What To Do When a Parent Repeats the Same Things Over and Over

Text Size: - +

25 Comments

 Print

Email Email

 

One sign of the aging brain, even without dementia, is that people repeat themselves more often, especially when they tell stories. There are reasons for this that are not related to dementia, though of course with dementia, this tendency has a different root and is much more frequent. We'll discuss dementia shortly.

Why Would an Aging Person Repeat Stories if No Dementia is Present?

As we age, life takes on a different perspective. There's a human need to make sense of what has happened in one's past, and reflect on what will be our legacy. The added years give us a chance to view our past with distance and some perspective. Retelling stories about our past is one way to work through this process.

In other words, if your parents retell a story every now and then, and you think "I've heard that a hundred times," please have the patience to let them tell it again. Your elder is working through the past to find a sense of meaning. Elders often want, consciously or unconsciously, to figure out how events shaped their present, and will play into their future and beyond.

But That's Different Than When Someone has Dementia!

I wrote the information above because I feel that adult children, once they understand the importance of an elder retelling personal stories, will perhaps have more patience with their elders. I also would like younger folks to know that the fact that their elder repeats some stories doesn't necessarily mean the elder has dementia.

However, my heart does go out to the many of you who must listen to the same statement 20 times in an hour, because the parent or other loved one has dementia and has lost short-term memory. This short-term memory loss makes it impossible for the person with dementia to remember what they just said, so they say it again – and again – and again.

How Do Caregivers Handle This Repetition Without Losing Our Own Sanity?

You'd like me to give you a magic answer, I'm sure. If I had one, believe me, that knowledge would be a headline in the New York Times. Unfortunately, I don't. However, my instincts tell me this:

Get educated

Try to understand. Your loved one isn't repeating statements to irritate you. Remember that this could be you one day. Your loved one can't remember giving you the message in his or her brain, so out it comes again – repeatedly. If you understand the reason for this behavior, you will likely find you can be less irritated and more patient.

 
 

Comments

 
  •  Comments 1 to 10 of 25 
 
 

pat1990

Give a Hug

Apr 13, 2011

Distraction and redirection are my intuitive friends so thank you for that validation.

 
 

alwayslearning

Give a Hug

Apr 13, 2011

What if the person is totally dedicated to getting validation, and the thing she wants validated is abusive to someone else? Her life's work is to project her craziness onto other members of the family and if I validate her she uses that to bludgeon them all the more; if I don't she pursues it with toxic vengeance.

 
 

gmbyacht

Give a Hug

Apr 13, 2011

I have a relative that has been repeating herself as long as I can recall-since her 40's. I know we are not talking about that.

I have another relative that is fairly self-sufficent elder man with alcohol related dimentia. He repeats stories over and over. He still drinks and I have decided I have better things to do than to hear his stories again and again when I would go over there to look after him. Let him ramble to himself or watch his porn movies.

 
 

My dad is a repeater also. He is 81 years old. I love the stories he tells about he and my mom when they were young. They knew each other since they were six years old. My mom passed away November 2009 so I cherish everyone of my dads stories even though I have heard them a THOUSAND TIMES Sometimes he surprises me with one I have never heard before. So I try to be patient and listen with a greatful heart.

 
 

RSLIndiana

Give a Hug

Apr 13, 2011

My FIL repeats over and over again that we have stolen his money... with several variations on the theme His money has been exhausted and he is pending Medicaid approval. :( Obviously validation isn't appropriate and redirection doesn't work. We try reassuring him - "Dad your money is used for your bills and everything is fine - you don't have to worry about bills or your money..." Sometimes it gets us through the visit but not always. We know it will never end.

 
 

LillyLu

Give a Hug

Apr 13, 2011

My mom would repeat things for 25 years. Then, after her hip replacement operation the table started to turn around. Now I have to remind her about the things that she used to repeat so often. She is 86 now, and not on any Alzheimer drugs.

 
 

I give always-truthful but slightly different responses each time. Not that it isn't challenging! But that way, keeps it a creative challenge for me, and I'm engaged with integrity, not faking it.

 
 

Mimis

Give a Hug

Apr 14, 2011

Several of the above commentators, in my opinion, don't understand Validation. Please check out Naomi Feil and her Validation Method. Validation is different from agreeing with what they said. It's letting them know you heard what they said. There is a difference.
A common example is spoken of above. Someone stole dad's money.
You repeat the accusation in the same volume and tone of voice. Then go on from there. 'How awful!. What should we do about it? Etc, Etc.

Another difference in posters in the attitude. Some are actually able to laugh and enjoy their loved one through this time. Can the others believe a time will come when they wish they were asking endless questions? Try to model the attitude of Victorianrose. Try singing the question and answer to a common ditty. you might get LO giving the answer back in a song. Just be sure there is a love laugh, not mockery, in your voice.

And if, in spite of everything it's still having a very negative effect on you, time for respite for yourself.

 
 

ociesev

Give a Hug

Apr 17, 2011

I am not caregiving but have loved ones who are recieving care. I see that if caregivers and recievers could everyday and everyway remember to love one another as Christ loved us and He accepted death on the cross to save us, their lives would change.

 
 

Calsdaughter

Give a Hug

Apr 18, 2011

I am very lucky that even though Parkinson's dementia has taken my father to some misty place in his mind where I can't follow, he is still very gentle and gentlemanly. However, I have had to come to terms with responding to the same questions every few minutes. I remind myself that he is not doing it to irritate me; to him it is a fresh question and a worry every time he says it. I change my replies slightly each time: "When do we leave?" "We'll leave after your nap/ after a good supper/ not today because I have to work / oh, not until the weather clears up, we must not drive on icy roads..." It gets very tiring, but I try and help reassure him. I try and make him WANT to do what I need him to do - for example, not leave today! I give him reasons that make sense to him (icy roads, supper is ready, etc.) The advantage of short-term memory loss is the next day he doesn't remember my answers, so I can use the same ones over and over.

But it is tiring and can be annoying - hang in there!

 
  •  Comments 1 to 10 of 25 

Add Your Comment

Find Senior Housing And Care That Fits You Needs

I am looking for:
Search location:











Housing


Care


Stay Connected

Sign up for our newsletter and receive practical tips and support for caregivers

 

Like AgingCare.com on Facebook