Follow
Share
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
My mother took in my grandmother when other family members did not step up. My grandmother was not an "easy" person to care for. I grew up watching my grandmother belittle her daughters while praising her absentee sons. It was stressful for her to deal with a aging mom, husband, and children all who wanted her undivided attention.

My mother is MUCH easier to care for than was her mother. I am very thankful for that.

The one thing that has changed is the "system." Seems like there is much more red tape now and more "warehousing" of seniors than there was when I was little. Also, seniors are living longer; so I see more incidents of dementia and other more serious, lingering and debilitating illnesses.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

my moms parents lived in germany and died there, my husbands parents died early - heart attach in their 50's- and i agree i get so sick at heart when the parents are always more interested in the absentee child who doesnot give a hoot- i am glad your mom is easy- my mom is too so far - only been 2 weeks though- sometmes she knows who i am sometimes does not
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

I just saw this thread.

My fathers dad passed a long time ago. I never met him, but his mother I do remember her. She lived with my aunt right up until the day she died, come to think of it. She wasn't ill that I can remember, gosh it was so long ago, and I think she died at 78. My dad would always take me over there and I can still see her looking at me with those deep Indian eyes. I think between he, my uncle, and my aunt they took really good care of her but it was my aunt whom she lived with.

My moms parents lived on the East Coast and I remember they lived in a big old house with a well in the back yard. I can hear "papa" telling me "stay away from that well gal", like it was yesterday. My mother said he told everybody that although no one ever fell in. When he died we went back for the funeral.

My moms mother died a few years later, still living in that same house with the well. She lived on her own, and never got sick, just died peacefully in her sleep.

No as for as my mom she never took care of her parents, she actually lived 3000 miles from them.

Hey this is a nice thread. Took me back a bit. Thanks Nutz.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

hey Nutz,

Pamela's right. Nice thread!

My grandma (mom's mom) had 11 kids and lived in Michigan while we lived in NJ. As I was told, Grandma had some dementia and she came to see us in nj and would stay for maybe 6 -8 weeks. Mom would take her out and get her new clothes, etc. Grandma visited all over where her kids wound up and when she got to where she didn't want to travel anymore, my mom's s-i-l did most of the work even though there were other children right there.
I still remember that my aunt got crap from other members of the 'family' but she was the one who went to Grandma's and changed out a lightbulb, brought all the groceries, etc.

Grandma had a heart attack, went from her home to the hospital and died there a few days later.

I tis true that medical science these days is keeping people alive longer who would normally pass away due to something or another and the dementia is more prevalent because we have meds for heart issues, etc that make the body last, but not the mind.

lovbob
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

HEy Y'all thanks for the comments, I was very curious... I dunno It just seemed that when I was young, most people didn't die @ home, rather in the hospitals. Gosh, I cant remember my parents or any of my aunts or uncle ( all ten of my mothers siblings) taking care of their parents or inlaws. Maybe it is the technology that is causing us to have a longer life span and changing circumstances.
Technology is a wonderful thing, but sometimes even though we can, one often doesn't stop to ask if we SHOULD! I think im going to continue my bad habits. Im gonna erase all those wonderful years @ the end. NO THANKS. * can someone please pass me the Krispy Creams ? with a side of lard?
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

omg I love KrispyKreme.

You know, I'm kind of the same way. I don't want to live to 90 if I'm crapping my pants. I figure i've got maybe 10 years to go if I'm lucky and that's why I'm obsessed with the boat.

I'm actually here licking my chops thinking about KrispyKreme. i am pathetic.

lovbob
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

My mom, as an only child, had to move her mom from another state to live with her and my dad. Mom and gma had never gotten along so you can imagine. Mom made gma's life a living hell. Felt sorry for gma, wished I could've taken her. To this day, my mom has never shed a tear over gma but I have.
Dad's 7 sibs pitched in, built my grandma a little house in one daughter's backyard,hired a caretaker plus all took turns on weekends and showered grandma with love and respect. She eventually had to go to a nh,died there. I'll always remember dad and his siblings pulling together. Too bad my absentee sister doesn't remember. Of course, she's the one my mom favors. It's puzzling to me.
90 with crappy pants and a hateful attitude, please God, NO!
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

My mother mentions that her mother cared for HER bedbound mother for many years. Assume Mom was a child then. Mom's mother herself got colon cancer and Mom brought her into her home, with FT nurse I believe, for a few months before brief stay in nursing home. Both grandfathers dropped dead of heart attack. My Dad's grandmother was independent until ovarian cancer was discovered, then it was quick nursing home stay before she died. We never went to nursing home.

I did visit Mom's mother a few times in the nursing home (I was 19 perhaps), but she was delirious and didn't know what was going on.
I probably stayed only a few moments. Looking back, I was pretty shallow then. Now I would have sat with her regardless and been by her side in her final hours. Made sure she had a pastor visit her. Brought her photos from home. I don't think my mother was very hands on with my grandma, as grandma had done a shocking thing and ran off with a preacher man when Mom was a child.

I was around Mom's mother more when grandma lived at Mom's house for those few months, and I was "honored" to hear her tell the story of the day her second husband died a few years before. That was the man, the preacher man she had run off with, we always considered Grandpa.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

goinnutz, I hear ya!!
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Let's switch this around a bit. Who do you think will care for you when the time comes. ME? Nobody. No children. The two deadbeat sisters actually didn't consider this when they plotted to abandon me with Mom when she got older.

"You didn't have any children, so it's YOUR turn to suffer!" That's the sort of thoughtless peashooter mind insult you sling in the middle of an argument. But the two deadbeats kept repeating it in person and emails (and they are grown up people now!). Finally one of them wrote me that they'd been griping about my single lifestyle all along, decades, and had this curse on me.

Yeah, my single lifestyle: on boards of nonprofits, cofounder of a healing arts center, headed a drug abuse prevention task force, community building committees, interviewing the brightest minds in the world. Hey, I knew someone who was on Elisabeth Kubler Ross's hospice team. Left all that to care for Mom, who makes no viable contribution to society any more.

So Mom is not the Curse of my choice: it's that I will do all this for her (reaching 8 full years), yet have no one to care for me. I imagine there are a lot of single, no-children women out there who got stuck as caregiver. And they are wondering when they'll be rewarded...with the possiblity of NEVER, not for you. Heaven maybe. "You're earning good karma," as my mom's Public Guardian told me. Whut about this lifetime?
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Alz, I have thought about this some. My husband is 11 years my junior. He has joked that if he has to change my depends or whatever that he will wear one of those anti-toxic suits. I really don't want to put him through all of that. I don't have any kids and neither does he. I don't want a nursing home either. I'm hoping God takes me in his arms before any of that is necessary. That may be a terrible thing to hope in some people's opinion but it's the truth. Alz, I truly believe God will make sure you are taken care of kindly on this earth. You are an angel. I have a neighbor who is in a nursing home and hates it. She has been there for going on 5 years. If she would have been open to hiring a caregiver to live with her I believe she would be at home. She had nursing home insurance and that would have helped pay for the caregiver. She insisted she only needed someone a couple hours a day and the docs wouldn't send her home. She's very independent. Never married or had kids but I bet she wishes she had had more of an open mind when this all started. I don't know. Sometimes there are no good answers. Only the best answer. I try not to look too far into the future. Ignorance is bliss? LOL :)
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

I am told that my grandmother took care of her mother until her death at age 94, and I am also told by my mother that she can clearly remember Gram having to escape to the kitchen and just shake, she was so stressed and upset about what her mother was putting her through. The funny/infuriating part about it is, whenever I told my Mom & Dad about what she was doing to me, they would say "Oh, yeah, her mother used to do that to her. It drove her nuts." Will someone PLEASE explain to me why it was not okay for her mother to treat her like crap, but it's perfectly fine for her to do it to me?!?

Alzcaregiver-I am in exactly the same position. I am not married, I have no children, and when all of my caregiving days are over I will have no real family left. I have often wondered what is going to happen to me when I'm the only one still alive. But, as Miz Demi has said, I firmly believe that I am here because God wants me here, and as long as I do what He wants me to He will take care of me. I have to have faith that everything will work out in the end, even though I have absolutely no clue what that end will be. Just hangin' on here by my fingernails, waitin'.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

I am Primary Caregiver for my m-i-l, who has Alzheimers. I remember when my husband & I began dating that his mom's mom
had moved in with them. She had Alzheimers also, but it wasn't called that then. I think it was called senility. I remember as my husband & I continued dating, I found out that his mom and dad had separate bedrooms. They explained it away as he snored too loud and she had to get up early in the morning to cross the school kids. Now that I'm reading these posts, it was probably from a variety of things. I had heard that his dad had not liked his m-i-l.
My husband and I share the same bedroom still, but now I'm beginning to wonder if this was such a good idea taking in my m-i-l, his mom. I'm wondering if we are going to repeat the same thing.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

My mother slapped her parents into nursing homes, where her father was drugged into submission and died of aspiration pneumonia, and her mother died from sepsis in a wound. My father's father killed his mother and then took his own life. My brother died of mysterious circumstances at age 48, and my Father died in surgery. So no, I don't remember my parents doing this. My mother hits, bites, kicks, pulls hair & scratches me. After being told all my life that I was the result of a family planning mistake I'm not real gung-ho on her well being, but I do the best I can. I pay for her to have 24 hr in home care out of my pocket.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

lach61,

The situation that you describe raises so many red flags for me. It sounds good on the surface, but when you put a son in the same house with his mother and his wife, that is a triangulated relationship that is just begging for trouble far more often than not. I think you and your husband need to have a serious heart to heart discussion about this. From what I've seen, people with the healthiest marriages do not have their in-laws living with them from day one, (I heard one case where the groom's parents went with the couple on their honeymoon) or living right next door.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

I have to admit, this has come to my mind also. My uncles, aunts and parents visited for 1-2 weeks (in another state) and "took care" of my grandparents. It really isn't the same as being there and making all the decisions with them and then doing all the physical work. Not to mention they are all doing the same thing so no one felt guilty. I am the only one and find I feel guilty still.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

My mother and dad took care of her grandmother in our home when I was growing up. She was not a pleasant person, and we had a very small home, so she & I had to share a room. I remember her throwing things at me when I would come in "our" room. Nonetheless, she and my mother were very close and no one else would take her. She lived w/us for several years, and I remember feeling guilty as a child that when she died I could not bring myself to cry. As far as who will take care of me, who knows? I have 2 sons, both single, and 2 step sons-both married w/children. I am finding that mothers of sons do not have the "connection" that mothers of daughters do. It is easier for a woman to take care of her mother than her MIL. So, I don't have much hope that a DIL will do it. I just pray the Lord takes me before it becomes an issue.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

I remember when I was little,early 1970's, that my family moved in with my grandfather after he had a stroke. Don,t remember much but always remember mum was very upset alot and grandad was demanding
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

I only remember one of my grandparents and he passed away before care became an issue. I was a late baby. Mom & Dad were 40. None of our relatives lived here in the town I grew up in.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

I'm depending on 'daugher-in-law insurance'. My d-i-l is gonna put a pillow over my face and call it good. I'm gonna have to make sure she still likes me at the time though, don't want that pillow too soon. ha.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

naheaton, works for me!! ;)
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Lol Naheaton!!! and as for me... Im gonna try and get some long term care insurance if I can afford it,, if not... well.... there are always alternatives.. as I sit here sipping on my black russian, I hope to eliminate those "Golden" years.. after my experience with my mother,, I know for SURE i dont wanna go there myself.
If God is Merciful to me, perhaps I will just drop dead with a Heart attack in my early 70's before dementia and or cancer gets me.
~Nutz
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

In my family, grama's grampas aunts uncles anyone who got old came to live with you. It just seemed the way it was. I don't know why my Dad is so scared that I would put him in a nursing home.(siblings perhaps..??..)He even bought some 200 a month crappy insurance that was supposed to help him with long term care! No way, it's deep in our roots to take care of owr own..that I am sooo thankful for, without those prior experiences...I AM freaking, but its only because somehow I gotta find some money to get a small downstairs toilet put in before they move in with me!! Things I can actually control! Yeh!
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

My grandmother lived with us when I was in highschool. I now understand some of what she did/said during those years. It is a valuable tool for me to use as I care for my mother-in-law. I look at this as an opportunity to love someone. How would I like to be so forgetful. I think she has outstanding survival and coping skills to cover as well as she does for what she cannot remember. I need to always remember to allow her dignity.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

I think the older elderly are afraid of nursing home because of the image of going to the "pour house" that is in many of their heads.

I remember my great aunt, my grandfather's old maid sister who felt she was too good for any man, lived with him, his wife, along with my mother and me following her divorce. It was a year or two before my grandfather died and several years before my great aunt died. She got worse and worse plus seemed horrified to have a little boy in the house. Believe me being around two high strung older women and my high strung mother, I was very hopeful that life would be better with a step-dad but that was a dissappointment too. My grandparents were of the old southern culture who did not believe in children eating at the table with adults until they were like teenagers. So from age 3 until I was 12 when my mother remaiired I ate in the kitchen with my unofficial black family of the cook, the yard man, and other help who changed from time to time. Praise God for these dear people!
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Crowe you probably had a better time with them then you would have with your own family.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

I did and may I take some liberty in digressing.

Frankly, many of my best friends are African American people. Shoot, go to an AMEZ or about any African American chuch and let them know you are clergy, then see how much more respect you are treated with than in other congregations with the exception of Korean.

My SIL had the same experience when she was pastor of one white church and one black church on what methodists call a circuit. My therapist is somewhat surprised that I didn't mary a black person. My son and I very often attend a downtown think tank which is made up of about 98.99% black people and we feel right at home. Dang, many of our relatives in our extended family are not as nice to us as they are and they are very supprotive of various drama that we have to deal with.

I know that I'm painting with a very large brush, but with few exceptions this has been my experience since I was in high school and I'm not the only white child who was raised more by their families African American help than by their own parents.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

My aunt did all the caregiving for my mother's parents. She took care of my grandmother for 20 years after my grandfather died. My grandmother died after a hernia operation, had a large hernia that incapacitated her for 25 years, when the doctors finally thought they could remove the hernia in 1960, by that time she was too weak and had heart problems to be able to recover from the operation. My aunt kind of encouraged her to have the operation, later she admitted she was burned out from doing all the caregiving and housework, plus trying to work full-time in a laundry at the local hospital. I took care of my mom alone for five years and didn't have a job, then she started falling down in the apartment, so she is now in a nursing home. I do not know how my aunt did it working full-time and then coming home and caring for her mother. My mother tried to help them out a little financially, but the only time we came to visit was once a year in the summer, they lived in Colorado and we lived in Iowa.

On my father's side, his mother came to live with our family after his only other sibling died. However, she had a heart attack less than a year after she came to live with us, died in our living room. Dad had a fancy new home built with extra space in it for my grandmother, it was sad to have her go so suddenly. It was really hard for her to make the decision to come to live with us, she really wanted to live on her own in a small old, run-down cottage on White Bear Lake in Minnesota, but it was not winterized and she was having a lot of health problems, and it was an 8-hour drive to go up to visit her from our home. No discussion about moving to be closer to her, as my father had a good job as a Music Professor at Drake University.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

In the past extended families lived together and ths grandparents helped raise the children and later on the parents and the children helped the grandparents when they needed help.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

NUTZ:

In the Brazilian side of my family, the elders -- whether disabled or not -- lived among us until the day they died. They were engaged, loved, involved, respected, and often venerated. Some wove baskets, others helped in the kitchen, babysat, or functioned as kindergarten teachers while everyone else was working the fields. Unless they were very, very sick or mentally impaired to the point of being a danger to others placing them in nursing homes or "looney bins" was tantamount to betrayal. My father lost his bout to prostate cancer at the age of 62. His mother, 103, is still The Queen and runs the farm like a boot camp. You don't pull you don't weight, you don't eat; and that's that. She raised me since the age of 3 1/2, and I worship her.

In the Puerto Rican side of the family, things were much different and elderly abuse in all its manifestations wasn't uncommon. From "hurry up and die already so I can get a man to stay overnight" to "I'll slap the ____ out of you if you don't shut up, eat that soup, take a bath," etc. My mother and her 5 vulturish brothers would tend to Grandma Lupe every time she was bedridden hoping she'd keel over her rice and beans so they could divvy up her property. The old lady, 90+ and still strong, has buried two of them already -- with four sickly, worn out, and prematurely-aged ones to go. My money is on her. As horrible as it sounds, she'll be shoveling dirt over their coffins.

I'm still amazed that both my grandmothers and their contemporaries rarely get sick. Their husbands, whether in Heaven or the Netherworld, loved the drink but did a lot of physical work and were in great shape compared to the bowling pin bodies we're so accustomed to seeing today. Their diets were cleaner and relied on basic home remedies for their ailments. In sum, they took better care of themselves so they wouldn't be a burden to others in their old age. Like them, I look younger than my age, exercise, watch my diet, and build community by sharing what I know. In a nutshell, I network and do my best to be self-sufficient. In today's complacent American society, I'm seeing less and less of that.

-- ED
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter