Follow
Share

I am retired and my parent wants me to care for her by moving into her home as she needs round the clock care.  I don't want payment. If no money is exchanged, am I simply my parent's roommate paying half share for utilities and food costs along with performing household cleaning services?

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Dat, what type of care does your parent need? If she needs around the clock care, meaning 168 hours per week, that is impossible for one person to do... that is like working 3 shifts per day.

You don't need an employment contract if your parent is not paying you any wages for helping them via a caregiver. But when and if she does, do draw up a contract, it will come in handy in case your parent needs to apply for Medicaid.

We have to remember that our parent will still think of us being 30 years old being faster than a speeding bullet... more powerful than a locomotive.... able to leap tall buildings in a single bound. When in fact we are senior citizens ourselves with our own age decline issues.
Helpful Answer (12)
Report

If you are truly just there for companionship and as an occasional driver then I guess you should pay room and board, but be fully aware that once a precedent is set it can be difficult to change. Your parent's care needs will inevitably increase and you may find yourself caring for them in ways you never expected. They will not only have a live-in caregiver, they will have one who actually pays for her keep. If you have sibs, are you fine with them sharing any future inheritance equally even though you have done all the work?
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

Also know that my parent's home does not have a mortgage and my father left her a funded account to pay property tax. She also has a widow's pension and social security. I have my own pension and social security.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

cwillie: I would not be there "just for companionship and as an occasional driver." My parent requires assistance with meals (prep, cook, serve, cleanup), medication prompting, appointment setting, bathing assistance, laundry, household cleaning, yard care, etc. As much as I want to provide caregiving without pay, I also do not want to incur costs to do so. I too, have a home without mortgage. She wants me to live in hers.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

It sounds like you do not want to move in with her. Follow your gut.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

So what is the plan for your own home, will you become a landlord? And what of your possessions?

It sounds to me as though you will be performing the duties of a full time live-in CNA, why would you be expected to do all that and still help pay expenses?

Do you have any thoughts on what might cause you to reach a "line in the sand" when can no longer provide care? Even if you are determined to care for your parent until the end there may come a time you physically can't do it any more. Have you both discussed an exit plan?
Helpful Answer (10)
Report

I think you'll find that the demands of caring for 2 houses are overwhelming, and you'll start burning out. I would list all of the indoor and outdoor tasks, consider which ones can be hired out (yard work, indoor cleaning, laundry, etc.) while still living in your own home. And start calling agencies to provide in-home care. Your health will not deteriorate as much as if you moved in and took over all the work.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

Thanks everyone. Yes, I have to rent out my own home and am not looking forward to being a landlord as I will have to pay to have repairs and improvements to accommodate tenants. I don't want to sell it as the market it is in is not profitable right now. Perhaps it's that I am "green" to caregiving for a parent and not considering the consequences to my own health and well being. It feels like the right thing to do, but it is scary, and is fraught with consequences. There are two more siblings. One sibling adopted his grandchildren and said moving from his home he owns into mother's would not work and that moving her into his would be an overwhelming situation for all. The other sibling wants nothing to do with the caregiving stating it is mother's problem and not hers but has volunteered to carry out POA duties for mother's business matters although she has complained of the time spent handling mother's insurance paperwork and billings and legal matters. She compares it to my providing the hands on caregiving and round the clock accessibility. She is the one who prompts me to be concerned about living in mother's home. My sister does not want to move in with mother or have mother move into her home, a home mother also owns in which she is living for free over the past seven years with the exception of paying yearly prop tax and insurance and her utilities. She wants me to pay the same for the house my mother lives in while I am providing caregiving. As I said, I am good with the utilities and food costs for mother and me. My sister has threatened to file IRS 1099 declaring that I am receiving financial gain by not paying rent - however, if I do as she (my sister) does and pay property taxes and homeowner's for the house my mother lives in, then she won't carry out her threat. I did not want to seem like a drama queen, so I posed my original question as bare bones as possible. Thanks for listening.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

It sounds like a bad idea to me. You can spend hours on this forum reading the horror stories of children trying to care of their elderly parents. I commend those that manage it but most do not and regret giving up their lives to caregiving. Meet with your sibs, figure out the finances and get in home help or facilty care.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

My mind just refuses to accept your sisters line of reason- that you must pay to be there. That she doesn't want you to have any "financial gain" - what a selfish twit! And to make IRS threats? Wow. Perhaps sis needs a reality check in learning how much her own financial gain i.e. her inheritance - would be eaten up if your mothers money was to go to pay for Assisted Living or a nursing home. For you to do the full-time plus work as your mothers caregiver AND pay to be there is insane. If you go through with this get a caregivers contract - even if no money is paid you and it is merely stipulating your work in exchange for living expenses.
Helpful Answer (16)
Report

Just say no. Find a nice Assisted Living faciluty for mom, she'll love the activities and socializing. What you are proposing will be a financial and emotional disaster for you before very long.
Helpful Answer (12)
Report

datrnlawilldoit, you mentioned you are retired. Think about this, the last time you visited a hospital, assisted living, or a nursing home... how many workers were your age? Probably none and there is a very good reason for that.

For my aging parents who lived under their own roof, and me living under my own, yet I did all the errand running, doctor appointments, shopping, etc. then eventually took over as financial POA which was like having a part-time job in itself trying to sort though a ton of paper, pay bills, keep track of the stock market, etc. Eventually I crashed and burned from the stress and here I was in my 60's. I am now 70 and still trying to recover from the unbelievable stress that was placed on me. Make sure you know fully what you are getting into. And have everything put into writing and notarized.
Helpful Answer (11)
Report

Oh, you mentioned that your parents needs "assistance with meals (prep, cook, serve, cleanup), medication prompting, appointment setting, bathing assistance, laundry, household cleaning, yard care, etc." Who was doing this prior or was this a sudden medical issue?
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Red flags and warning lights going off all over the place.

Do not do this.

I don't know if your sister is greedy or just ignorant, but paying to provide live-in care for your parent is crazy, crazy, crazy.

You don't want to be landlord. You will be. You expect to simply be a companion. Ha! You will uproot your life so that your mother doesn't have to uproot hers. And hers is more important than yours because .... ??

Love your mother. Help your mother do what is in HER best interest as well as good for you.

I do believe that family members can live together peacefully and productively. But this arrangement is already causing conflict with your sister and you are still in the planning stage. This does not bode well for long term.
Helpful Answer (15)
Report

Your sister sounds like a problem waiting to boil over. You have not moved in yet and she is already threatening to report you? and she lives in a home owned by mom and pays only minimal? Just say no! Or get a contract so she can;t come after you later, and she will,, with the POA behind her.
Helpful Answer (10)
Report

NO. This is NOT right. Do NOT be the caregiver at the mercy of someone else holding POA who is a complete cheapskate with no more appreciation of what being a caregiver means than the man in the moon...who understands costs and values cutting costs, but has no values. You'll be spending your money on Mom because Sis doesn't want to and does not see the legitimate needs for things that will be staring you in the face, including a little respite for you now and then. And good luck with the absentee landlord thing. What if Mom gets to where you can't get away to go resolve some problem or other back there? No NO NO NO no. Right thing to do sure - under the right circumstances, NOT like this. Your gut is trying to tell you NO. Listen to it. Consider elder mediation or counseling and even getting an eldercare attorney to advise on how things really ought to be run.
Helpful Answer (14)
Report

I agree with the other caregivers - this has problems written all over it and you're not even through the planning stage yet. I've been caregiving for my mom for 14 years. Can you do this for that long? Once you're in it, it's hard to get out of it. So take your time to make the right decisions.

I don't live with my mom but just dealing with her (she'll be 97 in Dec) is sometimes almost enough to drive me round the bend. And I don't have a nasty sister second-guessing my every move. I agree with finding other options for your mom. Don't give up your life in service to hers - your life is just as important as hers is and your sister's and your brother's. Put yourself first and figure out how to help mom without upending your whole life.
Helpful Answer (13)
Report

Why does your mother think that you should provide care at no cost to her? This is costing you your time, your retirement years. It's a burden on your health and your back. At a time in your life when you need to be looking after your own health ( healthy eating, exercise and your own doctor appointments) you're going to be providing a free ride to mom?

Is she without funds for care? Help her apply for Medicaid. If she has funds, she should use them to hire help.

And please. Don't try to do the yard work. That's a young person's job.
Helpful Answer (9)
Report

Looks like the apple (your sister) didn't fall far from the tree (your mother). They both are very selfish. Is your sister wanting you to be the slave so that there will be something (house) to inherit when your mother dies? Is this also your mother's plan?

As others have written, do not do it. You will live to regret it. Your health will suffer. Your mother may outlive you. Let your sister live with your mother!
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

A useful line I learned here.... " I couldn't possibly do that".
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

If you want to enjoy your retirement years stay where you are. Why would you want to give up freedom, privacy and financial security to become an unpaid caregiver and being threatened by an ungrateful sister? No one owes their parents care at the expense of their own lives becoming chaotic!
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

I missed the fact that your sister is living rent-free. what a piece of work!
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

I have to agree with virtually everything that has been said by others, above. I wanted to add one thing, though. Don't forget that you are in control here. You have the power. Don't let yourself be railroaded. This is your life to do with as you see fit.

IMO, if you take care of your mother and let your siblings off the hook, you SHOULD receive financial compensation for that, to whatever extent your family members can afford it. You will be working an exhausting and consuming job and saving the rest of the family a whole lot of time, energy, effort, and money that would otherwise be expended on paid helpers. It's not financial GAIN, it's COMPENSATION. For your sacrifice, hard work, and acceptance of a huge responsibility that allows other people go on and live their lives. It's WORK, and don't let anyone tell you it isn't.

Your sister is already being an idiot. There's no guarantee (or even glimmer of hope) that she will become more reasonable in the future. And, she has power of attorney. Under those circumstances, I agree with those who say "DON"T DO IT!!!"
Helpful Answer (11)
Report

NO! Better do some heavy research on this site and carefully consider all the pitfalls; whatever looks "not so bad, I can handle" now will not look so great later when mom needs lots of care.
Now, if you have a plan to save on housing/living expenses in exchange for caring a couple years for mom; and all siblings will sign a legal doc stating they are in agreement with this; then fine. Have a back up plan for when mom needs extra care or you decide to move on and transition to a new home, your own activities, etc.
Just have a sound plan as to how long you are willing to do this, how much care you are capable of and agreement that mom will accept outside care or residential care if needed (and be aware that she may say "yes" to that now but when the going gets tough "adamantly refuse all outside care" and beg you to stay, didn't know you planned to move on; how can you leave me, etc.

THink real hard. Is this how you planned to spend your retirement? You deserve some fun, independent living, new friends, new opportunities, travel, PT work, volunteering, clubs, etc.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

I agree with what everyone has written here. I am a live-in daughter. My parents refused to leave their home. They wanted to die in it. When my marriage ended my mother figured God had done it so I could come home and care for them. If I could go back in time I would never, never do it again. It made sense at the time. Really it still does if only I weren't treated like a slave that owes somebody something for being born. It usually takes about 6 hours a day to take care of my mother in some fashion, whether it be house cleaning, medication management, yard work, cooking, house maintenance, or putting up with the nonsense coming my way. Wrestling with the modern healthcare system is a real trick. A lot of days I end up so frustrated and angry dealing with it for a woman who is so mean.

I don't pay rent here. My mother once mentioned I should use my money to pay for everything so she could keep hers. ROFL. If anything is left over in the will, it will be divided four ways. That would mean I would pay for her to live so she could leave any money saved to all the children, three who weren't even involved in her care. What sense would that make?

If I had to put a money value on things I do for my mother it would be about $500 a week. That doesn't include pay for the time I spend stewing about something mean she did or writing here on the group. She has the house paid for and covers the power, gas, and water. The two rooms I occupy and the utilities are the only things I get from her. That is probably worth about $1000 a month at the most.

It is so strange that people can see live-in caregivers as moochers that owe someone something. They are already donating their lives and enjoyment of living. To pay to make these donations is just crazy.

Personally I think you're sister should move out of her free house. Or at least she should write herself a 1099 for $20K a year, which is about what she is benefiting in today's housing market around here. Pssft! Your sister p*ssed me off with her craziness.
Helpful Answer (9)
Report

I agree that I would not place myself anywhere that your POA sister has any control over, such as your mom's house. I suspect that based on your sister's living situation, she has a huge conflict of interest regarding her POA status. Has sister, as POA, consulted with financial planners, tax experts about how she is managing your mom's assets? Is it really in mom's best interest for her to live rent free in her mom's house? Now that mom needs help in her own home and it may cost money, that sounds like a potential source of funds that should be explored.

So, if mother competent and willing to appoint a new Durable POA? And if she did, would you want to take on that responsibility? Is sister acting as mom's POA now? It sounds like a lot of heartache to me, but you know if you're up for it. And if sister is really acting poorly, it could end up in court. I'd get a legal opinion from an experienced Elder Law attorney before making any decisions.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

I missed the sister living in another of moms houses - rent free. Okay, so if I'm understanding this right - sis is doing financial POA work and living in a house mom owns - not paying rent but is paying property tax and utilities. Sis feels that if you move in with mom you should pay all property tax and all utilities and do 24/7 caregiving with no compensation- and she feels the work that each of you will be doing for your mom is comparable? Is your sister mentally unbalanced? Seriously? I've been DPOA- both heath and finances - and yes, my mom had a chunk of "business" that required dedicated monitoring. It took a chunk of my time. But in NO WAY can your compare one job with the other. As long as I respected due dates I could schedule most of my work - push it off a day or two if I wasn't feeling good or wanted to go out and do something fun. If a 24/7 caregiver isn't feeling good they don't get the option to say "I'll feed you tomorrow- I'm not up to it today". And forget about ANY spontaneous fun - period! If I read it right, sis doesn't want your living with mom - is she trying to intimidate you out of it? What's her suggestion for moms care? What is sis afraid of? You finding out something? Her losing control of the money? I think I'd be very suspicious of your sisters motivation, if I were you. And - do not do this as long as sis has POA!
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

Your mother needs to do one of two things. Either sell the investment house or charge your sister market rent to live in the house so that your mother has the money to pay for her own long term care needs. Your mother and your sister are using fear, obligation and guilt on you. You are a grownup and you are in charge of your own life. Put on your big girl pants and tell them "I couldn't possibly do that."
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

Dat, if your sister is living rent free in one of your Mom's investment properties, then Mom is losing a lot on her income taxes. She cannot deduct any costs and depreciation that are the result of that property since there is zero income coming in. Even below market rent would be frown upon.

And if for some reason down the road your Mom needs to apply for Medicaid, they would see that your Mom owned an investment property that has non-producing income, and that could throw a wrench into her being approved for Medicaid.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Having read the question and the replies I'm wondering where did the Sister or Sisters come from, since there's no mention of Them in the question.
( A ) You should not have to pay towards house hold utilities or food costs when You are Caring for Your Mother. I'm very sure Your Mom would not want this.
( B ) On the assumption there are Sisters, I would get a Contract drawn up and signed by Your Mothers Doctor for authenticity, and have receipts for all expenses so that if the Family become heavy handed and They inherit Your Mothers Estate You can put a stay on the WILL until all of Your bills and expenses are paid first. Naturally there's no kneed to mention this to Sister or Your Mother, as You kneed to cover Yourself.
I cared for My Mother for three years and I would not take payment, not would I apply for Carers Benifits from Our State, simply because I adored Mam, and I was honoured to share every day and night of My Mothers Long and beautiful Life. In the end all We have left are memories of beautiful tender moments to be savoured in Our Heart till Life's end.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter