Follow
Share

I have trouble understanding some of the things he is saying to me. It seems he whispers some stories in a rather dramatic way. Is this common, or is it my hearing? He badgers me if I ask him to repeat very many things. Not pleasant!

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
Volume will be decreased when there is pressure bearing on the diaphragm, the person has COPD, sore throat, or many things. If they wear hearing aids maybe they think they are yelling the words. Try having him write down what he is saying (if he can still write and understand what he is writing), but don't get stressed or angry. That won't help either of you. Just do the best you can and hope that is enough. Best wishes!
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Based on answers above, I'd surmise this reduced speaking volume IS common among people with dementia. But certainly my mother -- who has dementia "consistent with Alzheimer's" -- has grown much more soft-spoken during the latter stage(s). And I think vecharo's suggestions were especially helpful!
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

It would make sense if they lose auditory function as they also lose hearing, vision and olfactory sense.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Since I personally knew two of them, I would definitely have to say no on this one. Their voice volumes definitely didn't change a single bit, in fact, one of them actually got a little bit louder since he couldn't really hear too well and he wore to hearing aids. The other persons voice also didn't change a single bet, that person had their normal voice volume. Everything I know about these two people is exactly why I must say no to losing one's voice volume because it isn't necessarily true in dementia patients because from what I've noticed, dementia actually affects people differently
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

My husband also does this. He has dementia and parkinsonism. Also has a habit of putting his hand in front of his mouth when he is talking which makes it even more difficult to hear. I've tried to tell him to put his hands down so I can hear him but that just makes him angry and he tells me I need a hearing aid. Oh well.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

My wife doesn't talk when I first show up at her facility but then mumbles quite low. I take her to Speech Therapy and then she opens up. It is amazing to me that she then speaks in complete, grammatically correct sentences. Afterwards, it is back to the silent treatment. She may have NPH but not sure at this time. She knows the words to many songs and sings them. The S.T. can get her to associate many words, like opposites, and can finish many sentences. Afterwards its back to the silent treatment. It may be just me; I don't know. She is a PhD in mathematics and she can still count and do addition. So much for the PhD. Dementia is horrible but one just has to swing with it or go crazy.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Yes, it is common! My mother got to the point where she would speak another language almost. I could not understand her. Her final stage was just moans, could not swallow, and stopped walking.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

I don't know if it's true for all dementia patients, but it's certainly true of my mom. Sometimes I have to put my ear way down to her mouth to hear what she's saying.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

My husband who is in the late stages of dementia, does the same thing. I can't hear what he's saying most of the time and seems to be telling stories. I just say yes to whatever he's telling me. This seems to satisfy him.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

My mother was always at least a moderate volume speaker and really got loud with a few glasses of wine. Now it's a whisper and if I ask her to speak louder she almost yells "OK!" but then goes back to whisper next time she says anything. So, is it the dementia or is it something else. No UTI. She is very healthy "otherwise" I think it must be fairly common to lose volume with dementia and maybe also with advanced age.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

My mom had Lewy body with parkinsins. As her speach declined, her voice became softer until she finally stopped speaking in sentences. She would say yes or no or tea or juice, just one word answers to questions. However if you asked her if she wanted to say the Hail Mary or our father prayers, she would say every word!
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

I can only tell you that my husband who has Parkinson's and is starting to get dementia speaks very softly. Most people complain about not being able to hear him. I have been told that with Parkinson's their hearing is more acute and they think they are talking louder when in fact they are speaking softly. There is therapy that actually encourages them to yell to be able to practice speaking louder. I do totally agree with Vecharo.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

my dad's voice had also reduced to a gravely whisper. The VA sent him to speech therapy using the LSVT Loud training. Here's a video on the effectiveness below. It made a huge difference in our interaction. Sometimes he will revert to whispering. When that happens we simply say, " use your LOUD voice".
the therapist said that it's a bit of a cycle. They get used to not speaking up. People don't hear them so they don't speak up. Then they get used to not being heard. I asked my dad and he agreed that because it sometimes takes a while for him to process what's being said or asked of him he doesn't speak because the relevance of his comments has passed by the time he gets the words right. So, he just says nothing at all. Not using his voice lowers the volume.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

understanding some of the things he is saying
whispers
====
simple answer yes
Some also speak in alphabet soup
loose and mix words and their meanings

loose the ability to speak
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

I like the suggestions about seeing an ENT and also speech therapy if he's having trouble speaking. However, you mentioned that he seemed to be telling stories in a dramatic fashion. Is he really talking to you or is he just reliving an even for himself? If he's just reliving an event, then there's no need for you to ask him to repeat it. I'd just let it be.

It's all in the context of when he does this.

Take care,
Carol
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

I have no idea if it's common with Dementia patients or not. But my Momma appears to be horse a lot of times as if she talked loudly for days, when she has always been soft spoken all of her life. Did he ever go see a ENT (Ears, Nose and Throat Specialist)? Momma has seasonal allergies and takes a allergy pill a day which controls her sneezing....but it doesn't do anything for her hoarsness. Keep asking questions to his doctor and in here. I hope you find your answers.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Alexander4, I don't know if that is common in all kinds of dementia, but it certainly is in Lewy Body Dementia (which my husband had.) Speech therapy helped a lot. He didn't remember to do what the therapist taught him all the time, but I could remind him and that would help for a while.

Have you discussed this with your loved one's doctor? Ask if speech therapy might help.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

Please check to make sure its not a UTI.My mom passed recently and the dr.thought it was start of dementia, here she was getting urinary infections which have the same signs.I have never heard of either causing lowering of voice.Good Luck.Shame our parents never teach us how to handle these things when we are young.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter