Follow
Share

My mom will be 94 next week. She still lives in her condo apartment and is in relatively good health, except for arthritis aches and pains. She is legally blind and uses a walker but is quite independent and social.

Ever since she stopped driving at age 75, I've been her main "go to" person for grocery shopping, appointments, etc., as well as caring for her emotional needs. My brother does help out occasionally. I am self-employed and have a very hectic schedule.

Mom has always been an impatient, demanding woman and has become worse in the past couple of years. She has started to get more confused and doing some troublesome things, like freaking out if I don't answer the phone right away. The other day, I was in our swimming pool. The phone was inside. She called four times with a half hour. When I returned her call, she said she was worried that I was sick. She called my brother, who lives 20 minutes away, and told him to come to my house to check if I was okay. Fortunately, I was able to reach him to tell him I was okay.

This is not the first time mom has freaked out like this when I haven't immediately returned her phone calls. I suspect some dementia is setting in. I notice that she's getting a bit more confused, too.

Mom has said a couple of times that she wishes I called her every day, because some of her friends' children do that. She says she gets "lonely." Meanwhile, my sister calls every Sunday, my brother calls one a week, my niece visits her almost every Monday, I call Mondays and Thursdays and usually take her grocery shopping every Friday. Plus, she plays cards every night with the people in her building and goes out to lunches and other functions almost every week, so I'm not understanding why she's "lonely."

I really don't want to commit to calling her every day, for a few reasons, but most of all, because if I don't call her every day on time, she'll flip out and worry. As I said, I run a business and it requires me to be on the road every day, I also have battled anxiety for years and it would be just too much for me to deal with her drama on a daily basis. Certainly, I am always there for her if she needs anything, but calling every day would be absolutely too much for me to handle.

She's been on the list for assisted living for four years. I think she'd be much happier, less needy, and less "lonely" if she were in such an environment.

Anyone else dealing with a similar situation? Am I being selfish?

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
Lol Cat me too!
Thankfully we're all different which means we can meet different needs.
Personally I am the kind of woman who'd have loved to have children, I couldn't so I raised other people's privately & as my career. Problem solved :~) Though I still have my "feminist moments" :~)
I believe that unless we're choosing to deliberately damage others or the planet, then we should be free to live our own style of life as far as possible, within the confines of our society. You shouldn't need to apologise for not having a nurturing nature & wanting to have contact boundaries. I shouldn't need to apologise for having a nurturing nature & wanting contact boundaries.
Rejoice in our differences, celebrate our similarities and stay as safe in ourselves as we can! For me that's the way to go :~)
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

@LucyCW: Also a good point. I am not really a nurturing person, even though I am kind and compassionate, if that makes sense. I'm mostly a feminist and have always had a career, so mom has trouble relating to me and my lifestyle sometimes. She waited on my dad hand and foot. I remember at the dinner table all he needed to do was point at the salt and pepper shakers and she'd hand them to him. Whereas, if my husband did that, I'd ask him if his arms were painted on. LOL
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Sadly for us Cat, your Mum's generation see men not as equal to us but Demi Gods to be worshipped & adored or overgrown children who need cossetting in case they over stretch themselves.
Where as women "the weaker sex" (lol) in men's eyes of that generation, run homes and look after their man/men.
It's frustrating but too late to expect them to understand equality :~(
You're doing a grand job though :~)
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Oh, I think you're totally right, Linda. Mom worked at home as a seamstress, so she was able to run our household on a strict schedule: Mondays, laundry and ironing. Fridays, housework. Saturdays, grocery shopping as soon as the stores opened at 9 a.m. Sundays, church and visits with family. Meanwhile, our generation does household chores when and if we get around to it. So, yes, it's always been difficult for mom to change her regimen to suit my schedule.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Cat, I don't know if your mom worked outside the home while raising a family, but I think a lot of our ongoing issues are because our moms can't relate to the juggling act we do. Errands were fun and an outing to them, to us, they are a drudge that we try to consolidate and reduce. Appointments were made without thought to getting time off, and schedules for shopping, laundry and such were set in stone. We, on the other hand, throw in a load as we run off to tend to something else.

Yet another aspect of generational differences colliding.

As I asked my mom to adapt her usual routine and I adapted mine, I explained it as "helping me to be able to help her". So calmly, decoratively tell her that while you can still take her shopping etc., you'll need to do it on your schedule.

And yes, I've wondered if I had a brother if he wouldn't have gotten a pass on helping.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Thanks all, for your input. What I've learned from your comments is that I need to establish boundaries (which I have) and stick to them. It is difficult, though, when mom has a hissy fit when, for example, I say I can take her grocery shopping on a Thursday instead of a Friday. She would also prefer to go shopping first thing in the morning, but I usually can't be there until noon because I work in the mornings. This has always bugged her, but I have a job. She always has to be at her doctors' appointments a half hour early. If I happen to be 5 or 10 minutes late picking her up at the appointed time (when there is still lots of time to get to the doctor's office), she freaks out. This is what I deal with constantly. So funny that when my brother takes her places she treats him with respect and never gives him a hard time. And he's retired, so he has much more time to deal with mom's needs.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

I am the go to person for my 102 year old mother and she does not have dementia or alzheimers (she remembers everything). She has been in an assisted living facility for about 3 months because she is frail and needs help with her daily needs. There are caregivers available 24 hours a day if she needs assistance with anything. Needless to say she is very demanding and if she wants something outside her home, I am expected to get it asap. If she has made a doctor's appointment on a day I have other plans, I am expected to cancel them.. I can't put my life on hold to help her with her daily so I have set boundaries for her to follow. Each week I put my schedule on her calendar, which she needs to work around and I visit her once a week. She has always been a social person and her facility has something for her to do every hour of everyday and there is no reason for her to be lonely. She is difficult to be around because "nothing" makes her happy, and I find myself treating her as though she was a child.
No it is not awful of you to not to phone your mother everyday. If you set some boundaries for her to follow, life will be much better for you.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

I understand completely how you feel. I have been the sole caregiver for my mom since my dad passed 27 years ago. My husband and I bought the house across the street from mom the year after my dad passed. Mom hasn't needed a lot of help until the last 8 years or so. I have to say, it is sometimes "all consuming". I also work full time as an IT specialist for the State, so I work on average 50 hours a week. I still call and/or go over to see mom now every day. Yes she is demanding, a drama queen, a hypochondriac, and very selfish at times. However, she has also been through breast cancer twice, back surgery, a partial knee replacement on one leg, and a full knee replacement surgery on the other knee, which ended up being 3 surgery's in 4 months time because of osteoporosis and broken bones. She had to spend 8 months in a rehab facility. Do I like having to deal with her attitude (which is awful most of the time as she has been dealing with depression for many, many, many years), her drama and her countless demands? absolutely not... but I don't see any other choice. Thankfully my husband is very supportive and doesn't complain that I have to spend so much time taking care of mom. Two weeks ago I went for a walk after work (my exercise and stress reliever). while I was out walking for 45 minutes, mom called my phone 8 times and left me 4 very nasty messages because I didn't come right over after work and get her trash for her. Wow... needless to say, I was not happy. She always apologizes later for her behavior, but the apologies get old. I'm 50 years old now.. I want a life too... but I just cannot stop caring for her. No one else will, and I sure cannot live with that either. The only advise I can give is hang in there, give yourself a break as often as you can.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Garden, Glad, Country, when my parents were well they were very polite. They knew instinctively when to call and always let you off the hook if you were busy. How lucky was I? They even frowned on the intrusive behavior of some of the parents of my friends. They are different people now due to dementia, ill health, loneliness, and isolation. Now dad calls nonstop some days and is very demanding. He wants it now! Mom is super needy, child like, helpless, and hungry for company. I'm trying so hard to keep them happy which is impossible, and still work, sneak in a little fun, and rest. Thanks for letting me vent. You are the best!
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

One time she didn't speak right away. I'm ready to call 911 on my other phone, thinking the worst! Her response=I was getting situated! Scared the h##l out of me!
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

She's laying a guilt trip on you. DON'T let her! Let me tell you for about the last 3 yrs of my mother's life, I did call her every day; sometimes even more than once a day. A disaster! While I was speaking, she would be, too! I said "mother, it does not work when we both talk at the same time. So I'll talk first and now it's your turn." Response= silence! She clammed up like 5 y.o.!
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Countrymouse, that was a very good and yet sad example of the potential of just what the Demented mind goes through while trying to make heads or tails of their thinking process. I pray that it never happens to me! My own Grandmother was a blank Tape at the end of her life, although they did find a latent Syphilis result in a blood test after a very disconcerting episode in which she had an upsetting disagreement with my Mother ( my Grandmother immigrated from Wales, to live with my parents when I was 12 years old), and she went to her bed, stayed there for 3 straight days, and my parents sent her to the ER via cabulance, she stayed in hospital until she was Dx'd with Organic Brain Disease, the precursor to Alzheimer's back in those days and she then went to live in a Nursing Home, as it became way too much for my Mom who still had 2 kids left in the home, and she had cared for her for 7+ years, and had had enough! There were a lot of other mental issues going on with Gma, that just weren't evaluated and treated way back then, and of course, I was only a kid, and don't remember all of the details.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Cat, you need your time, too, and it sounds like you already have a schedule you can adhere to. I would offer this, however...set your boundaries but monitor the behavior in case it gets worse.

My Grandmother (who was in an assisted living facility) began doing this with my Father. After talking to her once or twice a day, he thought he was setting boundaries by not answering the phone anymore that day. My Grandmother would continue to call and leave messages, slowly spiraling into a very horrid state of panic and anger. None of us had any experience with dementia or any other brain disorder. But looking back on it now I can clearly see she should have been tested. I don't know, because of the lack of diagnosis, if her mental state could have been helped with medications, but I do know that the problem got worse, not better. So please, just be wary.

Hugs to you for being a great daughter!
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Where does this expectation and demand come from?

Well, let's face it, some people are like that - but they're not the issue so let's gratefully ignore them for once. The issue is to do with people who have been more or less normal and reasonable in their behaviour previously, but who are now turning into phone stalkers who freak out if you don't instantly answer the phone. What's going on with them?

Sit in a chair and imagine that you have an uneasy feeling that you should be somewhere else but you're not sure where. Your thinking skills don't seem to be working; as you might feel, for example, if you'd gone without sleep for 24 hours and then were shaken awake just after you'd dropped off - you'd seem to be alert but decision-making and information-processing? Fat chance. You think your memory's fine, and the gaps where information is missing are something that you are unaware of.The only location you can picture with any certainty is a house you definitely lived in sixty years ago. The only people you are completely confident you have a connection with are your mother and father, who must be around somewhere but you don't know where to look for them, and your children; those are the physiologically rooted bonds that go deep into the heart of your being. You have a sense of dread and you're not sure why, but something isn't right. You must consult someone. Who you gonna call?
Helpful Answer (9)
Report

Cinderella, yes, it starts with calling numerous times a day, it becomes calling five times in five minutes, twenty plus messages in your voicemail when you return from work. Eventually she will forget how to use the phone, or what a phone is.

It is lonliness, for now, but will become much more predominant as time goes on. Is she living at home? Maybe now is the time for her to move to assisted living, or independent living in a senior complex where she would have somebody else to talk to each day, activities, day trips....

If you see a move in your mom's future, when dementia is in the picture, the sooner the better. The adjustment will be far easier for her as she may have some sort of an idea where she is.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Cinderella, perhaps it's not a control issue but rather a loneliness issue? Your grown children have lives of their own and are presumably moving forward, not backward or standing still as are many elders.

Can your mother still drive? Go anywhere she wants? Work in her garden? Travel? Or is she limited by physical conditions? That physical mobility makes a big difference in the ability of someone to find her own interests and pursue them rather than turn to her family for companionship.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

My mother calls me constantly--but at the wrong number (for instance, my home number when I'm at work or on weekends, my work number but I'm home) and it makes no difference to the away message, she doesn't listen. Yesterday I came home to 3 messages starting at 8am until 5pm--on my home phone. Her messages start pleasant but as the day goes on and I don't call back (because I didn't know she called in the first place), her messages start getting anxious, then angry then begging me to call. But when I finally call back, its "just wanted to hear from you." Mind you, I call every day. Thing is, she doesn't remember I call now because of the Alzheimer's so really makes no difference if I call or not call. There is really nothing to say on a daily basis. I get up, go to work, come home, rinse, repeat mon-friday lol yeah that's sad. I can't really talk about work because she is incapable of holding a real conversation or following one. I am going away on vacation for 2 weeks for the first time in over 15 years. Even though I tell her i'll be away, I can't imagine the panic she will have. I will be out of the country so no, can't call on a daily basis. I'm hoping my father will catch her making the calls and remind her I'm not home.

Funny thing is she doesn't bother calling my brother lol

My own grown kids don't call or text me every day. I don't expect them to. Where does this expectation and demand come from with our mothers? I think its very controlling.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Yes, Trying and Cat, so true! It depends on the parent. Phone calls are not the best way to communicate with elderly parents who can barely hear and have dementia. I have to yell and they forget I called so I don't even get points for calling. Although it helps MY guilt for taking a day away. Also, they forget how to properly hang up the phone, so it remains off the hook for hours.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

I'm going to echo what so many others have said. It sounds like you are there for your Mom so you have no need to feel guilty.

Before my Mom was ever elderly I would call her everyday because she is extremely needy, sometimes I called twice a day. It was all drama and complaints. If I went a couple of days without calling she got nasty with me. Calling everyday REALLY too it's toll on me. Finally a counselor suggested I cut back to about three calls a week. Funny how we often feel the need for permission to take care of ourselves. Mom sulked for a long time but she eventually got used to it. Now that she is elderly and caring for my dad I call more often. I was back up to daily calls and it was too much. Now I take a day or two off a week but I do tell her ahead of time. If I know I have a long day ahead of me I tell her I will not be able to call until the next day. That seems to work.

I'm OK with calling as much as I do but that's the pattern I have always had. Now I keep the calls to just about ten minutes (they used to be much longer). I listen most of the time, Mom has never been very interested in what I am doing. I don't encourage her to go on and on but I do try to be supportive of her feelings. Sometimes the conversation is pleasant, those days I stay on the phone longer with her.

Each person is different and you must go with what you know is best for you. Your Mom has lots of support. You do your part, that's enough.

On another note, you said you suspect dementia might be setting in, maybe her increased neediness is a symptom of that?
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

@Carla: Thank you for that. This is exactly what I'm dealing with. My mom is "drama queen" to the max. My sister and I always joke that ma goes from 0 to 60 in one second. LOL
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

I think the question of whether a daily call is "a lot to ask" depends a lot on what your parent is like and what your relationship with her/him is like. My mother at this point can't make conversation about anything but her own needs and problems. I dread her calls because it's invariably some "emergency" that she wants me to take care of. Her anxiety is not about whether I'm all right. Her anxiety is about making sure that any issues that arise are immediately transferred to someone else for immediate action. Her calls invariably make me angry, anxious and agitated. Luckily I can forestall most of the "emergency" calls by stopping in almost daily (which also leaves me angry, anxious and agitated more often than not). So I totally relate to someone not wanting to call every day, especially if the parent does have that "drama queen" mentality.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

@gladimhere: Thanks for your comment. Mom says she's lonely during the daytime. She plays cards every night with the ladies in her building, so that keeps her occupied week nights. Meanwhile, she has caregivers come in every Monday and Friday morning, my niece usually visits every Monday at lunchtime. Either my brother or I take mom shopping once a week. I have suggested that if she's lonely, get a group of ladies together to have afternoon tea once or twice a week. She shot that idea down. Didn't give me a good reason. I can't be there in the afternoons because I work.

She has been on the list for assisted living for four years because we are trying to get her into a rent-subsidized place. To do that, you go on a waiting list. She could get into somewhere sooner if she chose more than one facility, but she's chosen only one that she likes. She refuses to see or consider other facilities. Hence the long wait. The other option is to get her into another facility where she'd have to pay $3,000 plus a month. We've been trying to avoid that up to now, for financial reasons.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Cat, your mom is lonely and bored. Perhaps there is assisted living that would be appropriate. Maybe she would get so busy she wouod forget to worry about you. Your mom has been on a wait list for assisted for four years?! Who are they calling when they have availability? Not mom I hope. If this wait list is for real it is time to find more communities.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Thanks so much, all, for your comments and support. I have to be very honest and say that I've never felt comfortable in the role of caregiver to my mother. There's a reason why I decided I never wanted to have children, and that's because I didn't want the responsibility. Now I have taken on the responsibility of caring for mom. I do love her, don't get me wrong, and I try to accommodate her every whim, but it's so difficult to deal with her impatience, weekly freak-outs and her treating me like her personal servant.

About the calling every day thing: I doubt if she's asked my brother and sister to call her more often. It's just ME she wants to talk to every day, and that's a lot of pressure for someone like me who has anxiety. I do think it's time for assisted living very soon.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

In my experience with aging parents, my in-laws, elders get lonely and there is never enough contact from their point of view. If you've never spoken with your mom on a daily basis it's going to take a lot out of you to make the small talk that those phone calls inevitably become. You do not sound like a selfish person. Caregivers need to manage our parents' expectations. Some will say that calling every day is a small thing. I disagree. If speaking with your mother every day is going to increase your stress then how is that going to make things better?
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

Setting reasonable limits with a truly needy loved one is not easy. But do something you can live with. Maybe a call every day before your or her bedtime would work. Pick a time that is not too hectic for you and feel free to keep it short and sweet, emphasis on short if it can't be sweet.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

Cat your being a terrific daughter and you need to be good to you too.
My M used to beg a daily call too, then it got to be twice a day "So I can say goodnight." Pretty soon it would have built up to me never being off the phone!
My widowed BIL is now starting the same pattern.
My advice is to reassure her the days/times you'll call. On the time give yourself a leeway for events. Mum I'll call you Monday between 9 and 10. If I don't call, don't worry because it just means I'm in the middle of something & I'll call as soon as I'm free.
BTW it's lovely to read of folks who so miss loving parents & would dearly relish 1 more call. Sadly we don't all get that relationship and calls bring grief, pain, anger, lack of self worth and a whole bag more of not feeling good.
Helpful Answer (11)
Report

You're not being selfish, no, but you might like just to check that you're satisfied (YOU are satisfied, note) with your boundaries. I totally agree that you have to have some! - especially as your mother's overreactions cause you anxiety that you really don't need on top of your daily routine - but don't let her distorted sense of proportion infect your own.

I suppose what I'm thinking of specifically is this request from her that you call her once a day. Would that actually be too much? - feel free to say yes it would, but I must admit that to me, not having to do it any more, that doesn't sound like a lot to ask. You would have to add some riders, true, such as that you may not be able to call her every day, but that you will let her know if you can't and she is to make a note of it -

Actually, what you could do is have a dedicated answer phone for her so that you could record reminders on it. Anyway.

- so that she doesn't freak out on those days when you can't call. And for the not wanting a daily litany of troubles, you keep the conversations very much within bounds, and as soon as they turn into poor me tales you say "well lots of love, I have to go now, speak to you tomorrow" and ruthlessly detach yourself.

But above all please yourself. The reason I make these suggestions is *only* that YOU don't seem to be comfortable with how things are, and that's the aim. Best of luck.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Not all elderly parents call their adult children every day and I'm glad they don't. I would make me feel like I am their "eternal" little child.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Oh, I forgot to add. I wouldn't feel bad or guilty about not wanting to call her everyday. It's not a morality thing. I don't see anything to feel guilty over. It's your feelings and you have a right to them.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter