Follow
Share

I am writing on behalf of my sister. She has wanted to leave her loveless marriage for some time, but her husband is bedridden from osteoporosis and other issues. He literally cannot do anything for himself.


Here's the big issue: he has refused physical therapy, other nursing help AND has actually kicked out several paid caregivers. He expects my sister to take care of all caregiving duties (she works full time from home for the State).


She recently arranged for an ambulance to take him to the hospital since that's the only way he could get examined by a doctor(s) and get some sort of planned next steps. When the ambulance showed up, he refused to go. He is supposedly able to make his own decisions. I know that legally he cannot be forced to go to the hospital.


Even an ultimatum likely won't work e.g. "You are refusing to take the necessary steps to try to get well. I refuse to participate in your demise. Either agree to go to the hospital or I'm leaving and you'll be on your own. Call 911 if you need help". It'd be harsh and she likely couldn't do it, but it may be the only way to get him to the hospital and for her to have a life.


This has many legal and ethical issues involved. We'd be grateful for any suggestions!


My sister works, is exhausted and doesn't know where to turn.

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
My gosh, I feel so sorry for sister. Of course, I feel sorry for a person who is sick but why would a person refuse medical treatment and not expect to suffer the consequences. Could it be some type of fear or is he a stubborn mean man? It’s awful either way. Fear is crippling and stubborn refusal is torturous for both of them. He is clearly taking out all of his frustrations on her, which becomes unbearable for her as the caregiver.

It must hurt you to see your sister going through this difficult period in her life. I totally agree with others about seeing a lawyer. I hope that she will find peace and joy in her life when all of this is behind her.

Please update us on how things are going for her. We care.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

If she presents him with all the options open to him, a phone, and a mini-fridge stocked with water and snacks, I'd say she has no reason to feel guilty about his situation. He, not she, has destroyed the marriage, and while we take vows to be there in sickness and in health, we also vow to be our best selves for our spouse and he has broken that vow. She can report him to APS on her way out the door, and she should be able to walk away with a clear conscience.

I know that all sounds mildly ridiculous, but the fact is that he's not going to change until she makes good on her threat to leave and actually does it. Even then, she needs to keep going out the door, because if he finally relents, he'll turn around and be a jerk again if she agrees to come back. If she feels completely overwhelmed with guilt, then she can oversee his care from a distance by writing the checks needed, but she'd be smarter to separate herself completely from him and their assets and allow a guardian take over the responsibility of his care.

Step 1 -- see a lawyer.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Yes, she needs to see a lawyer.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Gee, your BIL if awfully young to be so disabled and I understand your sis being done.

I'm not sure I completely understand, if her husband is willing to accept outside help, is she willing to stay with him despite their loveless marriage?

She does need to first get things lined up, financials, attorney. She should write down everything that needs to be done by hubby then sit and calmly give him an ultimatum - she has a job outside him that has to be done and she does not have the energy to take care of him and do her job. That he must accept outside help, move to a facility for care and not say no or he is on his own.

If he continues to stay the course, she moves out and asks social services or APS to check in on him.

Good luck to your sister.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

An ill person has rights to be cared for.

However, the person does NOT have the right to insist a particular individual provides it.

1. Advice him to accept care agency staff (ie non-wife carer) or take the natural consequences. (Which is no care).
2. Arrange a care agency. If he cancels/obstructs let the agency note this & deal with it. Wife could physically leave the premises once agency is on site. His tantrums may cease if his target audience (wife) has left.
3. If he has made care from agency impossible ie aggressive, take the next steps.

The natural consequences are there is a vulnerable unwell man, refusing care.

This should prompt a mental health crises situation - Baker act.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Your sister should FIRST see a Lawyer to handle her divorce. She should separate our her money from his and get all that financial stuff done. Then she should sit with your husband and explain to him that she is leaving him, will be divorcing him, and that it is crucial to get him into care so he can be cared for. If there are no adult children willing to help him, and he refuses, then, yes, he is left with 911 or she can call APS and report him as an Adult at Risk and alone. She should be gentle, not argue, not be driven to anger and tell him that she is done now, does not love him any longer, and if he is cooperative in moving to care she will assist him; otherwise he will be alone in working things out when she is gone.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

She’ll likely have to do an ultimatum. Hire help or she’s outta there. See how he thinks he can get along with her being gone not 24 hours. Might be the impetus for him to change his tune.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter