Follow
Share

My mother has daily help from caregivers found for us by a local agency. She has settled into good relationships with two of them in particular. One of them, who I will call Julie, spends every shift telling my mother about her many financial woes and talking about how little money she has. Truly, she seems to have some big problems (bad credit so cannot get a landlord to rent to her and her adult son and so instead lives in an overpriced residence hotel, refuses to give up a pet and has been thrown out of some living situations, another son who asks for money all the time, down to only $150 in her checking account, etc. etc.) but these are not, of course, my mother's problems. My mother knew poverty for a time and is very sympathetic to these issues (as am I) but I do not want her becoming (more) stressed out worrying about Julie's problems. I worry too that Julie is going to start pressuring her directly for financial assistance. Already, she is pressuring her indirectly I think -- leaving long pauses for my mother to fill in with "I'll help..." during these many litanies, etc.. We have had a hard time finding people to come regularly and work (small town, understaffed agency) and so don't want to lose Julie unnecessarily. What would you do?

This sounds like it may soon lead to more direct requests for financial help. Though it may be an uncomfortable thing to do, I’d speak directly to Julie, tell her the oversharing is inappropriate, and to please stick to providing care, while also reinforcing that you appreciate her good work with mom. If you haven’t already, be sure all valuables and financial information in mom’s home are either removed or well secured. If the talk doesn’t put a stop to it, you’ll have no choice but to report it to the agency and request another helper be assigned.
Helpful Answer (10)
Reply to Daughterof1930
Report

I was a homecare worker for 25 years and am now in the business of it. The best way to handle 'Julie' is for you to tell her plainly but not unkindly that she is not to discuss her money woes or problems with your mother because it upsets her. Let 'Julie' know that you're talking to her about it directly and have no plans to discuss the matter with her boss because you know she's a good worker and your mother likes her.

Then wait and see if she puts the brakes ont he complaining and lamenting to your mother. If she does, then all will be forgotten. If she doesn't, you call her boss and tell them what she's doing.
Helpful Answer (10)
Reply to BurntCaregiver
Report
Grandma1954 Aug 16, 2025
this is a kind way to handle this.
It places the "reason" on mom's stress and avoids discussing this with the boss unless it causes mom more stress and it becomes necessary.
(3)
Report
See 1 more reply
This predator is on a phishing expedition into your Mother's wallet.

You should request a different caregiver today. I would not tolerate this and I wouldn't trust that she'd persist in doing it in other ways. Don't take no for an answer from the agency. No employee is irreplaceable. In my 4 decades as an employer I've found that everyone is replaceable and a bad employee is NEVER worth keeping.

You don't tell your Mother you are reporting it or asking for a replacement. If your Mom asks where she went you say, "I don't know."

You should also secure your Mom's house so that no one can peek around into drawers or mail or closets for valuables. Sorry, theft by caregivers is a crime of opportunity, so don't give them any.

I have my Mom's checkbook and Visa card at my house. She has a tiny bit of cash "hidden", and all her banking and financial info comes to me. I hold her SS card and passport. There's almost nothing in her home of value that anyone could sneak out with.
Helpful Answer (9)
Reply to Geaton777
Report
BurntCaregiver Aug 16, 2025
@Geaton

You don't know for a fact that the caregiver is looking for the OP's mother to give her money.

You don't have experience being a caregiver/companion to elderly people. When you're sitting there with an old person hour after hour, day after day it gets hard to make pleasant, generic small talk about nothing. It can be compared to watching paint dry. Sometimes the conversations get personal because you're with this person every day for many hours.

If the OP's mother likes this caregiver and they are a good fit, leave well enough alone and have a talk with the caregiver. No one should be so hasty like you're advising to snitch her out to her agency and maybe get her fired. No need for that.
(1)
Report
See 8 more replies
What Julie is doing is unprofessional. I agree, talk to her. Explain that telling your mother about her financial woes upsets her so please stop.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to JoAnn29
Report

Time for a talk with Julie. There are plenty of other topics to discuss when they are together...her financial issues are totally unprofessional. Be nice, but let her know that needs to end.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to lkdrymom
Report

Thanks so much, everyone, for the thoughts. In the end, I decided to make a quiet call to the agency and ask to have Julie reassigned. I also told them why. They told me that they instruct all the aides not to discuss money with clients. I made the decision after my mother told me a few more things about her daily interactions with Julie that bothered me. These included dumb stuff such as my mom offering Julie some packages of cookies when the grocery order was delivered with a few wrong items and Julie telling my mom that she didn't want those cookies (sure, whatever) but that she DID love the other cookies my mom keeps in the cabinet and would like to take those instead (um...?). It also included not as dumb stuff such as telling my mother that she is just exhausted and needs a nap as soon as she comes in the door so that my mother felt like it would be an imposition to ask her to do some basic things. I think she is a somewhat clueless pusher of boundaries at best, manipulative at worst, and most definitely someone who just takes more energy than I have to give right now so I made the call. Thanks again for weighing in.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to IsItJustMeOr
Report

“Sob stories are rob stories.” Sounds harsh but unfortunately I think it’s something to keep in mind.

“Save the drama for your [own] mama.” Words to live by! 😉
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to SnoopyLove
Report
Beatty Aug 19, 2025
Love love love these!!!
(1)
Report
okay - this is waking me up. i like the idea of just not telling my mom and then just saying "I don't know" when she asks. Honestly, my mother has always had poor boundaries (wants always to be liked and thought to be "amazing" and so puts up with crap) and i have been the one who advocates/plays the heavy for years in our family so sometimes i worry i over-react. thanks for the splash of cold water.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to IsItJustMeOr
Report

Ditch 'Julie'. Pronto. Seems she is grooming your Mother for financial assistance.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to Beatty
Report

thank you! yes - the financial info bit has me worried a little and had thought of that but now will act. Good to know that I am not alone in finding this inappropriate.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to IsItJustMeOr
Report

See All Answers
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter