Follow
Share
Find Care & Housing
If it is true, tell the sisters he has been diagnosed by a competent and experienced doctor with a specialty in Alzheimer disease; therefore you plan to follow his advice and continue doing what you have been doing. If the foregoing is not true, make it so by engaging the services of a doctor with the appropriate credentials and tell the sisters to follow your lead as your approach to the matter is working.

I am not a professional in elder care but try to solve problems with an objective and professional (other than elder care) problem solving viewpoint.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to Paulcarrvt
Report

My FIL's sister refused to believe that he had dementia and often did the same thing. Tell him she didn't believe he had it. Support all of his delusions. We had moved him to a SNF and they were talking every day on the phone and it was agitating him. He was already struggling to use his phone, had deleted his contacts list etc. And when they talked instead of trying to keep him calm, she just jumped right in to ramp him up.

She is 10 hours away and had not seen him in 10 years. She even called the ombudsman and told them that he had no family locally that could check on him (full on lie, both his son (my DH) and daughter lived within an hour and we visited regularly)

We talked to her multiple times, sharing his diagnosis, what was happening to him, the fact that he often had to be medicated for agitation after talking to her because she played into his delusions and supported his confabulations, calling the facility over and over until we told them to block her number.

Eventually, this situation in combination with him really not being able to manage his phone any longer finally led us to remove his phone. We told her we were doing it and told her if she had any questions or concerns she needed to call one of us, not the facility. She was mad that we never added her to the "list" of family at the facility that they could share information with, but we knew what would happen if we did.

Removing the phone and them being permitted to not answer her phone number seemed to help a lot lol. Funny...she didn't call us to check on him.

She sent one of her nephews to visit him without telling us. She then called to tell us that we were telling the truth. Um....thanks...wrong answer.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to BlueEyedGirl94
Report

Mantogirl: Let his neurologist deliver the news.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Llamalover47
Report

Drop him Off at Her House 2 weeks .
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to KNance72
Report

Be patient with them, but stand firm for yourself. Time will change their minds. My husband’s family was also in doubt in the first year of his diagnosis. But in the subsequent years, as behavior changed, they all came around. They now understand and support all of the changes I’ve made to protect and support him.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Quitecontrary
Report

Remember. Alzheimer’s has varying types. It might be that he is socially appropriate. I would certainly talk to them. Ask them to please stop questioning his diagnosis. Rather they can learn more about it. If they are not willing g to attend a family meeting they would only be welcome to visit in my presence.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to Rose33
Report

This is a very common issue many caregivers have. You can have someone who is severely impaired and families do not want to admit or deal with a diagnosis. Many times because this means they have to accept change. People do t like change. What I always suggest is a family meeting. Do not allow yourself to be a target. Put it back in a professionals hands. When they are available you can set up a family meeting with doctor or others. If you get a chance explain the level of disbelief among family members to the doctor or nurse. They are used to it. Families want a scapegoat. Do not allow it. I also would directly ask the family member. Are you suggesting Mom doesn’t have Alzheimer’s? Wait for an answer. Have them say it out loud. Yes or no. No more passive stuff. Many times it’s due to their lack of involvement. I also slip in things that have happened. If they say they don’t believe the diagnosis maybe it’s time for you to take a trip and let them do some care.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to Rose33
Report

I find myself wondering if you have an actual medical medical diagnosis.
you should get one if you don’t already have one.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Lemon9
Report
Rose33 Oct 1, 2025
Based on what? Your comment is not supportive. We already have naysayers here in this poor woman’s family. She doesn’t need another.
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
Show your husband's sisters his actual chart. The doctor will give you a copy of it. Then get some pamphlets (your husband's doctor probably has some) about a dementia behavior called 'Showtiming'. This is when a person with dementia can pull it together for short periods of time for certain people and appear to be totally fine. 'Showtiming' is only effective on the people the person with dementia doesn't spend much time with or do much talking with. Sometimes they person can even get one over on a doctor or other healthcare professional.

You live with your husband every day, so there's no 'Showtiming' going on with you.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to BurntCaregiver
Report
Rose33 Oct 1, 2025
No. This man deserves medical privacy. His chart is not their business. This man can have Alzheimer’s and still have capacity and rights.
(2)
Report
My default setting is to cover all the bases by starting with showing proof and educating.

I would literally send the sisters a print out of his actual diagnosis from his medical chart. Highlight it and the date. Tell them if they want to think they know more than his doctor then they should call him/her up and argue it with THEM.

I would also print out info and articles (or even threads from this forum) about how to engage people with this diagnosis, and what happens when family members don't respect the diagnosis, the patient and the caregiver.

You could even go so far as to video his behaviors and show it to them. This may seem excessive, but I'm in favor of trying to preserve the family relationship and I personally would be willing to go this far. If your husband had good/close relationships with them historically, then I think it's worth the effort.

After that, they get limited or completely blocked because maybe they have their own cognitive problems setting in...?

Did you have good a relationship with them in the past? Maybe they are terrified to think this runs in their family and it's a weird sort of denial? You can suggest that there is now testing for this and they should contact their primary doctors... ;-)
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Geaton777
Report

Does this upset your husband or cause a problem for you?
If so you tell them that if they continue you will restrict their phone calls.
You can put the calls on speaker and if they begin that kind of talk you can disconnect the call. (oops, I hit the wrong button...)
If they don't get the hint then they just can't talk to him on the phone, they can visit. If they start in during a visit then you cut the visit short and walk them to the door while handing them their coats.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to Grandma1954
Report

Well, my Rude Aunt insisted that dad didn’t have dementia. She said he was just bored, and if we bought him some Sudoku books so he could use his mind, he’d be fine. Denial doesn’t get much worse than that!

All I could do was ignore her. Stopped talking with her, let her rant on, cared for dad as required, and got cut out of her will.

I suggest you ignore these sisters and mention them to husband as seldom as possible. Hopefully he’ll start forgetting what they tell him, and that’s good. Start planning ahead to care for your husband; check out facilities, look into home help, enjoy your husband while you can. Do not report to his sisters what you’re doing in that regard. Their denial is likely to continue. They almost certainly will be of no help. Accept that and move on.

I’m very sorry. We like to think we can count on family, but that isn’t always the case.
Helpful Answer (9)
Reply to Fawnby
Report
Goddatter Sep 27, 2025
Wow. Your Rude Aunt and my older sister… Sister - who spoke to our mother once per year by phone - told me our mother didn’t have dementia, she was just bored and lonely. Just… wow, the obliviousness of the uninvolved!
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
Tell them to come visit and care for the man for a week and see the reality of his diagnosis, for crying out loud!

Nobody should be talking about Alzheimer's with your husband ANYWAY. Why beat a dead horse? Limit the sisters phone calls if necessary, or tell them to visit their brother in person. Then you can talk to them once and for all. Seeing is believing.
Helpful Answer (8)
Reply to lealonnie1
Report

I am assuming you spoke to them about his diagnosis. Other than to tell them they are causing him harm, and said harm may result in further confusion and earlier needs for in-facility care, for which THEY will be responsible, there is little else that you can say. Assuming you have a diagnosis and can prove that he has this disorder, his medical team's diagnosis should negate their denial if they have any "capacity" to understand.

I don't know the level your husband is at, nor even how much their input affects him, or over how much time, and nor do I know other than phone calls, how much contact they have with him. Nor do you explain what the result of a conversation with
"sisters" results in. So there's little else to do other than wish you the best of luck.

Almost certainly, given a person's long ability to confabulate, and sometimes even to fool doctors, the sisters aren't seeing "the real deal here" and their skepticism may be warranted. Surely do wish you the best of luck.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to AlvaDeer
Report

Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter