Follow
Share

Is there any way to prevent a "family friend" from taking Dad for everything he's got? Since Mom died, he's been spending a lot of time with a former employee of the family business. Unbeknownst to the family, she's been driving him to Dr appts, going into the exam room, presenting herself as his "caregiver", and then telling his doctors that he has dementia. We also found out that she's been accepting unknown amounts of cash in exchange for cleaning his house etc.


This came to light when she took him to the ER for a suspected "stroke" (but managed to stop at the bank on the way so he could make a suspiciously large cash withdrawal.) While in the hospital, he did in fact obtain a formal diagnosis of early stage Alzheimer's, but to our knowledge this diagnosis did not previously exist. Even though we have been noticing symptoms (sleepiness, confusion, easily forgetful) off and on for a while, we believed this was mostly due to the stress of caring for and eventually losing Mom to a prolonged terminal illness.


We believe this "friend" has been using these symptoms in order to gain/maintain control over him. She has been taking it on herself to make medical decisions for him without the family's knowledge, withholding information because "he didn't want anyone to worry", and positioning herself as the person we must go through to access him. In the ER triage, she was talking over both Dad and daughter to answer the nurse's questions herself. Apparently before the family arrived, she told the ER staff that he has Alzheimer's but don't mention it to the family because it upsets us?!


He is in his early 70s and is medically stable, still able to drive and live alone. The dr says that with medication to slow the mental decline, he should be independent for many more years. This is great news, but we are concerned that his ability to retain his independence means he will have many years in which to be scammed before his children have a valid reason to step in.


Obviously he can spend his time and money as he wishes, but we understandably don't want his retirement savings drained by an opportunistic parasite. He has a history of giving large sums of cash to family members, which is fine, but this is unacceptable. There's no reason why this "friend" should be doing these things for him (and getting paid handsomely.) His children and adult grandchildren all live in the same town and we would do these things for him if he asked us.


At this point is there anything we can do? If he would give one of us power of attorney, can they even do that, even though he's still medically able to be independent? We accept that it will be impossible to keep her away from him when he is a willing participant in this "friendship", but we'd like a way to stem the bleeding to a slow trickle at least.

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
POA won’t give you the power to control him. He will still be able to make his own decisions, see who wants and spend his money as his pleases as long as he’s mentally competent. You could report the friend to APS, perhaps a little investigation would scare her away?
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

If you suspect she is a financial predator, then she will disappear as soon as she drains him (and she might even have him change his will or create one with her as the beneficiary and even put the house in her name). This is what happened in my family before anyone realized or could react to it. It will eventually become your problem, so why not try to head it off in advance if at all possible.

When you said it was a former employee, it made me wonder if they were having an affair prior? I'm an employer and I found it very odd... not that it changes anything except her sense of entitlement in the pecking order now that your mom is gone. Sorry, very harsh but have to float it out there.

What state are you in? Do you or relatives live near your dad? This info would be helpful. He doesn't seem like a candidate for guardianship base on what you've disclosed. Even if you were somehow able to get durable PoA assigned to you/family member the "friend" could still find a way to get back control if she isn't out of the picture completely. Of course this won't make you popular with your dad. Maybe pay for an extensive background check on her and if the results show a sketchy past, you will have some ammo to present to your dad (but don't get your hopes up as she whispers sweet nothings into his ear, among other things she may be doing to "make him happy").

If his recent "diagnosis" is accurate, it will be too late (I think) for him to assign PoA. You could get him to an elder law attorney and they will be able to determine if he is capable of authorizing PoA. When I took my 90+ yo aunt to one in FL no one was allowed to be in the room with her and the attorney and their explanation was to assess for manipulation. Ugh this situation sucks and I hope your family can work it out in your dad's best interest!
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
jacobsonbob Sep 2019
If he is still competent, should a diagnosis of an early stage of dementia prevent him from assigning a POA? Aren't competence and dementia two different things, such that although advanced dementia results in loss of competence, having a mild level of dementia doesn't in itself necessarily result in loss of competence? In any case, I'm more optimistic that Villagemama6 can still be assigned a POA at this stage.
(4)
Report
See 3 more replies
You say that his doctors feel he has early dementia? Who is his Health Care POA? Who can medical discuss him with? I think it sounds now like no one has a very clear idea of how much dementia Dad has. Whoever the health care POA is can speak with doctors to ask if they feel that Dad is competent to handle his financial affairs.
You say that he is very generous and has given sums to family members, and "that is fine". Guess what. It is fine if he gives it to people who are NOT family members, as well, especially if those persons are cleaning for him, visiting him, taking him to appointment, and taking him to ER when he needs to go.
Perhaps if family who is receiving all this money is willing to spend increasing amounts of time with Dad he will not end up as prey for predators. And mind you, I am not saying this "friend" is in any way a predator, because she is a friend he has known from work, and seems to me is doing a lot for him.
Speak with Dad about all this, why don't you? Seems to me that would be a good place to start. Good luck. Hope all goes well.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
thepianist Sep 2019
Great points. It sounds to me as if the family member has gotten worried about Dad only now that she realizes the woman is being given money. And it is Dad's right to do this!
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
What about asking for W9 to declare payments for tax filings? If it’s payment and tracking to cover for Medicaid, that puts her on notice it’s being tracked. It reminds dad that giving money away means no Medicaid coverage due to gifting penalty. By the way, the same holds true for big amounts given to family if he needs care and applies for Medicaid within 5 years of gifting money. Read up on it. Several posters have family members that cannot get Medicaid help to pay for care due to gifting.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

Being No One, Hun, Is any sort of POA, Nothing much you can do but Talk to the Friend. I see a Leach, For Certain, Someone who will Reach and IS..Into Sad Dad's pockets.
Have a Chat with Dad, Explain that when the Money is Gone, The Honey is LONG GONE too.xx
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

I’d get dad in to see an elder care lawyer as soon as possible. The lawyer can determine his ability and competence to fill out POA and other documents that need doing. The lawyer may also advise you both on how to best proceed with the friend, often a third part is better at taking on a subject like this tan family is. Dad has what could be a long road ahead and shouldn’t be giving money to anyone, his resources need conserving for what future care he may require. Is the family prepared to step in and do all the things this friend has been doing?
Helpful Answer (10)
Report
Villagemama6 Sep 2019
We do step in and help where needed, for example we do all his lawn care.

I'm talking about random, not-urgent jobs like cleaning his pool table, organizing the shed, painting some room he takes a wild hair to paint. Stuff that is not the obvious, "we gotta do this for dad" type of task that he randomly decides to do. Like the stuff you might decide to do on a Saturday morning when you don't have a lot going on but don't feel like watching TV.
(1)
Report
Alert his doctors to not give info to anyone except who you the family decide. It's part of the PrivacyAct. BUT if you are relying on her to give care, she must know some things. Area Agency on Aging can help you find someone to take care of his finances. Explain to him that dosen't mean he loses control of his money. He can request money if he wants to make a big purchase. And they will require receipts for most things but give a agreed "allowance" every month. If this "friend" is truely there to help, she won't mind at all. Even if she is nickle and dimeing his account it is still taking from his future care. She does deserve to be compensated for her help.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

If he is being passive and not speaking for himself in these different situations, then I am seeing dementia.
Be assertive. Have a couple of family members stay with Dad for a week or so. When she arrives, tell her, he is not seeing anyone today. Consult a lawyer and figure out the competency status.
I agree with the idea of having APS get involved. If she is up to no good, she just might scurry away.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Sounds like you need to have a talk with Dad. Also sounds like there needs to be more involvement from the family. If you all live in the same town and didn't know ANY of this was going on, what does that tell you? Your best option at this point is to communicate with him AND his friend. A POA wont do anything unless he is incapacitated and cant make decisions for himself. There are two sides to every story. You see a parasite who has "no reason to be doing these things". He might see a family who isn't stepping up to help him, so talk to him! Sorry if I am blunt but this doesn't need to escalate further if there is full communication. If nothing else, have him sign a HIPAA privacy form that allows your family to inquire about his medical condition with his doctors.
Helpful Answer (9)
Report
thepianist Sep 2019
Yours is an excellent reply, Samsung. I would caution, though, that PoAs are not limited to the time after a person becomes incapacitated, unless that is expressly written into the document. Sometimes a person simply wants, for convenience, to have another person authorized to conduct business in their name.
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
Your father is probably lonely after the kids of his wife, and is grateful to have an attentive "girlfriend.". If he is competent to handle his own affairs, he can give her money if he wants to unless he and the family agree to a financial POA.

When the term POA is used in this forum, it often seems to refer to a "durable POA" which takes effect only when someone is declared incompetant. There is another kind of POA which gives an agent immediate responsibility for someone's finances. Your father would have to be willing to set this up. It's not something you can force on him.
He might consider a POA a good idea or he might think family is over-stepping. Does he welcome or resist family involvement?
Your father may indeed be being manipulated by his "friend," or the family may be upset that father's inheritable resources are being diminished.
Financial opportunists are not uncommon in these situations. I can understand your suspicions. Just try to be sure you are assessing the situation objectively.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
thepianist Sep 2019
PoAs don't necessarily only take effect if a person is mentally legally incompetent, not unless it's drafted with this proviso. It takes effect when it is executed (signed and witnessed) by the principal and delivered to the agent.

A Durable General Power of Attorney is one that lasts for the lifetime of the person executing the document, and ceases to be valid at the person's death.
(2)
Report
See 1 more reply
Get an elder attorney. Get those POAs done.
Then, get a restraining order on the friend.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Active sweetheart scammer! Stop her now by hiring an elder law attorney!
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Speak to his doctor and explain he is vulnerable and at risk of being manipulated into giving her money. That she is not family and should not be involved in his medical care at all - not even to sit in with him as it is not her family member. That she’s informed hospital personnel he has Alzheimers. Ensure they have a contact number for you and other real family members.

Obtain POA for health and finance as advised earlier. That shouldn’t be difficult if he’s vulnerable to being scammed.

Request a mental health check and or his medical records to confirm whether it’s been officially determined re any “Alzheimer’s”.

Then confront her - and ensure she knows the next time she meddles there will be an investigation especially regarding her involvement in his medical care when she is not family. If proven she’s lied re Alzheimers to medical personnel that could have had serious implications re medication,

If she’s been proven to have lied about Alzheimers I would then point out there’s the large sums of money handed over by a vulnerable former boss to his devious former employee....

Good luck
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
Villagemama6 Sep 2019
Thank you. This is great advice!
(1)
Report
Report this woman to your state agency for aging issues, as someone suspected of elder abuse (financial). Try to get your father to make you PoA. Clarify IN WRITING what this 'friend' will do for your father, and how much she is to be paid. Make it clear that it is the family member PoA who receives and provides medical information to any doctor. Please don't wait for your dad to ask family members for help. Be there for him, offer to provide needed help. If the family isn't there for him this leaves him vulnerable to those who might take advantage.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

This is the proverbial sticky wicket. And, it could lead all the way to marriage and new wills giving this “helpful friend” everything.

You mention that the family is nearby nearby and willing to help - if only he would ask. Asking is humbling. It means accepting that you can’t do it alone anymore.

May i I suggest a proactive approach of asking Dad what is on his schedule for the week or even tomorrow? Is he able to keep a calendar with his appts? Jot down appts or take a quick picture the next time you are there. All of this so you and your family will know about upcoming appts and can volunteer to drive him. If he doesn’t volunteer the info - simply say that he mentioned it the last time you talked. Move the conversation forward by saying what would be a good time to pick him up. You are empowering him with decisions but gently guiding him to allow you to do him this favor. Tell him you owe him a few million for raising you.

If you can find a closed site that allows you to post his calendar, then family can discuss amongst themselves who can take him the next time. And, getting the follow up scheduled so the info goes back on the calendar.

There are other things like like grocery shopping and clothes shopping that maybe he needs a little help with. Having those tasks shared by family can help. Posting times when someone simply is visiting or taking him out to dinner helps and ensures the whole family can see constant family engagement with him.

However, someone always becomes the keeper of the calendar. And, the negotiator for others in the family to help. And, getting those helpers to get info from Dad about upcoming appts and needs. Sometimes all tasks can be shared. Sometimes it’s better if this person always is with him at his primary care appts and maybe another is always the one at the neurologist, etc. Maybe it’s easier for someone to be the grocery shopping assistant because then they know what he likes, how he is stocked up, recommending easy snacks or meals etc.

Other than the family being very proactive and then being there for the long haul, call his dr offices and ask if they can put your number down as the contact number and your email as the contact email. That helps tremendously.

I have advanced directive documents naming me to take care of my husband’s medical decisions. Most of the doctors realize that while he has some good days that I need to be making those decisions now and I am the one who needs to be called and notified of any communication. While a little back and forth earlier in my husband’s decline, now if they call and he answers, he simply says “you need to talk to my wife, she keeps the calendar and can tell you when we can come.”

And, there is lots of good financial and legal advice already posted. Those are hard steps as he is at a tenuous point in accepting the oncoming decline. He may be gracious and think it’s a great idea to protect his money from himself or anyone - family or others.

I wish you good luck in these next chapters with your Dad. The whole family may find that some of these trips are good times to talk and share and remember. They will become precious memories.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
WifeNeedingHelp Sep 2019
One more tip. There is an app and website called: Lotsa Helping Hands

It allows you to include members who could see upcoming tasks, notifications of current status or test results, etc, etc.

I am not an expert on this tool and in particular the security around only team members being able to see the contents.

I believe there are other apps like it.

Maybe this app or another similar would allow the family to share info needed and allow family to volunteer for upcoming tasks.

Or, could update with their latest contact with Dad and any pertinent info for the family.

In other words - a tracker of who’s called, who’s seen Dad, who’s helped with errands that week, who all has taken him to his dr appts that week. Using the tool to see what’s upcoming and who’s volunteering to cover that one.

God bless, I hope it helps.
(3)
Report
See 1 more reply
I think when one person takes total control over someone to the point of shutting out family, then something is wrong. If you were to tell him how you feel about her, he may get very angry and even not speak to you. So you have to be careful in this situation. Do everything you can not to let her get legal control, then that would really be bad. Good luck.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
Phoebe2019 Oct 2019
That happened to me. My husband and sister were very vocal about how we felt this guy was preying on her. My mother actually threatened to have the guy burn my house down. Terrifying. My mom has not been diagnosed with a mental illness, but we don’t have the ability to get her to a doctor to find out. The guy keeps her isolated.
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
First of all, seek out an experienced elder care attorney for advice. Second, consult the Adult Protective Services who can evaluate the situation and who will step in to help if it is justified. Also call the Office on Aging for help.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

We are currently going through a very similar situation with my father in law who has dementia. The woman acted as his “fiancé” and took several thousand dollars and caused us so much distress. She was arrested yesterday for exploitation of a vulnerable adult. We contacted social services and the white collar division of our sheriffs department and they worked with us to provide bank statements showing withdrawals and credit card statements to prove that she took the money. They subpoenaed the banks to get photos of her with him at the counter.
This is such a stressful event and my heart goes out to you struggle through. I would definitely recommend becoming his medical and durable power of attorney as quickly as possible.
Best of Luck!
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
Isthisrealyreal Sep 2019
Good news Lunabear. Well done!
(1)
Report
So sorry. I suppose an attorney is the first step. Best of luck to you.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter