Follow
Share

My dad passed away 5 years ago leaving mom on her own. She is 82 and suffers from no major illness but does take medication for her heart, and has uses a walker to get around due to knee operations and a fall she had 2 years ago. Mentally she has no problems but due to her age we limit alot of her activities such as using the stove and climbing any stairs when we are not present. Meals are also prepared for her with her participating when it is simple. My brother had been living with them due to dad's illness and continued to do so after dad passed away. We live 4 hours apart and we had agreed when my dad passed that my mom come for visits at our home 2 times a year for approx 1 1/2 months in order to give my brother a break. I also would go up to visit often and spend up to a week taking care of her doctor appointments and any other issues that needed to be taken care of.


My brother does not work in the winter therefore he was not concerned for that time period. It has now been 5 years and my brother is finding it harder and harder to care for her for long periods of time. He has requested that we take her more often for longer periods of time. For instance she would spend 2 months with us and then back to my her home for approx. 3 months and then back at my home for approx 2 months and so on. So it would be like sharing her so that both can have a break from the care. One of the issues is that my home is a small cottage so therefore there are stairs to go to the bedrooms where her home is a bungalow therefore much easier to care for and much easier if one has to go out to run errands and not have to worry about her using the stairs to go take a nap or go to bed. Therefore when she is at my home I worry so much that I spend the time scheduling everything around those times. For instance I will not leave the house till she is downstairs and had breakfast and ready for the day. I make sure I am home when she goes up for her nap or when it is time for her to go to bed. Being that it is a small cottage it means we are basically all together for most of the day....privacy is non existent. This puts alot of stress on my relationship with my husband as he feels we cannot do anything spontaneous and he feels when my mother is here he basically looses his wife and feels we have no privacy due to our home being small.


As time goes on me and my brother have realized that in a couple of years she will need much more care as with time and age she will demand more care and at that time we will make other decisions such as a home for elderly. She is ageing and new medical issues have started to appear. I have no issues with this arrangement my brother has proposed. My mother has always been there for me. She has always helped me at times when I needed her. Such as spending time away from her home and dad when I had several operations or for any other reason I may have needed her. She was always here for me at a moments notice. The problem is basically my husband who resents having my mother here for longer period of time than one month at a time. He feels two months at a time to long and is only ok with her visiting 2-3 times a year no longer than one month at a time. I feel torn and am resenting his lack of support. I have tried explaining that she is not yet ready to be in a home and when that time comes we will deal with it. For now I want to do this with all my heart. I cannot imagine placing my mom in a home at this time. This is causing alot of stress between me and my husband. I love him very much but I feel like he is asking me to choose between my mom and him. I find this selfish on his part and find that his lack of support a slap in the face.


My mom is not here 365 days a year why would he be so opposed with helping me and my brother care for my mom. She is not just my brothers responsibility but also mine. I am so stressed by this that I find myself crying daily. I never would of expected him to react in this manner. Am I wrong for feeling this way? We have been together for 21 years. Can our solid years together not be able to support this arrangement for a few years to come? I find myself not feeling I am becoming distant from him because I cannot understand why he would not want to support me with this. I find myseld asking "Who is this person" In tears while I am writing this and any suggestions would be appreciated . I apologize if I am rambling away but it feels so good to have gotten this off my chest. Thank you for any suggestions or insight to this issue.

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
I'm a husband and I sympathise with your husband. It's very common for the spouse, husband or wife, to come to resent an elderly in law in the home. As you have a small house with no privacy this is difficult. Why not find an assisted living place near you for mom. There is absolutely no shame in this. And when it comes to choosing between your mother and your husband I feel the spouse should come first. He married you. Not you AND your mother.
Helpful Answer (15)
Report

Is your brother married? If so, how is this impacting his home life? Have your tried putting the shoe on the other foot of say if your husband was having to do this for his mother that often and thus ya'll had no privacy,etc. My gut reaction to this problem is that marriage can't be just be put on hold and that your marriage is your first priority. He is loosing you to her and who knows how long she will live and how bad her health will get before then. I think you and your husband need an objective third party to discuss this with like a family therapist.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Marriage first. Or you will be caring for mom without a husband who is second place in your life. Putting mom in a home is not neglecting your duty to her, just carrying it out in a way that doesn't sacrifice your marriage.
Helpful Answer (11)
Report

I agree. Your husband and marriage come first. Maybe she can try assisted living. Read bout it before you say no. She can have help when she needs it but still have her space. 82 is not all that old to be independent.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

My brother is single and the only way for now it is impacting his life is he needs a break here and there. Yes I have placed myself in his shoes and have in the past been very supportive of any issues that he has needed support with. While his mom was alive she was unable to live with us because of extensive medical issues. She was in a home and during 8 years before she passed I was the one who tended to all her personal needs outside the home she lived in. They are three brothers and he was the only one married. I worked from home so therefore was easier for me to be there to help. I brought her to doc appointments....took her shopping...took her to dentists....visited her during the day 3-4 times a week. I also prepared weekly family dinners and all holiday dinners to have her her to visit with her family. Because I was a woman it was almost taken for granted by all the siblings that I would be there to help out seeing she was a woman and she felt more comfortable with me. I also took care of my husbands 3 children from a previous marriage and basically gave up alot of my own freedom and self to do so. I did it because I wanted to...because I felt when you marry someone you are there for them through thick and thin and anything I could do to make it easier for him by supporting him I did it. No questions asked. So yes I feel I have supported these and many other issues he has had to deal with throughout the years. I am asking him for this arrangement for a couple of years as we know and have discussed even with my brother that at some point she need will need more care and at that time we have to place her in assisted living. Maybe this is why I feel so resentful is because I have gone above and beyond in our years together to help with any situation that he faced. I never asked questions...I did it out of love and understanding. Now I am asking for support and getting none. : (
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Sounds like I am wrong in my thinking : (
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

StarBright777 - I understand why you are resentful of your husband's lack of support when you supported his parents & his children. You also mentioned that you did this because you wanted to. It seems like you naturally have a large heart and a lot of love and that you have given that love.

Your husband does not sound like a caregiver (I know I'm not) and it is a big imposition to have an elderly in-law live with you so much. It is also HIS home and he is making clear he no longer wants your mom to live with him My husband can only tolerate about 24 hours of my mom staying with us. Your husband and your marriage come first - help mom find assisted living.

There is no shame. Good luck to you
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

No he is not a caregiver...but I am not asking him to be one. Funny part is that he actually gets along very well with my mom. I know that this sounds cliche seeing that she is my mom. But she is very sweet....never demands anything....and minds her own business. She also has treated his children as her natural grandchildren and has cared for them during vacations ....need time away for us weekends etc. She would travel to come stay with them here. She has done alot for us during the years....and I could say she did not have to. Basically she has given alot and I guess I am torn as I truly believe when someone was there in your time of need you do the same for them. Assisted living in her home where she is now is difficult as she lives in a very small town and not much is offered. It is either an elderly home or where she is now for a couple more years. Guess I have alot to work out.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

StarBright777, I understand your resentment. My sig other has the attitude "not my parents, not my house, not my problem" and that doesn't sit well with me because if it was his parents I would be there to do what I can.

And when sig other does do something to help out, my gosh, you'd think he is looking for a parade so that everyone in town can see how he had helped :P Why can't people work as a team? Why is their free time so much more important than your free time? If the spouse would help out, then there would be more free time to do things as a couple.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

fregflyer , I agree totally. My brother had taken on this role for my dad and now with my mom. I am her daughter and feel I should step up and help. And my gosh I want to do it whole heartedly. My brother is not asking that she live here 365 days a year, but for periods of time to give him a chance to breath. Both me and my brother agree it is to soon for her to go into a home. Me and hubby been together for 21 years and are very much homebodies. I do have to say that I have spoiled him over the years. I am very maternal (not always a good thing) and have always catered to all his needs and always put him first and gave him support when ever he needed it. Possibly this was my error. : (
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

awww.....sounds like you are a giver, you give and give and give. A caretaker, you care and care and care. You have a Great. Big. Heart., ready to help help help. And you expect others to treat you as you have treated them! It certainly does NOT work that way outside of a Hallmark movie. So stop crying! .... It's your husbands home, too, and no matter how much of a darling your mother is, or how obligated you feel to her and brother, that doesn't matter one bit. You are still stuck in "I must be the worlds best caretaker, oh how they need me!" mode, but you have your marriage to think of. Both you and husband are getting older now, too, its no time to create bad feelings...Is there any assisted living place near you that would take your mom for a month? Like a respite? You could go visit her and you would still have her at your house for a month. If your brother wants a breather so badly, if I was him I would go to Florida for a month and arrange for a sitter, paid, volunteer, a neighbor, to look in on mom. Then you could go get her and do your month. But stop the crying, and blaming your mean old husband for not wanting mom in the house for months. (My own husband wanted NOTHING WHATSOEVER to do with my family, and when I was running myself ragged during her decline and eventual nursing home placement, gave me zero support. I felt awful, hurt, angry - but I realized that's the kind of man he had always been, self-centered and cold, but he had some good qualities, too and supported me financially, and at least didn't make my life harder by being demanding of my time and attention!) Because I found we are all eventually going to be on our own in this cruel world, and not depend on Others, hurtful as it is.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Starbright, you are waaaay too kind and giving. That's an odd criticism but think about it. After all you have done for hubbys family now I want to smack him too. But the fact remains it's so very hard on marriages when the inlaw moves in. My mom is a pretty sweet 85 year old lady but the thought of her living with me and my wife...OMG! We would all be nuts in a week.

And FF I'm waiting for my parade too........
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

Lassie I understand what you are saying and "It`s his home too" also applied when his mom was still on this earth. I bent over backwards to do everything I did to support him. I did not hear him complaining then about me running myself ragged for his mom and his children. Family was of the utmost importance to him until his mom passed. So now I need some understanding and support and am not getting it. I do not believe I am stuck in the "I am the best caretaker..ohh how they need me mode" That mode I believe comes from my culture growing up. I lived in a home where my grandparents remained till they passed. I also witnessed my mom and dad take in many family members at times for long periods of time if they needed it. My parents loved each other dearly and never recall either one of them saying anything or feeling upset with the situation at the time. I guess I will have to think this over and do what is in my heart....not out of guilt or caretaker mode but out of love. In the end I have to feel at peace with what I do...because if I do not then that will also affect my relationship. Like they say you may forgive but you do not forget.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Your husband is willing to have his MIL in his small home for a month at a time, a couple times a year, and you call him unsupportive. Hmm.

You say this period of longer and more frequent visits would be for "a few years." How do you know it wouldn't be 15 years? Really? If her health remains stable and she is about the same as she is now in, say, 7 years are you just going to say "it's been long enough" and kick her out? You are counting on her needing increased levels of care but it doesn't sound like she has a chronic condition that would make that less likely.

Find a suitable care home for your mother now, either near you or near your brother. It could be independent living but with a full range of care options, so if she needs assisted living or even skilled nursing as she ages she can easily move to the level she needs. As long as her health permits it, she can still visit your brother and you for weeks at a time.

You marriage should come first. Yes, spouses should be supportive of each other. But for heavens' sake, your husband hasn't refused to have anything to do with your mother or been unkind to her. He is fine with her visiting.

Your brother also deserves his own life back.

To me the obvious solution is to find Mom a new home with the level of care she needs now built it, and room for more care later. Obviously she has some say in this!! But if you and Brother step out of the "we'll sacrifice anything" mode she may be happy to have such an arrangement.
Helpful Answer (11)
Report

I think when it comes to care giving when there are spouse's feelings involved you need to weigh the pros and cons of each situation individually. There are no right or wrongs. Its whatever works best for all parties at the time.

I know in my situation my Mom did not want to be a bother to anyone and so her health became very bad before she let on that it was a problem. By then it was too late to have her come live with any of us cause the situation was very serious.

I know if my husband were to suggest to me that his mother or father come live with us I would seriously object simply cause I have never had a close relationship with either of them and it would most likely destroy our marriage. But every situation is different.

If I were you I would sit my husband, brother and mother down and have a frank discussion about how you could make arrangements that would suit everyone involved. Good Luck to you.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

" I have tried explaining that she is not yet ready to be in a home."

Says who?

There are "homes" available at ALL levels of services and care. She isn't ready to have a small apartment that someone else cleans, with meals served in a lovely restaurant? What do you have to be to be "ready" for that? (The ads I keep getting for senior living places are looking more and more appealing to me, and I'm 71 with health that allows me to be fully functioning."

I think you and your brother need to educate yourselves about what is actually available, and then perhaps educate Mom. Making assumptions about what she is "ready" for is not doing anyone any favors.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

Star, do what suits you. Talk to your husband about the things you have discussed here. It's certainly not unusual for people to take in the elderly. Many do with great success and others find it to be overwhelming and a strain on their marriage. Maybe you have to bring mom home, see how it goes and decide which is the lesser of two evils. Or maybe it will all work out.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Good advice here. I didn't catch that your husband wasn't objecting to her one month visits a few times a year - but to increasing that amount to almost 1/2 time care. Plus look at what you write about how you twist your schedule around her day. No wonder he doesn't want that to increase more. And he can probably forsee that this is going to get worse and more intense. Help her choose a place while she can still enjoy it - nice apartment, others her age, meals prepared, someone on call 7x24. The more I have read the more I'm in your husband's boat on this one.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Thank you all for your much appreciated advice and suggestions. From the responses I am sensing that I am not being reasonable for asking for my husbands support in doing something that would make me happy. Just to clarify when I said two years that is because it has already been discussed with mom and she has agreed that in two years she will move to home suitable for her needs. The other thing is that it is not actually 1/2 time care. The two months come in the summer when brother works long hours....then again in October for 1 1/2 to 2 months and in all the stretch of winter (6-7 months) would come once for a month just to give him a break. As for twisting my schedule I can do so as I work from home in my own business. I can chose my hours time and how much I want to do. I am also financially independent and by no means does my husband need to work more if I chose to work less. What I think he is more concerned about is that I may not be there to cater to him as I have done throughout the years. Do not get me wrong I love my husband dearly and he is in many ways a wonderful good man...that is why this has me very upset. I will try to talk to my husband in the hopes of coming to a compromise. Right now to tense to attempt such a conversation.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Star, if you need to adjust what youre doing to the extent that you describe, your mother needs a higher level of care than she currently has. As Jeanne so sagely points out, there is a panoply of different senior living options, but if your mom can't use a stove unsupervised, she's already past the Independent Living stage of the Continuing Care contiuum.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Yes Babalou in certain areas . But I do not see this any different that the 8 years I spent helping to care for his mom as I mentioned earlier. Or the years I spent taking care and raising his 3 children(whom I adore) when he worked nights etc etc., Why would me having to adjust my time and life be more important for those things and not now for something that means alot to me. Seems one sided to me....alot of thinking to do. : (
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Star, it really sounds like you've made up your mind, you came here hoping for agreement and affirmation, and instead you are getting suggestions contrary to what you have decided to do. I don't doubt you are tense right now and not ready to discuss this with hubby. Let it settle. Get used to some of the suggestions. Even if you reject them, having considered them carefully will put you in a better frame of mind to discuss the situation with your life partner.

I think we'd all love to hear how you resolve this. Please keep in touch!
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Star, as a very happy stepmother myself, my view is that when you married your husband you married his children. You knew what you were getting into and you accepted that situation, for better and for worse, etc. This is vastly different than the role either of your sets of parents play in your life. Marriage is separating from parents and establishing a new family unit. Of course you will go on loving your family of origin, but your responsibilities now are toward your own family unit -- including any children you acquire at the time of marriage or later.

Comparing how your husband should accept your mother to how you accepted his children is not apples and oranges -- it is elephants and computer chips. They have nothing to do with each other.

Since you feel your marriage is very one-sided, perhaps it is time for some couple counselling. Would you consider discussing this with an impartial third party, trained in listening? I think in the long run you want this marriage to succeed. Putting it in jeopardy for a personal 2-year goal may not be in your best interests. But giving up that goal and simmering with resentment won't be good for you marriage, either. Would you consider letting a professional help you both sort this out?
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

Thank you Jeanne...you are right. I think right now I am feeling to hurt by his reaction and yes tense. It is not that I was looking for agreement or affirmation but possibly some insight as to why my husband would deny me this. I truely feel like I have been slapped in the face. I will let some time pass before I approach the subject with him...need some cooling off time. And yes you are also right when you say I pretty much have my mind made up. I do not think I could live with myself with any other decision. But I am not closed to hearing his concerns so that we can work around them. I so appreciate all the folks who took the time out of their day to give me their thoughts and honesty comments concerning the situation. I will post back when it is resolved.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Star, i think the thing that confuses me is that your husband is willing to have your mom stat for as long as a month...just not several months. And yet this doesn't feel like enough to you? Can mom simply go back and forth more often?

Looking back on the years when my mom and aunt did this with my grandma, a nice AL would have been a better choice, mostly for Grandma, who missed out on being around people of her own age.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

I would definitely do that but getting hubby to let someone into his personal life is another challenge. But I will make the suggestion. I may have not explained myself properly concerning my stepchildren. I love them with all my heart and there was never any resentment from me having to care for them. Gosh no. All I meant was that it was not an easy feat....I was not their mother. I went above and beyond to to make it work.....and I never gave any ultimatums as I would never have done that to him.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

No not really Babalou...she lives 4 hours away and would be difficult to do the trip up and down on a regular basis such as that. But it also would not work as he does not mind her being her for a month but at most 2 times a year.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Starbright, I would love to slap your husband silly, because I don't like the way he has reacted either. But HE is your husband. He is not some other husband who can appreciate and even enjoy having your mother in his house. You are asking him to do something that he can't really STAND to do. It's not like you want to paint the house a different color. You are asking a lot. You are justified in asking, but he is justified in telling you what he can accept and what he can't.

What if he said yes to make you happy, but in two months he blew up because he couldn't stand it any more? This is a time when he is telling you something you don't want to hear, but he is really "treating you right" by being honest about it.

I hear how committed you are to taking care of your mother. Can you consider any other situation that would allow you to care for her without destroying your marriage?

Could she get an apartment or AL in your town, so you could see her every day? Could you use her money to build a first floor "master suite" where there would be no stairs to worry about and less intrusion into your family life? What would your husband think about you spending a month at her home? Try to be open to other possibilities that are acceptable to you and your husband.

Or you could just divorce him. I'm OK with that. Just don't think for a minute that you can get him to see that "it's only fair" that he should go along with this. As we all have to learn, what's fair and what happens, what exists, are often far apart. God bless you. It's a really tough one.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Star, a couple things jump out at me. First, your brother is asking that your mom stay with you more often and for longer duration. Also, you are so worried about her safety that you have rearranged your daily schedule. And finally he has said that when your mom is with you, he loses his wife. Many of us will tell you that competing with an elderly parent for ones spouse's attention and time......well, husbands have an uphill battle there. When a parent lives with you, you are in constant daughter mode.

Going out on a limb here...I think he's concerned that the visits will evolve into long stretches of time, as she needs more care and your brother becomes more burned out. Many caregivers find that you take a step and another, and one day, you wonder how you got where you are. I think you're looking at things as they are now, and he's looking at what it could evolve into.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

Here's what I think - I suspect that your husband wasn't as alright with the twice annual month long visits as you think. I suspect he was probably at the end of his acceptance and patience at 30 days but did his best to seem "alright" to please you and because he loves you. I suspect he knows any longer than the times mom is already spending with you and him would be more than he could deal with. I think he is probably looking at this now as you making a choice as to whom you're going to put first. Is this fair - given things you've done in the past for him? Well, sort of - I'm my opinion. When a person does things for another, shouldn't it be plainly because they choose to - without holding a marker to call some day in the future? That's pretty much how I look at doing "good deeds" - you do them of your own free will because you want to and choose to - expecting gratitude or repayment shouldn't be a part of the package - although appreciation certainly would be nice. But here's the thing - I fear this has or will become an issue that could irreversibly damage your marriage. If he gives in, will he always resent it, you and her? If you give in, will you be able to ever get past this? I honestly believe if you value your marriage, the two of you should see a marriage counsler prior to making any decisions about moms visits. I'm sorry, but that's my take on this.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter