We moved in with my MIL when my DIL passed. She makes it very hard on me to live there. Any advice?

Sounds like MIL is a pro at emotional blackmail using Fear, Obligation and Guilt. Has she always treated you the way you describe. If so, then she might have a personality disorder.

Your husband took the vows of marriage which among other things also means to put you before all others which includes his mother. For the sake of his mother and your marriage, she needs to go to an assisted living and the two of you live together again like a married couple should.

Sorry to write so bluntly, but this is a common theme on this site where an adult child has made a promise to a parent and the keeping of that promise is wrecking their marriage. Sounds like you and your husband need to have a very serious heart to heart discussion about your marriage, your future, and your MIL.

Kim, has your husband ever been to look at an assisted living facility? Most of them are like 4 star resorts. Your father in law was probably thinking about the old institutional settings of the 60s and 70s. Find a facility nearby and take a tour. This might change his mind. Hugs!

You have done the right thing, and hopefully he will come to his senses. Yes she is putting on acts of neediness to get her way. This is pretty common in early dementia, but you have to walk away from it. She needs Assisted Living, where she will play with people her own age. Leaving him with the full burden may help him realize what she is doing.

@cmagnum: YES, YES and YES!!! You are soo right about everything!

Thank you all. My MIL does gave Lupus but she won't do what the dr tells her to do and she is not honest with us on how she feels. My husband I have been married 31 years.

Lupus? Well, she's not putting on then, is she. And, yes, that makes a difference. The key difference it makes is that the death-bed promise your husband made to his father was unusually foolish. It was given under duress, and took no account of your MIL's predictable future needs.

WHY do people do this? What is it about leave-taking that makes people detach completely from truth-telling and reality? Perhaps when I get there I'll understand, but for now… it beats me.

Be that as it may, it was a promise your husband made to your father. Your husband now has to examine it and decide whether he feels obliged to keep it. The factors he needs to take into account are his mother's welfare, and whether he will be able to ensure it living alone with her (he won't); his marriage, and whether he is prepared to sacrifice it to the unfeasible goal of ensuring his mother's happiness (if he is, he will be breaking his promise to you, of course - he's all right with that one, is he?); and the consequences of breaking his promise to his father, which is a matter of internal soul-searching - would he be able to accept the necessity, what would be the likely impact on him of breaking it?

Essentially, he has made two mutually exclusive vows. He has to sort out which has more wriggle room.

Can you help him with this? Can you help him, specifically, by moving back to share his mother's house with him? Well, you could try setting out conditions and gaining agreement to them from both your husband and your MIL. But given your MIL's likely progression, there is a limit to what change in her behaviour you can expect. And given that you've already been driven to walk out once, how much, realistically, can you be expected to take?

I sound harsh on your husband, I know. I feel harsh, and I'm venting. He made this absurd promise without pause for thought and you are suffering the consequences. In due course, so will his mother suffer because her needs will be too onerous for him, or for him and you together, to manage. He has been a noble idiot; other people are paying the price; and you're the one who's feeling the guilt for this?

I'm sorry, but this is all on him. Get him to look you in the eye and come up with a real-life plan.

I know exactly what you are going through. My husband and I have been married over 40yrs. and he's always been all about his parents. We have always lived close to them so he has always delt with them and their problems on a daily basis. After his Dad passed about 20 yrs. ago, he always goes by his mother's before work and first thing when he gets off before he comes home. This past week, he spent night and day with her (she's 92, can barely get around with her walker, and no short term memory) and finally gave up to put her in a NH two days ago. His crazy hoarder sister that the home health nurses turned in for elder abuse had moved in about 2yrs. ago to be her caregiver full time. Anyway, it has been really ugly the past few days. After he had to spend 24hrs. a day in that nasty mess of a house crazy sister had created and take his Mom to the bathroom about once every hr. and fix her meals, he finally figured out that it was NH time. I had already made up my mind and told my two boys, that if he chose to quit his job and stay with his Mom, it was time for me to go my separate way and get on with my life. They agreed and I guess had a talk with him. He put her in a really nice home, had to get POA and an order of protection against crazy sister who tried to kidnap her from the home the very first day. Anyway, long story short, when it all comes down to him having to take care of everything without your help, it probably won't take long for him to decide to come back home. Good luck with the situation. I can totally identify with always playing second fiddle to Mom and her needs and it isn't fun! Wives should come before parents.

You seem to be the cup that runeth over in you MIL's eyes,,Your husband made a promise to his late father I get that, but what about the promises that he made to you first. He is your husband and needs to act like one, you seriously need to put your foot down here and come up with a better plan of care here. First you and him need to discuss the situation and make your husband see your side of the coin here. He promised not to put her in a home but that didn't necessarily mean to put his marriage in jeopardy. So first you give him your demands as to how you want this resolved and be strong about it no "if's or but's" here. Then the mother has to be approached and whether it is both of you or just your husband doing it she has to made to understand that you have a place within this situation and she either likes it or lumps it. It's good that you have a go to place to be able to get away from the animosity. I so dearly wish you all the best of luck, sounds like you are going to need it and make sure that all of your feeling's are put out there. Best of luck to you.

Moving in with someone else is always tricky. It might be hard to get them to move in with you, but then it is YOUR home, not THEIR home. I think she will always see it as hers. The other option is to get her into an apartment close to where you live so that you can eat meals with her, spend time with her, check on her, etc...

Realistically, though, even if she would have moved-in with you, I think she'd be a problem. She probably was truly lonely and depressed but that doesn't mean she'll appreciate your efforts. Helping someone does not necessarily bring appreciation.

You are not the one who deserted her. Your husband choosing to honor an agreement made with his Father (out of guilt) is wrong. He deserted you by not standing up for you and setting boundaries. I know we all have guilt. I live with my Mom (talk about critical and difficult). I am going to look into LTC because I can't continue to do this, and my brother refuses to contribute in any way re assistance.