Follow
Share

I pay my caretakers $25 an hour when I go back to my apartment for a long day in NY. There are two and they split the time. I haven't had a vacation in 6 years and want to attempt an overnight. I know when I interviewed someone last year (and I never used them) they said they'd charge $150 for an overnight. I don't know if my caretaker will expect me to pay her $25 an hour for an overnight. Should I offer her the $150?

Find Care & Housing
Mine was $160 per night just so I could SLEEP. His getting up in the middle of the night just about killed me! That was over $3000 per month just to sleep like a normal human being. 😴
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Caregiveronce
Report
BurntCaregiver Dec 17, 2025
@Caregiveronce

You were paying way too much. He could have been medicated at night to prevent getting up or wandering.
(2)
Report
Speaking as a person who was a homecare for 25 years (both agency-hired and private-pay) and now a homecare business owner, here is how you determine what you pay an overnight caregiver.

What do the caregivers actually have to do for you? Do your care needs require them to be up all night? If such is the case then what you're paying them now ($25 an hour) is more than enough for a their services.

Are you a person who really just needs someone in your apartment at night so you're not alone? Or maybe they get up once or twice a night to assist you with toileting? If such is the case, then you basically should have a 'Sleep Duty' aide. You pay by the shift for the overnight (not an hourly) and you don't even have to pay minimum wage. Sleep Duty aides get paid like hairdressers and waitstaff in a restaurant. They are not paid minimum wage. This $150 a night is absolutely ridiculous for this kind of aide.

What you expect from your overnight aides is what determines what you pay them. You're paying privately so you have a lot of choices available to you. Put up a profile on a caregiver site like care.com and explain exactly what your needs are and state that the pay is negotiable. You will get a lot of responses and will find what you're looking for. Good luck.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to BurntCaregiver
Report

Basically, with caregivers, they charge what they charge. While your thinking may be that there is usually little to do at night, night work is harder on a worker in every way. Many of them do two jobs, and many of them have children or duties that can only be done during the day, hindering their ability to rest adequately. As an RN who spent my last years doing night shift 12 hours three days a week I am well aware how difficult it can be to get good sleep for enough hours during the day. My being on my feet so much more gave me quite the case of Plantar Fasciitis.

So basically, as with the cost of anything, the price is what it is, and you as the consumer are left with two choices: pay or don't have the "item".
You surely can speak to the caregiver. But I don't know that your arguments would work, no matter; the price is what it is.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to AlvaDeer
Report
BurntCaregiver Dec 17, 2025
@Alva

I did overnight aide work and also did 'Sleep Duty' aide as well. In a homecare setting night care is not harder than day work. In fact, it is usually easier because the care client goes to bed. Most of the time if they are a dementia wanderer, they're medicated at night. No aide is hired to follow a demented person around all night so they can wander. Most overnight homecare work is toileting a couple times, changing a diaper, or repositioning. There is no bathing, dressing, feeding, entertaining, and housekeeping involved like there is for the homecare day shift.

It really doesn't matter how many jobs the aide works, if they have children, or what their story is. The price is not the price when you're hiring and paying privately. The price is what you negotiate it to be. $150 a night is outrageous for a 'Sleep Duty' aide if that is what the OP is in need of. Even with the cost of everything today.

Being a homecare aide in a client's house in the overnight is very different than working in a hospital or a nusing home. You're dealing with one person not a whole floor.
(0)
Report
Out of curiosity, Will the care giver be expected to be awake the entire shift and perform care duties for the majority of time or are thay only acting as a person to an on call situation?

If the caregiver is able to rest or even sleep a flat rate to equal minimum wage would be offered and negociate as needed if care is required.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to AMZebbC
Report
BurntCaregiver Dec 17, 2025
@AMZebbC

If it's a 'Sleep Duty' aide position you don't even have to pay minimum wage. Sleep Duty aides are like hairdressers or waitstaff.
(0)
Report
My client has 7 caregivers 24/7 in his home. Overnight caregivers are paid the same as daytime. There is less physical work but the requirement to stay awake is difficult because the spouse wants no lights, no electronics and no talking.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to Tanti65
Report

We’ve all been there! 😜
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to LoopyLoo
Report

Just wanted to ask, have you become an employer? There's rules about how much you can pay per year, over that you must become an employer. You're hiring privately so I'm just concerned that you could be in trouble. I wanted to hire a person for my mother until I found out this information and didn't want to go through all the paperwork with taxes and such. I hope everything is in order and you get your much needed rest!
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to JuliaH
Report

Did you hire the caregivers privately or do they work for an agency? That will determine a lot of the cost.
If you have hired them privately ask them what they would charge you for an overnight.

I also think the cost might depend on how much care you need.
Also figure in that you will be paying them for the travel, food, lodging as well as the hourly rate.
(By the way was that $150.00 per hour or was that for the night say from 7PM until 7 AM?)
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to Grandma1954
Report
TakeFoxAway Aug 29, 2025
Privately.
There is absolutely no care from 9 at night until breakfast time around 8:30 in the morning.
I don't want to ask them because they don't know and will probably just say $25 an hour.
No the $150 was for overnight. 9p to 9a. That is what another caregiver I interviewed but didn't use was charging.
Thank you!
(0)
Report
Overnight care rates really vary, and it’s smart you’re checking before offering. In New York, overnight caregivers usually make about $17 an hour on average (roughly $200 for 12 hours), but a lot of families go with a flat overnight rate instead of hourly. Most commonly, that’s in the range of $120–$200 per night for a 10–12 hour stay.

So the $150 you mentioned is actually right in line with what’s typical. I’d just have an open chat with your caregiver, maybe saying something like:
‘This is my first overnight break in years, and I’d like your help. I was thinking $150 for the 12 hours — does that sound fair to you?’

That way it’s clear, respectful, and you both know what to expect. And honestly — after 6 years without a vacation, you definitely deserve this time.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to TenderStrength5
Report

Don’t know but the autocorrect in the title is kinda funny…

Wait, does she take a 12 hour sh!ts?
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to LoopyLoo
Report
TakeFoxAway Aug 29, 2025
OMG!!!!!! Holy moly. I did not see that!!! It's too late to edit it.
(2)
Report
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter