Here are some of the thoughts I've had:

Perhaps my previously diagnosed cognitive impairment has resolved and I've gotten better.

Unlikely. My symptoms haven't gone away. Also, any cause of cognitive impairment (of longer than six months) that might improve with time (vitamin B-12 deficiency, for instance) has been medically ruled out. These things just don't get better.

Perhaps all the brain scans and the neuropsychological tests have been wrong.

Unlikely. Any medical test, of course, can be normal even when the disease is present. In the case of the tests I've taken, this "false negative" rate is very roughly 10 percent for each. Mathematically, that means that there is more than a 99.99 percent chance that at least one of the tests would be positive if I had Alzheimer's.

Perhaps it's some other form of cognitive impairment.

Unlikely. Not only have I been thoroughly evaluated to rule out the other reasonable causes, but the intense cognitive testing indicates no sign of impairment for any reason.

Perhaps I'm imagining it.

Always a possibility, but people very close to me have also seen obvious evidence of impairment for several years and no one, including a trained psychologist who knows me well, finds this possibility credible. I don't either.

There are a number of other possibilities I'll explore in later posts, but for now, any explanation I've been able to come up with is highly improbable.

As I written before, all of this can be extremely unsettling. For several days last week, I felt quite unmoored.

I'd come to terms with my identity as an Alzheimer's patient and now it has become, at the very least, uncertain. This life over the past year as an Alzheimer's patient has become very meaningful and fulfilling.

What am I now? What am I going to do?

But after lots of conversation with friends and family, I no longer feel so unmoored. This is but one more twist in a bumpy, uncertain road. I can trust myself and my perceptions. I can simply wait for the next step in this strange journey. I feel ready to let go and see what exciting things will happen.

These test results, whatever they ultimately mean, are good news.

At the very least, the impairment I perceive is progressing very slowly. At the very least, this is another opportunity to learn to live with uncertainty, just as most people with mild cognitive symptoms have to. It's an opportunity to let go of self.

This wild ride continues.

Editor's note: David's journey with Mild Cognitive Impairment was chronicled in "Fade to Blank: Life Inside Alzheimer's" an in-depth look at the real lives of families impacted by the Alzheimer's epidemic. His story continues on his personal blog on AgingCare.com.

An author and former physician, Dr. David Hilfiker was diagnosed in 2012 with a progressive mild cognitive impairment. His doctor thought it was Alzheimer's but additional testing proved this initial diagnosis to be wrong. Now David must learn how to come to terms with the reality of worsening cognitive issues that appear to have no cause.

Visit: Watching the Lights Go Out

View full profile

You May Also Like

Free AgingCare Guides

Get the latest care advice and articles delivered to your inbox!


Some of us docs don't know that certain meds - even thyroid meds - that have been stable for years may become overdoses as their metabolism slows down with age. Something they have tolerated may no longer work well, e.g. Benadryl. Lower doses make sense, and I would not go to any doctor who acts like they don't believe in side effects. I suppose having had to take some meds myself and learning about side effects first hand was a blessing in disguise...
Thank you for sharing this most recent news, I am looking forward to your future posts. Please know that your willingness to share this journey is encouraging to me in many ways.
I mainly want to send you a hug. You are going through a tough time with your good news/bad news.

Are they considering types of dementia that would not necessarily show up in a brain scan? As you probably know, Lewy Body Dementia is often called roller coaster dementia, because the cognitive and behavioral symptoms go up and down without warning. Test results can look better or worse than the patient's overall day-to-day symptoms, depending on whether the test is taken on an "up" day or a "down" day. I sure am not qualified to suggest a diagnosis for you! But I am curious as to whether LBD has been specifically ruled out, and if so, on what basis. I do a little volunteering with caregivers of persons with LBD, and I'm always interested in learning more about how it is diagnosed/ruled out.