Follow
Share

To will executors, has anyone had a major blowup after the death of the elderly parent, due to disputes about estate distribution, even though a legal will is in place? What was it about and how did you handle it?

I was executor of my dad’s estate. He didn’t have a load of money as a retired teacher. I knew there was big potential for issues with one sibling who has lifelong undiagnosed mental illness. When the time came for distributions, I hired an estate lawyer to handle it. He went over the assets and settlements and wrote letters to each sibling. I mailed them with cashiers checks enclosed from his office. It took my fingerprints off of it in a great way. It showed I’d hidden nothing and someone independent checked my work. It was a step I didn’t have to take, but it cost little and was well worth doing. Difficult sibling still grumbled but knew there was nowhere to go with the complaints
Helpful Answer (21)
Reply to Daughterof1930
Report
JanPeck123 Jun 8, 2025
My hat off to you. Good planning.
(0)
Report
Executor & more than 1 time. Each one was different and each was a learning opportunity. My big takeaway is IF there are challenges aka “contested” from others as to the will entered into probate court being valid, that is 100&1% work for a probate attorney who does litigation.

Most probate guys do NOT do litigation, they are more about following the path that is well establish for your State laws for just how probate and its many filings and forms just flat have to be done according to your State laws. It’s pretty routine but precise stuff, even if there are Claims against the Estate, even if you do in-chambers meeting(s), even if a heir dies while probate is simmering along.

But if the will is actually being contested, actually being challenged- not just family complaining and whining stuff - that needs to have an attorney who is experienced in litigation. Probate guys who do litigation are different level of expertise and will take time and have co$t$. If this is what’s happening, I’d suggest you have an upfront conversation with your current probate atty as to their ability to do litigation and its negotiating skill set. They resign or do a cocounsel with new litigation savvy probate atty.

& also - not to be harsh - some folks are not suited to be an Executor. They take criticism too personally or don’t have the ability to ignore pests. Often it’s that the now deceased named their favorite to be their Executor without realizing they were not the best choice to do the organization and timeline for the chessboard that is probate. And as they were the favorite, there are existing resentments from the rest of the family. Sigh! If that’s kinda what’s happening to you, talk with your attorney about having an inchambers done and maybe you can get your Independent administration Executor changed to be a dependent administration (so court oversight). That will probably shut down complaints and whining as now it’s before a judge or their legal staff.

Also your attorney should be deflecting complaints. If they are not doing their job, that’s a whole other type of conversation.
Helpful Answer (9)
Reply to igloo572
Report
tokyosteve Jun 8, 2025
Very thoughtful advice.
(1)
Report
I'm currently the Personal Representative for my late Aunt's humble estate. I have been working with her original elder law attorney while things go through probate because it is out of state for me and I have no experience with this process. There are some heirs (nieces, nephew), me, my Mom (her sister) and her church. The only bitter person in this group is my 96-yr old Mom who has moderate dementia and doesn't like one of the niece/inheritors and is wondering why her sister didn't leave my Mom everything. It's not a rational conversation when I discuss it with her, and it's none of her business, anyway. Who is blowing up and why? If you are going by the rules and laws of your county and state, the "exploders" can go off all they want but it won't change anything unless they decide to contest the Will. And if they lose, they will still have to pay their attorney and maybe even yours. You handle it by making sure you are legally crossing all the T's and dotting all the I's. Also, if it involves people who were expecting an inheritance and it didn't happen, it's none of their business so don't discuss it with them. Again, make sure you are doing everything legally correctly and then they won't be able to say or do anything to you.
Helpful Answer (7)
Reply to Geaton777
Report
Shellann Aug 24, 2025
Hi Geaton777,
I am executor for my Mom who passed in January and POA for my bonus Dad. They wrote their Will 8 years ago and were married 38 years. My brother and I will be the beneficiaries. Our step-sister has been estranged for several years due to poor life choices and only since the passing of our Mom has been resurfacing. While she is noted as his child in the Will, she is not a beneficiary. I do suspect this will cause us some issues and likely be contested by her.

I am still in the process of taking my Mom's name off of accounts and putting them in our bonus Dad's name. This includes our Mom's Retirement account, IRA's, CD's and their house. I find this very intimidating that her name is being taken off of her assets etc...

Should we be worried if this is contested by step-sister? We are working with an elder law lawyer but have not met with her for a few months. I do have a phone conference set up but was not able to get time with her for 2 weeks.

Also, if all goes smooth, my brother and I are not opposed to giving her some inheritance. What is the best way to do this?

Thank you for your thoughts and advice.
(0)
Report
As Executor you follow the Will. You honor the persons wishes. First all debts and leins have to be met. So lets say a house is left to someone, if the debts and leins are more than than the assets are worth, then the house needs to be sold to cover them the beneficiary does not get the house. With me my brother inherited the house liens and all. He was not going to be able to cover those liens so the house went back into the estate. It was sold, the liens paid and the money left was slit between the siblings. When all is said and done, an accting is done which all beneficiaries need to sign to get their inheritance. Thats when they contest.

As an Executor you cannot change what is in a Will. You would need to go to court and have a judge rule.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to JoAnn29
Report

My husband is an attorney and handles disputes like this. You are so smart to ask what people can do to make the process go smoothly. The single best thing people can do to prevent disputes is to communicate clearly to everyone what the will says
and how things will be divided before they die! Also, divided equally doesn’t always mean equal monetary value. For example, a son and daughter may each inherit property but it could have different monetary value.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to CarolineY
Report

This is a really personal question the answer to which is likely irrelevant to your own case.

There are state laws that are in place that dictate how an estate MUST be distributed. It gives the executor a lot of power in most states, but it DOES dictate the time limits in which the executor must let all beneficiaries of the will know that they ARE beneficiaries. Said notification doesn't say what amounts or items are, simply that the person is a beneficiary. It doesn't say much more.

If you have concerns about a beneficiary in a particular will that you believe you are a beneficiary of, then you should contact a probate or a Trust and Estate attorney to represent your interests in a particular will or trust. All wills are filed and open records to the public. Trusts are not and need not be.

If you are collecting info for a research paper of some type, this isn't really the place to do that without clearing it first with admins. If you have a problem you think we might give you info or help on please state what that problem is. Welcome to the Forum.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to AlvaDeer
Report
Peekie1928 Jun 9, 2025
Why are you always so cruel in your responses? I stopped visiting this forum because of folks like you. You and Margaret seem to be hell bent on hurting others...wondering if you are the same account/person- or if there are two equally miserable women who have nothing better to do than hurt others who are genuinely looking for advice during the hardest chapter of their lives.
Your passive aggressive shtick is probably from years of pain that you suffered.
Hurt people, hurt other people.
(0)
Report
Rude Aunt was the only beneficiary of my dad's will. The rest went into a trust to support mom, who had dementia. There was very little cash due to Rude Aunt's mismanagement of my parents' businesses. At 88, she was the bookkeeper and no longer doing a decent job, if she ever did. My dad had said she was getting "senile," which was my cautious observation as well. It was clear that she was no longer as cognitively sharp as she used to be, though she, as always, thought she was smarter than everyone on the planet.

According to state law, beneficiaries have to be paid first, and she wanted her money immediately though my mom's dementia care was gobbling up all available cash.

Rude Aunt sued my co-executor and me because she wasn't getting her $100,000 fast enough. (Rude Aunt was very wealthy due to having been a rich man's mistress for 35 years; she didn't need the money.) Rude Aunt was angry that dad had not made her executor, and she hated my mom. The first time she sued, judge threw it out of court. It cost $6000 of dad's estate to defend against her suit. The second time she sued, in order to pay Rude Aunt, we harvested the timber on a pristine property that dad owned. Now, Rude Aunt was an outspoken environmentalist who only lived (according to her) to save wildlife who so cruelly were being forced out of their homes by developers. Cutting the timber destroyed 66 acres of habitat for the animals Rude Aunt claimed to love, but it was the only way to get the money and get her off our backs. I cried as I watched the timber company clear-cut and remove many trailers of logs from that beautiful place.

Because of this and the way she treated family during dad's final illness, I never spoke to Rude Aunt again.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to Fawnby
Report
SnoopyLove Jun 8, 2025
Good grief! That is ghastly.
(5)
Report
See 3 more replies
I assume that there are several mentioned for equal shares. Has the will been sent to probate?
If there is no will, then probate has state laws on distribution.
The executor can hold distribution until all final expeses are paid including taxes next year. The process can take over a year and if there is contesting, may go longer, especially if lawyers are needed. As an executor , I would hear sob stories to distribute early. I could allow small distributions but the final had to be closed in probate.
So the executor has to express that legsl fees will eat away $
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to MACinCT
Report

Executors must comply in all respects with the will. There is no discretion to change the distribution. If they are not confident to explain this to beneficiaries and inform them their only recourse is to contest the will (at their own expense), hiring a good estate attorney is very helpful. They will supervise the executor's work, do all the legal and tax filings, and facilitate the distribution. They charge a fee for this, of course. I wouldn't recommend going it alone without an attorney for a situation where a beneficiary is disputing the distribution. You want to make sure everything is done correctly in case they decide to take legal action.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to iameli
Report

I think our own personal experiences (I have none, being the only beneficiary of my brother's Trust) in the realm wouldn't be relevant and likely would be quite personal to discuss on an open Forum, JR.

The executor is in charge of the will. That person doesn't discuss distribution with ANYONE and shouldn't. The will will be filed and is an open document. If the beneficiaries believe they aren't being notified timely (and there is GREAT latitude given in court for the settling of an estate; it often takes more than a year) then they can hire an attorney to check on and represent their interests.

According to law of your state the Executor has a given time limit in which they must notify all beneficiaries of a will that they ARE a beneficiary. They do not however discuss amounts or anything else, and should not. They simply get on with paying all bills, gathering and selling assets, paying taxes, and THEN distributing the remainder of the state as dictated in the will. They then file closing on the Estate EIN taxes and the work is done. I acted as Trustee on my brother's Trust. Trusts, you should understand, don't get filed in open public records.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to AlvaDeer
Report

See All Answers
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter