"I Secretly Wish My Elderly Mother Would Die"

Text Size: - +

246 Comments

 Print

Email Email

 

Occasionally, someone on the AgingCare.com forum will say that they secretly wish the parent for whom they are caring would die. The parent is sick, miserable and hard to care for. The caregiver wants her or his life back. Of course, those who admit they have had this thought wonder if that makes them a terrible person.

Most of these people are decent folks who love their parents. What has happened is they have taken on the role of caregiver, as so most of us do, out of love. Our elders need us, so we hop in without a thought. We have no idea that this role could last for years, or even decades.

Let's say a widowed father has a stroke. The family goes into crisis mode. The doctors bring him through, and then what? He's disabled and can't go home alone. The family doesn't want Dad to go to a nursing home, so the daughter who lives in town makes some adjustments to her home and takes dad in with her. Everyone is on an adrenaline high.

Then reality sets in. The daughter who is caring for her dad is left alone as siblings go back to their lives. She manages her teenagers, her part-time job and her dad's many doctor appointments, therapy appointments and daily care, while getting help through only a couple of hours a week of in-home care.

Her teenagers begin to resent their grandfather as a sick intruder. They resent their mother who seems too busy for them. Her work slips and her employer criticizes often. Her husband is annoyed more often than not.

Still, the family says, "We can't put Dad in a nursing home." The caregiver agrees and keeps on keeping on. Her life as she knew it has disappeared.

She starts to have fantasies that her dad will soon die. While at one time she would have been devastated by his death, she feels now that so much of him is gone he isn't really Dad anymore. She knows he has pain and is depressed. The doctors have done what they can. The caregiver starts thinking how nice it would be if Dad just went to sleep one night and didn't wake up. She believes that, then, she'd get her life back.

Guilt nearly overwhelms her when she has these thoughts. But is she so abnormal or terrible? She has, in many ways, lost much of her dad. Added to that, she's taken on a huge role as a caregiver. Caregiving has changed her life. In reality she has taken on another full time job.

 
 

Comments

 
  •  Comments 1 to 10 of 246 
 
 

cece

Give a Hug

May 5, 2010

Get someone else to help and pull out. Let the person that wants the parent to stay in the home to take over.

Stress kills the caregiver, it's real. Seek medical attn. for cardiac yourself.
Get your bloodpressure checked and everything you can.

Your life is as important as your parents and your parent would not want you to sacrifice yourself for them if they were well.

 
 

Jaye

Give a Hug

May 5, 2010

I think when we are watching someone we love decline... it is VERY, VERY hard! Please do not beat yourself up... I asked the Lord to take my Grandma to heaven because it was hard to watch her suffer. She had pneumonia and coughed... I loved her and did not want her to suffer...

 
 

jlcadmtkct

Give a Hug

May 5, 2010

I have been struggling with this situation. Mom is so far gone (vascular dementia and Lewy Bodies) that she is nothing like the mother I knew. I know if she could see what she's become she would not want to live like this, but every time I think of putting her in a nursing home, I feel like I've failed her. No matter how much we feed her she keeps losing weight, and now looks like a Holocost survivor-has no concept of who my sister and I are-and talks constantly to her invisible people. After working all day and taking care of mom all evening-I'm finding myself saying "why can't she just go to sleep?" The guilt never ends.

 
 

Jaye

Give a Hug

May 5, 2010

can you get some home care help, medicare will pay for a certain amount of homecare... I would encourage you to check into what is available... If I was close by I would help you... don't feel quilty please... It is counterproductive and hurtful to you!!! You are a good and caring daughter... take care, god bless...

 
 

Jodigirl1000

Give a Hug

May 5, 2010

If you feel overwhelmed and even remotely have negative thoughts regarding your parent(s) - either resentment or guilt or anger then you need to seek professional help for yourself. It is not normal or healthy for you or your parent to have negative feelings. I put my life on hold for over 3 years to care for my dad 24/7. It was a blessing to care for him.

 
 

AlzCaregiver

Give a Hug

May 5, 2010

I recently told the story of my mother's nasty cat, the one that put mom in hospital with a broken hip on one occasion (from tripping her), and the other time for a more vicious offense, awful knifelike scratch on Mom's arm. At that time, I got the cat declawed, and she mellowed out a bit. There were many times I thought of hiring a hit man to make the cat disappear.

So, we have toxic adhesive cloud envelope us for several days from renovation next door. Mom and I leave premises during the day, and return after workmen are gone. The cats, however, could not leave. All four of them lost weight, with the Evil One (Cleo) not improving. She was old anyway, but still, I tried special cat foods, supplements, and force feeding her.

For years I wished that cat would die or just disappear. At the time, our finances were screwed up so could not take Cleo in to the vet to do the humane thing. So now, I was responsible for this monster, and it was as you said, adrenaline overload for several days. I stood by her during her convulsions, her tortured backflips (which Mom saw...I tried to make the cat sort of disappear into other rooms, but of course, she saw the worst part.)

So the problem is with longterm caregiving, is that we are NOT on adrenaline overload, which causes us to be so focused with helpful intent. I used to send messages to that "loving" daughter of Mom's (the one who would yell at me and write me nasty messages to the effect that 'you don't even love Mom, and I do"... she scammed Mom out of thousands of dollars, has pulled all sorts of sabotage BS).

After a few months of silence, I'd shoot her an email with subject lines such as "Every Day is MOTHER'S DAY now" and "What About Your Mother???" That is to say, that the family considered holiday visits to be adrenaline charged enough to HAVE to show up. But none of it was about helping Mom.

For Mom, I will do anything ANY thing to help her be more comfortable or less afraid or more engaged. When she is sick sick or in danger, I rise up like The Hulk to help. That doesn't mean I don't have thoughts about "when this gig is over" and "will there be any inheritance left for me to start a new life?"

When I first came to care for her 8+ years ago, my thoughts were "WHY am I putting all this effort into someone who can't even say a complete sentence? I am lighting all my matches against a wet wick!" My "real" life before consisted of starting community projects with a snap of my fingers, arranging concerts, steering an artist friend to a publisher. My efforts would have community-wide impact. For me, that was the painful part, that all efforts went into a sink hole of one person (who didn't even respond to any efforts for over a year, until Zoloft got her spark back). To put in all this effort to someone who will not get better, and who might not appreciate your efforts at all. That's a hard one.

Worth seeing is "How to Train Your Dragon," where the young Viking had snagged the elusive "toothless" dragon. He really HAS to slay a dragon to be a grownup, yet he struggles intensely, seeing the obvious suffering of the creature. Even though the dragon would kill him in an instant, the boy cannot make himself do it, and cuts the dragon free.



 
 

anne123

Give a Hug

May 5, 2010

Carol, this article is fantastic. So well said....THANK YOU.

 
 

Emerald4Me

Give a Hug

May 5, 2010

What an honest article! So glad it was written. There have been times when I have complained about my mom and I will have friends who say "I wish my mom was alive!!" Doesn't help. Thanks for the guilt. That is one of the reasons I like it here. People in the same situation as I am.

 
 

linda09

Give a Hug

May 5, 2010

its a wear and tear on caregivers body . was suppose to take pa out for adventure ride today but he sure aint up to it ,
whiney and leaning . he doesnt feel good . use all my strength to get him up and down into his recliner . and im thinking gosh lord why does he have to keep living like that ? that is not a way to live ! but then again its not up to me to decide .
i hurt all over , muscles aches , from liftin him . sad sad ...

 
 

Jaye

Give a Hug

May 5, 2010

very good Carol... I know what you are going through is not easy... but as you know it will not last forever! as for the daughter who stole, she will as it were get hers you know... My Uncle did the same thing and it caught up with him... trust me... take care

 
  •  Comments 1 to 10 of 246 

Add Your Comment

Find Senior Housing that fits you needs

Search location:
I am looking for: