Elders Who Abuse Their Family Caregivers

368 Comments

Most of us have seen evidence of people being harder on those they love than they are on strangers, or even people they don’t like. We tend to show our family members every side of ourselves, including the least flattering one because we feel safe enough with them to just “let it all hang out.”

This typically holds true for our care recipients as well. Age and illness bring a host of difficult emotions to the surface for seniors, and caregivers are subject to their anger, fear, frustration and sadness regarding their circumstances. For some, though, there are deeper problems lurking behind an elder’s moodiness and outbursts. These feelings may turn into abusive behavior or exacerbate an already abusive personality.

Why Do Elders Turn on the Caregiver?

I believe that care recipients target the person doing most of the care because they feel safe enough to do so. They are frustrated and need to vent about getting old, having chronic pain, losing friends, forgetting things, being incontinent—all of the undignified things that can happen to us as we age. They turn on the person who shows their love by trying to take care of them because, on a gut level, they trust that this caring person won’t leave them.

In other cases, a caregiver may have been a target of criticism and negativity in the past. If a relationship has been historically abusive, it is likely that this toxic behavior will carry over into caregiving. Mental illness or a personality disorder may be to blame. If other family members have decided that they do not wish to participate in the elder’s care, it complicates things further. There is a great deal of pressure on one primary caregiver to shoulder the burden of care and bad behavior, and coping is an ongoing challenge.

How to Cope with an Abusive Elder

When it comes to handling a loved one’s abuse, clearly, the best option is to remove yourself from the situation. But for many caregivers, that is not an option. Other family members may not be willing or able to assist. The family may lack the financial resources to hire a third party to take over the elder’s care, or the elder may vehemently oppose the idea. A mix of hope, love, fear, obligation and guilt typically compel the primary caregiver to continue seeing to their loved one’s needs. In order to make this arrangement work and minimize its detrimental impact, caregivers must learn to set boundaries, detach from their care receiver, and prioritize their own wellbeing.

A Caregiver’s Experience

I think it helps if the caregiver can do their best to not take every insult or outburst personally. Detaching with love is the best approach for interacting with a bad-tempered elder. My experiences with difficult family members don’t compare to many of the stories I read on the Caregiver Forum, but I was subjected to some pretty nasty treatment by my mother a few times.

She was a wonderful, loving person at heart, but her escalating physical frailty and frustrating memory issues would cause her to lash out at me. There were times when I was nearly in tears by the time I left her after my daily visit to the nursing home. Several of my family members had lived in this facility over the years, and the staff knew me and my family very well.

One day, a nurse overheard Mom’s particularly foul behavior and suggested that I just skip the next day’s visit. I couldn’t imagine carrying out her advice, so I ignored it. Things smoothed over, but eventually the same scenario transpired again. It was a Sunday and the nurse said once more, with added emphasis, “Carol, just skip a day.”

On Monday morning, I found I just could not make myself go to the nursing home. I didn’t do this to be stubborn or make a statement. I was just hurt and exhausted. I knew Mom was in good hands, so I gave myself a well-deserved day off. I didn’t even call her on the phone that day.

When I resumed my daily visits on Tuesday, Mom was sweet as pie. I couldn’t believe the difference. The nurse was right—I needed to stand up for and take care of myself. It also showed me that even people with dementia are sometimes able to sense when they have crossed the line. If the caregiver shows that they won’t be treated in an abusive manner, the elder will often behave—at least temporarily. Use this to your advantage.

Keep your boundaries firmly in place. If abusive or disrespectful behavior continues, remove yourself from the situation and take some time for both of you to cool down separately. This is harder if you and your loved one live together, but there are ways to protect yourself while providing adequate care.

Find Backup and Take a Break

Bringing in professional help can be beneficial for everyone involved. Seeking respite may help your loved one gain a new appreciation for all you do, while still letting them see a new face. Best of all, you will get a breather. Regardless of the type of respite care you choose, making preparations ahead of time is key.

Research home care agencies, adult day care centers, and other care options before they are needed. If you have everything set up when your loved one acts out, you can calmly say you won’t tolerate such treatment and promptly arrange for an alternative care provider. If you can’t follow through quickly, the consequence is less likely to have an impact on your loved one’s behavior.

Acknowledge their pain and frustration, but stand up for yourself and make it clear that you are doing your best. Remind them that if that isn’t good enough, then someone else will have to take over. You may be able to explain this change by saying that you are bringing in a professional, since your company seems to be so displeasing to them. Follow through unless you see an immediate change in behavior.

Know When to Walk Away

Unfortunately for some families, no amount of counseling, boundary-setting, detachment or respite care will change an elder’s abusive behavior. Continuing to provide hands-on care for someone who refuses to show you respect and cooperate with the care plan will ultimately jeopardize your physical and mental health. Whether you feel you have been roped into this scenario or have voluntarily taken on this role out of love, it is crucial to know when enough is enough. Permanently handing off your loved one’s care to in-home caregivers, an assisted living facility or a nursing home will ensure they receive the assistance they need and allow you to limit your interactions as much as you see fit. It is a difficult decision to make, but sometimes the best option for both parties is separation.

Be strong and resolute. My flawed goal of trying to please everyone, no matter the cost, taught me many lessons that I hope I will never forget. I learned that I have feelings and I count. You count in the caregiving equation, too, so make your wellbeing a factor in your loved one’s plan of care.

Carol Bradley Bursack

Follow this author

Over the span of two decades, author, columnist, consultant and speaker Carol Bradley Bursack cared for a neighbor and six elderly family members. Her experiences inspired her to pen, "Minding Our Elders: Caregivers Share Their Personal Stories," a portable support group book for caregivers.

Visit Minding Our Elders

View full profile

You May Also Like

Free AgingCare Guides

Get the latest care advice and articles delivered to your inbox!

368 Comments

My mom has been living with us for four years. She is so much like the article describes, but even when she was young (and I was young) she treated me this way. It has gotten so much worse lately though. One factor that has contributed to this is that she fell in March and had to spend some time in a nursing home. She blames me for putting her in the nursing home and now she says that I have said things to her that I have not said ("I want her out of this house" "No one wants you" "You are ruining my life") I have asked her doctor if I can come out and talk to him, but he won't see me unless she is with me. THEN his nurse told her I wanted to come out and talk with him and now she thinks I want to have her committed! I try to walk away...I tell her that I will not stand and listen to her call me names and treat me this way...and she just gets madder and madder. I don't talk to her much because whatever I say ends up in an argument with her hurling insults at me and calling me names. Yesterday her doctor said she is fine...memory is good, etc. I'm glad he sees her for 10 minutes and can make that determination! I know it is her age, but it is SO hard to deal with!
Parents and children need to sit down and have a talk BEFORE the parent becomes elderly. I am 42 years old and have already told my daughter when the time comes to put me in a nursing home. Period.
I saw my mother's health fail due to taking care of her parents and later my dad. People are often guilted into doing so because they are told, "well, I changed your diapers, fed and bathed you." Well, it sure is easy to do that to a 10 pound baby moreso than a 200 pound adult who will fight you.
My grandparents saved a ton of money by using my mom. And yes, they used her to she almost dropped dead. They let a severe visually imparied woman with a ruptured disc and kidney problems fix their meals, wash their clothes, and wait on them like a daggone slave -- and heaven forbid she ever asked her brother to pitch in because "he had to work and couldn't be under stress." Oh, and he had two adorable children. Mom just had me. They even told her once that her brother would be horribly upset if something happened to HIS kids. Yeah, real nice.
My husband is now going through the same thing with his father. Same ungrateful, entitled, "keep you under my thumb" behavior. That is not love.
So in my opinion (and from firsthand experience), many of these people are not struggling with dementia, feeling safe to lash out at someone or any other mental problem -- they are MEAN and have been for decades. Many of these adult children have had little to do with their parents for years, only on holidays, graduations or birthdays and were treated horribly as children.
Unless you have a very unique relationship with your parent and you have gotten along well for 20-30 years -- do not be put in the caregiving role. That same controlling, abusive person is still there, just older and more bitter.
And if you DO have a great relationship, consider very carefully if you want to keep it. 24/7 caregiving is Hell on earth.
Hi, This is Jeff again,
I am a caregiver to my wife. I love her very much and have always been gentle with her. She does respond much more peaceful with love, patience and gentleness.
I have been playing the game so to speak, when she forgets who I am and wnats to know where her husband is, I have found that no matter how much you try to convince her that you are her husband, she will not believe it. So I tell her that I am a very good friend of her husband and that when he leaves he has me come over to take care of her. She has been accepting that and keeps telling me she is so thankful that I am there. Than just as suddenly as she forgets who I am, she will remember that I am her husband.
The question I have is, is it ok to play the friend of her husband or will this do more harm down the road?
Thanks,
Jeff