Follow
Share

This weekend i got the surprise of my life. MY FIL and MIL were here for a short visit - they live 1000 miles away. My husband has always had a stressful relationship with them - no matter that we are in our 50's - they come, feel like they can criticize all that we do, that we don't know anything - expect us to change when we eat, what we eat, wait on them hand and foot - completely take over. We have full time professional careers that they criticize, opinions that they criticize, parenting skill that they criticize. We have set boundaries but they still try to get us to knuckle under each and every visit "We are your parents, you should......" I am usually wild by the time they leave after 48 hours.


ANYWAY - the last day of their visit over lunch - before DH took them to the airport - they mentioned that they want us to consider buying a larger house (with their financial help) and that we move in together. They want to see more of our son as they age and then as they age, we can help them.


I was stunned. DH said "we'd think about it" and then we got into a huge fight when he came back from the airport. He has absolutely no experience with caregiving. when my dad was at home and i did respite care - my DH was not there. Not to see the decline, the combativeness, the incontinence, the meals thrown on the floor - the constant doctor appointments for hours at a time, the constant getting up a night. The stress and exhaustion that you all know so well. I was wrung out after just a weekend - imagine my step mom who did this for five years!


I feel they should buy into a continuing care community - where they start out with independent living, gradually add services for assisted living, then finally skilled nursing and memory care. They won't consider this because they expect their children to care for them (even though FIL's own mom went into a continuing care facility).


My DH is in his own fantasy world - picturing the Walton's existence, three generations around the dinner table enjoying each other & him finally having the good relationship with them that he never has. In reality - they complain about what we cook and use the dinner table to criticize what we do, how we live, how we raise our son, our opinions, etc. I can't believe he is seriously wanting us to do this.


We can't get along now with them. What about as they age and need more hands on help? it will be ME they expect to drop my job to take them on round after round of doctor appointments, clean for them, cook for them, etc. because i am a woman. My DH disappears when they get on his nerves and i have to deal with them.


Yet - we have fought about this several times since Sunday. He feels I'm "abandoning" his parents by not wanting to consider living with them. He won't look at this website to gain experience, or talk to co-workers going through this, or counseling about this, or listen to my step mom's experience with my dad.


I am going to see a counselor on my own. I have told DH that this is a deal breaker - i WILL NOT live with them. Have any of you dealt with a spouse with his head in the clouds? How do i get him to at least start asking about the experience of others? He wants me to try. My counter point is that this is awfully expensive and disruptive to "try" as we will never be able to unwind this fiasco - so research now. We are at an impasse. Thank you!

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
1 2 3
This is a great question with great answers. I read, thinking I could drop by with some help. Instead, Kimber has it all handled, came back to give updates, and I learned alot.
Thanks for being there, everyone.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Wow, Kimber, you and your DH both did great with your in-laws on this visit. You really had your ducks in a row, and got on the same page together so that your in-laws couldn't drive a wedge between the two of you. It is amazing, as you say, that the in-laws are over 80 and have not yet started talking about how they'd like to handle their old age. I guess the belief (however unfounded) that family will step in and make the whole problem go away can lull people into a false sense of security. Hopefully you and your husband lit a fire under their backsides with your responses to them on this trip. Good for you!
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

We went to see InLaws over Easter and it was a good visit - overall. My nine year old helped grandpa take down and re-build a trellis for honeysuckle - both like tools - so it was fun for both. We saw family, we went out for lunch, we went exploring local museums etc.

Interesting - my FIL initiated a conversation with us about aging and what he was considering (assisted living etc) but as soon as my FIL started talking about this, my MIL shut him down "I'm not ready to talk about this!!!" almost screamed it out. It seems he is willing to consider some kind of senior living arrangement for more help when they need it for laundry, cooking, bathing etc. but my MIL is NOT.

My MIL had a private conversation with me that was a bit sad - she wanted me to say that she could live with us if she survives FIL. She refuses to consider any type of living other than their current house or ours. "I'm not going to some old people's home where they have stupid craft activities". She mentioned that she knows nothing of their finances except the bank name on the checks she writes for groceries and therefore I imagine she is afraid.

During the visit she kept harping on us about how small our house was and that our son needed more room (the kid has a bed room and a year round porch off his room and the run of the house and yard and he needs more room??) or that we need to host an exchange student sometime (WTF??) and she kept on my about retiring at 50 - so many children of her friends are retiring at 50 and they spend all kinds of time together and live together.

It came out during the private meeting that she is hoping (expecting) to live with us if she survives FIL. While i listened and empathized I told her as gently as i could that i was planning to work until 67 - the new retirement age - and that is almost 20 years, especially to get son through college and save for retirement. I also told her that while DH and I would help her find some place if she no longer could live in their house - that we were not planning on having anyone live with us.

Our house is paid off, the commute for all three of us is reasonable, and we plan on using any extra money for son's school and our retirement, not buying a larger house anywhere else.

I mentioned that our financial planner has people that could help her manage her funds if she survives FIL. That while we would not abandon her - we would not be taking over for FIL to make the decisions and have her live with us.

Overall she took it pretty well - THEN. She thinks i'm a softer touch than DH. She cried and said that we all (two sons and two DIL) going to throw her to the curb. I let her cry it out and reminded her that we would certainly help her. I also suggested that she start to picture surviving FIL and what that might mean for learning about their finances and thinking about living arrangements. That we would be happy to talk with her any time about her fears and concerns and what we might jointly find for her locally for senior services. She wouldn't talk about it any more. Then.

So she pulled DH aside the next day when DS and I were sent on an errand - and ripped into him. DH is smart - he called FIL into the room and told them they need to get on the same page for their elder planning as they obviously were not. THEN, they need to plan survivorship in each case, both FIL and MIL each as the surviving spouse. That while we would be around and would help -that we were not in a position to take someone in. This diverted FIL and MIL who started to have a fight with each other. He accusing her of always wanting someone to take care of her and she accusing him of making all the decisions without consulting her. Their same battle as long as i have known them.

The next day we came home. Aunt from old country called this morning to chew out DH but he politely said "MIL and FIL are not on same page - this is for them to resolve, not me" and hung up.

Interesting developments. I do think it is scary that they are over 80 and have not talked to each other about aging. Do they want to live at home and bring in care? Have they researched what is available locally for seniors? Would they consider assisted living at some point? etc. We will offer help researching or getting them into contact with local social workers, in fact - other DL is a social worker for the elderly in their area - she is a source of information but they are not talking to her.

More as the world turns in the next few months i am sure.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

K not that you like doing windows but rather that the ILs need to be done and you’re the one!
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

My nine-year old loves to help (bless him) and we did the windows before the in-laws Thanksgiving visit - i love the new windows that bend in for cleaning!! He proudly announced that he cleaned the windows. And made the cranberry sauce from scratch.

That probably gave them the idea that i like doing windows. They admired how clear the view was. My DH said "oh, i don't know. I miss the soft Italianate light filtered through dusty windows". Maybe we can say the light is softer if the window is dirty?
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Actually the least you can do is nothing as my English teacher Mom used to say;) and you’re happy to do nothing re windows just like in laws.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Great job Kimber, you picked a man to marry and father your children. I bet your buttons pop when he stands up for you.

Wow, you owe your in-laws, they are toxic, I would never leave my child alone with anyone who belittles him in any way shape or form. Just my opinion. I would think about what transpired from your husband taking them to airport alone. They obviously have zero respect for you, or that conversation about house sharing would have included you. Protect your son, narsisists know no age boundaries. Sounds like a divide and conquer tactic, dad works on DH and grandma works on dear son, while mom is being degraded. IMHO.

Can't wait to hear how Easter plays out. By the way, Honor thy Father and Mother is about respect, Bible also says we leave father and mother and become one with our spouse, also says what God has joined together let no man put asunder. I love my Gods word and hate when people use it to be manipulating and bullying.

Ask for scripture reference, chapter and verse to help you understand when uncle uses it to belittle your DH. Maybe he will see how destructive using Gods word that way is and stop.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Kimber over the Easter lunch you have GOT to have George Formby on as background music "... if you could see what I could see, when I'm cleaning windows!"
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

It’s like you have opened the door for your husband to stand up to his parents. And husband is enjoying the practice!! Come on dad, pitch me another one and let me see how hard I can hit it back. He is a fast learner. Now schedule yourself a massage since you have a volunteer babysitter lined up for that time slot. I love this thread.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

And for the price of a few rounds of golf, someone could be hired to clean those windows! Your hubby is a gem!
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

It was funny to see my thread come back to life. We are visiting my inlaws over Easter. They have told my husband that they expect me to clean the windows on the Saturday before Easter - all of the windows on a 2 story house - that haven't been cleaned the eight years they have lived there. It is the "least i can do" - somehow they think I owe them. [my InLAWs have always tried to get others to do things for them for free] While i'm cleaning the windows - my FIL/DH are supposed to go golfing & my MIL will take my son to the playground.

My DH said "no way in hell is she cleaning your windows. Your windows - your problem. if you can swing a golf club, you can swing a paper towel with Windex. We'll do it together" and his dad said "no" - housework is women's work. So my DH said NO.

I'm glad he stuck up for me. But we'll hear about it with all of the relatives over for Easter dinner how we (me) refuse to help elderly parents in failing health. I usually just smile and pretend i'm not listening and DH pushes back hard.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Invite them to buy a house in the neighborhood - but don't live together as you will either go insane or divorce your DH.

When my own father suggested living with us as he didn't have long to live - - - I told him, You have too long to live to live with us.  And yes, he lived another 25 years.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Kimber, Wow you and your husband handled that like champs! Thank you for sharing your experience.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

I am so thrilled to hear the outcome of your story, Kimber. I can imagine the discussion that went on at your in-laws' before these discussions. "We certainly don't want to end up in a nursing home like FIL's mother." "So, let's move in with son and DIL, and DIL can retire early and tend to us." "Great idea! Let's call them up and tell them about it!" It's so common for aging parents to think they can decide what they want to have happen and the kids will just go along with it, regardless of the consequences for their kids' lives. It's so hard to row against the tide of those expectations, I know from experience. It's so great that you and your husband could get on the same page about this, and that you got it figured out before decisions or promises were made that would be hard to back out of later. So many of us get swept along with the tide and don't realize what a huge mistake we've made until we realize we're drowning. It's so great to hear a success story for once!
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Your DH saying he'd think about it is not the same as agreeing. But it did forestall any more arguments from his parents.

If I was held accountable every time I said I'd think about it - - - suffice it to say, that is my standard answer if I know I'm not going to do something that is suggested to me.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Well done Kimber! And you must be so proud of your husband!
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Good for you and your husband, Kimber. Your in-laws have options still and need to plan for their care. It's lovely when family can do the caregiving, but very few families can do so without hardship. We thought taking care of FIL would be easier than it turned out to be and ended up having to move him into a facility after two years because his dementia and immobility reached the point we could not meet his needs. He never asked us to sell our house or stop working, though. Such major changes would have disrupted your lives in ways you would have regretted. You and your husband made a sound decision for all involved.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Stick to your guns, my parents moved in with me for two months and the friendly fun only lasts for about two weeks and then it was a disaster. They were telling us what to cook, what to do, blasting the TV on super high and taking over the house. I came home from work and thought I was loosing my mind. The TV was blasting as my dad was sitting in the living room and my mom on the table overwhelming me with everything she wanted me to do. I was losing it and feeling I had no space for myself. Yes, I care about them but from those two months, I realized I had my head in the clouds and could never never live with them. they bickered constantly, they shoved their opinions around and I was shocked at how overwhelmed I was. Stick to your guns, he has not clue what it will look like. Do not accept money to buy in --trust me it is a trap and if they want to see your son take him to lunch. Hope this helps
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Kimber, you and your husband's responses should be an example to many about the way to set boundaries. Excellent!!
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Way to go, Kimber!!! My husband's parents long term care plan was moving to our state and my husband and his brother (read THEIR WIVES) would "step up". Because I work part time, the assumption was that I would take time off UNPAID to help them. When my husband took them to tour assisted living near us (she has parkinson's/cancer in remission and he was stroke/cancer survivor with late state copd), they got mad and bought a house near his brother 65 miles away. By the way, MIL is now in SNF due to her parkinson's and an old promise from my husband when he was a teenager to never put her in a home was invoked MANY MANY TIMES.. I told my husband at the time that if she moved in, I moved out. She is still 65 miles away in SNF.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Kimber, I'm smiling as I write this. Your updated post is so heartwarming, and so welcoming, that your husband stood up to his father and made his position clear. You have a strong husband.

I was shuddering a bit though as I thought of how the family developed the scenario and just expected you and your husband to accept it.

I'm so happy for both of you that the attempt to change your lives and force you into home care was thwarted, and that you made a stand against the assumptive and overbearing relatives.

Congratulations!
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

Well - they came for Thanksgiving. They arrived on Wednesday - and we went to my son's school for his presentation. Thursday we all enjoyed the meal and walks. Thursday night they wanted to talk about the living together and "how we could make it work".

My DH has had alot of time to think since the blow ups previously and he stated politely and quietly "we have paid off our house, it is in a great location for our work commutes, and we like it. We are not moving"

Then I asked them what they were assuming would happen when we lived together. We found out that since I'm early 50's - that once i reached 55 I'd likely stop working and then would be available if they needed help - to the dr, etc. So i politely told them that i had no intention of stopping working at 55 - that i loved my career, that we needed to save for retirement and our son's college. In short - i could not afford to leave.

They expressed a lot of disappointment but it was not vitriolic. Later i found out my FIL had pulled my husband aside and asked him to promise to take care of MIL and "never put her in the nursing home". Bless my DH - he told his dad that that was a promise he couldn't make, that he saw how grandma needed nursing home care and how my dad needed nursing home care - that we were not full time nursing / hospital in our house.

My DH told my dad straight out - "you have made your own decisions all of your lives. Now you need to make plans for your aging - and loss of mobility especially and eventually loss of ability for ADL and mental capacity" what are your plans when you can no longer drive? etc.

Dad's response was "well that's why we expected you to step up" and my DH reminded his dad about his dad's mom - who chose to move to senior housing when she was 75 - then to assisted living - then to nursing home where she died at 99 1/2.
MIL and FIL were not happy - we got alot of snippy comments about the "young people of today" and self centeredness etc. which we ignored.

But, now it looks like living with us is put to bed. Hopefully they start planning for their future. They are 78 and 80 - no long term care insurance, house with stairs, yard to maintain and no plans for declining years.
Helpful Answer (9)
Report

Kimber166, you handled all of that absolutely perfectly. I'm sure the turmoil and contention wasn't easy to weather. And, still isn't over. But good for you for standing your ground.

And some good points made there, for others to remember (myself to name one). If spouse won't discuss it .. that still doesn't then mean that the other spouse has to acquiesce and go along with it.

Great points. So glad you are standing firm.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Kimber 166 - I so admire you for standing up for yourself and handling this entire situation beautifully. This story is most interesting to me. Please keep us posted. Peace and Prayers.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Unfortunately they allocated some extra time to look at neighborhoods. So they are arriving Wednesday before Thanksgiving and leaving a week later - Wednesday. At least they are not staying with us - they are getting a room through AirBNB. I told hubby, i work Friday after thanksgiving and the week after - so he better think of some entertainment. Especially since our son will be back at school Monday. Interesting days ahead.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Ohmygoodness. Things might be a little tense around the turkey table next month! But you and your H have time to get totally on the same page for this Thanksgiving's script. The title of the play will be "You Must Take Care of Us."

How long are the in-laws staying?
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Good on you for standing up for yourself, Kimber! It sounds like your husband comes from a family of bullies and narcissists - luckily he doesn't seem to share that trait. I'm sure he hates being put in the middle and it would be easier for him to just go along with what they want. I do hope you go to the therapist together and are able to work through your differences and present a united front for his family. Good luck!!!
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

I lit a fuse.....explosion ensued....LONG POST.

On Saturday my ILs called to give me flight information for their Thanksgiving visit. I spoke with them because DH was at work wrapping up the end of some work travel. Then they asked me how it was going getting a realtor. I decided to be truthful "we don't have a realtor nor have we been looking for one. This house is paid off, near our work and school, we are not selling it." Stunned silence.

So, as gently as i could - i asked them what they had pictured happening. As i thought, it was some Walton's view of us having family dinners together, they going to our son's activities. One big happy family even though we cannot agree on what to make for dinner or how clean and neat a house should be.

I asked them about their comment that we would "help them" as they aged (from their last visit when they asked us to "think about" this plan of living together.) Apparently some friend who was widowed last year moved to Arkansas near his daughter. She retired from teaching at age 55 and her kids are all in college or working. She therefore has free time to take him to the doctor and help him around his house. They thought that i would probably work less after 55 and be available for the little bit of driving they would need (little bit! ha!). When i asked about them needing more care like bathing they didn't say anything - they haven't really digested that they would need this kind of care someday (they are 80!! and they avoid thinking about decline)

I told them that neither DH nor I would be financially able to retire at 55, that we would likely be working at least 10 more years beyond that due to needing to fund our own retirement and help our son with college.

More stunned silence. I decided to wrap up the call before they could get angry and said "It looks like you made some assumptions that we just cannot meet, unfortunately. I'm glad we had this talk so you can adjust your plans" and then rang off.

When DH got home i told him about the conversation and when he got upset that i told them nada to the move because we had not had a chance to discuss it and come to a decision. I kind of shut him down "We've had weeks to discuss it and you have not wanted to. I've seen our therapist twice and have invited you to come and you haven't. I have seen no sign that you wanted to discuss it. I would be happy to, but we will discuss it with the help of our therapist - we'll get too angry and the conversation will get too emotional otherwise"

The @#$#$ hit the fan on Sunday (yesterday). They called DH breathing fire and since he had them on speaker phone in the next room i could hear a good bit. They were furious that he "let them down" about the living together plan. They said that while I was the kind of person who "dumped her dad" in a nursing home, they had expected better of him (even though my FIL's own mom went to a continuing care community - Independent Living to Assisted Living to Nursing Home). On and on it went and DH didn't even try to get a word in. It was pretty ugly but very much the standard when they get crossed. They were too angry to try to get him to agree to living together - they just wanted to shout at him. Then they hung up.

Then later in the day, his uncle on his dad's side called to let him know how hurt FIL was and that he needed to "honor his father and mother" (they thump the Bible to try to manipulate us) and told my DH he needed to "man up and take care of his responsibilities". My DH got one shot in and asked why then had their mom not lived with one of them and his uncle said "not the same situation" and hung up. Now DH is getting pretty boiled up about his parents, me, his uncle (as oldest brother uncle feels he is head of family and can tell all of his siblings and their children and grandchildren what to do). When he is angry, he goes silent..... until he has too much and blows.

Last straw was this morning - he got a wake up call at 5:30 am from aunt/uncle in the old country saying all of the same hurtful things that he already heard. He hung up on them and just started venting. I let it go on for awhile and then said

"You brought this on by letting time go by where your parents clearly thought you agreed to their plan. I don't even know if you agreed to it or not - you wouldn't discuss it with me. I only informed you that I would not be part of it. You've had plenty of time and opportunity to talk about this and you haven't and it didn't go away, but has become a nasty fight. I love you and want to work through this with you. Will you come with me to the therapist on Wednesday, when i have my next appointment?" and he agreed to come.

He went to work feeling pretty picked on and angry with the world. But i think any interest in trying to live with his parents pretty much went up in smoke. Now, we'll likely need our therapist help role-playing the "we intend to stay in our house" etc.

I think the next hurdle will be if they still want to move near us, how much are we willing to do for them. As angry as they were - i predict they'll stay in their house and keep leaning on my BIL/SIL to do for them as they currently do. I think Thanksgiving will be an "interesting" visit - they have already bought their tickets. I think they will still come - if they have given up the living together idea - it will be a visit of "you disappointed us". Worse case - they'll try to manipulate us into agreeing to their plan.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

"We've discussed this issue and no, we won't be looking at houses to buy. We are happy living as a nuclear family and are not wanting to change that."

"Again, no, we're not calling a realtor. We are not interested in moving. We are happy living here by ourselves"

(They indicate that THEY are not happy)

"I understand that you would prefer that we accede to your wishes. But the answer is no, we're happy with our current living arrangements"
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

Whirledtravel makes some great points. People often do have trouble speaking their mind. It can be done calmly and in a nice way. Still, some adult kids just can't seem to be honest about their feelings with parents or even other family members. My family is very much that way. I don't get it. I say what I think, especially, if something needs to be said. lol

For some reason, some people are so concerned about making someone else feel bad......but, what about me feeling bad. That's more important to me. If I'm being put upon and taken advantage of, WHY would I feel bad. Better, that those who are ignoring my boundaries and disrespecting me to feel bad, rather than me. I think more could be worked out if the air was cleared and everyone knew where they stood.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

1 2 3
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter