Follow
Share

Dad is 80, he and I have always been hunters. The past few years he goes to deer camp but doesn't even get out (He cooks). The last few years I went (got tired of being the valet) I had to help him put on and tie his boots for him. We had some of the same issue with my grandfather which my uncle did a lot of work to keep him going. So now dad wants to go hunting near where I live and conned a friend to show him a place. The trouble is it is a walk into the woods and dad can't even walk through the kitchen without holding on to something or use his cane. We had this discussion at dinner the other night and it was "I'll use a cane". Right, "good, you will use a cane to walk a mile into the woods and carry your gun and a chair?" as I told him "I will be the one to have to come get you out". He didn't listen. Then it was "did you order my license?" I don't know what to do at this point. I have done everything I can short of telling him an absolute no. If I do I am the troubled son... The family doesn't talk to me now so I'm not losing much. He wants to drive 8 hours to camp. I am against it but I can't stop him. I know just going and not event getting out doesn't bother him, he like to get away and be with his friends but the long drive (he breaks it up and the fear of him falling in the woods gives me pain). I know the family and friends will look out for him but times have changed. So what do I do? tell him no? I keep putting everything off but only for so long. My hope is that he wants to think he is going but knowing how he is he wont go at the last minute. A few years ago I spent a lot of money flying him west on a last big trip for him and me. Cost me thousands. He did about 2 hours of fishing on a 8 day trip.... At least I enjoyed my part but he fell and got hurt the first day..... but he sure went out to dinner every night on my dime! Dammed if I do dammed if I dont.

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Wow! Pile on people! Thank you to those who support venting. Really, how else does one get (constructive) advice unless one vents. Funny, some of these pile on people have not posted before. So go ahead, if it makes you feel better to trounce on someone go right ahead. I take no offense to it. It just tells me more of who you are and I feel bad for you if that is the way you support others in this situation. I thank those who provide good advice. Do you know my situation? What is going on in my life? I think not. So before you pile "tough love" on to someone think twice how it may affect someone who does not have the thick skin I have. If you start your post with "you wont like this" You are right and I move on. I have no time for people like you. Yours are only words on a page that I choose to ignore. The mere fact that I do come to solicit advice is that I am in an area I have never been before and I look for positive solutions. So if your is to tear down and denigrate then go right ahead. It will only fill your mind with the thoughts that do not help. I actually chuckle at your posts..... I will continue to support those who look for solutions and ignore the haters......... hate away people, it gives me something to ponder how bad you feel inside...... So lets call this thread done.... Thank you to all who have given positive advice.... the rest of you....... fill in the blank space.... Have a nice day.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

I support your right to vent. I know at some point you'll find either a solution or peace with your situation. Stay on here because there's a lot to learn.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

TG, vent away! I think you've made MUCH progress, because you are no longer saying and thinking "I just need to be nicer to everyone".

You have a very tough situation; I wish you much luck with your family.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

...it's like what GardenArtist said 10 days ago...fighting a whirlpool etc...
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Venting yes, crying no.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

I agree. Venting itself is therapeutic, isn't that at least half the point?
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

I'm going to jump in to defend TG because I know he won't defend himself. TG has a long history on AgingCare and has never been anything but polite, despite being dressed down by people who aren't satisfied that he is moving fast enough in resolving his issues. If you can't let the man vent then just move along, nobody is forcing you to read his comments.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

tgengine.
You are not going to like what I have to say so stop reading here.

I suggest your head all your posts in capitol letters: I AM JUST HERE TO VENT. DO NOT SUGGEST SOLUTIONS AS I WILL JUST CONTINUE WHAT I AM AND HAVE BEEN DOING FOR YEARS.

It seems to me obvious you cannot or will not act on the help you have been offered. It sounds to me that you are just here to express the old "woe is me, I'm so alone and misunderstood!"

Nothing is going to change until and unless YOU make up your mind. That being said you need professional help which you seem not to be prepared to undertake.

Like most of the people who want to be of some help I empathize with your situation and would offer the same suggestions as the others but you, apparently it seems to me, do not really want to overcome your problems.

"I need to learn to use tools to help them all understand. Doing reading, research on how to deal with this all. Just plain saying it to their face doesn't work, for some reason they dont hear me,. its like talking to the dogs... get the same dumba** look... " Of course they "don't hear", why should they, they have heard it so many times they know it means nothing, nothing is going to change.

To me you are beginning to sound like you're trolling. Get real, get off your duff or let everyone know for sure you are not going to change.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Thanks, it is easy to armchair quarterback. We all seem to be in the place where we are givers not takers. It seems I am in the place of a giver. As far as dad, I have tried 7 ways from Sunday to talk, fix, encourage but to no avail. To those who say "move him out" that is not applicable. Would you throw your mother out on the street? No, I didn't think so. It is easy to say "tell this person this or that". It is another thing when they live with you. Sure I can tell my daughter to move out and be done. I will be a lonely old man some day. I am trying to move things along the best way I know how and using the things I learn here. They may not be right. When someone has the ultimate answer that fits all let me know.
As far as dad I have no choice, he is here. Siblings do not talk to me, family has pretty much shunned me due to what ever he tells them. I try to talk to him, ask him but he continues to do what he wants. Sure I have said I have no money, then he gets overages and then I have to cover. Sure I can let him go but someday it will be MY problem.
Trying to help my daughter along. Outside of saying "get out, get a place I have no idea what to do". Trust me, we have been talking and coming up with ways to help but He is a loser and she is my daughter. If I leave it up to him they will be in a sh*t hole like their first year of marriage. He would be happy and her miserable. Until she sees the light not much I can do. We try to help with getting them direction, giving them the right people to talk to so they can get a place. We have found places for them. So again outside of giving my daughter whom I love the boot not sure what to do. He is worthless so I would kick him out in a second but I have to intend her.
I have tried everything with dad, talking about cleaning the floor, leaving cleaning supplies in the bathroom for him to clean up after he pees on the floor. Tough love doesn't work like some wold say. I need to learn to use tools to help them all understand. Doing reading, research on how to deal with this all. Just plain saying it to their face doesn't work, for some reason they dont hear me,. its like talking to the dogs... get the same dumba** look...
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

" If you don't like what I post then move along and don't read if I have not taken your advice. Really, I do read all the posts. I have taken advice. If by your reasons I haven't taken your advice in the short time I have been or long per your standards then move along."

If only you could talk this forcefully to your son-in-law!

tg, everyone on this forum is rooting for you. What I failed to remember is that in your case it is extremely difficult for you to make any sort of change. I know you mostly left a few months back (except for some posts in the dysfunctional families area) because someone referenced some of your old posts and pointed out that things were the same as quite a while before. You didn't like that being pointed out.

When I was a telephone crisis counselor many years ago, there was a type of caller that was characterized as "poor me, ain't it awful, yes but..." I should have recognized you in that description. I am not one to offer constant "tea and sympathy," but rather like to point out the obvious. Yes, I can be rather brusque.

Since I now know that you really don't want advice from people, I will no longer respond to your posts. All the best to you and your wife, and I hope you can find some peace in your situation.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

TG, I know you're overwhelmed but you need to do an exercise. Come up with a plan for what you'd do if Mrs. TG becomes ill and needs your attention and less house chores and calm. Come up with a full game plan. Then take a look at all the steps and start implementing them. Please be proactive in protecting her health rather than be in reaction mode when she becomes ill again. If DD and SIL are in their own apartment, you'll be better able to manage the situation with your dad.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Really, I don't need cold water in my face or a swift kick. If you don't like what I post then move along and don't read if I have not taken your advice. Really, I do read all the posts. I have taken advice. If by your reasons I haven't taken your advice in the short time I have been or long per your standards then move along. I have tried to set boundaries, say no. But to some I have not done what is expected of me. Really I didn't know there were expectations here. I come here to learn and vent not to be judged, trust me I have enough already here. If by your standards I am not up to snuff then please by all means dont read what I post, I will not be offended. I am new to this game of caring for an adult. Along the way came some other issues. Many times I have deleted my link to this account only to come back to read then I get a couple that decide to pile on. Really? Not what I need right now. Maybe it is time for me to sit back and read and not post. I appreciate those who are in similar conditions. I look for camaraderie not to have social media guilt. A little tough? Yes maybe but that is my feeling right now. Thank you to those who understand. Your positive remarks bode well. I have enough negative in my life right now.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

After all this time, not much progress has been made at all with SIL and D. I remember deadlines that were supposed to happen months ago now where they were supposed to move (or have a plan to move). Nothing.

As far as the father and the hunting trip? Don't give him $ and don't enable him in any way. I don't see tgengine hauling his father to the doctor to get therapies that the father probably won't even cooperate with (right?) as worth tgengine's time and trouble.

But I guess what will happen is that tgengine will drive his father to the camp, give him $, or whatever the father wants. The more time that elapses, the more that things stay the same.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

If your dad has mobility issues what are you doing about them? Ask his doctor to order PT and OT for him. Get him in shape before hunting season. If he can't do exercise to get stronger how can he go hunting? You don't have to tell him no. Let the dr tell him or his own fragility. He needs to be strong enough to drive x number of hours a day. He needs to be able to walk x number of minutes over possibly rough terrain. He needs to be able to carry his supplies. He needs to be able to put his own boots on. He needs to get in shape. He shouldn't wait until it's time to go and cause everyone else to have to wait on him. How manly is that?
I would think of every physically challenging aspect of the trip and have him get prepared for it. Then you don't have to worry about him falling in the woods and you can enjoy the time he is gone. Use the hunting trip as the incentive he needs to keep fit and keep busy. Pull all his gear out and weigh it. If the therapist comes to your home they can more readily see what the trip entails and his current living environment. Medicare will pay for the therapy. Tell his doctor that he's surfing the furniture and having mobility issues, possibly his balance is off and he needs to be assessed by a therapist. Tell your dad you will help him order his license as soon as he gets started on the therapy. Maybe he should take the SIL with him on the trip? Win win.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Oh, TG, your crystal ball was working just fine. It's the reality that is heavier going that anyone can appreciate until they're in the middle of it.

Harden your nose. Dad wants to go hunting, Dad can take himself to the woods for a recce, can sort out his own licence, can rely on his buddies for any assistance he needs. And if he can't do those things, then ipso facto he can't handle the trip, because preparing for it is part of doing it.

The only bit you have to work on is saying 'not my problem' if the trip goes t*ts up. And, to look on the bright side, maybe it won't, and he'll have a nice time, and you'll get a break. And then again maybe his friends won't be so easily conned next year, on account of they'll have learned something.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

"He will not change. So I have to learn to adapt. "

Of course he won't change. Why should he when you're willing to compensate for him?

"Not allowed to ask about pretty much anything but yet everyone continues to live here scott free."

Honestly, I can't even think of anything to write in response to this. It's such an admission of subordination, of not even trying to stand up for your rights, and of just accepting that you're going to be a doormat for freeloading relatives.

"I know it wont get better so I have to look at this as my new normal."

TG, have you ever really, seriously, considered getting psychological help to establish boundaries and regain your sense of self respect? Or are you content to be a doormat for your family? Or is it that you just like to come here and get sympathy?

When you first posted some years ago, I never would have thought I would reach these conclusions, and I don't write them to be nasty. But you've come here repeatedly and asked for help, been told to stand up for yourself, set boundaries, get help, yet nothing seems to change. Months pass by, you're back again with the same complaints.

If you're willing to tolerate a subordinate position in your own household, accept that, but recognize that the situation isn't going to change if you're not willing to. And be honest that you want sympathy for a situation to which you've contributed by refusing to address it head on.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Just ignoring dad for a while so to speak. He will not change. So I have to learn to adapt. After 3 years I am tired. As far as SIL and daughter, they are still here. Not allowed to ask about the house situation. Not allowed to ask about pretty much anything but yet everyone continues to live here scott free.
So I just continue doing what I need to keep my place going without any help from anyone (except my wonderful wife).
As far as dad, I will see when the time comes. He will ask for money and I am prepared to say no, he will have to figure out a different solution.
Right now working on me. Did a side job yesterday to get some extra cash (really didn't need it but always need some extra). Went back to the gym to get me in better shape (week 2, 5 days a week). Feel so much better. Gets me out of the house.
I have been painting outside, dad some to me and asks if I was done..... lets see 3/4s of it plainly can see is not done. He said he would love to help but he can't climb a ladder. Now he can't climb a ladder? For 3 years he has been telling me he can (I wont let him). Plus I was on the floor painting...... I had to laugh. He is only handicapped when it is convenient......
As far as SIL, he keeps the drinking hidden. Still can tell. I gave up as long as it is not in front of me or he gets out of line. I feel bad for my daughter, she is wasting her time with this guy. Going no where. Soon it will be too late for her when she wakes up. There is on so much we can tell and show her.
I wish I had a crystal ball before I got myself into all of this...... I know it wont get better so I have to look at this as my new normal. Saying no more often, cooking for 3 more often.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Hi there TG!

"Sure I can say no, it is like saying no to a child but he is not a child and I have no "ammo" to say why."

Sure you do. Ask his doctor if your father is fit enough for this hunting trip.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

TG, no, this isn't about guns.

Your question asks " how do I tell him no?"

That is at the core of all of your experience with your dad, how to say " no". You have difficulty with saying no to other folks too, but let's start with dad.

What happens when you deny your father something? Does he get angry? Sad? Whiny? Tell tales to others to get back at you?

How did your mom say no to him? What was their interaction like?

Ponder those questions a bit, you may find some answers to your dilemna.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Read what NYDaughterInLaw wrote. And then read it again.

Your uncles sound just like your father. Your father cooks all the meals AND they don't even contribute? Freeloading moochers.

After all this time, nothing has appeared to change. You say NO to your father. No help getting the license, no driving him to the camp, NO $. So Daddy gets mad? The best case scenario would be he would get so mad that he would leave and start living with someone else, right? (Maybe he could move in with one of the Uncle Moochers?)

(P.S. Any good updates to the rest of your story? How's D and SIL? Is he still drinking? How is your wife doing?) 
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Here we go again with the "yes...but".
No, TG, no one is ganging up on you or your father because of a gun.
No, TG, you do not "HAVE" to do anything.
Yes, TG, you can do nothing because anything you do enables your father, cheeses you off, and then you come to this forum to complain about why nothing changes.
Learn to say "no" and your problem will be solved. Saying "no" is a skill, which you have yet to master.
Helpful Answer (9)
Report

No, I am not going on the trip, He can go locally which is what he wants. I would have to walk him out there pre-hunt to show him how it will be. its a walk in the woods, maybe I need to do that.
As far as the trip, it is a annual thing I used to do but since he moved in it took all the fun out of going so I dont go. I can work it that my uncles can change the cooking schedule so he doesn't have to buy all the food. they all chip in but somehow he always comes up short on the money. He enjoys the cooking, they enjoy not having to but I dont enjoy the finance. He can cook there but not here, go figure. I will have to start saying no more often, been trying to. One day he is all needy, the next he has things in control (or so he thinks). It is like living with a child but this one can drive and make decisions.....
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

What ammo do you think you need TG? If he is perfectly capable of writing a cheque sending for his own licence then that is reason enough "Gee dad, I think you can do that without my help, I'm too busy". Period!! "Oh TG, can you loan me $500 to cover the cost of the food?" "No dad, you never pay me back and since I have so many people to support now I just can't afford it, I guess you will have to work out sharing the costs with everyone else that is going". If there are others in the family that have demonstrated they can look out for him while he is there then hooray, as others have already said enjoy the time without him!
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

TG, are you saying that YOU are going on this trip?

I'm confused why you think you have the ability to say yea or nay to the TRIP.

If this is about YOUR money, then you say no. You don't have to fund his luxuries. Let the rest of the family chip in if they want him to hunt with them.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Gee, All I had to do was say guns and everyone comes out of the wood work. As far as the gun, that is not an issue with me. (Sendhelp I would appreciate you not using that kind of humor again, pretty low).
My issue is his inability to deal with issues. He has no cognitive issues other than he likes to be waited on. He is ambulatory but needs assistance. As far as his going to camp, I am all for it as long as I dont have to fund it like I ended up doing last year. This year will be a big "NO". I cant afford to fund his cooking for camp (My uncles and friends). My family has always looked out for one another at camp. I doubt he will even go out. As far as walking in the wood, we have safety processes we use to avoid misfires. I can do a lot of prep calls to the family and friends to be assured he is not unsafe. Like I said, I doubt he will even leave camp, pretty cushy camp. We used to take my Great Grandfather out when he was much older, I highly figured they didn't even load his gun at that point, he just wanted to get out. Same with my grandfather. You would have to be a hunter to understand. My big issues is the long drive. There are no issues per-sea other than he is getting older.
Here it is another story, Most likely I will take him out for one day and show him how difficult it will be. If he gets out one day I am sure that will take care of the issue.
It is just the he makes it that I have to do everything for him. I get it, there are things he cant do. It is just difficult with no time off for me from all of this. Maybe if I drag my feet some more it will go away. Only hope. Sure I can say no, it is like saying no to a child but he is not a child and I have no "ammo" to say why.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

If it were me, I'd let him go. I probably wouldn't send in
for the liscence, that seems to imply I approve. Let
the other folks contend with him. Hopefully they'll
realize his limitations and keep a close eye on him or
not put live ammo in his gun. Right he drive seems
to be a lot. Can one of the others give him a lift?
Let him go and then you and your wife can have
some nice time together...enjoy it!
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

I seem to recall that TG's dad drove 8 hours last summer to visit sister.

Although The Old Man has some reported deficits (balance, urinary, possible dementia, certainly psychiatric issues), he is not being "cared for" by anyone in the sense of needing help with ADLs. He's just broke and entitled.

So, all TG can do is say "no" to whatever his dad is asking him to do (get me a license--no dad, if you want a hunting license, you'll have to do that (and pay for it) yourself).

If his dad pursues this, so be it.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

Barb, I think you're right. From past posts, it does seem as though TG's father needs to be a dominant figure, and that he's frequently at odds with TG, whether it's over something like this or his dog's unruly behavior.

Maybe this is more of a man to man issue than a caregiving issue, although the latter complicates the situation.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

I think the "did you get my license" thing is more of The Old Man ordering TG around, which is what he seems to like to do.

If The Old Man can arrange this trip himself, pay for it himself and get himself there and back, then fine, he gets to go.

But if he gets hurt up there, he gets taken to the LOCAL hospital and TG is unavailable to show up. Let sis the RN go get him.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

TG is stuck between the proverbial rock and a hard place - if he totally steps back, he can't stop Dad from driving 8 hours alone to the hunt site. And he's leaving supervision to others, who will be there to hunt and thus, distracted. But if he tries to maintain some control, he'll be driving Dad and supervising. And yes, Cwillie, that's how it works - fill out the form, add a check for fees and mail. Even if TG fills out the form, it's his dad who's applying for the license, which simply allows him to hunt for a particular animal during the designated dates.  There's no testing involved.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter