Follow
Share

Quite a narcissist. She gets all her narcissistic supply from my husband and doesn’t care much about staying at her other kids homes, who are also i am sure relieved that they don't have to bear with her behavior for no more than couple months at a time.
I have suggested many times that she lives 6 months here and 6 months at other kids homes. But whenever she goes there she has some drama there and very soon tells my husband to get her a ticket back to our place. My husband doesn’t have the guts ( or maybe the desire) to say no to her. He keeps reassuring her that our home is her home and she doesn't need to stay anywhere else.



What should i do…

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Your expectations;
Did you expect to be in a 3-way marriage? Was it discussed beforehand? Or expected?
Did you think it would be ok but the reality is different?

Husband's expectations;
Did he always expect to house his Mother? Does he expect Wife & Mother to harmonioulsy get along? To not require their own space? Maybe he never thought about it..? Does what Mother tells him to do..? (Never questioning a parent's authority).

MIL's expectations; that an adult child must house & provide for her? Due to custom? The old ways? What she did for her parents/in-laws? Does she think it is her choice which adult child must provide her housing? Do the adult children get a say? Or does she expect obedience?

WAY too many questions!! Sorry!

You can see this can be hot topic.
It may take a very culturally sensitive marriage councellor. If you have a religious/faith leader, I'd start there. For some 1 to 1 support then leading to couple councelling.

Having that third person to explain each other's viewpoint can be very beneficial.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

How did it come about her living with you? Why was it agreed to in the beginning?
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

I have seen the over-used term “narcissist” one (okay, a zillion) too many times on this site. People! It does not MATTER what the other person is…YOU are the one in control of what YOU will put up with! YOU get to set the limits, establish the boundaries, and use that golden word, “NO.” (Or its stronger version, “HELL, NO!” if the issue is changing an adult diaper 😷🤮).

Hey, just an idea: become a so-called “narcissist” yourself, if that’s what it takes to reclaim your own life!
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
waytomisery Oct 30, 2023
It’s not that easy for OP , she’s in a marriage of 3 people . If it was her own mother this may be easier .
What she says or does effects her marriage as well.
(3)
Report
See 2 more replies
"But whenever she goes there she has some drama there and very soon tells my husband to get her a ticket back to our place."

You're the easiest to get along with, so you get the prize? Um, nooooo.

When she's at their homes, something happens to make her uncomfortable and unhappy. What could it be? Other daughter-in-law refuses to become her narcissistic supply? Other son refuses to spend time with his mom because he values his wife and family over her? Maybe her daughter tells her to shut up and won't cook for her? Do you know specifically how the "drama" starts?

Find out. Then start your own drama. Make your home unpleasant for her. You do have the right to stand up for yourself and to keep your home happy for yourself. At present, it isn't. You need to create an atmosphere that is not what MIL wants.

In other words, you are being too nice to her. And you're being too nice to your husband, too. He is your problem. She is your nightmare. You can fix both, but it would involve becoming someone you didn't think you were. It's up to you whether you want to do that.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Are you expected to provide care and do the cooking and cleaning?

Is there a possibility of treating this situation as one might a difficult roommate situation?

For example, if you work from home, maybe you can spend your days at a library, coffee shop, or shared work space? If you are expected to cook, maybe put something in a crock pot and tell husband and MIL to help themselves but you will be at [fill in blank...yoga, book club, walking group]. For cleaning, maybe a housekeeper? (At least they get paid for their labor.)

Go to bed early with earplugs or white noise; leave early the next morning.

If these are options, you are the envy of many who contribute to this forum.

If husband expects you to care for and serve MIL, then you do have a marriage issue to sort out. And it will be a tough one given the longstanding male expectation that unpaid care work is women's work.

Good luck to you!
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

My uncle’s wife agreed to take care of mil for the rest of her life as a cultural obligation. She flaked after less than a year after saying she would do it for life. She just hated grandma being there so uncle booted her. Uncle would have not gotten immigration or been a doctor without his sisters who assumed he would, at least, take a measured approach.

Uncle basically divorced himself from his whole extended family over this.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
sp196902 Oct 30, 2023
"Uncle basically divorced himself from his whole extended family over this."

I think it was more like the family disowned uncle because he chose his marriage over his mother. Good for the uncle. Too bad more husbands weren't like your uncle and put their marriage and lives first over their parents. I am sure uncle would never have had to worry about getting any type of immigration status if his mother hadn't chosen to come to the USA.

I don't see how the sisters played a part in his becoming a legal citizen or being a doctor. If the culture is that the male child gets everything and the female children get the shaft (very common in Asian and other cultures) then this mentality and mindset needs to be changed not encouraged and supported.

Trying to say uncle owes his mother and sisters his entire life in care giving for his mother is not fair.
(4)
Report
See 1 more reply
Is this a cultural thing? Yes, if you needed to walk away, could you? Are you expect to care for her as she ages? I don't believe in ultimatums unless your ready for the consequences. "Its either me or your Mom" He says "Mom" then you say "two women cannot live in the same house, so I guess I will be leaving. Because this is my home and your Mom thinks its hers" Wives come first. Men marry, Mom is no longer #1.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
sp196902 Oct 30, 2023
Culture is just another word for forced slavery and oppression of those deemed less than.
(3)
Report
The problem is your husband not your MIL. He is a mama's boy.

Whether you want to live the rest of your married life that way is up to you. He will not change.

My mother is 98, your MIL could also live that long, keep that in mind.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

You don't have a MIL problem but you DO have a marriage problem. Time to seek out a marriage counselor or skip that step and go straight to a divorce.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Take a girls vacation with some friends or go alone and have some relaxation. Start mentally checking out and plan your escape. Speak to a divorce lawyer and not tell DH so you can find out if it comes down to it what you need to do, how to do it and when to do it.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

What do you feel you want to do ?

If you wanted to leave this situation , would you be able to support yourself ?

How long has MIL lived with you ? ( how long married ).

Is your husband willing to go to marriage counseling ?
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
AndSoItGoes Oct 30, 2023
These are all really helpful, clarifying questions. My only concern about the marriage-counseling recommendation is that plenty of psych professionals participate in traditional gender-role expectations. So if the counselor believes that wives should sacrifice their own hopes/health/sanity in order to care for MILs, the OP won't get much help from counseling. The counselor may even link arms with husband/MIL and affirm the exploitive relationship.
(2)
Report
See 1 more reply
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter