Follow
Share

I am 60 years old, and have been caring for my, soon to be 90 mother, for the last 10 years. She lives with me. She was diagnosed with dementia and cognitive decline, several years ago. I'm not a "Negative Nelly" but I try to be honest and realistic about situations and life, in general. One thing I've noticed, however, that is exceptionally hurtful to me, is w when some well-meaning individual hears of my current situation and feels the need to comment on how fortunate I am, to still have my mother. I feel angry inside, immediately. Not only are they clueless about my individual living situation, but they are also ignorant about just how long TEN YEARS can feel at times. I'm not even sure how to answer their comments. Maybe I should just agree? I already know I am blessed to still have her presence in my life... the hard part is that it's not even really "my mom" anymore. :0( She's often silent. Doesn't engage much, except to silently do crossword puzzles at the kitchen table, while I clean, cook, etc. I've been saying "goodbye" to the person my mom used to be... for years now. But I feel sad, broken and angry, when folks feel the need to state something so stupidly obvious like, " you're lucky to still have your Mom with you. " Have any of you been in this same boat? How do you normally respond? Not trying to be ugly, am just hurting and feeling quite misunderstood by friends, and distant family...

Find Care & Housing
Lucky is winning the lottery.

Unlucky is living to 95 or 100 with advanced dementia suffering daily.

Extremely unlucky is the daughter who chose to care for that parent in home and witness the decline, deal with the histrionics daily, clean up the messes and struggle to have a life at the same time.

People are ignorant who make comments about how "lucky" we senior citizens are to still have seriously demented parents alive. They should be in our shoes for a week or two, eh?
Helpful Answer (13)
Reply to lealonnie1
Report
ShazzamBeanie Jan 15, 2026
Thank you for replying to me. I so appreciate finally feeling like a small handful of people are in my corner...I wanted to reply more, but also work a full time job from 5 pm until 1 am. Lol... gotta have insurance. Good grief. Need to run. God bless you. Sincere and heart felt hugs to you.
(8)
Report
See 1 more reply
It's in the same vein as the thoughtless people who tell you a death is "God's plan". Discussing topics like death, old age and dementia makes people uncomfortable and they're trying to comfort THEMSELVES when they say you are lucky. Most people just aren't brave enough to put themselves in another's shoes and they want to feel better and get out of the conversation ASAP. Why on earth people can't seem to even muster up a "that sounds really hard" I will never understand.
Helpful Answer (10)
Reply to Slartibartfast
Report
ShazzamBeanie Jan 18, 2026
True that!!!! Your response resonates with me. In done ways, I guess it's good though, in a way... because I've learned through other people's unnecessary responses to my own situation. Sometimes just being present and truly hearing someone is all they really needed in the first place. Right? Maybe I am a better person when I come out on the other side of all this mess.
Thank you for your response. 💕👍🙂
(2)
Report
It's a hard thing to hear when you are going through a hard time and people try to tell you how "lucky'" you are. Never going to sit well.
Helpful Answer (8)
Reply to Hrmgrandcna
Report
ShazzamBeanie Jan 18, 2026
For real. I hope I remember how hurtful it is when I feel compelled to "respond" to another humans plight...
Thank you. 🙂👍
(0)
Report
I’ve told some people that I lost my mother twice, first when a horrendous stroke took her every ability, then four years later when she died. Those four years were much like not having her, similar to what you’re living now. I found most people, despite good intentions, simply weren’t capable of understanding. I tried to discuss it little, mostly to help limit the stupid comments. I get the feeling misunderstood and hurt, but not sure there’s a fix, other than to give people forgiveness for their lack of understanding. I wish you much peace in the storm
Helpful Answer (7)
Reply to Daughterof1930
Report
Hothouseflower Jan 15, 2026
I envy people who don't have a clue because they never had to do this level of caregiving or haven't started yet and don't know what they are in for.
(5)
Report
See 1 more reply
Choose not to be offended. I think sometimes people carry their grief around with them for years and there's a part of them that would give anything to still have their loved ones with them, even in the sad, pitiful way they may have been at the end of their life. You could respond by saying - you really miss your mom, don't you? Or - I'm terrified of losing my mom but I hate the way she is living now so I have to hope/pray her suffering will end soon.
Helpful Answer (7)
Reply to cwillie
Report
Daughterof1930 Jan 15, 2026
Wise words CWillie
(2)
Report
See 2 more replies
I totally understand. My parents died at 92 and 95, and they were actively in their dying phase for 5+ years. There was nothing lucky about their living so long and being so sick - for any of us. Managing their EOL illnesses upended my life, cost tons of (mostly their) money, caused a neverending feud with Rude Aunt (who didn't help take care of them but had plenty of useless irrational advice and criticism), and I'll resent them forever for not having a plan that didn't include me.

One short note about the money - I'm glad they had it. The problem was that I had to manage their business, their legal issues and the money on top of caregiving chores at a time when I had serious family issues of my own to take care of. It was way too much because it alone was a full-time job that was way beyond just keeping a checkbook and paying the water bill, which I also did. On autopay, which was something they'd never heard of.

I never found a good response to those idjits who told me I was lucky that they were still alive. Or to the others who would say that God never gives us more than we can handle. Seriously? When an omnipotent God could take away the problem by calling them home to him? Unless he didn't like them due to my dad's being a nonbeliever? Or something equally ridiculous?

At this point I think I'd respond with "Mom's the lucky one because she has someone to take care of her - me." And maybe drop it at that.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to Fawnby
Report
ShazzamBeanie Jan 18, 2026
Yes. A good response idea, for sure! 👍😉
It appears you are speaking from a wealth of experience, yourself. I'm so sorry for all you went through with both of your folks. Thank you for your response. Great respect and love to you for having traveled this road already. Hugs to you, right now.
Sincerely. 💕👍
(1)
Report
My dad died 22 years ago today. He was 84 1/2. He had had a stroke about 1 month before, recovered a little after the stroke, and then quickly declined. It was rough.
My mom is still alive. She's 97 1/2. She has dementia and congestive heart failure and probably other things. She lives in an assisted-living memory care facility. She's no longer the person she once was.
Now I think that we were fortunate that my dad died when he did and how he did. I don't feel "lucky" that my mom is alive. But I don't say this to other people. If the topic comes up, I explain how she's doing. They can decide for themselves whether mom's current existence is good.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to Rosered6
Report
Hothouseflower Jan 15, 2026
My father is 97 and is a semi-vegetable in a nursing home. He eats, sleeps and drools. There is no connection any more. No conversation. He just has an empty vacant look. He is a zombie for want of a better word.

No I don't feel lucky. My father's existence is nothing but a burden. I am very resentful that a. he's still alive because he's already been gone a long time as far as I am concerned and b. that his very existence is making my life miserable because I have to deal with his Medicaid crap because he and my mother never put their damn affairs in order and I'm left dealing with their mess. It's been three years and counting dealing with their garbage.

Of course if someone says something to me about how lucky I am, I just smile and think to myself if you only knew how I really feel. You'd be appalled if you did.
(10)
Report
See 1 more reply
I feel the same way you do. I believe the people who say things like that, have parents who have passed away or have never been live-in caregivers. They reflect on their personal feelings of having lost a parent.

We love our parents and provide the best care we possibly can. Dementia and Alzheimer's makes it extremely difficult. Agingcare.com is definitely a blessing for all caregivers to come together for support. You are not alone.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to Coping26
Report
ShazzamBeanie Jan 18, 2026
Yes. True. I feel like they are often speaking from their own pain and deficit. I guess I could practice some of what I need the most right now. Lol... just listening, and letting them feel heard and understood, without commenting on their luck or current life status. True.
Thank you for your response. :0)
(0)
Report
The last 3 years of my father's life were not a blessing. He just sat and stared off into space. Visits revolved around him asking when my next visit would be. He lived to eat and poop. The relatives he held in such high regard (over me his only child) no longer visited. NOW I was important to him because I was all he had left. This was no way to live.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to lkdrymom
Report
ShazzamBeanie Jan 19, 2026
Wow.... very sad. Yes. That is undoubtedly no way to live at all. I'm so sorry you went through that.
I was always terrified my mom would die first and leave my sister and I to care for my father. Thankfully, that did not happen. Unfortunately, my sister passed away unexpectedly, during the pandemic, so she and my father are both gone. I am all that my mom has left, and it's truly frightening and exhausting. My heart goes out to you. Much respect to you as well.
🥹💕
(3)
Report
Friends and family do NOT understand! I think we can all relate to that.

When anyone suggests that you are lucky to still have your mother, you can reply, "Lucky does not describe it."

Seriously, you can go into a whole lengthy explanation of what it's really like, if anyone cares to listen. But, really, people don't understand if they haven't been there themselves.

Try not to let careless remarks get to you. You don't need more stress.
The statement that gets me riled up is, "Why don't you just..... ?" followed with some suggestion that they clearly don't think I have considered already, or don't understand how difficult it is to do something that seems so "simple".

It's usually, "Why don't you just put him in a home and get on with your life?"
or .."you can still find another man" Really?! Do I need another man?! HA!
"Why don't you get a real job?" or "Can't you hire help?" "Doesn't your family help?" hahaha!
It's hard to find help. The help wants to sit and scroll through their phone, paying no attention to his needs, or they meet with him and say "no" because he's difficult and it's a lot of work, or they might be hard working and qualified, but don't want to drive this far (20 min). Young people don't want to work or do anything hard. So, I'm killing myself doing it all alone, because I love this man more than anything!
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to CaringWifeAZ
Report
ShazzamBeanie Jan 18, 2026
Yes. I hear you. I respect and admire deeply what you are doing and sacrificing!!! It's the hardest thing I've ever done. I'm perpetually tired from lack of sleep, shoveling snow, grocery shopping, working nights, and caring for mom all day...i love her more than life itself, so I know you are coming from a place of true love for your dear fellow. My heart and thoughts are with you, friend. Thank you for the heartfelt sincere, response. Much respect to you! 🥹💕
(1)
Report
See All Answers
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter